06-reference/transcripts

moonshots anthropic 72m average employee faa ground stop starship caught transcript

2026-11-19

mute in between. >> Really? >> Yeah. >> Uh it sounds like a rodent on your on your microphone. >> Yeah, it just a lot of [laughter] >> a lot of noise. >> I'm sure I'm sure it's just a pending rant. >> If I do nothing, you're still hearing. >> No, it's gone now. >> No, it's when you're moving on. >> Okay. >> All right. >> It's when you're talking. [laughter] >> Yeah. Just don't talk. >> God damn it. Do you guys realize >> by the way you talk? What time is it? >> I want to say it's it's 1:00 a.m. here in Bangkok, right? >> I'm staying up again through the middle of the night. I'm I'm tired. >> Whose fault is that? [laughter] >> It's scheduling of of you know, we did this 24 hours ago. Note, I've got the same shirt on in the same hotel room. Holy crap. >> Same lighting. I'm tired. I'm hungry. >> I'm cranky. I'm jetlagged. And you guys are wanting to do this live with no editing possible. Hello. >> [laughter] >> Yeah, I can tell already. >> It's like you're trying to It's like

[00:01:00] you're trying to hurt me. >> Oh my god. I love you, Sem. Thank you for your dedication. [clears throat] >> Best episode ever. >> Oh my god. So guys, a lot happening in the last 24 hours, right? So, President Trump landed in China. Uh, President Xi met him with on the tarmac with a handshake and a hug. Uh, a rare welcome for US President. Uh besides President Xi and President Trump, Vladimir Putin is there. The trilateral meetings are going to be hot. I can't wait to see what comes out of that. >> And then the last 24 hours, what's that? >> What could go wrong? >> What could go well? Hopefully, what could go right? >> Yeah. Yeah. >> Uh so funny. Did you see the the the stairway down from the airplane? And like the pomp and circumstance in China is insane. There must have been a thousand people there waving their little flags. But then Xi Jinping walks up to the bottom of the staircase and I was like, it was just like this awkward moment. We're like, is Donald in the bathroom in the in Air Force [laughter] One or like is he supposed to go up the stair? Like what's going to happen here? And finally, >> it's all positioning. It's all

[00:02:01] positioning. [clears throat] >> Yeah. Coming down on the other world leaders is always a good look, huh? >> Yeah. >> Did any of you have like 1984 flashing before your eyes? Remember in 1984 there were only three countries. There was Oceanana which was basically the Americas and the British Isles. There was Eurasia and which is basically Europe plus Russian land mass. And then there was East Asia. Those three countries. Did Did any of you see Oh my goodness. 1984 politics. >> Yeah. Right now they're like who gets Malaysia? Well, do you get Salem if you get Malaysia or does he come with that or not? >> I don't know. This is the great game of risk. >> So you're in Thailand. Where are you right now? Bangkok. Bangkok and and when President when President Xi landed in and they met in Alaska, of course, President Trump had all of the jets flying overhead, you know, >> show of power. >> Show of power. And and >> yeah, China should launch one of those hypersonic missiles right over the meeting. [laughter] >> No, no, no ideas. You're not You're not head

[00:03:01] of state anymore, Dave. [laughter] >> That idea. Okay. And then uh Nvidia uh just reported on earnings last night in the first quarter since Jensen resigned, right? The numbers were huge. Revenue was 115.8 billion, up 103% from last year, 100% growth year after year. Uh data center revenue was up 107 billion. Uh you know, net income 65 billion. These are incredible numbers. And the stock still went down about 1.5% this morning. So interim CEO Colette Crest, you know, guided fourth quarter uh earnings at 130 billion. Uh and then of course the whole Jensen soap opera is going on. Um so what do you guys think about this? Right. So Jensen saying I'd come back if you asked me. The board saying no way. Everybody's weighing in. >> Thoughts? >> It's a disaster, man. It's a total disaster. >> I have a I have a clear thought. So I

[00:04:00] did a little research. It turns out the board for 10 years has been trying to get him to do a succession plan and he's not been doing it. And he surrounded himself, his kids are in the company and at some point the board kind of just went, we can't run a $5 trillion company this way and there's no coming back from that. That's my thesis as to why this is happening in the way that it is. There's no question that there's going to be a massive issue. They had to take the pain s sooner or later to deal with this. >> Yeah. And then all the comments in the peanut gallery, right? We've got uh Jeff Bezos and Sam Alman saying Nvidia will do fine without him. Jeff saying, you know, bring back founder power. Elon saying bring back the founder. >> It's a little different from the Sam Alman, you know, weekend of being fired in that Sam was fired, outright fired, blindsided by the board and then created an employee and shareholder uprising and got himself reinstated and then he just, you know, quietly eviscerated the board. Um but Sam didn't want to go. uh Jensen quit in in a in a very emotional kind of

[00:05:02] state judging from all the reports and what he was saying, you know, and >> you know, because you've got the the infidelity home life thing going on concurrently, but he quit, submitted a resignation. So that that's a little bit of a different dynamic. Also, Sam's a very young guy with a lot of future in front of him. And Jensen's been running the company for three decades or more with no succession plan. So, it puts the board in a really awkward spot. And I guess it's divided now, too. There's three people on the board that want him back and I don't know, God knows how many. What's really weird to me is that it's it's apparently a handpicked called in the press pushover kind of board, >> but they're saying majority of them are saying no, don't come back, which is kind of odd. Like you would think a handpicked pushover board would spine for each of you. What's your prediction? Is he coming back, >> Alex? >> Oh god. Watch for the Exactly. down the middle. >> Watch for the activist investors. This would seem to be a ripe case where activist investors of the Bill Aman

[00:06:02] genre should and probably I I would expect will step in and attempt to overhaul the board. This is just it's smacks of terrible governance on so many different levels and it's I I think frankly an embarrassment for America that our most valuable at least until recently by market cap company is in the middle of such an absurd governance failure. I expect the activist investors to circle and take aim and try to fix the situation >> and do what? >> I'll take the other I'll take the other side of that because that would maybe work in a normal environment but given all the espionage issues and leakage of chips to China and so on. I think that is the uh the seals the deal. >> So you think there's no way he's coming back? >> I don't think he's coming back. >> Sam Sam is [clears throat] out. >> Not that I don't want him to. I just don't think he's out. I mean, Sam was out for a weekend. He has Greg Brockman as a super loyal right-hand person, and

[00:07:00] you could come back quickly. Time is going to kill this thing. Like, if if you said, "Well, we'll figure it out in three weeks, four weeks, five weeks, the board is torn." Every week that goes by, whether or not he comes back becomes less relevant because it's very, very hard to come back and be empowered again after six weeks or whatever. like like getting it back to where it was a week ago is going to be damn near impossible if time goes by. So they better they better figure it out fast. >> Steve Jobs came back to Apple after years through a reverse acquisition. I I think there are all sorts of scenarios where Jensen comes back. But I I think what >> well Steve Jobs came back to a company that was borderline bankrupt. So if you follow your analogy along, sure Jensen could wait three years for this thing to completely fall apart and then come back like a white knight. Yeah, that could happen. Actually, that may be why Poly Market Poly Market doesn't think he's coming back uh for this year. Um but what was the Poly Market like by the end of next year? 30% chance I think is the

[00:08:00] last >> things may have to fall apart a little bit before they want him back enough or before Nvidia gets acquired maybe by SpaceX Tesla. You never know. But I what what what what struck me most in this is history tends to rhyme and I just I wasn't around for the 70s but I I read history and the the period of uh call it the 70s plus or minus a decade was a period during which the great powers were in many cases playing games in the Middle East for oil because oil was the great commodity that made the world go around at the time. Now the great commodity is GPUs 50 years later. And the commodity isn't coming from the Middle East anymore. It's coming from here and Taiwan largely. And I I can't help but escape the idea that the great powers, including our great power, the United States government, is can't resist the temptation, including factions within the US government, to play games with leadership for the the

[00:09:00] 2020s version of oil. In the in the 1970s, it would be you'd launch a decapitation strike against the leader of a Middle Eastern country that wasn't maybe friendly toward US oil consumption. Now, it's a decapitation strike against the largest US company that maybe isn't adhering to certain desirable policies regarding import export of GPUs. >> Well, I tell you what I would do if I were Jensen. I would I would say, look, I'm a three and a half% shareholder in this company board. I will go quietly if you go ahead and cash me out. Uh I will take that, you know, many billions of dollars and I'll do something else for a year, year and a half because during this next year, CUDA is going to get obliterated by AI. The C the CUDA moat is absolutely going to get obliterated by AI. And all these competitive inference time chips, you know, from all these other companies, Posatron and uh Xcale, and there's many of them now, they look really, really good. And so let that all bottom out. Uh and then

[00:10:02] come back like Steve Jobs the way you said Alex, you know, come back to to turn it around because there's going to be a huge pile of cash no matter what. >> Nvidia. >> Yeah. I and I I I maybe David to add to your comments. The hyperscalers and the Frontier Labs, they all have their own Nvidia, CUDA, and just Nvidia in general chip competitors. at at this point whether it's partnering with Broadcom or building what they're building internally or just using Frontier models to design their chip architectures. In many cases, they may think they don't need Nvidia's chip design prowess any longer. The AI has superseded however many PhDs Nvidia has on staff doing their chip design. They may feel that >> that at this point they don't need Nvidia's chip architecture anymore. Maybe they need the indirectly the TSMC transistor supply, but they don't need Nvidia per se. And the argument would go if if you follow that to its logical conclusion that the only thing keeping

[00:11:01] sort of the finger in the hole in the dam is Nvidia's alleged circular financing to prop up neoclouds and and startups to purchase Nvidia particular architecture versus alternative architectures from the hyper hyperscalers neoclouds and frontier labs. Jensen leaves. The circular financing scheme, as reported and/or alleged, vanishes under the watchful gaze of a new interim CEO who's mindful of pressure not to engage in circular financing schemes. The thing collapses. Not investment advice, but the the the scheme collapses. in particular the artificially as reported propped up demand for Nvidia's chips props collapses due to that that circular financing collapsing and there are many ways to collapse I don't mean like literally overnight collapsing there's a lot of demand but over the the longest term collapses and then >> right and and then Jensen can say uh you

[00:12:01] know I I was displaced and the the thing fell apart uh proper hawk post hawk Ergo propped hawk. So you know you should bring me back [laughter] a >> after after this slash that. Therefore because this or [clears throat] that. In other words, >> thank you. [laughter] >> Confusing confusing. >> You you you forgot you forgot the open pen and closed pen. [laughter] >> Open PN closed PN. Uh but the the the point is a lot of people will be tempted to conflate causality or causation with correlation when in fact it might just have been the circular financing scheme that was propping everything up. >> I I think the [clears throat] uh there are a lot of posts saying this circular financing propped up it sounds like a big Ponzi scheme but I I actually don't see it that way at all. I think they have massive amounts [clears throat] of cash piling up. They're going to end up doing a dividend which is insane. like a for an AI company in hyperrowth to do a dividend because you can't figure out what to do with your money. That's

