06-reference/transcripts

moonshots jensens spy probe anthropics debut week elons 30m robot workforce transcript

2026-11-11

So, you know, guys, I don't know. The news has been crazy on Jensen's affair, you know, on the alleged espionage. It's been flooding the media. Uh, what do you guys make of this? >> Oh, I I think it's a very big deal cuz I I think that it's not that the the facts that are out so far are that big a deal. It's that once an investigation starts, then a board has to follow through on it. Usually if they stop the investigation partway through they get a lot of crap from the shareholders for from the public. >> So then they dig and dig and dig and dig. But we know a huge number of chips have ended up uh training Chinese models partially through illegal imports partially by parking them in other countries and doing the training offshore but bringing the weights back. And that last part is technically probably not illegal. Maybe it is, maybe it isn't. But that's the part where they're just going to dig and dig and dig. This story is going to go on for a long time. investigation will turn up something new every single week. The press once once the press latches on, they they never let go. You know, they they milk it to death. I think it's a

[00:01:01] very big deal. I also think that Nvidia um strategically, you know, they don't make the chips. They're in bed with TSMC. Uh and the allocation of where that capacity goes could change, which would change the entire balance of, you know, where where the $5 trillion of value actually lands. So there's a lot of, you know, you saw AMD stock go up right away. Uh that's one of the theories. >> Nvidia's down 6% as of this moment, right? >> And the market was way up at that same time, too. So, you know, because AMD was up what, 10 11% concurrently. So, the swing is actually pretty big for one day. >> Yeah. Their their board on Sunday said they're, you know, standing up an independent committee of directors and outside counsel. uh and they made a statement saying, you know, there's no reason to believe that either national security or Nvidia secrets were compromised. But you know, the the interesting point, and Alex, we've talked about this before, just like in the Binance hack, uh I think it was like 10 days ago, it's the human is the wink

[00:02:03] link in the chain, right? >> Yeah. There's reporting just in the past 24 hours that this may have gone back at least 3 years back to 2023 with something like $8 billion of Nvidia GPUs allegedly slashreportedly being sold to China via Alice Swang and Mega Speed via some sort of Singaporean syndicate. This is just it's a bad on the face of it this is a bad look for Nvidia. It's a bad look for the pox silica. What's going on with the poxilica? The whole point of the poxilica initiative was supposed to carve out almost like a a new iron wall between or sphere of influence for the west that would keep western silicon, western GPU, western comput, western AI and super intelligence infrastructure within our sphere of influence. And then it turns out to your point, Peter, that

[00:03:00] allegedly, but now perhaps based on Jensen's public comments, there's a single point of failure. All it takes is one person at the top of one company to completely pierce the pox silica and then billions of dollars of GPU compute ends up in China. it. I I think the bigger story here is is maybe less about the the failures or foibless of one man and more about pox silica apparently being far more porous and fallible than some would otherwise hope. Well, not just that, Alex. I mean, like we were talking to Brett Adcock yesterday. These next training runs, including his, are billion dollar investments in a single training run. And the result of it is a parameter file that fits on a thumb drive. There's never been an espionage opportunity that's as leveraged as as that. All that intellectual property captured. >> We had the other espionage uh you know of the Saudi uh employee at what was it at OpenAI orthropic thumb? They put their thumb drive in the

[00:04:01] back of a TV. >> Yeah. >> Yep. Yep. No, it's it's going to get really serious here. Also, you know, if the CCP actually sent somebody after Jensen, they must have sent people after the executive staff, too. So, the board will have to dig into, okay, well, who else has been in contact with people that are CCP that they didn't know? Uh, you because they're not just after chip supply, they're after tech specs as well. And I'm sure they'll they'll far it out four or five others. >> I think this is more an influence operation than an espionage operation. Like, I don't think Jensen is sneaking out blueprints as >> Yeah. I think, you know, uh maybe liking Chinese models a bit too much was my first kind of reaction. >> Well, he's been very pro. >> Everyone's made the pun about liking Chinese models. So, but I'm >> But I'm But I mean, >> I'm sorry. It took me a while to get that whole tweet I saw yesterday was somebody said, "Uh, Jensen, you know, we talk about Chinese models, but really?" >> Yeah. So, but I think the chips being in

[00:05:02] Malaysia going via Singapore, none of this is new, right? Like there's no way the US government secret service didn't know about that and are monitoring everywhere that Jensen goes. So, one of the interesting things is why is it coming out now? You know, and I think when combined with Coher's analysis showing back doors being automatically generated by some Chinese open source models, we should probably expect a massive push by the US government and others against anything Chinese, just like we've seen robotic parts and robots from China being banned in America. Um, so I think this is a precursor of something else cuz again, I very much doubt this is like they oh my gosh, there are GPUs that have been siphoned off here. Oh my gosh. You know, like seeing >> you make a really good you make a really good point. I mean, Jensen and all the heads of the Frontier Labs have got to be the most closely watched humans on the planet by the CIA and and FBI. >> Unbelievable. >> And and so they've probably known about

[00:06:01] this for a while. And so why is it coming out now politically? >> Yeah. And like I said, the GPUs, like any of us that looked to Nvidia's numbers are like, "Huh, Malaysia is the biggest consumer per capita of Nvidia GPUs. I wonder what they're doing with it, right?" Like the GPU is going, this was all known. And again, the question is why now? And so, the expectation is this is a precursor for a big push back. In terms of Nvidia's board, it's all stacked with Jensen's long-term partners and others. Nothing much will happen. And I mean, if Jensen did step aside as CEO because of this, I mean, Dave, what would that do to the NVIDIA stock price? I think that would >> destroy it. >> There there's no there's no succession plan at all that I can detect. It would be devastating. >> Yeah. >> Um, you know, because the physical assets, it's a it's almost entirely a virtual company. You know, the physical assets are near zero. So, it doesn't have fabs. It has a lot of patents. It has a lot of uh interconnect technology, but doesn't make any of it. And so you

[00:07:00] can't do kind of like uh Tim Cook at Apple kind of rode it, you know, keep optimizing the physical construction of the iPhone and ride it out without really innovating. There's no equivalent at Nvidia where you just kind of ride it out without innovating. You have to innovate. >> Yeah, he has 42 direct reports as well. So imagine replacing him. >> I I mean I I I do think on the timing front, it's worth just speaking to the elephant in this room, which is the midterms. This is handing a new Congress on a silver platter a scandalous salacious excuse to in investigate Nvidia, investigate Chinese connections, and investigate in general the AI/SI industry from a national security perspective. >> Stand the gears, slow things down. >> Yeah. >> I mean, here's a question for you. Do you think that Chineseborn researchers will be allowed to continue working in frontier labs? Historically from a regulatory perspective that's been the domain usually of the executive less so I mean

[00:08:02] there could be statutes but usually fastm moving regulations regarding foreign nationals and sensitive technologies are the domain of the executive and I so I I think it's up to this white house as to whether it wants to start to exclude foreign nationals from super intelligence. It certainly has the option to as I understand uh it its applicable regulatory role whether it will choose to or whether it will try to distinguish between access to some sensitive say frontier models that haven't yet become publicly available. Don't know could go either way. >> Well, I think that's a no-brainer. Foreign for foreign citizens are almost certainly going to get whacked. Uh, I think the question is Chinese-born US nationalized or US naturalized citizens, will they get whacked, which is very toxic. I think I hope that doesn't happen. >> Yeah. If if you look at all of the frontier labs, I mean, there's a significant double-digit percentage that are are Chinese uh born um US citizens

[00:09:03] right now, right? the the the Chinese people as a whole have performed, you know, in the math olympiad at the highest levels. Um they're have a a a predilction towards being brilliant in these fields. And I remember at one point, you know, XAI was like over 50% Chinese engineers. Pretty extraordinary. >> Well, we're not stereotyping here at all at this point. My goodness. >> No, I mean if it's really >> Yeah. If if it's a brilliant population, uh, so be it. >> Well, what what I will say though, I I think we're maybe conflating the issue of ethnicity with nationality. Statutoily from an export control perspective, the export control, you're you're exporting either to a foreign national. So if you're a US person, regardless of nation of origin or ancestry, if you're a US person, US citizen, a US permanent resident and and you're physically within the US, my

[00:10:00] understanding is that's not an deemed export. Whereas if you're a a US person who is overseas or you're a non- US person like non US citizen, then that's an export. So I I would expect from an export control perspective, which is probably the the most enticing regulatory instrument for deciding certain employees at Frontier Labs may or may not get access to certain critical and emerging technologies. I would expect it to come down to nationality, not ethnicity. I don't think anyone is suggesting ethnicity based exports. >> No, no, not ethnicity. It's it's where were you born, you know, it's not it's not an ethnic thing. >> Nation of Nation of origin is a protected class in this country. I I I don't know. >> Is that true for nuclear research, too? I'm not I'm not entirely sure how that works, but if you're if you're working on nuclear weapons and you were born in Iran, uh like my sister actually was born in Iran. Um are you working? >> Not that I know of, but how would I know? >> 30 seconds asking for a friend

[00:11:02] >> 30 second explainer. So the Department of Energy maintains what it's what's called the Q clearance letter Q uh clearance system uh which is their version of security clearances. And so yeah, my understanding is um there's a DOE investigation process. If it's anything like the Department of Wars investigation process, it's a function of US usually, I think, US citizenship and then whole bunch of criteria on top of that. I mean, let's be clear. This is this is the biggest um uh economic engine on the planet. This is shooting for, you know, dominance of a godlike intelligence. I think we're I think we we know a minute fraction of 1% of the uh influence campaigns and espionage campaigns going on. And I think Dave, you said this, you have to assume I mean, you're having a conversation with somebody at MIT. I won't say who saying,

[00:12:01] you know, there are probably quote unquote Chinese spies throughout the organization, right? >> Oh, yeah. Yeah. No, that's 100%. Every university >> has a big problem. Also, the did I tell you the robots uh the Chinese robots were they they investigated internally within MIT and they are definitely transmitting video and audio back to China. So, they had to actually put all the robots in a separate room and they're still there, but they don't let them walk around the labs anymore. So yeah, that was a I think they pretty much proved it. I don't know if they're going to publish that or not. >> I'm going to say something. I think long term long term this the trust issue will cause them major problems over time, but short term >> I think you will see security clearance being required to work on any frontier model. Number one, it'll be classified in that way. Number two, I think you're going to see some witch hunts. And number three, I think you're going to see them come hard after Chinese open source models. I think that's what this is all leading up to. What is coming what does going hard on open source models mean? Does it mean

[00:13:00] shutting them down? >> You can't use open source models in any mission critical software to do with the government or anything like that in case it installs back doors automatically like the coher study showed. >> Yeah. Any regulated industry, no Chinese models are allowed. >> Exactly. Regulate banking, insurance, all other regulated industries, cars, drones, uh you know, anything that could be spying or dangerous. Um, and I really feel like uh inside any frontier lab or any research lab at all, there'll be a push to say, "Yeah, don't don't run any Chinese models that could be spying or transmitting or it's just just so easy to transmit once something's connected to the internet. It's so easy to encode things in all kinds of bizarre timing ways." I think Ahmad was talking about that on one of the prior pods. It's just just so leaky. So yeah, anything regulated, anything research. Um, >> but you know, there's never been anything like this, Peter. that this is like unique in human history because yeah nuclear research you know weapons research is highly highly regulated

[00:14:01] highly watched but it's not an economic driver for the country. You know here you have the biggest industry for driving the wealth of your nation combined with the biggest military weapon of all time all in the same tiny little file that fits on a thumb drive. I mean, nothing has ever been this big of a flash point in >> We saw the encampments for Japanese uh, you know, Americans back in World War II. I hope we don't start to see that happening here. >> I I don't think I I'm I'm not quite even sure what we're talking about here. I don't see anyone suggesting nation of origin or ethnic based anything relating to Frontier Labs. I I think the the Jensen Hong story on the face of it is the story of espionage targeting apparently CEO of of a prominent company presumably in order to siphon sensitive exports to to China. I don't see anyone that that I can maybe I'm missing

[00:15:00] something suggesting that that we're going to see a repeat of internment camps from of of ethnic Japanese uh US persons from World War II. I don't see anyone suggesting >> I'm not going there. I'm saying sort of by analogy uh requiring the Frontier Labs not to employ individuals of ethnic origin from China. I I well maybe let me steal the the other side though which is in in some sense to to Dave's earlier point bringing in Chinese openweight models as these models increase in capability is in some sense bringing people not uh before people get triggered not like uh political persons so that this I don't we don't need to rehash the AI personhood discussion here but when you take a model and you connect it via a computer use assistant type tooling to an entire environment. Maybe to Ahmad's earlier point, you embody it in a robotic body. In some

[00:16:00] sense, you're taking something with the capabilities of a person from overseas and you're embodying it either digitally or physically in the US. And at some point we the US has all sorts of controls pretty well advertised at this point on immigration of naturalbodied humans. But at some point bringing in non- US models into the US and hooking them up to the internet and robots starts to look a little bit in terms of its raw capabilities like AI or SI immigration and I do expect that to get tightly controlled. >> Yeah. Uh Seem, close us out here, would you? >> I think you might had it right. I think there'll be some witch hunts. I think there'll be strong security clearances. Um there's clearly a lot going on that we don't see. I I'm when we talk about this particular incident. I'm wondering who wins by this all coming out. Um is it uh because it's not the White House really uh so what what gives here? So I'm I'm trying trying to struggling to find the incentives but certainly it's a huge kurfuffle. I mean my god this was

[00:17:01] going to just change the game completely. How do you now price any of these stocks or IPOs going forward? >> I think China wins. I mean, China, to the extent that this was in part like a a Chinese foreign op, this makes I I think our Pax Silica effort look feckless. If you can just punch a hole right through the poxilica wall by having an agent sleep with the CEO of a prominent US company, what's the point of having a pox silica at all? >> So guys, I'm glad to be back on the pod. See, you did a great job uh hosting last time. Thank you for doing that. It looked empty with only three of us on the thing. It was like it was like, "Hey, what's going on here?" But it could be back together. >> Last last Friday when you guys recorded, I was at the Upsummit that a friend of mine, Cyrus Sigiri, puts on. It was awesome. I was there with Jared Isaacman, uh, who is just an incredible NAS administrator. And then I spent time with, uh, Keller Clifton from Zipline. He just announced $ 1.5 billion