[00:13:00] that's nuts. Um but there, you know, I think Peter, you said $130 billion next year at 80% or 75% gross margin on that. There's never been a cash pile that big piling up that quickly before. And so building out your own ecosystem around you with that money is actually a very natural thing to do. I don't think it's fraudulent in any way. But I also completely agree without J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J Jensen at the helm, the board and the CFO are not going to keep doing that anywhere nearly as aggressively as Jensen was doing it. And I I really think he does need to act a lot or the company needs to act a lot like Elon in this moment to be relevant because there's no way you can sit on your existing GPU architecture and say, "Yeah, that's going to be around 5 years from now, seven years." >> That's so important. They need to build, you know, what Elon does extraordinarily well is build adjacent companies over and over again. He's going up and down the stack and Nvidia need to do they started to do that with open source models and I'm I'm curious uh you know what Jensen's departure is going to do to the open source world. >> Oh my god, I don't know if we have more

[00:14:01] time to talk about that, but I I cannot believe how big a deal this is and the balance of power between Google and everybody and the rest of the world. Um, and I, you know, Elon immediately came out supportive of Jensen. And I was like, well, I know he needs the Vera Ruben chips, but why is he so supportive? And then realized like Elon is, he he started Open AI purely to counterbalance Google taking over the entire world and then he lost control of Open AI to Sam and now he's, you know, trying to counterbalance the world with XAI instead. But Google has all the data, more data than any CIA or any other foreign government. They have more data than any government on the planet. And now the TPUs are starting to really take off. And and so that's, you know, that's a vertical monopoly like the world has never seen that is on the cusp of total AI takeover. And you notice they're very quiet in the press. They don't there's no drama type person. >> Have you seen the rumors about, you know, Google is going to pounce soon uh

[00:15:02] and and sort of take the lead across everybody? There's a lot of expectation of what Google's going to do given the power. >> Yeah, I saw a post saying they're they've already released a bunch of new uh new chips and so on. So, they're going full out. >> Google should have pounced years ago. They they haven't been especially competent and I I say that with full editorial independent independence of any relationship Google may or may not have with this podcast. I I think Google can and should have acted years ago to take the lead as a frontier lab and they've flubbed it. Google Google's Gemini 4 >> not over yet, Alex. They're going to come back. They're going to come back with vengeance. >> Gemini 4 carbon is an improvement. Yes, I'd love to. And I have friends on the Gemini team, but I I'd love and friends on the TPU design team. I I would love to see them actually pulling ahead and and not just, you know, doing whatever they can to tread water as a number two or number three. Mark my words, Alex. There are going to be we're going to see

[00:16:00] this I don't know next next 90 days, 120 days max. >> What what happens in the next 90 or 120 days? >> Google comes out with a plan that sort of shakes the the Frontier Lab infrastructure. >> You have insider info on Google's 90 to 100. >> I have I have expectations of what Sundar can and will do and what Sergey Sergey is not going to sit back and let this be. I mean, he's way too silent. They're cooking. They're cooking in the background. >> Yeah, they're they're Yeah. The the ultimate, if you want to go conspiracy theory on it. If you really wanted to sneak up and take over the entire world, you would not be on stage. You your your models would not be, you know, constantly leaprogging the other guy. They'd be just like a one notch behind. You'd stay out of the limelight. Yes. >> You would you would slow play your hand while you build out your TPUs. But if you look at the actual TPU compute, the amount of compute that's getting cranked out now, it's grown exponentially in just the last year. And and nobody talks

[00:17:00] about it's not in the news. It's just sort of, you know, quietly ready to pounce on TSMC and take over this entire void that Nvidia has left. I mean, you can argue who's the light side and dark side of the force here, but the balance in the force is hugely different with Nvidia not counterbalancing Google. >> Yeah. Yeah, [clears throat] if I if I had to make the bull case, the the steelman case for how Google pulls sort of pulls ahead from behind where they're so obviously number three right now among the frontier labs. I I suspect it would be via some XAI cursor style acquisition or strategic partnership that surprises the market. It it's it's difficult, not impossible to imagine them organically becoming number one or number two. Just like GCP still not number one or number two public cloud, they're they're still a solid number three. Yes, it's good for their business and everything. Uh but they're not number one or number two. Similarly for their frontier model status. >> Yeah, I can't wait to send you a text.

[00:18:01] Called it. [laughter] >> I I can't wait. I look, Peter, I I want the frontier to be competitive. Frontier liberation, frontier we go. I want Google to to leaprog everyone else. I I just haven't seen it happen yet. >> All right. All right. Well, let's get into the show. Welcome to Moonshots, everyone. Your number one podcast in all things AI and exponential. Your front row seat to the hypersonic tsunami that we call the singularity. You know, it's it feels like the singularity. I mean, the rate at which stuff is happening is through the roof. Today we've got the fantastic four AWG our resident physicist and genius Dave Blondon our impreario of AI investing is our globe troder. So Sem again for the records where on the planet are you and what time is it there? >> It is 1:25 a.m. I'm in Bangkok. Um I came here for a leadership retreat um for a big company and I'm flying back in 10 hours. Uh, so how how many hours on

[00:19:01] the ground are you there? You are a probability function. >> It's Yeah, I've probably got the worst uh carbon footprint in the world right now. Um, and I'm going to say it again for the record. I'm tired, hungry, cranky, jetlagged, and we're you guys are doing it live like like literally I think you're trying to hurt me. My brain is trying to like crank. It's hard enough keeping track with all you guys, but but late at night and it's, you know, anyway, we'll see what we can do. >> All right. I'm going to rely on the comments from people to get clever ideas to talk about. >> Yes. And we are live streaming this on X just for fun. Uh and just to really help people get a sense of where things are going. So I'm Peter D. Madness, your host, your data driven optimist. Our mission, help you understand what happened the last few days, what it means for you, your family, your company, and keep you abundance minded as we're going through this hypersonic tsunami. Okay, the number for this week is 22 and 1/2 hours. That's how long ship 42 stayed up before the uh the

[00:20:01] Mechazilla arms caught it back at Starbase. If you're new here, uh please hit subscribe. You know, our mission here is to get, you know, sort of the optimistic abundance-minded news out to as many people as possible. We put this out twice a week. Uh you're not going to get it via email notification. You're going to get it if you subscribe. So, please do. Also, uh, on X, our handle is moonshots_pod. Uh, we have a clip channel there for the hottest takes in particular, what Alex's genius has put on the show. We cut it out and feed it to you. All right, let's jump into our first story. Uh, it's the Anthropic IPO and the growing wealth in San Francisco. So, tomorrow morning, at the time we're recording this, Anthropic starts trading under the ticker ENT. Today, they're expected to set final price. The deal is for $825 million shares marketed somewhere between 70 to $78. There is massive demand, right? There's 5x demand for the shares they're

[00:21:00] selling. At the top of the range, the offering would raise about 64 billion uh valuing Enthropic at 1.4 trillion, still below the 85.7 billion SpaceX raised back in June. Wall Street expects it to rise to about 80 bucks a share. I'm curious if any of you are buyers, but we can talk about that afterwards. The filing shows third quarter revenues at 17 billion, up 1.4 billion uh from a year earlier in an annualized run rate of about 81 billion as of October 31st. Seven companies, including Google, Nvidia, AMD, and Microsoft agreed to buy 26 billion of non voting shares in the IPO. Reminder, the seven co-founders have pledged to donate 80% of their personal equity. Uh a huge amount of capital is going to be flowing in the philanthropic world out of open AI and anthropic. Uh this is the public market's first hard mark on the frontier AI labs, you know, to see how they dominate the stock market going forward.

[00:22:02] uh it's going to be the S&P like three between Anthropic SpaceX AI uh and uh ultimately open AI. In a related story, Bloomberg Business says that in a 7 mile wide city of San Francisco, barely 800,000 people, the AI boom has minted thousands of fortunes worth over $10 million. At the midpoint of Enthropics IPO range, the average employee would own shares worth $72 million. So, if you can go back in time, get a job at Anthropic. The average OpenAI insider take is worth almost 126 million uh for their employees based on the firm's most recent valuation. With only 0.1% of the world's population, San Francisco is now by some counts absorbing more than a third of the global venture capital marketplace. Uh Dave, let's go to you first. Uh your thoughts on the IPO and on this concentration of wealth in San Francisco. Oh my god, that those

[00:23:01] numbers. So it's 72 million. That was the average. Just take take insider holdings divided by headcount. >> Yeah. And then for it's 126 million at their current um estimated valuation. I mean it's it's crazy. >> Yeah. I know. This is where you know people people don't generally they don't think a lot about trillion being that much different from billion. But then when you divide it out it's like nothing the world has ever seen is of this scale. And I was looking at the data on the wealth in San Francisco and it is so dwarfs any other event at any city in any point in human history. It's just miles and miles and miles ahead. I think a lot of people also don't realize the SpaceX IPO you kind of associate that with test with Texas now because Elon moved but almost all of the shareholders and investors from the early days uh also come from San Francisco. Steve Jervson and a whole bunch of other friends of ours uh and all that wealth already landed in San Francisco. So, OpenAI is not liquid yet, but when you add it all together, it's so funny on

[00:24:01] that chart. The wealth from Anthropic is a big bubble. The wealth from OpenAI is a big bubble. All other companies combined is an equal-sized bubble. [laughter] That's that's how big these these are. Uh so, it's it's just a massive concentration of wealth. It definitely moves the financial capital of the entire world to SF. And you know, New York can complain about it, but it's just a it's a mathematical fact. And also when people look at global wealth, you know, they usually look at all assets combined, most of that is real estate. But if you go and ask somebody, hey, I want you to invest in my company. Can you give me your real estate? That [laughter] that's not a conversation that ever flies. But after this IPO, if you go to somebody and say, hey, can you invest in my company with your new liquid cash that came from this IPO? Also, all the slides and all the postings say this is paper wealth. That's nonsense. This was trading wealth that will be fully liquid right after the the lock up which is a very short lock up. So this is real money >> far against it. Yeah.

[00:25:00] >> I mean what what's interesting is all of the accelerants on the singularity right we talk about acceleration from uh from uh you know the the GPU expansion on the planet but we also have an acceleration from the fact that these thousands of employees will individually become angels and super angels seeding the next companies coming out of the Bay Area in the rest of the world. So, it's just it's it's a hyper acceleration that's going on. We're not seeing an exponential. We're seeing a hyper exponential. Alex, your thoughts on this? >> Yeah, I think it's disappointing that it took this long to get to an anthropic IPO in the first place. Individual retail investors, certainly via exposure through index funds, had exposure via Google, for example, to anthropic and via maybe financial services institutions, but no direct exposure. And I I think it's a travesty that it's so difficult to IPO in this country that Frontier Labs wait until they're worth almost $2 trillion to give retail direct exposure to to them and the wealth

[00:26:00] creation. So I yes, it's great that in my mind that Anthropic eventually got around to IPOing. It's not great that it took until$2 trillion dollars to get here. And I would love to see real reform of the way IPOs are handled in this country to make it in a true incentive for the next anthropic to IPO at a much lower valuation at an earlier stage in their development to to give retail investors direct indexed closed PN there's no open PN there exposure exposure to that equity. >> Yeah. And and when we start trading 57 on the on digital exchanges, it's going to accelerate things. >> Yeah. I I want to I want to push back just a little bit on this, Alex. The company was formed in 2021, right? It's barely 5 years [laughter] old. Like, you know, I I I know it would be great to have it IPO soon, but you

[00:27:00] got to get it to some level of maturity and stability. Not that this is a stable environment, but I I think I think this is kind of the most unbelievable wealth creation we've ever seen. What I like about this is we're seeing uh intelligence become an asset class now. And that I think is a really good portend for the future. I I would maybe just comment the uh hypersonic if you will growth trajectory of anthropic from a standing start from really a schism with open AI putting putting the schism aside we want to see rapid growth for ipoable companies. If anything I would say >> you do >> so I I I would say again uh hopefully Anthropic fulfills their S1 vision of capturing $30 trillion. If so, there's a lot of delta left between where they are right now and saturating whatever their ultimate target market is. But on the off chance that they don't completely fulfill their vision, that is a lot of