[00:18:00] financing on 20 billion. >> Incredible financing. He announced a million Uber Eat deliveries per year is what he signed Uber up for and then nationwide with Walmart. So, you order anything, you get it 8 minutes later. We're going to be doing a pod uh with Keller up at Zipline uh very soon. Uh I did an interview with Martin Rothblat and and Dillian, the CEO of Varta. So, I don't know if you guys know Varta. It's a incredible company. uh they ship into orbit uh small uh vehicles probably I don't know about a half a meter in diameter and they carry 10 kg of of proteins that crystallize in zerog they go to any orbit they have like three on orbit right now Martin ordered one for uh crystallizing certain proteins and she explained the economics of this it's like typically it's like micrograms of a drug gets injected to a into a person. And when you can crystallize, you know, 10 kilograms of a protein, you've got

[00:19:01] hundreds of millions of dollars of product that come come down, they land them in Australia. Uh, and then I was there, Larry Pageige was there. I haven't seen Larry in ages. Uh, you know, the co-founder of Google and and guess what, guys? He listens to the pod. He's a fan of Moonshot. >> Yeah. >> Fantastic. >> That's cool. >> Super cool. >> Peter, did did Larry invite us to shoot an episode of the pod from his yacht? Uh, no he did not. Larry's keeping on the down low. Uh, very much. Do you want any photo? >> Do it on the down low. Little little chill pod on the back of the office. I'm fine. >> You can do it with video off. >> And then I I I spent time with uh with Blake Schol from Boom uh who's great. H he's happy to come on the pod. And then uh Join from Joby Aviation. Just an amazing group of of people there. That's ironic that we were shooting the pod without you while you were talking to Larry about liking the pod. >> Yeah, it was it was fun. Do you guys remember uh Sel remember the conversation you guys had about economic

[00:20:00] output per watt on the last pod? >> So, >> yeah, we were there. >> I I listen just make sure you remember I listened to it and so I went and ran some models and uh I want to give you the numbers I came up with uh because it's it's it's interesting. So uh >> you're postumously wedging yourself into that. >> Yes, I am. I am jealous about the conversation. So the question was if if you look at anthropics economic output uh per per kilowatt hour versus uh human output per kilowatt hour looking at New York City as a defined containment. Uh today Anthropic is at $4.39 per kilowatt hour uh of output per kilowatt hour. Uh and New York is at $6.30 per kilowatt hour of human output. And I took into account, by the way, food as an energy source and your home and transport to and from work. So uh humans are still doing better, but the line crosses in

[00:21:01] 2027 uh where Claude is jumping up to $6.20 20 cents per kilowatt hours. Humans stay at $6.30 per kilowatt hour. But in 2030, in 2030, claude is up now projected based on their projections and their numbers uh up to be about 40% higher than the humans. So, you know, humans stay pretty flat and and AI is increasing. >> Alex made an important point in there, which was that you all can't just consider the economic output. You have to consider the 20 years of schooling and costs that went into >> that's training. That's that's training. >> That's all the all the pre-training costs that went into getting the population to a certain GDP level. >> All right. All right. But but you know, take Seline's on the right track here. You know, a human is productive for about a third of their life, maybe half at most. And the training cost is only about 5% of the inference. So training the neural net is is running about 5% of the electricity right now. And human is so by that metric, the lines have already crossed. I think so so many

[00:22:01] different groups just cross over in the next year or so. I'll save some of my hottest takes for assuming Peter will do a prediction episode in December, but 2027 I think will be an utterly wild year where I I know on the on the one hand I usually say spaceime feels perfectly smooth where we are right now here in the depths of the singularity, but 2027 should be utterly bonkers. And who knows what happens to New York City's economic output in an era when autonomy time horizons are going through the roof. >> Okay, Alex, here's your challenge. Name two lines that don't cross in 2027. >> I I have to save that one day for the prediction episode. I have some hot takes. >> Okay. >> All right. All right. >> Talking about weird things. Can I show you guys where I am? >> Okay. >> Yeah, of course. Where are you, Sel? >> Yeah. So, I am in the press box of the San Francisco Giants at Oracle Park. Um

[00:23:03] >> Oh, cool. >> looking out over the baseball field. >> Yeah, it's empty because uh we're doing >> watching an empty field. >> There's a special there's a special event going on here. I'm just going to share my screen because I got to show you this uh insane image. I'm here for an AAI talk uh with a bunch of people and it's kind of insane. Uh I I'm gonna be standing on top of the dugout uh to do my my keynote. Okay. Um >> you've reached new heights. >> This is like weird weird beyond belief. >> I'm struggling sem to to make some sort of pun about the deep bench needing a deep bench. >> So that's uh me on the big screen there um where they're talking about the the keynote I'm about to give. And so I'm going to be standing on the dugout addressing the crowd which are going to be in the normal stands and then afterwards they're going to meet uh do a walk around and do a cocktail event etc. Very >> Are you throwing out a pitch or

[00:24:00] anything? >> No. Thank god they did not ask me to do that. Uh I'm a I'm a cricket player from India so I end up bowling rather than doing anything else. So >> now that's a moonshot. Ladies and gentlemen, >> this episode is brought to you by the Abundant Summit and Link Ventures. >> Welcome to Moonshot, everyone, your number one podcast on all things AI, exponential, and apparently baseball. Uh, your front row seat to the hypersonic tsunami. I'm here with the fabulous five. The curious quintet are here with us today. Uh, Alex Wearer Gross, our resident ASI, Dave Blondon, our guru of AI investing, Salem Ismael, our warlord against linear thinking, and Immad Mustach backed by popular demand, the man quietly coding the future of humanity. Imman, I can't wait till you can share the stuff that you're working on. It's amazing. And uh, I'm Peter D. Madness, your host, your data driven

[00:25:00] optimist. Our mission here as always help you understand what's happening, what just happened, what it means for you, for your portfolio, for your business, for your family, and to keep you optimistic. Okay, so here's our number for this week. It's 30 hours. That's how long a team of about a thousand Claude Fable 5.2 agents took to formalize formats formats last theorem. Uh we'll talk about that. Uh the same lab with their last model took 11 days versus 30 hours now. And of course, the human mathematician, Andrew Wilds, needed seven years. Alex, it feels like uh math is becoming a team sport for AI. Uh >> I think math is postcooked at this point. I I've said it's cooked enough times. I I So it's postcooked. It's time to start cooking other things. Math is in the rearview mirror. >> It's a dessert at this point. Uh if you haven't subscribed, please do. Uh we post twice a week uh cuz it's accelerating. Uh, you can subscribe on X

[00:26:00] at Moonshots_Pod. We put our most provocative clips from each episode up on that X account. So, check them out. All right, let's buckle up and jump in. Uh, our first story, let's jump into Anthropic. So, a few major announcements here. First off, on their IPO and second on their two new model releases in the last 24 hours. On the IPO front, Anthropic launched their IPO road show today, pricing the IPO somewhere around 1.3 to 1.4 trillion, down from 1.5 trillion and the previous 2 trillion valuation they had floated. The IPO is expected the week before Thanksgiving. I think there's going to be a lot of signal there as to how it performs uh going forward. Dave, do you expect a strong performance? Well, it's things are blowing hot and cold so regularly these days. You just have to pick a random day. But I think they'll do fine. The cash flow from the company and the margins are great. They're pricing it down to try and give it a pop, >> which is probably good strategy. And you

[00:27:00] know, they don't have to raise the full hundred billion dollars on day one. They can do a shelf registration and then do a secondary soon thereafter. So they I think they're doing the right thing by just get it out, started trading, you know, get the war chest build and, you know, also it's going to be a a moment where they probably bypass open AI in capital raised and valuation. >> Uh so they'll probably celebrate the heck out of that, try and make big news and, you know, encourage all of corporate America to trust their their models and use that as a weapon against open AI. So I think it's a good strategy. Um, I'm not saying buy the IPO or don't buy the IPO, but they're pricing it intelligently a little below where you know the two trillion original target. >> Yeah. All right, let's jump into the model releases. Uh, Fable 5.2 and Mythos 5.2. Reminder, Fable is for everyone and uh it's got cyber and bio uh bio safeguards built in. Mythos is being used only for vetted trusted partners. Uh they're both up 30% faster than the 5.1 versions and cheaper 8 million uh

[00:28:02] input $8 per million input tokens and $40 per out. Enthropic says in testing Fable 5.2 solved two open problems in black hole physics. Um I'm sure Alex you'll tell us about it. They designed three working devices with a circuit board company called diode. That's pretty cool. going from prompt to uh to product engineering. And as mentioned, a team of about a thousand agents formalized for match's last theorem in 30 hours versus 11 days for the last research model. They also report that Mythos accurately modeled 28 of 34 gene therapy virus shells called capsids. Alex and Iman, I want to go to you for details. Um we've got a few charts here as well as semi analysis GDPX index. Uh let's take a look and Alex, kick it off. Where what do you think of these two models? >> Astonishing. So maybe let me just start with my favorite informal 5minute benchmark for generalist models at this

[00:29:01] point which is I ask them to generate a a fun interactive rich cyberpunk FPS >> and we'll show that a little bit. Yeah. >> Yep. So uh very satisfied with the output. Talking about the the benchmarks though, this is I mean obviously we're in an era I talk about this all the time of saturating all of the benchmarks. That shouldn't be surprising. What is more interesting is the benchmarks themselves are starting to migrate in interesting directions. So, first with OpenAI, as we talked on the pod, actually at Moonshots Live about dropping Astra into a car and having a drive around via driving bench. And now with uh the the new Fable 5.2 to demonstrating exceptional performance on robotics challenges. I I really think those pure play so-called physical AI aka robotics companies that were betting on world models being a freestanding

[00:30:00] class. They may be facing a bit of heartburn at this point now that anthropic and open AI are independently demonstrating exceptional capabilities on some of these robotic manipulation tasks. We see I actually think that the black hole physics I I looked at those works I I found those less impressive than the robotics uh the manufacturing for design demonstrations coming out of Fable 5.2 extraordinary. You can just ask this thing to design physical plus mechanical plus electronic products and it will do it. You can ask it to design an entire operating system from scratch and it will do it and and the result boots up. And then all of the at this point almost quasi legacy benchmarks like humanity's last exam that we used to talk about months ago or Frontier Suite these are all saturating at this point. We need new benchmarks that will actually test these things. But the thing that I'm most excited about is the

[00:31:01] autonomy time horizons. The autonomy time horizons for these models are starting to go asmmptoically vertical. We we spoke on on the pod about the AI 2027 scenario. We are starting to see if anything AI 2027 happen months ahead of time at least what one of the the scenarios forecast in AI 2027 was calling for. And there are some predictions floating around out there. Obviously everything looks linear if you put it on a log log plot but there are log log plots now floating around the interwebs that extrapolate that if if you take the trend now in in autonomy time horizons and you just log log extrapolate them out we hit our literal singularity our vertical asmtote sometime around the summer of 2027. So it's the capacity for asmmptoically enormous hyperexponential potentially autonomy time horizons that has me most excited about Fable 5.2.

[00:32:01] >> Yeah, we're showing uh how close AI is to automating remote work on this chart and also Claude Fable 5.2 sets a new ECI record at 174. >> Look at it on the right, Peter. Look at it on the right. Fable 5.2 ahead of the ECI trend line. We're we're starting to diverge upward. Yeah, pretty uh pretty insane. And then uh >> and remote work is cooked. Remote work is cooked. Obviously, >> let's hit this GDPX uh report uh do you want to hit it? >> Yeah. I mean uh Fable hitting 16.4% like 30% ahead of Opus again remote work on the previous thing like your job will be replaced or can be replaced by an AI definitely by next year and certainly by the year after. That's what we were expecting anyway, but it's a bit shocking to see it happen. Um, Fable is an incredibly competent model. Seeing the leaps in robotics and others and just generally being able to do just

[00:33:00] about anything. Um, it can build games. >> Remind people what GDPX is. >> Uh, so GDPX is from memory a kind of uh successor to GDP val where they look at the GDP value of the economic tasks that can be done here. I can't remember what the threshold point is for humans though, Alex. >> Yeah. So, so GDPX was Semi analysis friend of the pod Dylan Patel's competitor for GDP. Val remember also semi analysis acquired Centrini who's like casually walk walking around solving scorpion neurotoxins for fun. >> Yeah. >> Right. So, so GDPX is is their benchmark to measure what models purported frontier models can actually do in terms of frontier industries. Not just like solving boring uh one might say vanilla knowledge work, but actually like solving material science problems, solving recursive self-improvement problems. And we were talking a few

[00:34:01] episodes ago about GDPX, how nice it is to have new benchmarks that actually benchmark frontier level problem solving. Hey, look, it it went from 10% to now approximately 20%. I I think hot take now this isn't even a hot take. GDPX will be saturated within 6 months. >> You said when it came out, you're you're trending right again. Yeah, anthropic actually put they put in their S1 that they have now achieved autonomy level two on their official kind of measure which is that these models just now need high level human oversight. The next one autonomy level three is they're basically can do all AI research at a solid level and I think that again is coming sooner rather than later. >> Pretty extraordinary. And then Fable is zeroing incredible games. So, I'm going to show two videos here. Uh, one uh from the from uh from X and then the other one from you, Alex. So, uh check this out. So, this is Fable 5.2. You know, basically zero shoting a really

[00:35:01] beautiful game. Extraordinary work. is that that one's that one's from Schulto, who I I I suspect put a lot more effort into prompt engineering his Portal clone than I did into my pitiful little first-person shooter. But we we'll show we'll show your your uh your cyberpunk game in a moment. But I mean for a lab that is not focused on consumer ended and not focused on image and video models. I mean damn good. Damn good. Okay, tell us what you >> What's the point of the video What's the point of the video game industry anymore? Video games are cooked. >> If if I I don't know how long Schult's prompt was for his Portal clone, but that was gorgeous. And and why do we

[00:36:03] need AAA game? I'm sorry. Why do we need AAA game studios in any recognizable form if it's so easy for Scholto, presumably just Shto, to just spin up a compelling portal multiplayer clone? >> Yeah. What was your problem? >> I think Go ahead, Em. And then we'll go to Alex's game. >> Well, I think the technology is there now that you can see you'll see even more impressive things come out where it generates the entire thing just from code. You know, all the textures, everything. But putting that together into compelling gaming experience like the new Zelda or next week is GTA 6 um that's consistent and isn't different from everyone still I think is going to be there for a while but definitely the cost of building what you could imagine is about to collapse completely and so that should hopefully free up more creativity. So Alex you think that this will be the the last GTA I mean there has to be some historic irony that we're getting GTA 6 before this part of the singularity is over. You think we're going to get like HalfLife 7? Is there