[00:28:02] wealth creation. Uh the maybe it call it paper wealth creation. Arguably real wealth comes from creating greater future freedom of action for humanity and not just from moving dollars around. But that is at least a lot of paper wealth creation that retail investors missed out on that certain private investors captured. So even the fact as you're pointing out See that it was just a few years from a standing start in schism to IPO. I would say if anything I I want more 42 one year from start to IPO ability companies rather than saying this is an anomaly. >> Okay. So I've got a question for you guys. Um at some point is the is the uh holding period 3 months or 6 months in this case? I think it's 6 months right? >> Normally I think they have a early release on some of it. >> So assume it's 6 months. At the six month mark do we see a flood of exits as people liquidate and go do their own

[00:29:02] thing or is it so exciting to be there that people are like damn I can't I don't dare to w leave this place. Which way does it go? I I think anthropic based on what I read has what's perceived by markets as a relatively unusual schedule for employees taking their vested shares and liquidating them that this may not be business as usual as you would see with a conventional IPO. >> Yeah. And I think it it's uh it's a huge amount of rotation on that day, but you know there'll be a ton of people taking probably half off the table. Uh but I the demand is so high I don't you know it depends what it's trading on at at what level it's trading that day because it's not it's not going to be anywhere near the IPO price. You know usually it's either much higher or much lower 6 months later or three months later. Uh but I don't think they'll have too much trouble rotating it out. So then that'll all be fully liquid and reinvestable and and like Peter is saying it's all going to get reinvested back into AI startups and AI you know series A's. It's going

[00:30:01] to be >> Dave. Check out this check out this uh this graphic I made. I went and looked at time between founding and reaching unicorn status. So in 2000 it was 21 years dropped down to 11 years in 2010 uh four and a half years in 2020 and a year now right. I mean the the rate of wealth creation is you know it's insane. >> It is insane. It's the best it's the best founder time I've ever seen by so wide of a margin. I can't can't even overstate how wide a margin it is. And I keep telling people like don't AI could do anything. You know, two years to three years from today, you don't know what world we're going to be living in. But right here, right now, you know exactly what you should be doing. Sprint. Build your company and sprint in that direction. And this capital, you know, it most of my life, the entire venture capital industry combined has been, you know, 20 to 40 billion. Now it's bigger than that. It's over 150 billion plus. Now, this is 1.4 trillion

[00:31:01] in personal liquidity. So it's it's like a decade of the venture capital entire industry that's unleashed all coming from people who made their money in AI and so naturally they want to reinvest in their roots or what they what they know worked. I mean just the scale of that reinvested capital is like nothing the world's ever seen. So >> would be amusing if if time from founding to unicorn status actually went negative. I could imagine crazy scenarios where cross >> backdate your options like how does that >> where where the value exists before the company >> like where where you've achieve yeah >> Alex you're absolutely right so what happens is you know in the companies that are getting you know unicorn valuations out of the gate it's dependent on the people they collect so you've got some known founder who aggregates two or three other rockstar founders and just based on who they are not even on their projections or their business plan, they're getting

[00:32:00] billion-dollar valuations out of the gate. >> That's right. >> We saw that already with uh we saw that already with some of the early folks leaving um anthropic and open AI. >> Sure. Sure. >> I mean I I I see this all the time actually. uh now that I'm forcing myself to think about it, we are in narrow cases call this spiky spiky uh antic-causal or aausal unicorns where safes are being written to teams at unicorn valuations before the company exists all the time. So in a spiky sense we're already there query whether we could see this more broadly in the market where time to unicorn status goes broadly negative. So, so advice to entrepreneurs out there uh listening, you know, your team matters more than anything else. You know, find some extraordinary people who have pulled it off before. Uh have a a clear, you know, moonshot vision. That's the most important thing when I'm investing. I'm in, you know, when when Brett Atcock, we

[00:33:00] just released a podcast with with Brett at Figure that Dave and I did. When Brett first came to me, you know, in the earliest days, I was an early investor through my fund, Bold, uh, you know, what was amazing was his success having, you know, hit [clears throat] multiple exits, him putting his own money in, but the team he aggregated was through the roof and it was like, if you can do that, we're going to we're going to write a check. >> Well, I'm telling all the teams, too, go to SF. You don't have to move there. In fact, if you're, you know, the schools and the ecosystems that are hugely untapped are, you know, like Carnegie Melon, Carnegie Melon, Georgia Tech, you know, those those areas, Villanova, uh, Northwestern, stay close to wherever you're recruiting from, but spend a ton of time in SF and you'll you'll the difference is so noticeable just walking down the streets and talking to people. It's like it's like first world difference, you know? You you'll you'll see it immediately. And uh that that's where you're going to want to do all of your idea generation

[00:34:00] and your capital raising, but not your recruiting. If you hang out in the schools, I don't want to get in trouble with schools that I really love. But if you hang out in the major universities in SF, there's a very, very noticeable talent void. You're like, where did everybody go? But then you look at the amount of money that is trapped in their vesting schedule at Anthropic and OpenAI. They're not going to walk away from an average of 75 million or 140 million that's still got two years of vesting in front of it. And if you look at Anthropic, you know, like Seem just said, it's only a couple years old. So everybody's still early in their vesting cycle, so they can't leave. And so, okay, well, who's going to start the next wave of companies then? And it's like this huge void of talent with this massive surplus of of capital. So, what you want to do is recruit somewhere else, but go to SF and spend as much time as you can there networking and getting to meet people. >> How many trillions of dollars of IPOs in SF do you guys think it takes before SF looks like it is a city that hosts trillions of dollars of IPOs?

[00:35:00] >> Like until recently, I walk around Union Square and I see people in the fentinel fold. At least that's been somewhat cleaned up recently. But what is it? How many IPOs does it take before SF looks like a city befitting all this newly created wealth? >> Yeah, I would say >> you mean how long before it's cleaned up? >> Yes. >> And moderniz like how long until it looks like the future that that it's minting? >> I would say three years I think because the the the liquidity has to happen first and that happens tomorrow. Uh, and then you know Mark Andre and a bunch of people were trying to build a new city like just in East Bay and I don't know how that's going but you know it takes a while to build a brand new city from scratch. That takes a few years but I think AI as a management tool uh is going to start to penetrate SF you know like if you look at Whimo as an example it's like you could say three years ago when am I going to see Whimo everywhere? Like what what is taking so long? Now you're like oh wait it's here. It just sort of happened. So that's the delay.

[00:36:00] It's not in Cambridge. >> Just not in Cambridge or Boston. It's awful. [laughter] >> Uh we're going to have we're going to have optimist and figure robots walking around the streets of San Francisco cleaning things up, taking people into the halfway house. Yeah, we're going to have >> Maybe that's the solution. It's it's not obvious to me. I mean, it it's again sort of a best of times, worst of times in SF where on the one hand you have super intelligence. In some ways, SF feels post singularity. What one can look at parts of it and imagine Starfleet Academy or Starfleet headquarters being built there at some point in the near-term future. And then you see people who were so obviously on fentinel uh or you know other criminal problems that that are just happening very visibly on the streets juxtaposed next to each other. Bladeunner. >> Okay. So, so Blade, so you're saying this is the cyberpunk future, uh, aka high-tech, low life. But do we really want a high-tech lowife cyberpunk city being like our embassy to the future? I don't think >> we want we want Mecca to look academy.

[00:37:00] We definitely do. >> We have predicted that we're going to be running all science fiction plots in real time. So, we're seeing that happen. >> Yeah, >> I did like Bladeunner. [laughter] >> Okay, I'm going to move us on. So, you know, let's go to our next story here. So, this week, um, you know, started out with a number of what do we call cyber attacks and system failures, uh, on our email, our banks, the entire US air system, uh, making it all look fragile all in six days. So, four blows came close together. Uh, it's not a campaign, but let's talk through it because there's a lot of fear circulating throughout the public discourse. Last Thursday, Microsoft Outlook and Exchange went down. Uh, Down Decoder logged nearly 130,000 Outlook reports across 74 countries. It hit me. Yes, I'm switching over to Gmail. I have my Gmail. I just need to make it my number one email. Uh, then on Friday afternoon, the FAA issued a nationwide one. What's that? I just

[00:38:02] have just f memories of you hitting, you know, every time you landed you on a flight, I would get 20 emails whacked into my inbox and I go, "Oh boy, Peter just landed." And you could see you've been in Outlook on the whole flight typing away. We were just begging you [laughter] move out, you're finally doing it. It took a global Microsoft hack to do it, but thank God. >> Uh this was that those days were were pre Starlink on the airplanes. So um okay, let's continue. So then on Friday afternoon, the FAA issued a nationwide ground stop for more than 4 hours, the longest nationwide ground stop in 25 years. Transportation Secretary Shawn Duffy said about 3,500 planes that were ready in the sky uh were driven to land uh making it, you know, he made use this as a plea for his $50 billion revitalization of this ancient system we call air traffic control. And as a pilot, believe me, it's an ancient system. you know, the fact that you're actually, you know, talking over a open

[00:39:01] channel to air traffic control. You're reading your comments to them, they're reading it back, you're writing it down, you're reconfirming it, then you're entering it into your your flight control system. It's insane. About 12,462 flights were cancelled. Homeland Security Secretary uh Mark Wayne Mullen said there was no indication of a cyber attack. Then on Monday, three major US banks were facing reports of widespread service uh disruption, including Chase, Bank of America, and Wells Fargo. JP Morgan called it a software bug uh an on premise hardware with no evidence was a cyber related attack. It was resolved that evening. And then also on Monday, there was a confirmed cyber attack. Attackers used a flaw in Optimizely's ex uh experimentation signup flow and injected hostile JavaScript into 178 organizations. Companies like CNN, Zoom, HSBC, Equifax, Salesforce, and IKEA. Apparently, the code tried to hijack

[00:40:00] crypto payments, skim cards, steal cookies uh and screenshots, and load iPhone exploits. Optimizely says it closed the hole the same day. So the question is should the public be concerned? So you know I think they should be concerned about centralized systems that are old equipment uh and you know and trusted vendor scripts that need to be rewritten right this was not a coordinated mega hack. Uh for me to my eyes at least the ground stopped and optimizely were the worst of them. Uh the fixes are all boring. Essentially we got to rewrite legacy handbuilt software and modernize the legacy hardware and interfaces. So, uh, I went to you, Alex, on this and asked what's your opinion. Uh, you said no big deal. >> Yeah, it was a nothing. I mean, I unfortunately I I was not in the position, although sorry, Dave, I I I know you were in the air when this happened. I was not in the position where I needed to fly. So, I I I don't want to write it off completely. It was terrible inconvenience for for all

[00:41:00] concerned. But at the purely technical level, I I I think I is there some grand scheme here? probably not. Is this if if you want to squint at this and tell some sort of story uh in in some cases it's been reported that some of these outages were the results of attempting to uh to produce patches for software. Sometimes patching software can be just as interruptive as as vulnerabilities being exploited. I if I had to stitch together a conspiracy theory tying together all of the recent Infra issues without reference to that I think pretty hilarious Saturday Night Live spoof, it would probably be something about how we have aging hardware, aging software infra on the one hand. On the other hand, AI has now made vulnerabilities and uh CPEs and exploits too cheap to meter. And there's just going to have to be a a great overhaul of all of our