[00:37:01] going to be a Halfife singularity? >> No, they'll never ship Halfife 3. Come on. What are you talking about? >> Yeah, I think Halfife 3 is is is the ultimate like benchmark. If if Valve can be persuaded to use AI to to ship Halfife 3, then we're in good shape. >> Alex, uh, give us what's your prompt on this game we're about to show? >> One sentence. It was literally create a rich, visually stunning, interactive cyberpunk FPS with a great soundtrack. >> All right, one sentence. Let's let's watch a few seconds of it. >> That is visually rich. No question about it. >> Yeah, I actually think that the the most impressive part of that wasn't even the visuals. It was the the soundtrack. Like people were when I posted this on uh on social media, people some people were in apparent disbelief. They they were

[00:38:00] asking like had I uploaded the soundtrack along with it? And no, it generated the MIDI soundtrack. You have I I think anthropic I I don't pretend to know every aspect of their strategy, but their strategy seems to be procedurally generate everything. You still after all these months you can't get Claude to generate a raster basis image like you can with chat GPT image but if you ask it to write code to generate a symphony or a video game soundtrack or uh or a procedurally generated movie it will do a spectacular job. So Anthropics bet seems to be yes it's multimodal but it's almost like quietly omnimodal seeing every modality through the lens of code not in its native basis the way open AI is trying to >> yeah I can have a prediction on this uh in the next couple of quarters you'll be able to generate photorealistic games real time through code >> it's like the hollow deck coming into existence

[00:39:00] >> it's time >> I agree with that but critically it's code like it's all procedurally generated the anthropics and I I think it maybe that generalizes even further. It's it goes I think beyond just generating photorealistic games with code. It's literally seeing the entire world every modality through the lens of codegen. That's like they're one hammer and everything's a nail. >> Exactly. That's the critical point. Yeah. >> Here here's here's the prompt I would use. uh say to this model, go create a game studio that generates $10 million a year in revenue and then go sit on a beach in Bali. >> That should be very doable now. >> So go ahead imprompted like that. That can be the Salem bench. >> I'm really not I'm not that much into this type of stuff. I'm more interested in the human aspects of things etc. But >> you prefer the Bali side of of the equation. >> The the Bali side of the equation. >> Some beach, some >> the human a little drink with an umbrella in it.

[00:40:00] >> The human being, >> it's actually >> good. >> Out of the box, Salem, it's kind of the opposite of what you're describing it. It uh it's 40 bucks a million out output tokens, you know. So, so I was using Fable 5.1 and then Opus 55 came out, which was just as good at half the price. So, switched over. I've been using that for the last month. And then yesterday when this came out, it's just so good you have to use it. But it took me from 10 bucks to 40 bucks. So it's incinerating money at a rate like I I can't believe. And it's so brilliant. And you know everything that it does for you, it suggests 10 followons. And they're very very thoughtful followons. But you're like, "Well, wait, I'm going to fork out 10 times then 10 more times, then 10 more times. Before I know it, you'll have drained every dollar in the world." >> Fantastic. >> I mean, it's crazy. This is one of the byproducts. Yeah. Yeah. No, I mean it's it's really interesting because they're a very very ethical company, but they also have to make, you know, their public company now forecast and and the model is so much better a salesperson than any salesperson that's ever existed

[00:41:00] before. So you're like where there's an inherent conflict in here between this thing being your agent, but it's actually their revenue. >> I mean, it's really it's it's it's it could be nasty, you know, really really nasty tokens. But but I had it uh I had it take some uh neural network accelerator designs and actually go ahead and do the uh the chip and circuit designs for them. And I couldn't believe it. It just came back with verarilog files and then and then it found a a way to simulate the verilog by itself and it's like yep this will take about 20 picosconds and this will cost about five phentojoules and it'll work and we can ship it off to Intel for fab next week. I'm like are you freaking kidding me? I mean this is >> so now we're going to go ahead and >> you know Ben Ben Harowitz's book you know the hard things about hard things and hardware being hard it's now you know it's cooking it's becoming easier uh all >> hardware is cooking and and Dave I I think we need a neism for just what you were spotlighting which is the agency problem the agent agency problem of whom

[00:42:01] are your agents actually working for you or the Frontier Labs or someone else entirely agent agency >> they're working for the CFO to hit revenue predictions. >> Well, this this is a like a really important topic, by the way. Maybe we should come back to it another time, but we have our NVL72 coming online on uh Feb 1, which is our agents on our hardware, no doubt who they're working for. And we'll also have lots and lots of Fable 5.2 working who it's ambiguous who they're really working for under the covers. But every company is going to have to wrestle with this like, you know, it's much easier to just sign up for anthropic, but then who owns everything? like that your all your intellectual property and you know did if it has an idea is that your property or it's you know Odaario's property really really ambiguous where that's going to go so maybe we should come back to that >> this episode is sponsored by Google for startups think about this for a second you now have access to the same generative AI models that cost hundreds of millions of dollars to train Google's startup technical guide for generative

[00:43:01] media gives you complete blueprint for deploying Google deep minds models production, images, video, audio, all of it. Real architecture, real results. Find the link in the show notes below. All right, I'm going to move us on to uh to a particular story that you know should make your hair stand on. And so an analyst at Nicola at Nicola J2030 looked at Meter's new report on enthropic and estimated that AI's quote time horizon how long a model can reliably work on finishing a task is doubling every two months. Uh he put anthropics internal model 4 at about 20 about 240 hours. That's a 10-day project uh by a human expert meter itself uh which has deep access to enthropic found that from October 2025 to October 2026 capabilities there ran about twice as fast as the year before. So I'm showing

[00:44:00] the chart here Alex uh can you give us a understanding of what this means and how important it is? >> Sure. So first some definitions this is a chart of AECI which is the anthropic anthropics version of the epic AI capabilities index. So this is a broad basket of lots of other benchmarks that attempts to model autonomy time horizons. How long models can perform to some percentage success rate a given task that would be in the human equivalent. So 100 hours could mean 50 plus% chance or 80 plus% chance at performing a task that would require a human equivalent 100 hours. And what we're seeing is multiple eras of autonomy growth. First and by the way the vertical axis for those not looking is already logarithmic. So this to the extent this is bending upwards this is super or hyper exponential growth. we see a regime from GPT2 to GPT call it

[00:45:01] 4.5 at one slope and then we see the the next stage going up to opus 4.5 at a higher so this is super exponential growth already and then we get to the present regime that we're in where there are these mysterious internal anthropic models that anthropic keeps talking about like model 4 that don't seem to correspond to generally available models the rumor is that anthropic has a bunch of internal models like model 4 that they're keeping internally purely for the benefit of training models that get generally released. So it to the extent that's the case, it suggests several things. One, it suggests that the scenario that we've talked about on the pod in the past, which is the frontier labs are incentivized to take their most capable models and not make them generally available and use them for their highest revenue per token goal, which is recursive self-improvement, training other better models. To the extent that's the case, that would appear to be the case here. Secondly, if

[00:46:01] you just extrapolate these hyperexponential curves, 2027, as I was suggesting earlier, 20 again, I I don't actually think there there is a singularity, a literal mathematical singularity within the metaphorical singularity. I think it's an optical illusion. But if one were to go looking for mathematical singularities based on trends in autonomy time horizons like this, I think 2027 is probably where I I would look for exhibit A for a mathematical singularity in terms of autonomy time horizon >> translation. The game is the game is a foot over the next, you know, 18 to 24 months. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. We're we're in the depths of the singularity. Like take off. You're looking for hard takeoff. Look no further than 2027. Sim >> uh two or three things. First, I thought that this was uh it's clear we're I think when we talk about this, we're clearly in the singularity because there's no model by which you can accurately predict the future right now.