[00:42:01] hardware telecoms software infra stack to recognize that there's now a new asymmetry between the both the needs of modern software and super intelligence to consume bandwidth and compute and also the capabilities of modern super intelligence to be able to discover flaws in the existing legacy stack. And if you look as just another barometer at the Linux kernel, Lenus Torvalds thinks now we're actually past the peak of number of patches to the Linux kernel that AI is discovering. I don't know whether that will hold up or not, but to the extent that we're in some sense past the worst in in his view of AI discovery of software issues, maybe this will just take a couple of years to percolate throughout the rest of the economy to some of the slower lanes before finally we have an upgraded stack. >> It's amazing how concentrated our risks

[00:43:00] are getting, you know, over time. Everything is built on a few platforms. the entire US aviation system can go down from a single point of failure. That that alone is remarkable. But you I was on a plane uh coming from SF back to Boston and we were over Minneapolis and then everybody's iPhone at the same time gets the same news alert saying something's wrong. All flights are grounded. Nobody knows why. So there's immediate like, you know, panic ripple goes across the entire plane. >> Did you get diverted or did you land in Boston? >> No, very few flights got diverted. It actually worked out fine for me, but what a show for everybody trying to leave. I couldn't believe when we when we got into the airport. the the line filled the entire big snake filled the entire terminal and I was estimating how many people are in this line and how quickly is the line moving from the back of the line was eight hours to the front of the line and more people were piling into it >> and so you know everybody's like I missed my connection and you know I can't seem in Bangkok and and it was just it was just horrific for everybody

[00:44:00] outbound and it was totally fine for flights coming inbound because they they generally went to where where they were originally originally destined to go. But man, I talk about like single points of failure pop up all over the place. And I I think you know there there's a cyber security issue that's percolating, but there's also a vaporware issue that's percolating where a lot of really kind of cheesy startups have have popped into the world with vibecoded frontends, >> right? >> And when they pitch them to a government >> software >> Yeah. have big software. You know, in the old days, like four years ago, if you built something that graphically looked like it worked and you click on the buttons and it worked, you must have done some coding. So, there must be some competence in your company. Now, if you're selling to the FAA, you could literally be totally fake and vibe code something using AI in about an hour. And from the FAA's point of view, it's like, wow, that looks like really good code. You guys must know what you're doing. And so I worry a lot about

[00:45:01] this this vaporware window we're in right now where it's transitional because the AI is getting so good that it actually can build, you know, solid server side code now too. But there's a whole window of time here where there's just so much garbage, so much so much fake garbage flying around. So I wonder to what degree, you know, some of these issues are not cyber security. They're just they're just they're just vaporware. >> Yeah. you know, >> you know, we've got we've got a whole we've got a whole civilization now that's so totally connected but not resilient. >> That's a dangerous combination. >> Yeah, >> that's a good point. You know, I'm the eternal optimist, but just to be clear, we are going to see major cyber attacks. >> We are going to see systems coming down. Um I don't know if it's next week or a couple months from now, but I mean people need to be prepared for that. Um, and that will be a transition period until we go and, you know, and patch up all of the old C and C++ handwritten

[00:46:00] code that's still in existence in background. >> It's it's not just that, Peter. It's all of our cyber offense is now human out of the loop with agents attacking multiple vulnerabilities in parallel at scale, but cyber defense is still human in the loop, patching one port at a time. That asymmetry is going to be ugly until they reorganize the entire cyber department of every major company in the world and government. It's going to be a very brutal 6, eight months. >> Every time I see a cyber disaster, I'm actually happy in a way that it's not a catastrophic nuclear meltdown type thing >> because we need an angry voter base to get the government moving. And there's so little motion and nothing we we talked Eric Schmidt about this four times. There there's nothing is going to move the government until it affects votes. And so we need those votes to happen with as little tragedy as possible because we need AI post AGI governance. You know, it's going to be totally different than pre- AGI governance, but they haven't even started. Just like if you look at what's

[00:47:01] even in being proposed, it's so trivial compared to what needs to be done. So these these you know like an FAA outage is actually a really good one because nobody died but it was massively inconvenient and that's that's probably enough to get voters to get active in the in in in like change. We need massive amounts of change and and much faster reaction. >> I I would worry though it it's it's such an opportunity to false flag if there's an outage of some important system point a finger at AI. point a finger at some politically expedient target when in fact it it could just be bunch of copper wires that haven't been replaced with fiber optics. I I I worry in an era when AIS is getting so politicized that outages far from being prophylactic and encouraging cyber vulnerability patching will instead get weaponized against

[00:48:00] broader progress with super intelligence. That would be my word. >> Totally. I totally worry about that constantly too. It's the same concern. >> How long before the systems are hardened, you think? How long before we have vulnerabilities still in the in our infrastructure? >> Oh gosh. I mean, I I can see scenarios where humans will be visiting other star systems and there there will be legacy code stuck in the starship or whatever it is and and it's unpatched. I think there's a long I think there's a long tale just just like we were talking about earlier with SF hosting multi-t trillion dollar IPOs on the one hand and having a a fentinel epidemic on the other. I I think we'll have interstellar humans riding on and Verer Vji dwelled on this just a little bit in in his novel Deepness in the Sky riding on legacy code bases that still are unpatched. I I think there is going to be like a and we wrote about this a bit in solve everything. I think there is we're in the middle of a great patching

[00:49:00] moment and it goes by a few different names, the great refactoring, the great factoring when super intelligence is going to be broadly used to fix every vulnerability, the the software equivalent of curing the top 5,000 diseases. But just because you've cured the top 5,000 diseases doesn't mean that it's been implemented in every possible patient. Same idea with software and especially embedded software that's just being used in the physical world without any plausible convenient ergonomic way to update it or patch it. >> Yeah. And >> there's a great comment from one of the there's a great comment from one of the viewers here called Tiffany. Inconvenience is the best case scenario. Catastrophic failure is the worst. We need leaders who don't leverage the mindless insecurity and fear of the masses. We need folks who can lead for real. I think there's a leadership failure in some of this also >> and also the inconvenience of replacing your 1990s hardware systems all

[00:50:01] connected to the web all sitting pretty for uh for cyber hackers. >> There's a lot of cost of upgrade is so much lower now though it's inexcusable to not upgrade ancient garbage given how low the costs have become in just the last year. Yeah, like if you're a year from today if you haven't patched your 1990s software, >> it's inertia. >> It's inertia. People not, you know, people don't pay attention till it happens to them. >> I I do think it's a market opportunity at the same time. So maybe rather than just lamenting purported failures of leadership, let's all adopt our own purported moonshot mentality and call out to entrepreneurs, go build the next trillion dollar company solving all of these embedded hardware, software issues, and make embedded hardware and software that never succumbs to all of these upgrade itis issues. >> Especially if you're if you're semi-technical, not you don't have to be super technical, but you're semi-technical, but you're very very articulate and you have good social skills. One of the highest callings

[00:51:00] right now is go into JP Morgan, go into Goldman Sachs, go into Madna, go into, you know, some of these big very very profitable companies and and work on the where's the data problem? How do I connect AI to it? How can we do this securely? You know, a lot of that is just social engineering trying to figure out what is the legacy system and you know, the people who wrote it are usually long gone. So you have to there's a lot of sleuththing to do, but that that's kind of the missing ingredient right now. >> Dave, go into SMMES. There are, you know, hundreds of thousands of small and medium-sized businesses that need uh, you know, need their systems overhauled. Need someone to walk in and say, "I'm going to redo your security. I'm going to rehaul your system." And any business owner who doesn't take advantage of that offering is is waiting to be hacked. >> Yeah, that's right. And you'd be surprised how big that void is. You know, you'd think, well, hasn't somebody already tried and stepped in and had that conversation? But AI came up came upon us so much more quickly than the internet that that community just hasn't developed, you know, quite yet. It just

[00:52:01] it's just so laggy. But if you go to any random company that you happen to know, go to anybody who works any friend of yours who works at at some midsize company and say, "Has a credible entity come to you with an AI upgrade plan?" And nine times out of 10, they'll say, "Not a single meeting yet?" >> Yep. >> It's like, "Okay, that's your opportunity. Step in there and and fill that void. All right, I'm going to move us to our next story. For me, the big story of this week, in my personal opinion, was the success of Starship Flight 15. So on Saturday, Mezzilla caught a Starship for the very first time. Ship 42 lifted off on Friday evening from pad 2 at Starbase, reached orbit, deployed 26 Starlink V3 satellites. SpaceX said it made contact with every one of them. They're working. After a long coast, after 22 and 1/2 hours, it deorbited, re-entered, lit three Raptors on the landing flip, and dropped into the tower's arms, uh, and made history. You know, for ever since

[00:53:01] I've been in the space business for the last 40 years, uh, fully reusable spacecraft have been the golden, you know, the target. It changes everything. This is a big deal. Let's watch an epic video. Uh, this is a video of Starship landing. Uh, filmed from the Mezzilla Tower. All right, take a look. See

[00:54:00] Oh man, I wish I was there. I couldn't make it. But watching the crowd just [clears throat] the roar of excitement, it was like, you know, the great believers of humanity's future were celebrating. The super heavy booster aboarded the tower catch diverted to an offshore landing in the Gulf. Remember uh on the first attempt of the super super heavy capture, it worked. And also on the first attempt of the ship capture, it worked. On Sunday, uh Elon shared his vision for Starship V4, which he says is going to be 70 m long, roughly 40% increase in length and 60% increase in propellant. Uh Starship engine count will also increase to 9 with three more high thrust raptor vacuum engines. I posted my own math uh of this on X. So if you look at a mature reusable refuel and go transport system like a car, a ship, a plane, fuel typically represents only 25% of the operating cost. So when Starship goes high volume, fully reusable with the propellant cost uh initially estimated a

[00:55:01] million to $2 million per launch that implies a total cost of four to 8 million per flight or 27 to 30 to $53 per kilogram. Right? Just to remind you, uh, the space shuttle was operating at about $54,000 per kilogram. This is a,000fold reduction in cost. And what it means is that the average 150 lb American, which is, you know, how much I roughly weigh, uh, can go to orbit for roughly $2,000 to $4,000. It's the same as a first class airline ticket. It's epic. Hours later, Elon tightened the fuel number. Uh he said propellant cost per flight will drop to $500,000 and payload will increase to 200 tons which means a per person ticket price could drop to below $1,000 per person to orbit. Uh I I find that awesome. Let's take a look at a uh a quick image of uh of what Steve

[00:56:01] Gerbbertson posted. Um, and we're going to be doing a a pod with Steve uh this coming week. So, here you see the cost per kilogram on the left axis running from $100 to to $51,000. Uh, and on the bottom, this is the time frame. And you can see, you know, the improvements in the old style systems, which were, you know, use once and throw away. They were basically ICBMs. You pull a warhead off the top and you fly them, were were pretty flat. Uh then you saw Falcon 1, Falcon 9, Falcon 9 Heavy, and now Starship, and we see this plummeting and and this is a curve that shows genius. Um and it's it's extraordinary. >> Alex, over to you. >> Well, my first reaction I wrote on X, the solar system is cooked. And I I I meant it. I I think this is one can analogize this easily to so many important moments in human technological history. But what what I think strikes