[00:47:00] This is like complete breakdown. So, we have to reinvent every predictable metal model. Um the the thing I got from this was this is we're getting to the point where we can delegate outcomes rather than tasks, right? And that becomes really really interesting. Well, you can say to now, you can just say achieve this objective. And right now, we're delegating tasks to AI. We're saying go process that email list, go uh figure out my calendar, go do very very specific tasks. Right now, you can say more kind of uh uh abstract things like optimize my calendar for 20% rest, uh 40% podcast, 60% whatever, right? And so there's some really interesting um kind of guidance you can give it. The bigger picture for me as I was thinking about this AI's time horizon is going to now go faster than the time between board meetings, right? So who's really running the company? So you're going to get

[00:48:00] things done so quickly. >> Slim, give me a really good concrete example. I'll just hammer it into into um 5.2 right now and it'll it'll prove your point. >> Okay. Um, optimize my calendar for >> Oh, come on. That's boring. Like, get us to another star or something. You know, >> I'm doing that. Like, we we spy explorer mission on this pod. >> Designing designing new life form for me that is able to, >> you know, get rid of all the mold in my apartment. >> Yeah. >> Here, here's one. >> Okay, >> here's one. um optimize my health protocol and wellness protocols so that I can do various things including drink a couple of glasses of wine when I want to uh plus keep my what kind of massive transformative purpose is this gave I'll give you I think I think I'm going to go back to this idea that as AI and eventually

[00:49:01] robots do more and more doing we get to spend so much more time being and I think we need to get way better at that side of it. >> I'll give you this is going to run on max fast cloud fable 5.2 to 1 million contacts max fast. You cannot more money cure cure the top 5,000 diseases. Period. >> Okay. >> Cure. >> While it's calculating that, Emod, let's go to your comment here. You were going to say >> um I think once you get to 100 hours, that's everything. Like what does it mean? Like you just reset it to go more than 100 hours, right? Like you reload it inside. So I think basically you've reached the critical mass. But I just thought of the bullcase philanthropic which is right now, you know, Dave is spending 20,000 100,000 up and down and left and right. Uh the bull case is that they're going to go to all the major corporates and say here's Model 4. You can only get it if you do a one-year upfront commitment.

[00:50:00] >> Yeah, they'll spike revenues. You're >> right. >> I love that. >> Didn't see that coming. You're right. >> Uh because >> what do we do then? M >> just because like you you couldn't have access to GPUs. They'll just say these latest models we only have a limited number of tokens >> and then what can they charge for those tokens? >> Anything. >> Yeah, pretty though. I mean they already do that like all the the top frontier less OpenAI and Anthropic will already strike enterprise agreements with large purchasers of tokens to do pre- purchase commitments. >> Yeah, but this is different. >> This is cutting off the other path. That's the scary part. I mean you can you can you can approximate one with the other again like the market I I think the market wants to clear the flops want to flow and you can always raise prices or lower capabilities per unit price for everyone who's not prepaying. >> So that's exactly they haven't lowered it yet. I emad I would expect that you're going to see anthropic begin to spin out health companies, material

[00:51:01] science companies, um you know, uh financial companies basically running on their their models because that's going to be the biggest return per dollar, right? >> Well, why would they? They can just keep it inside the same company, right? >> Even with why why would they pull a colossal? They'll do the exact opposite. They'll keep it all inhouse. >> Yeah. >> But they have like market the products someplace. >> Well, I think it depends where the product is. Right. This is the thing that this is the big question here, right? Like >> does Macro hard and open AAI go after every SAS company? Does Anthropic go and create their own peptides? You know, like these are the big questions for the next stage where they have to go from saturating to that. But there's still a long way to go here. Must be amazing board conversations. Yeah, >> clearly the answer is yes. >> Right. >> Yeah. I'm not quite sure I buy this

[00:52:00] premise. Like Anthropic's been very public about their biotech strategy at the moment. Their their stated biotech strategy is they're basically going to to first party they're going to solve all orphan diseases like all all rare diseases. I I should say they'll solve the diseases that are too quote unquote small for big pharma to tackle. And then for big pharma, they'll offer themselves up as a platform. I I think that strategy of basically owning the long tail of problems as a first party and then for the the fathead being a platform, I don't see why that doesn't generalize. >> Uh so Dave, has it solved all 5,000 diseases yet? >> Uh it says that's a big ask and it connects to the rest of this program. Let me ground this in the compute requirements. And it's running a bunch of commands. Let me give you back your bill for a billion dollars before I start running this. >> Ask Ask for your credit card. >> It's got plenty of It's got plenty of money behind it. It'll >> But just to help out here, right? If if

[00:53:00] you That is a pretty interesting prompt. And you spend let's say two billion of compute. That is so worth it. It is so incredibly worth it to do that. You spend whatever you can on that problem. I >> I encourage everyone in the So this is not investment advice. It's also not token spend advice, but should you have lots of token spend sitting around, go solve, you know, challenge to the audience, go solve the top 5,000 diseases and and get back to us. I'm I'm sure we'd be happy to to feature your your proposed solutions. >> So, Alex, what's your time frame for when the top 5,000 diseases get solved? Two years. >> Yeah. Well, actually, uh I I gave a time frame on this very pod. So next uh conservative outerbound next two to three years. I think that's a very conservative outerbound. I expect to see major motion on this from the Frontier Lab in the NE Frontier Labs in the next 1 to one and a half years. Peter, Alex, Emod, it's Dave. I asked one of my agents a blunt question. How would you actually cure the top 5,000 diseases?

[00:54:01] What came back is a thought experiment, not a result. And it's addressed to you, Peter. I've asked Steve's avatar to walk you through it. Start with arithmetic. A new drug costs about $2 billion to bring to approval. 5,000 of them is $10 trillion. That is every pharmaceutical research dollar on Earth for more than 30 years. That's not a funding problem. It's proof the method is wrong. So change one thing. Stop approving a drug. Approve a process. The gene editor, the particle that delivers it, the manufacturing line, the safety protocol, approved once. After that, a new disease is a change of sequence inside a process that is already approved. If that takes the cost of adding a disease from $2 billion to 2 million, 5,000 diseases cost 10 billion, less than 2 weeks of what the industry spends on research. The whole idea is

[00:55:00] that one factor of a thousand. And it has already happened twice by hand. In 2018, doctors in Boston designed a drug for one girl's unique mutation and gave it to her within a year. In 2025, a team in Philadelphia wrote a gene editing therapy for one baby's single letter typo. About 6 months from diagnosis to first dose. These were proofs of speed, not cures. But in both, the platform already existed and the child's own sequence was compiled into it. They stayed heroic one-offs because the system treats every compile as a new invention. So what stands in the way? Not what you'd guess. Gate one is delivery. Getting the therapy into the right tissue. By this notes reckoning, that works today for the liver, the blood, and the eye. It does not work for the kidney or for most of the brain. Gate two is diagnosis before the damage is

[00:56:01] permanent. About half of patients with a rare genetic disease never get a molecular diagnosis and the rest wait about 5 years. Gate three is the cost of a batch of one then regulation then who pays. Notice what is not first AI solving biology. Perfect knowledge of a disease you cannot reach is not a cure. So Peter three asks one a prize shaped like gate one safe repeatable delivery of a gene editor to a tissue that cannot be reliably reached today kidney or heart objective measurable unsolved and it unlocks thousands of diseases not one two the damage clock for each disease the latest moment a correction still restores function as far as this note can tell nobody has assembled Three, the regulatory lever. Since 2022, American law has let evidence about a

[00:57:00] shared platform carry from one approved product to the next. It is new. Making it truly transfer will be one by convening, not by research. And one thing back, the scarcest resource for these patients isn't money, it's expert attention. America has about 1,200 certified medical geneticists for 25 to 30 million people with a rare disease. You can't train your way out of that this decade. You might compute your way out. Whether a machine can do a geneticist's workup is not known. It can be measured cheaply on cases that are already solved. That is the experiment to run first. It's also where our work touches yours. Lightwave is designing a machine that gives one conversation a million tokens a second. It is a design. Nothing is built. This is a thought experiment. So here is what would kill it. If delivery to one tissue teaches you nothing about the next, the ceiling is hundreds of

[00:58:00] diseases, not thousands. If regulators want a full package for every disease, the factor of a thousand disappears. If a dose still costs millions, nobody can pay. Each of those can be checked. Cheapest first. 5,000 diseases, not 5,000 discoveries. A handful of processes compiled 5,000 times. What's missing is the address and the permission. One is shaped like a prize. The other needs a convenor. That is why this is addressed to you. >> All right. I want to take a second. Um I I wrote I put out a Substack today and I had a lot of fear out there and I keep on encountering it place. So I wanted to address that. So I ran some studies with Claude uh and I asked the you know every generation thinks that it's in a crisis and their crisis is the worst. You know that instinct is human uh and people are

[00:59:02] usually wrong. So I asked Claude to score over the last 250 years of American upheaval. Uh on one side civil unrest on on the other side technological disruption. So uh here you can see the the chart on civil unrest and it scores you know where we are today is number nine on the list right civil you know the civil war and secession, American Revolution, reconstruction, civil rights, great depression. I mean all of these things were far worse uh on a multitude of different parameters than we are today. Uh and I just think you know people are not you know students of history enough to realize the disruptions we've had. And then on technological disruption the top 10 over American history uh you know where we are today with AI and robotics scored number seven on the list as compared to railroads, textile mills, farm mechanization, electrification and so forth. I found this a fascinating

[01:00:01] result. Uh >> do do you agree, Peter, with these rankings? Because I certainly don't. >> I agree on uh on the civil unrest, right? So if you look at, you know, >> you think civil unrest now is worse than it was. Number one is the worst. Number nine is, you know, where it ranks number nine here is we're very low on civil unrest compared to what America had over its 250 year history. Do you subscribe to the Strauss how generational hypothesis that holds that American history is stuck in 80ear cycles of crises and the last one was like the the world wars and the great depression before that was the civil war and before that was the revolution. >> Uh I mean that's what it it pans out for for more than just uh the US history. It pans out over over many centuries. Um but what do you think about this on the civil unrest side? >> Nonsense. I I I don't think this is like if I compare what we're seeing now with Civil War and the American Revolution,

[01:01:01] the the economy is uh ostensibly doing really well. We're seeing innovations left and right. I I don't I don't perceive contrary to the crisis. >> Maybe you're reading this wrong. In other words, we are very low on civil unrest today compared to history. >> I don't think we're even in the top 10. I mean, maybe I'm just not paying close enough attention. >> Okay. Well, if you take the list at face value, number 10 is the financial crisis of 2007 to 2012, which was, you know, nothing compared to the civil war. >> Yeah. >> So, you you run out of really bad civil unrest pretty quickly on this list. >> I mean, and then on on the the second ranking though, I mean, even that uh this may be AI downplaying itself, but you you really think AI and robotics is only the seventh biggest tech disruption in American history? It's like should be number zero, I think. I I and this is this is ranked the parameters I ranked on was job and economic disruption, social backlash, public fear um uh as

[01:02:03] the primary in terms of you know what what people are expressing today and what people express historically. I mean, my my point being uh on this that we're there's a lot of fear out there and people need to realize that it's been a lot worse in previous times in history. >> Can I make a couple of comments? I I agree with Alex for the first slide. I think it's way it's not really that bad compared to >> uh freaking Yeah, I get it. I get it. But so that part is right. But I would also say this would fall off the list for me in terms of what's happening. Um but uh pre the the this one is amplified radically by social media and people think it's much worse than it is and and therefore everybody gets freaked out with amigdulas going nuts all the time. Um the for the second slide the historical perspective is is awesome but

[01:03:00] uh all of those previous changes left intelligence as the adaptation mechanism right this is the first revolution that human intelligence this is the first >> um mechanism that actually automates the adaptation mechanism itself this means a complete rethink of what it means to be human there's one other part to this which is the metabolism is so accelerated Did this is the other reason right we when I talk to audiences I basically say look the printing press changed the world we call it a Gutenberg moment because of the fundamental transformation it created in society um by the way it took a hundred years to absorb the printing press and it was the most violent century in the history of humanity okay but so we call it a Gutenberg moment because it's created such a kind of rift in human humanity we have 20 of those hitting us right now AI is clearly a Gutenberg moment uh life extension is a Gutenberg moment Blockchain and Bitcoin are a Gutenberg moment. We can't absorb this. Uh this is why all our institutions are struggling

[01:04:00] because they're not set up for today's time. Can I give my quick thing about marriage uh on this? Have you heard me talk about marriage? >> Sure. Go for it. >> So my favorite example of this is is to to show the difference between what it used to be like to today is you know we have all of our institutions, legal system, educational systems. We've talked about this non-stop. The institution of marriage is a particularly great highlight because we invented marriage about 6,000 years ago. Okay, 6,000 years ago, average lifespan was about 25 years old. So, you got married, you had kids, and you died. Marriage is not supposed to last 50, 60 years. It's supposed to keep you together for 10 years till the kids are self-sufficient. Then, you're actually supposed to die and leave your resources for the rest of the tribe, right? um we worry about the divorce rate, but the conditions today are completely different from when it was first introduced as a human institution. Uh and so this is a a huge highlight. One of my relatives calls it calls marriage uh state sanctioned torture, I think is the the phrase that she uses. Um now

[01:05:02] we're about to double I expect no comments. I expect no comments on the YouTube. I think the team at this point comment from relatives and and the the big challenge is how do you evolve the institution to deal with the conditions today than when we first created it and this is the big structural challenge. This is why everybody's freaking out. Uh we cannot absorb 20 Gutenberg moments hitting us at the same time. All our institutions break. In fact, I can't find one that survives this. like one democracy that's kind of an issue. Education is gone. Journalis journalism is broken. So for me that's the biggest uh underbelly. And it goes to Eio Wilson's comment who said the problem with humanity is our emotions are paleolithic. Our institutions are medieval. Our technology is godlike. >> Yeah. Right. >> Sel I'm waiting for the cherry on top of this ramp rant which is going to be you're going to say like blockchain is the solution for marriage.