[00:57:01] me the hardest is the transition that computer networks made from circuit switching to packet switching. It some of some of the folks here may remember circuit switch days when telephones and computer networks used to actually have a physical require a physical circuit in order to pass data. And there were at at the time that this was happening in the 70s, 80s, and uh '90s almost until 2000, there were wars over what the best way to packetize information would be so that information bits could be fully decoupled from atoms and you couldn't send one bit of information in a way that's agnostic to its physical carrier. the first packet, first internet packet or I should say the first arponet packet was sent in the late 1960s. Some would suggest that is when the singularity happened and not now. But I I think this is the packetsw switched moment for space in the sense that you remember how

[00:58:03] Jeff Bezos and Blue Origin were basically on paper laughing at Elon and SpaceX for requiring so many Starship flights in order to achieve a moon mission versus more monolithic proposals. And I think the recovery, the successful recovery of the Starship upper stage, Starship uh with uh with these tweezers uh with with these chopsticks and Mechazilla. >> Yeah. Um w with but in in a reusable way. This I I think underlines that we're going to have a this is matter um this is an analogy. We're gonna have a packetsw switched solar system where like ju just like with uh with cargo containers with standardized shipping containers you can packetize matter and ship it all over the world. The fact that it's now possible to do this with whatever you can cram into the current version of Starship or the next version of Starship. These are going to be individual packets and we need to stop

[00:59:01] thinking about monolithic missions like the way we used to assign names to uh say the the space shuttle back during the the era when NASA dominated human space flight. We're we're moving past the named space mission era to an era when a space mission is going to be composed of hundreds or thousands of individual packetized flights. That's what the last year >> that that then self assemble where they are to meet the mission. >> Correct. That re refuel on demand and the packets meet up in in LEO and can refuel and they come and land and it's no longer about the individual craft or rocket or engine or vehicle anymore. It's about just they're interchangeable and they're all constantly going up and down and sideways. That's new. >> I think shipping containers is the perfect analogy. >> Yeah. >> Um agreed. See or Dave, any thoughts? Well, one, just so you can remember, it's a it's a dollar a pound. If you if

[01:00:01] you say, "Hey, this weighs about a pound. I want to put this in orbit. How much fuel do I need to get this thing into orbit?" It's a dollar a pound. >> Yeah. >> There's actually a a used clothing store outside here in Cambridge called dollar a pound. So, you can remember it that way. [laughter] Dollar a pound. That's where Elon's going in that next bubble, which is only a year from now. So, >> um I I think it I literally get chills watching that thing come down and get caught. It's just unbelievable. I look forward to the day that it becomes so routine that I don't get the chills. >> Yeah. >> Uh that will be a cool day. >> Yeah. You know, it I the lore has it that when Elon sort of set out the Mechazilla strategy because why are they doing that? so they can catch it, refuel it, remount it on a booster, and go again uh theoretically in hours. Uh you know, people people thought he was insane. Uh but it's it's a beautiful architecture. It's >> a great example of uh the future is

[01:01:00] faster than you think, which is somewhere up here. >> Yeah. >> Um you know, the the the convergence of technologies. There are a couple of good examples in that book, but now what we're actually living in should rewrite the book actually. But if you think about the the process of landing [laughter] the process of landing this massive thing and exactly you this tiny little landing zone, you know, the confluence of technologies including GPS and and everything else. The feedback and control. How many other things can we invent now that take advantage of that level of feedback and control precision? >> Uh there must be thousands of things that we're not even thinking of right now that are suddenly possible. I I had a conversation this morning with the head of moonshot thinking at Laya Laya Biosciences and we're talking about the fact that you really have to delve into the area of crazy to try and really focus on moonshots because you know the Mechazilla mechanism is kind of insane and you know we talk about this all the time the day before something is truly a breakthrough it's a crazy idea if it's

[01:02:00] not a crazy idea it wouldn't be a breakthrough it would be an incremental improvement so where inside your organization are you thinking about crazy ideas and it's really hard. You know, we're so landlocked in our belief of what we can do, what is possible and there's self-imposed limitations and during this period of super intelligence, we need to literally shatter those expectations. And one of the best ways to do that is, you know, brainstorm with your favorite LLM like, okay, what's a crazy idea that would be 10 times bigger? And then go and pursue it. I read a really cool analysis of uh you know they to to land the way that Elon is landing you got to carry the fuel for the retro rocket. It's it's not a tiny amount of mass that you have to carry. Why don't we land like the space shuttle did you know just glide in and then you have to have this huge you know undercarriage weight but you don't have to have all that retrof like yeah dude we're going to be landing on other other planets that don't have runways. [laughter] I want to be going everywhere. Like,

[01:03:01] what about that? Like, oh yeah. >> But I mean, well, one can steelman this also. And and if if you squint at the the grid fins on the most recent Starship version, one could easily imagine a multimodal Starship 567 that doubles as what the space shuttle should have eventually been that can do maybe not necessarily even needing propulsive landings on Earth, but is able to do propulsive landings on the moon or Mars where atmospheres are thinner or non-existent while still being able to do a glide. I could imagine now that SpaceX has developed AI religion and is using AI design that we eventually do get sort of the perfect unified synthesis of the original space shuttle concept and the Starship. >> Yeah. >> Yep. >> Um I'm excited. You know, I I sort of consoled myself of not going to launch by saying we're going to be seeing thousands of these per year, so they're going to get old eventually. But man, oh man, what a beautiful moment.

[01:04:01] Congratulations to uh everyone at at SpaceX. All right, let's move. >> Somebody somebody put uh somebody put Rick Chhat says self-docking technology has come a long way since the Roomba. [laughter] >> Well, well said. >> It's better than the jet bridges on most airplanes. >> Uh all right, I'm going to move us to the whole chips and China conversation. Uh so let's weave three stories together uh on chips in China. One's diplomatic, one's regulatory, and one's policy. All aimed at who gets access to build super intelligence. So on November 15th at the PAC Silica founders retreat in San Francisco, the US and nine partners signed the San Francisco Declaration on the Secure Foundations of Enduring Prosperity. I love this name. It it feels Asian in some way. I don't know why. Uh the signitories are the US, Australia, India, Israel, Japan, uh the

[01:05:01] Republic of Korea, Qatar, Singapore, the UAE, and the UK. Uh they are treating economic security as national security. Uh and I think that's a a really critical point. There are five working groups that have been stood up covering policy, adoption, supply chain, safe harbor, and security. Then comes the hard edge. Politico reported on November 16th that Commerce Bureau of Industry and Standards has an interim final rule expected in the Federal Registry that would require licenses licenses before selling or shipping advanced AI chips to Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand and Brazil. Uh these were gateway countries you know for China. The aim is the remote control, the remote compute back door being closed so that China doesn't get access to these advanced chips. Politico said it would hit companies including bite dance and Alibaba. The third story uh and this is one Alex that you flagged this morning

[01:06:00] is out of the White House reporting that the Trump administration is weighing a rule that would make US companies tell you when they're using Chinese AI. Reuters reported that the Treasury Department and the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, this is Michael Kratos's gig, have discussed requiring companies to post their use of Chinese AI models on their websites. Airbnb, for example, uses Alibaba's Quen to power its AI customer service agent. The logic is simple. Chinese openweight models like Kimmy, DeepSeek, and Quen are cheap and good enough. and the three most used models on open router in October of this year. They were all Chinese. Hawks fear that the hooks uh US company that this hooks US companies on Chinese AI. Uh Airbnb says that AI runs overwhelmingly on US origin models and Chinese models are used uh and run only through approved US providers. So I mean my take is I'd rather see a label than a ban. you know, uh, clear disclosure, I

[01:07:02] think, is important to have. Uh, we've heard conversations, you know, people are stockpiling the opio models because they're fearful they're going to be taken down. Uh, so Jent, Seem, you first. What do you think about this? >> Um, I thought there was a couple of interesting things here. I thought that the way they've done the subgroups is very interesting because you've got these five working groups, which is a very interesting organizational design, right? It's like a network of countries trying to coordinate. I fear that it's a bit uh bolting the door after the horse is gone uh aspect to this. So there's not to thrash an old metaphor. Um but I think this seems uh a little bit too little too late. Um um and I'm concerned that a blanket approach is going to risk kind of harming some of the ecosystems we want to build. Uh I'm particularly interested in what's happening with India where they're a signatory but they

[01:08:00] desperately need compute. They have no uh compute in of any kind. Indian startups are really really struggling on this one. So it's going to be interesting to see how this plays out. >> Did you bring some GPUs in your suitcase to Thailand? >> Yeah, I've been carrying them along in my carryon. [laughter] >> Alex, uh you know, Pacilica, this potential ban on use of openweight models. thoughts. >> The sili the silicon curtain is descending it would seem. So we see on the one hand the pox silica and on the other hand the pox cynica which is in historioggraphy this is the the term for periods of relative stability in east Asia that are chinaacentric. These two could not be more visibly in opposition at this point. This is like cold war 2.0 with two basically carving up the world or at least attempting to carve up the world into two different spheres of influence in the form of different chip

[01:09:00] stacks, different models, import export restrictions. I I'm even reminded the the notion of labeling it it perhaps it goes without saying that we label our physical goods in in this country. They're actually required uh under interpretation of 1930s era statutes. those like made in China, made in Vietnam labels, those don't get applied at the moment to digital goods like models. So, I I don't think it's a terrible idea. Just like we would say, you know, pick up uh plate and say you look under it's made in China, you pick up a model, you look under and say this was trained in China. I don't think that's necessarily a terrible idea by itself. I'm also not sure it moves the needle that much. I'm not so convinced that enterprises or individuals if they have to put up the equivalent of California's Prop 65 warnings that oh we we've used somewhere deep in our tech stack a Chinese model whether that will be any influence at all on consumption

[01:10:01] by users. I tend to doubt it but I do think it's symptomatic of a broader issue. It goes back to the the Jensen debacle, which is >> battle lines are being carved right now. And there is there is a move to to do the great decoupling between America and its allies on the one hand and China on the other and to just to encircle them in in some sense with our tech stack versus their tech stack at least for the moment. All of these, the the Jensen drama and the the made or trained in China labels and the San Francisco declaration, all of these are just facets of the great game which has been played throughout the centuries between all the great powers. Right now, the great game is fixated on super intelligence and it's being played between largely the US on the one hand and China on the other and a whole bunch of bystanders and enterprises are getting caught in between. Dave, look, are we are we are we strengthening

[01:11:01] American leadership through these restrictions or incenting the rest of the world to develop alternative stacks? >> Of course, we'reing this is this seems really dumb policy from my perspective because you're going to and because the open source and open weight models are so good right now, you're going to drive everybody to that model. >> We did this in the aerospace industry when we put, you know, export restrictions on US satellites. It just meant that the European and Asian satellite uh manufacturers became more capable and competed with us. It happens over and over again across the board. Um >> I think the analogy though has a has a huge flaw in it. I I think it all comes down to hardware and not like the open source models don't matter a wit. And I'll tell you why. Because you you can take one of these models and you can transfer learn from it. You can use the thought traces to create a new clone off of it. You can you can disassemble the layers. Now, we're we're doing a lot of research with that in our quantization group. It's just it's this really amorphous product that it it just

[01:12:03] doesn't matter. What matters is where are the freaking chip fabs and what hardware is this all running on? That's the only thing you can measure, control, contain. Trying to trying to do anything related to the software is just a joke. You know, it's like you [laughter] can you can ban it if you want. It doesn't matter. You can retrain off it so quickly anyway. You know, the Chinese proved that if you take an if you take a foundation model, even if you don't have the weights, you can use it to bootstrap your new model for onetenth the cost. If you do have the weights, it's more like 1/100th the cost. And that's getting better. You know, with AI assistance helping with that, that's getting better and better by the day. So the software is not containable in the age of AI. Uh hardware and data centers are the only thing that are containable. And then you have to be careful on the hardware side too because the computing substrates are going to start shifting very quickly now. New physics will be discovered very quickly. Photonic computing will come online. So it's a you have to really race ahead of like where's it going next? Where's it going next? It's where I'm really really

[01:13:00] excited about potentially talking to the White House about this. You know what is the three-year view of photonic computing? Because it's all fine to ban the current GPU way late. Like you said, the horse is way out of the barn. Let's ban the current GPU. But the new computing substrates, well, what about them? They this won't even matter in 3 years. What about the next thing? So it all what matters is regulation at the hardware level, not at the software level. >> Interesting. Alex, do you agree? >> Yeah, I mean there's there's I think an implicit trade-off between short-term benefit versus long-term benefit of call it technical protectionism. in the short term if if if you think that we're in a race to um I mean I I think we're already in the singularity but uh call it a a max Q event uh of the singularity that could happen next year in 2027 then it if that's your mentality then it might actually make strategic sense to

[01:14:00] try to throw sand in the gears of China even if it means in the long term it just spurs Huawei to deploy more of their chips to Chinese frontier labs. Even if there it's not a long-term deterrent or a slowdown for them. If we're only months away from a max Q moment of the singularity, then every minute might actually count in the strategic calculus. If on the other hand, you think this is like years or decades away, then it doesn't matter at all as just bad policy. And Alex, to play this out for those listening, it's because if you when you hit that Max Q moment, any advantage you have is massively accelerated. >> Yeah. This is like, you know, to two racers on a I don't know, a a marathon or something. pick your sports metaphor and the finish line is potentially within sight and now they're shoving each other, jostling, doing all sorts of things to throw each other off their game because the finish line is so close and every second counts. >> So what does that look like by the way

[01:15:00] in 27? What does it look like if we're, you know, is it hard takeoff as we've described it? Surely you're not asking me to to spoil the predictions episode that that everyone's [laughter] going to want to do for New Year's. >> Oh, that's going to be fun. Yes, we do our predictions episode every year. >> And Alex coming up soon. Yeah, >> Alex is like 10 for 10, I think. >> Um, >> this year is We should do a retrodiction though, judging ourselves on how I I will say like I I feel pretty good about my predictions for 2026. And I have some spicy ones for next year. I I've missed Optimus on Mars big time. Anyway, [laughter] >> I don't even remember what I said, so I would have to go back. >> We'll dig it up. We'll dig it up. I >> I'm sure you guys have kept receipts somewhere. [laughter] >> I'm going to go and and re and edit the video so I come out better. All right, our next story. Well, Starship was making history at Starbase. Uh the same company, Space XAI, and again, full disclosure, it's my largest holding uh was breaking records on the ground in

[01:16:01] data centers. So Dodge designer highlighted a semi analysis report that SpaceX had finished Minihard part of the Colossus 2 campus in the Memphis area in about 5 months. A new site called Gun Range just south of the Tennessee Mississippi line is targeted for a roughly four-month build. Semi analysis says that most comparable projects are still fighting for an 8 to 12 month timeline. So I mean one of the questions is why is Elon able to build things you know two to three times faster than everybody else. Um he's got projects like Macrohard uh is the largest existing hall on Colossus 2 about 700 megawatts of requested power. Minihard is the new building next to it about 450 megawws. Macro harder is the next expansion. You know you got to remember Elon's a teenage kid when he names his projects. >> Jesus Christ with the naming [laughter] God help him. You know, the speed is not a one-off. Semi analysis says Colossus 1 retrofit put 150 megawws online in 122

[01:17:02] days and a later Colossus 2 retrofit put 210 megawws online in 91 days. So, uh, this is extraordinary. So, why so fast? Semi- analysis points to a dense hardware culture. You know, Tesla builds modular electrical and cooling gear so they're not stuck with vendor lines. You know, this is Elon's playbook. you know, verticalize, own every component of your system. Um, and then construction steps run in parallel. Uh, those build times and the 2.4 gawatt figure at that are semi- analysis estimates, you know, uh, end of the day, uh, it's pretty extraordinary the speed that he's building. Uh, Salem 4month green field data center, if they hit it, uh, it's a new tempo. What happens to everyone else when the build time, you know, uh, is moving faster? I mean, you know, >> this kind of speed. >> Yeah. This kind of speed creates such a

[01:18:00] massive like an exponential learning advantage, right? Cuz every time, every cycle, you're seeing things that other people aren't even getting to and therefore you're able to create learning loops around this. I mean, this is the organizational singularity made tangible, right? His competitive advantage is not from better technologies. is coming from the organizational velocity he's able to achieve which is now into physical. And that's kind of an amazing comment to make that. This is such an such a huge uh vector he's on where he can take any domain with hardware in it and just completely change the cycle time. >> Alex, he machines that builds the machines. And this is another argument for the SpaceX Tesla merger, isn't it? It >> it gets better. One of his data center sites is being named spam. And it was the warehouse where Hormemell was literally manufacturing spam products. >> We we've come full circle in this economy from from a warehouse.

[01:19:00] >> Yeah. From a spam factory to a spam factory. >> [laughter] >> It's funny you say that because last night uh Rob Fischer texted and said, "Hey, we can get half a gigawatt of power uh over sorry half a megawatt of power over at the hood yogurt factory." They they've abandoned that space. So I might grab that. Actually, we can put about I guess about 500 GPUs over there, but it would be the yogurt equivalent of the spam factory. When when we first >> this is not >> when we first came from India to Canada, my mother gave me lunch of fried spam because she read somewhere it was really good and I was like what are you reading? This is terrible. What are you doing to your kids? What are you doing? What are you doing to your kids? >> I want to say something about like beating swords into plowshares as applied to yogurt and spam. It It's an interesting [laughter] set of reasonzonings that we're going through. Oh my god.

[01:20:00] >> Culture GPUs. >> Oh my god. [laughter] Um, okay. >> Well, I think I think one thing that's that's missing from the story here is that AI is the greatest management tool in the history of all management. And one of the challenges actually I put in front of our team is for our interns when they come in, have them buy a piece of land somewhere in the country and build a house on it and then sell it for a profit and we'll split the gain 50/50 with them. And they go, "These are like high school seniors. What do they know about building a house?" I'm like, "Exactly. This will teach them to use AI. AI knows everything about how to build a house." And you know what happened historically is you go talk to a contractor, the contractor tells you a million things you can't do. Now you go to AI and you say, "Why can't I do this concurrently? Why can't the framing and the flooring be done at the same time? Why can't the foundation be done sooner?" And the just gives you a straight answer and you use that to manage the construction. Also the other really underappreciated thing is video capture AI in the if you're building something in the physical world every

[01:21:00] action by everybody working on it can be very easily translated from video feed into event or action like what is this person doing right now and that is the greatest management tool in the world hugely underutilized. One of the coolest things I've seen is they're taking robots on onto a building site and they're painting where the pillars and stuff would go from the drawing so that they have absolute millimeter precision as to where they're making their cuts and things. Incredible to see the progress that's happening around all that. >> And you're going to see this accelerate. I don't think 10x is going to be possible, but two or 3x when you put robots in the learning loop, right? where the AI is simply, you know, tasking the robot to do the thing and the robot's giving back feedback and it's just optimized in that fashion. >> I I I Jacu, Peter, I think you're thinking too linearly. 10x should be minimum in in what's going to come from this. >> Maybe we all the systemic compounding of everything.

[01:22:00] >> Yeah, we saw some Alman talk about this, right? in terms of uh robotics building next data centers. But I guess OpenAI also shut down their their robotics lab, didn't they? >> Well, they they shut down their their team dedicated to a dedicated robotics model because Astra GPD.x is doing is such a good generalist model passes driving bench. You don't need a specialist robotics team or model anymore. >> But I think they also shut down their humanoid robot effort. It will be interesting to see. I I I think it was actually their team focused on dedicated robotics. Now it's part of a generalist effort. And Anthropic has a generalist effort, too. They're all competing against each other to see which of their mainline generalist models can do really well at all these robotic manipulation tasks. >> Speaking about generalist models, yesterday OpenAI released GPT 6.2 Soul and GPT 6.2 Astra. Opening eye says Astra is its first release model to meet the quote high threshold for AI

[01:23:01] self-improvement. Altman posted quote these models can do amazing things and are very token efficient. A Frontier Lab is now formally rating its own product as a meaningful accelerant for AI research. Alex, over to you. Um, what do you think of GPT 6.2? Yeah. Um I my preference is still Opus 5.5 and Fable 5.2. But I am very glad that OpenAI at least according to Noam Brown from OpenAI is now releasing at least one of the in previously internal models responsible for their major progress aka slop drop in math. That is a very good sign. There are a number of leaderboards out there that track AI for math capabilities. Until this new model, until the 6.2 series was publicly available, the number one model, Peter, this will make you and probably Google happy was actually for for a few days.

[01:24:01] It was Gemini for Carbon, I think. And it that is no longer at the top of the applicable math leaderboard. It it this seems like progress for math. It seems like progress for the benchmarks that OpenAI cares about. We talked on the pod about life val seems like progress for doing well at a given price point on the ARC AGI 3 challenge. On the other hand, there are a whole bunch of people complaining that it the model just smells wrong that it's it gets itself caught in doom loops if asked to perform certain activities. I I would say anecdotally, and again, the model is newly out, so take this with a huge grain of salt, but anecdotally, my go-to is still Opus 5.5 and Fable 5.2 for their overall balance. >> Yeah, it's incredible how long Opus 5.5 has held uh that crowning reign. Um it's

[01:25:00] been many months. >> It's been all of like what, a month and a half now. [laughter] >> That's a long time. We get bored so quickly. My goodness, it's ancient. Long in the tooth. >> That [laughter] is funny. Opus [snorts] TV. I mean, Alex, sorry, not Opus. Alex, do do you uh what's >> the difference? [laughter] >> Do you uh Opus 55 is about a quarter the price of Fable 52? >> Um, is it better at anything though? I I've moved everything over to to Fable 52, but I'm paying through the nose. >> But is is Opus actually better at anything? >> I mean, depends on the task. Uh so if if you look at the broader leaderboards then you'll conclude Fable 5.2 is marginally better than Opus 5.5 at a much higher price point. So if if what you want is fast reactions, tight feedback loops andor lower cost at the moment in for everything that I care about Opus 5.5 is just chef's kiss. It's

[01:26:00] an amazing It's a good model, sir, as the the popular expression goes. And it would take it would take a meaningful step up from Opus 5.5 right now to get me to switch to something else. >> Interesting. Because with with 52, you're right, it's slow as but then you can put it in fast mode for only twice the price again. [laughter] >> It's actually pretty responsive, but it's like, wow, this this is getting to insane price points. >> Yeah. Um I there are upsides and downsides to each and you can always pay I from time to time I'll pay for the privilege of just using um what according to the the frontier charts regardless of the horizontal axis what according to the vertical axis is the best model. But in in terms of overall balance of responsiveness and big model smell uh and capabilities across a broad range of tasks OPUS 5.5 right now for me is the utter sweet spot. It is an amazing model. >> And then Astro 62 they brought in at about half the price of Opus 55. Is that

[01:27:00] right? >> Yeah. I haven't uh I haven't looked at the direct price comparisons, but they're both last I checked uh on the AI frontier chart. They're both on the frontier. >> Mhm. >> It it depends also on what reasoning effort you set for each. And open AI has not been in in my view hottake especially good about when they present their comparisons against anthropics models about making totally clear what reasoning level effort is being set. >> Well, we're going to need to get much more scientific about this topic soon only because right now AI is so mind-blowingly capable and cheap. It's just like this is just a miracle. Everybody's overjoyed with the miracle that it exists. But very soon people will want to deploy hundreds or thou or thousands of concurrent agents. Uh and then they'll say, "Oh, wait a minute. Now I got to be thinking like if it's half the price but one notch lower, is that a good buy or is that not a good buy?" And you know, am I routing the tasks to the right models? And all that

[01:28:01] complexity right now is just kind of a zoo. >> Like like I joke if if if only there were a company, let's call it hypothetically open router. And if if if only there were a popular way to route uh and benchmark on a price performance basis across a generic API surface. If only. >> If only. >> Oh god. >> All right. I'm going to move us to our final story and it's a fun one. Uh this is part industrial moonshot, part floating city. In other words, seasteading. Yesterday friend of the pod Palmer Lucky posted this render showing in the slide right now. massive concrete block in the open water with smoke stacks, towers, and gardens on top. The seasteading company is called Slab, and it's designed with a thousand-year design life. Love it. Uh the goal was to be cheaper than land and absent quote absent state and local laws that critical American industries, including metal processing, medical research and treatment, desalination, oil refining,

[01:29:01] and chemical engineering. He and a few friends including Joe Lansdale wrote the check uh cashed it up to a billion dollar valuation back in 2017. He says there's been significant progress but there's a long way to go reviving manifest destiny and westward westward expansion. I love that. You know having new lands to go conquer has become difficult. You need an army but building you lands is something that is now possible. He calls it a project designed to make America stronger. quote, "A relief valve for ill-considered or outdated rules and regulations, not a way to escape the United States uh uh you know, governance." Uh he and his uh he's not named a location yet, uh a size, a budget, a builder, or a date. Uh sitting outside state and local rules would not automatically put a platform outside of federal and maritime law. Uh seasteading is not new. Alex, you and I have talked about this. uh you know it's been something we both uh have written

[01:30:01] about and dreamed about. Uh the sea setting institute was founded back in 2008 by Patrick Freriedman and Wayne Garlick uh with early backing from of course Peter Teal. So, uh, Jent, uh, you know, a fun story, a thousand-year life. You know, I was flying back with Palmer on his plane from when he won the wildfire X-P prize, and he was telling me about this. You know, there are many South Pacific plateaus where the water is uh only, you know, hundreds of feet deep. Uh, you can build pilings and you can stabilize this platform out there. basically build it in the large ports in in South and Central America or in US and then you float it out uh and then you stabilize it and [clears throat] you've got you know a launch port or you've got a you know regulatory I love this longevity research facility where if you want you're the you know wealthy or national leaders you can go there and get access to experimental treatments

[01:31:01] that are not allowed uh in the US yet. Alex you've been tracking this for a while. Your thoughts? Yeah, I was a big supporter of the seasteading institute back in the Patfree Freriedman early days. Joe Londale was involved around that time as well and then more recently under Joe Quirk. I I think we I've made this point on the pot in the past. I think humanity thrives when we have frontiers and I think we're starved of frontiers right now. The internet not so much a frontier these days. Super intelligence arguably a frontier. Space arguably still a frontier. The oceans could be a frontier if we get our act together and start building seasteads and ocean cities, which is why I'm generally in favor of it and doing what I can to support it. But I I think we need more frontiers. And I think there is an unblock now that we didn't have maybe in the early days of the Seasteading Institute, which is Starlink. We now have the ability to get high bandwidth to almost anywhere of

[01:32:01] interest on the Earth. That simply wasn't an early option in the early days of the seasteading movement. It is now. There's another factor which is data centers not seeming to be very popular terrestrially. So the the same impetus that could and and seems at least on a trajectory to drive data centers to orbit and build out our Dyson swarm could potentially also be the the missing driver, the missing killer app for seasteading, namely oceanborn data centers. And those data centers could become the nuclei for ocean cities or or seasteads. I I think this is within the realm of possibility. So I I would say there were in summary two missing factors for why now and why we didn't get the dream of ocean colonization decades ago. One was on the supply side that you need a way to connect it up to the broader economy. Starlink solves that. And two was on the demand side. You need an actual economically valuable purpose for being out there other than

[01:33:01] just like oil drilling or something equivalent. And now maybe if data centers are persona non grata gratai excuse me on on on land keep my Latin correct then maybe uh ocean oceanic data centers will be the demand side killer app and we can finally get ocean colonization. you know, he makes the point in his uh in his ex post that this was pre- data centers that was not the driver here. It was simply, you know, was liberation. Um, Salem, your thoughts? >> Two things. I think, uh, I love the moonshot. I mean, it's great to have more than just Elon doing completely and utterly crazy things. It's it's we need a thousand people like this thinking where the only limit is your imagination, right? I think that's incredible. It's great also. It's been going on for a while. Uh but for me, the interesting thing is not about putting like a factory in the ocean, but you're

[01:34:00] you're trading an operating environment for industrial innovation that is the product. Like there's a whole foundation there of really interesting uh futures and I think that's really cool. Um I so I really really look forward to seeing what happens here. Uh I'm not really a big fan of seasteading. Uh, I feel like we we evolved for billions of years to get out of the ocean. Why the hell are we going back in? But indust [laughter] industed [laughter] data centers and so on. Uh, the sea is just really corrosive. It's really hard to navigate. You know, all those world islands in in the UAE never worked out. uh erosion is a very tough model to to beat there. But we've run been running oil rigs for decades perfectly fine. So in theory, this should work fine. And there's infinite amount of space. You want abundance. There you go. There you

[01:35:00] have it. >> Yeah. I you know, I think if this works, we're going to see hundreds of these, not just one. >> It's twothirds of the the Earth's surface, and we're just wasting it, right? And we haven't even properly mapped it, let alone colonized it. And it seems So agree. >> Yeah. Now is as good a time as any to, you know, we speak of manifest destiny in the US, but there is a certain sense, I think, in which the oceans are uh at at ocean level and and subsurface, I I should add, as well. The oceans are a a final frontier that we really should be aggressively developing. >> They have energy, they have cooling, they have lots of different attributes we can use. They have space. They have mystery. They have uh there are many many opportunities there. I think >> for sure. Uh all right, gentlemen. Uh you up for some questions? >> Absolutely. >> Always. >> All right, let's uh let's go to AMA with the mates.

[01:36:00] Okay, let's see here. See, uh you get first choice. >> Oh, I got to go with number one there. Okay. >> Uh, let me let me make this bigger so I can read it. Uh, when agents work for weeks, which business functions shift first from supervising tasks to supervising outcomes? And that's from Sully D7809. Um, you know, I think there's going to be huge batches of business functions that shift. I think first would be customer service and customer operations. They're really the outcomes are very measurable. So, and it's bounded. So, you could handle deal with resolution rates and customer satisfaction, all sorts of retention measurements. And so, there's a huge opportunity there. But the opportunity, the shift will go way past just customer service. Um, and we in this whole organizational singularity, we've been talking about coordination activities which were typically done by human

[01:37:01] beings now gets done by AI agents. and doing that you could coordinate for a long time very effectively. By the way, um just to put a placeholder here, we're just finishing up the pilot that we've been running for 3 4 months. The results that are coming in are unbelievable. One the first company we've looked at to see where they ended up. They took a process that took 20 days and now they're now doing it in 38 minutes. And so I'm really I can't believe how excited I'm feeling about what's coming out of that. So I'll report you'll share that fully on that. >> Yeah, we'll we'll get I'll get much more data. We're just aggregating it all right now. This incredibly exciting to see. But I think the organizational redesign is a massive shift towards how we're going to use agents to run all of our organizations, our government departments, our impact projects, etc. And all the orchestration and harnesses are just about there for that. So super exciting. >> Nice. If you guys don't mind, I'm going to take number two. Uh, what should education look like in a world where preparing for a job is no longer its

[01:38:00] main purpose? And that's from Stefan-Sswe. Uh, Stefan, you know, I've talked about this extensively and it's my, you know, next chapter of my life, reinventing education here. I I think what it looks like is using education for a few main things. Number one, shaping your mindset, right? The way you see the world is critically important. You know, your mindset, the way your neural net works as as a as a kid or as an adult is how you deal with opportunities and threats. What's your immediate reaction? How do you parse that information? Number two, helping you know somebody through educational process find a purpose in life. Some, you know, a passion they love that helps other people find a purpose because when you're given super capable, you know, superpowers from AI and robotics, where do you point it? You know, what do you love? What do you wake up every day with a hunger in your heart that you want to go after? Most kids and most adults don't know their purpose. My favorite quote from Mark Twain is there are two

[01:39:01] important days in your life. The day you were born, the day you find out why. So helping that kid find their purpose is a massive unlock. uh education should be about how to use the top AI tools and then learning entrepreneurship and instead of getting a job which is giving agency to someone else to give you a means of living, find your purpose, find something you want to solve, use entrepreneurial schools, use the latest AI models and build a solution, become an entrepreneur. Um and is entrepreneurship for everybody? probably not for everybody but it's for a much larger percentage of the population than currently are using it because it's become possible. So I think that's what education becomes giving kids agency to take control of their own future. Um and you know the more entrepreneurs in the planet and entrepreneurs someone who finds a problem and solves a problem the better the world is. Uh so that's my rant on on the future of education. Sure. Here. >> Okay. Uh Dave, over to you. Three or

[01:40:03] four. >> All right. I get number three. Could one AI directly adjust another AI's weights while teaching a robot a new skill from Frank Nef 2148. Yes, absolutely. I'm super excited about that. Thank you for asking. Uh there's there's a new paper actually out of MIT Cale. It's called weight space programming. So you're adjusting the the parameters directly with a neural net. So one neural net is is putting thoughts right into the brain of the other neural net. >> There also a lot of stepping st it's a very hard thing to do but there's a lot of stepping stones along the way. And so I might roll this into a prediction for next year. But the progress on this is going to be incredible. I know that already actually just from our internal work here. And you can do it the hard way by by trying to adjust individual parameters but you can also do it modularly by changing just the attention side or by adding entire new expert modules. uh and that that actually is an easier stepping stone to what you're talking about here. But this is going to be a huge breakthrough for AI because what we've done historically in AI is

[01:41:01] retrain from scratch every single time. Go back to bare metal, build the whole thing over again, and nobody ever cared about better ways to transfer knowledge uh until the training costs got really big. Now it's a hund00 million to train a frontier model from scratch. So all of a sudden it's worth recycling. And so there's going to be huge progress on this. But the short answer is yes. It's 100% possible. Tons of research going on in that area right now. Super exciting. >> All right, number four is for you, Alex. >> Number four asks, "Where is AI making real progress against viruses from longcoid to HIV?" And this is from TRP C8M. I think this is pretty obvious. Merna and OpenAI announced a number of years ago that they were well the partnership has been in place uh for I think three years. They announced more recently that it even existed. It is, I think, borderline obvious at this point that all of the major frontier labs are training off of

[01:42:00] genomic, probably multiomic and proteomic data as well. There's quite a large body of evidence. Folks go into the frontier models from anthropic and open AAI prompting them with genome sequences. I I wouldn't necessarily recommend prompting them with viral genome sequences, but prompting them with genome sequences and measuring their perplexity of the extrapolations. And it's the the same mechanism that uh the the authors and their guilds when they're suing the frontier labs arguing that they've violated copyright laws for training off of their books. Same concept. You prompt off of known text, in this case biological sequences, and you find that they're able to predict the remainder. they've been trained off of real biology. And so to the broader question of how is AI making real progress against viruses, I mean I I could flippantly cite a bunch of studies in the literature of particular point solutions to particular antivirals, but I I think actually the better answer is

[01:43:03] much broader. Um, and so I'll open parenthesis just for SEM. um Mechanize uh which is a a spin-off quasi spin-off um of of Epic AI folks. When they first started up, they posted a really interesting essay arguing that for some problems, not necessarily specifically antivirals, but for some problems, including problems in medicine, it's almost easier for the broad capacity of civilization to increase versus narrow capability increases. And I I do think that is likely to be in substantial part the case for AI progress against viruses. Yes, you can do point solutions for particular viruses, but I tend to think the the solve everything mentality of increasing our civilizational capacity by training off of basically all biology, all biological sequences

[01:44:00] anywhere, building those into our generalist frontier models to the point where the models speak biology and think biology is actually where most of the the net long-term progress against virus is going to come from. In the short term, it's probably Maderna using chat GPT tools to speedline all of their regulatory approvals and other paperwork. >> Uh there is, you know, uh to give a a quick citation, there is a AI discovered broadspectctrum antiviral that's called MDL001 that looks strong in animal models right now. Um and so I think this will come and Madna is very much focused on on this area as you as you so noted. All right let's move on number five six seven and eight sem over to you. >> Uh I think I got to take number seven. Uh what should an AI entrepreneur in India build when local infrastructure lags Silicon Valley? And that's from

[01:45:01] Kurran Jane uh091. Um so you know the obvious answer here is to you don't try and compete with Silicon Valley because you don't have the capital to build large foundational models and you've got huge expertise dedicated researchers uh to do this but what you can do is focus on applications uh and local problems where India has a massive advantage right so consider you help a small business um operate use a voice only agent to operate in multiple Indian languages. Uh you'll suddenly expand your business in the scope because people forget India has 20 different major languages with different scripts for each language. It's a complete uh patchwork of different u um cultures etc etc more like Europe than the US. Uh and so the the opportunities to manage that complexity with AI are

[01:46:01] absolutely huge. So I would just as an example build a voice first agent that would help businesses interface with different customers different languages that would create unbelievable economic value. Um there's already huge opportunities in taking very spe specialized workflows uh training with your hands and mapping that etc. So I think there's incredible opportunities. You don't need to copy Silicon Valley. who can build on it because the money is usually made in the application layer, not the infrastructure layer or the model layer over time. >> Great. Alex, >> can I do number six? It's a bit >> I was going to grab that, but go ahead. Go ahead. It's fine. >> Offbrand, but I I I can't resist. Uh, so number six asks, "What happens to democracy if longevity breakthroughs led dictators stay in power for centuries?" And this is from William L. Ramse. So, um, I'm sure you guys have all seen the Charlie Chaplan 1940 movie, The Great Dictator, where Charlie Chaplan is

[01:47:01] pretty bold for the time. Um, is basically it's a parody of Hitler. And at the the end of the the speech, Charlie Chaplan's character delivers a pretty, I think, moving speech that includes the line as, and so long as men die, liberty will never perish. And th this question I think speaks to that Charlie Chaplain line which is if people can live forever then dictators human dictators can potentially live forever as well. But I don't think actually that concern will stand the test of time. Even though it was an inspiring line in the Charlie Chaplain movie, I don't think it will stand the test of time. Why? Because people as late as the early 1990s used to talk about software as immortal. And what actually happened is software itself which doesn't have all of the necessarily biological frailties of human meat bodies itself is very much

[01:48:02] not immortal. Software has vulnerabilities and bugs and it operates in a complex ecosystem. And so software for it to survive has to be patched. It has to continue to evolve. Similarly with humans, I'm less concerned about a god emperor in the Frank Herbert style maintaining power for centuries because I I think the actual real world universe that we live in is so complicated that living for centuries is probably going to necessitate transforming oneself, reinventing oneself. if you will, at every level of the stack. In the same way as say if you wanted a piece of software to operate for decades successfully without falling over, that software is going to ship of Thesius style need to be patched beyond recognition. Same two for any wouldbe dictators. you know, to steal man this, you know, if you guys remember the hot

[01:49:00] mic moment, uh, I think it was last year when President Xi and and Putin were discussing organ transplants and and and she saying, you know, some predict that they could live to 150 years old. So, there's no question that these individuals are looking towards longevity to maintain themselves. But I think at the same time, you know, AI or SI is empowering the public. Um, and you know, dictators only stay in power so long as they're able to oppress their people. Uh, and I I think the people are becoming more powerful than ever before. Uh, Dave, you want to take uh number five? That looks like a good one for you. >> Uh, sure, I can take five. Could startups trade control of their businesses for access to a lab's mo most capable internal models? And that's from Wandering Joy. Uh yeah, and this is actually a frustration of mine. OpenAI already has a program for that and Sam Alman is great as an entrepreneur who's turned into a foundation lab CEO. He

[01:50:00] gets it. So he's the only one I know of that has an active program. It's relatively new. Um but inevitably this has to be done by all the labs. You know, rather than saying everyone's going to lose their job, why don't you say here's the road map of the future where everyone can contribute and here are the rules. And that's exactly what this question is calling for. So I really hope Anthropic gets its act together and does a program like this where you know they're not going to give their best models to someone who could use it for an evil nefarious purpose. But an application program where you're vetted and you're let under the hood and you know you don't have to give your control of your company to them. You just have to share the equity upside. I think that's an inevitably great outcome from the foundation models. and then or labs but open AI is already there Google is not as far as I know anthropic is not but they should be uh so yes I think that's a very likely outcome all right number eight can robotics

[01:51:00] finally make recycling work at the scale our waste problem demands and that's from MJ Bitcoin and I think the answer is yes it's not just robotics it's exponential technologies I can't wait for robots to be cleaning up the beaches here in Santa Monica going along the 10 and the four or freeway and picking up all the garbage. I mean, it's it's pretty incredible. But, you know, one of the things and we had an X-P prize for this years ago uh that uh never made it. I still love the idea. You know, a uh a dump or a you know, a waste management site filled with everybody's crap is resource refined elements and capabilities. So I always thought it'd be interesting to have a machine that basically goes into a dump. It grinds everything up into a slurry. It spits it out and then you know electron beam charges the particles as they come out and it sorts it into organic matter into copper into into silver into gold into

[01:52:03] plastics and and basically take a a waste dump and make it a resource uh refinement facility. I think that is something which is uh which is very capable in the future uh and and some way for us to recycle the the world that we are you know consuming and and tossing out in our trash. >> You know it's funny Peter out out in California uh where you are everything is always three bins you know all the restaurants and everything have three bins. You've got compost recycling and trash and then you look into the bins and everything is in every bin like the compost you could never possibly compost it. It's got plastic in it. It's got it's just, you know, everything's everywhere. Um, but it be it'd be so easy to build an AI capability that that sorts after the fact anyway now. So, it's got to happen. MIT actually MIT does have that though, Dave. Uh, you know, walk around the MIT campus, MIT

[01:53:00] trash bins, the three stream recycling have little cameras with an AI attached to them that will offer you the option of looking with computer vision at whatever you have and recommending a stream. Yeah, that's pretty cool. >> Or catching you if you if you put organic matter into the uh recycle [laughter] bin, >> big brother. >> Well, you know, if you if you make it social stigma, that's no fun. Just just sort it after the fact. But the microplastics issue is a major crisis actually. >> I didn't realize how bad it was, but a very good >> seven grams of plastic in your brain. A credit card worth in the average human brain. It is crazy. >> Oh, Jesus. >> All right, everybody, please send us >> Wait before you get there. >> Yeah, please. Before you get there, I've got two or three quick quotes I want to give from the comments. >> Yeah. >> Mr. Duckets 5818 says, "Need AI to tell me why I'm so addicted to this show." LOL. Appreciate the work you put in, fellas. Then B Greer 4752 says, "I always feel fired up after an episode as do we, Mr. Greer."

[01:54:02] >> Chris says, "I want I want Peter to live longer. He can steer human agency in space." You got this. >> Thank you. I'm working on it. Um, so we're all working on And by the way, we have an epic episode coming out with David Sinclair on the future of longevity. So that's coming out in a few. >> Oh my god, it's crazy. >> Oh, it was so good. It was so good. All right, please send us your outro videos. Uh, here is one from our dear friend CJ Truheart. CJ, thank you for posting. Everybody else, please catch up. We want your outro videos. Send them to us. You can send them to media diamandis.com. All right, everybody. Enjoy. [music] >> Time. What mission gets [music] defined? The universe conspires when your purpose is align. When you're moonshot minded, [music and singing] your purpose is alive. You can't change what you don't see.

[01:55:01] Can't become what you won't believe. Which is why we're here to say the future starts today. Keep your mind on the moment and your [music and singing] moonshot in your mind. When you figure out your gift, let go and let it shine. So why not take the shot? Put yourself on the spot. Want to be a moon? Then you got to be moonshot my day. [music] >> [singing] >> In due time it all [music] comes to pass. Nothing here [singing] on earth will forever come to last. So what legacy will you craft? What impossibility? [singing] Will you make your unique [music] ability? This is bigger [singing] than disruption, bigger than the next. This is human evolution. This is how far we

[01:56:01] can go. [music] When we aim beyond the ceiling, beyond what's been done before, every moonshot that we're taking opens up [singing] another door. For the kid who's watching somewhere, thinking dreams are just pretend with A PROOF THAT CRAZY ideas are just where breakthroughs begin. [singing and music] Keep your mind on the moment and your moonshot burning bright. When you harness your gift, you become the speed of light. So go and take that shot. Put in everything you got. Cuz if you want to change the world, maybe you got to be mooned. [music] >> We are mooned. [singing] >> We are moonshot minded. From this moment [music] forward, you're not the [singing] [01:57:00] moon. What are you waiting for? The impossible is possible when >> All right, moonshot minded gentlemen, as always, a great one. Seem, safe travels home, pal. >> Thank you very much. I'm looking forward to getting out of this out of this hotel room bubble that I'm in. >> Out of that shirt. >> You going to work the whole way home or you [laughter] get >> uh I'll probably do both. Um because I'm once you have um internet on a flight with AI, you can kind of start doing all sorts of stuff over time, you know, you have time to kind of really get into it. So, I'm looking forward to that. >> I've got a bunch of episodes of For All Mankind to catch up on and um u and the Rings of Power season 3 dropped. So, I want to track that out. I have no time to watch anything or read anything these days because I spend all my goddamn spare time researching these episodes or being with you lunatics. >> We love you for it. [laughter] Alex,

[01:58:01] thank you for your genius as always. Grateful for you. >> Happy to be here. Thank you, Peter >> and Dave. Same. Right back at you. >> All right, gentlemen. >> Until uh our next episode's going to be with Steve Jervson. That'll be a fun one. Steve. >> Yeah. Yeah, I get to bring up my parallel universe question >> and I'm going to talk to him about is intellectual property still a thing? Should you file patents? He said no last time. This was like 10 years ago. Let's see what he believes today. >> Oh, cool. >> All right. Until next time, guys. Take care.