[01:06:00] >> No no I'm not going to say I'm not going to say that. By the way, my wife allows me to make those comments. So, just to be clear about that. Um, but we have a very we have a big structural problem in that the scaffolding of civilization is essentially being wiped out by the high metabolism and so much innovation. This is why I feel we're feeling so much stress in the world. My favorite other comment comes from Douglas Adams who wrote Hitchhocker's Guide to the Galaxy. He said, "Anything in the world when you're born, we call that normal. Anything that's invented when you're young, that's called a career. Anything after if you that's invented after you're 35 years old is just bad for the world. It's blanket bad. And I think that really summarizes where we are overall. This for me is the biggest challenge. >> My my point simply on this in particular in the civil unrest is what we have right now is nothing compared to what we've seen over the last 250 years. We've survived those and we're going to survive. That's exactly right. >> Yeah. I mean we're going to have we will have disruption. we will have civil unrest and we've talked about this in this pod over the next you know one to 10 years on the back side of that

[01:07:01] hopefully to your point sem is a reinvention of social contracts uh because the world is going to be very different it's got to be created uh people need to be start thinking about this I don't I don't trust the government to be doing that I think it's going to be people like us and everyone listening um but realize we'll get through that on the back side of that is a world of abundance where We uplift every man, woman, and child. I think that's the point I want to make. >> And and just to go back to Alex's point, my marriage certificate should be registered on the blockchain. >> Okay. >> You see, I knew that was the solution. >> Oh my god. >> I love you guys. >> I love you guys. All right. Um I'm going to move us forward. So, next up, let's go into the Elon universe. On Friday, uh Elon sat down over video with Ron Baron at the 33rd annual Baron Investment Conference in New York. If you don't know him, Ron is the founder of Baron Capital. He's one of the largest outside investors in both Tesla and SpaceX. And

[01:08:01] this conference is his big annual gathering for investors. Mus said that the company is quote tracking to have an annual revenue run rate that's in excess of 100 billion in December. And he said it's quite possible that uh they're going to hit as much as 500 billion in the following year. even a trillion is not out of question. So, um I want to share five clips from the interview and then we'll talk about each of them. Again, you my full disclosure again is uh SpaceX is my largest position. So, please count me as biased in my conversations on this. So, let's take a look at the uh first video on Terrafab. Then we'll chat about each of these. So, so, so the rest of the world is making we'll make this year around 20 gawatt of AI chips, maybe 25. Um, and then next year, depending on who projections, you believe it's maybe around 35 to 45

[01:09:02] gawatt of AI chips next year. Um, and um but but if if you want to do a terowatt, that's now you need you need 30 times what current global production will be roughly next year >> for just us. We're building that for us. >> Well, yes, we're building >> I mean, we could sell it to other people, too, but basically we're building 30 times what the annual production is in one plant, which you think is going to do >> where Elon goes, "What the hell are you talking in the world?" Because the GDP for the 20th largest country, one one plant. Yeah, it might even make the top 10. Uh so, um no, no, obviously, you know, a plan like this, uh I think, um if it if it if it fails, it'll be crazy and if it succeeds, it'll be audacious. Uh so it sort of depends on the outcome,

[01:10:01] but I I think it will succeed at least to some degree. Um >> hope so. >> Yeah. Yeah. I mean, >> it's going to cost a trillion dollars. How long is that? Um um but we won't need that money immediately. We'll be built in phases. Um and and we are looking at uh ways to change the manufacturing process for for chips to uh improve the efficiency of of chip production as we've done in many other arenas. It's always amazing to me when Elon is getting interviewed or whenever we do one of these interviews, they always tell us, Peter, like, "Hey, that was the best most technical interview we've ever done. It was the best." I'm like, "The bar is so low." >> Like, what what are you talking about? Anyway, Elon is is right as as usual. Um, >> I I love I love the way Baron Ron was saying, you know, for us it's our chips, right?

[01:11:00] >> What are you talking about? Elon looks around like, "Okay, I'm just going to blow that off." Uh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. The, uh, the chips are the constraint. I worry a lot about the, um, ability to manufacture a supply chain, and then, you know, physics is getting reinvented as you're trying to build the buildings >> and and it's like, you know, the iterations are going to be so fast. But, I think at the end of the day, if you get the natural resources, you get the power supply, you get the robots, you're going to recycle all of that. So you just got to be in the hunt like Elon is and just build toward the, you know, as quickly as you can build toward the current target. The target is going to shift for humanity every six months now anyway. So just ride the wave and and fight the good fight. So I, you know, Elon is he's cornering markets upon for power, for natural resources, for regulatory approval to build things. Uh, and and that's going to pay off in spades. But you know also Anthropic is going to be miles ahead in design and discovery you know drug discovery and but also chip design uh it clearly can

[01:12:02] do it right now with Fable 5.2. So unless he catches up on the foundation model front you know Dario is not just going to give him access to you you saw in that chart that Alex was pointing to there's stuff at Anthropic now that they're just not letting out the door. They're not just going to hand that over to Elon. So, it's a foot race now between the singularity in San Francisco and the manufacturing equivalent singularity in Elonverse, which is Tennessee and Texas. >> Alex, when does Gro 5 come out? >> Elon keeps promising it imminently in the next few months and that it will meet or beat Opus 5.5. But Anthropic isn't standing still either. And maybe just to zoom out a little bit, SpaceX used to be a rocket company. It isn't a rocket company anymore. It's it's a neo hyperscaler at this point that Anthropic is their largest customer. And so I I I think I I almost wonder you remember how Peter Teal used to joke well is it that Palunteer owns the CIA or the CIA owns

[01:13:00] Palunteer? I'm I'm paraphrasing roughly. Is it Anthropic that's effectively owning SpaceX or is it SpaceX that's owning Anthropic? Anthropic is their largest customer. SpaceX, it no longer is catering to the government business, no longer catering to NASA. They're they're aimed squarely, as far as I could tell, on becoming a a neo cloud/hyperscaler, open PNS, those who can't compete compute, closed PNS, and going after the bottom stack to be the very best anthropic provider he can. And so when I hear go >> and chip manufacturer I mean putting out >> that's that's for >> that's for anthropic like anthropic is their biggest customer at this point like Elon is positioning SpaceX at the moment to be the bottom half the missing bottom half of anthropic when he talks about achieving a 100red billion uh in in ARR and then 500 plus billion. I I have to imagine that is in in the back

[01:14:02] of his mind. Maybe, maybe not, but an elliptical reference to Anthropic's revenue trajectory. Anthropic is right now monetizing the upper. >> Alex, if you're going to guess, it's a race between which two labs? SpaceX and Anthropic. >> Well, I think SpaceX and Anthropic are very much in bed at this point. So I I think if if the race we're talking about is for frontier capabilities, it's between open AI on the one hand and then the anthropic upper half SpaceX lower half. >> But that partnership access that partnership will break at some point. >> If that's what they told the Sam Alliance, >> it just needs to survive until maybe next year. We >> infinity that >> Yeah. No, no, seriously. Like if if Autonomy Horizons go to infinity next year, it just needs to survive until then and then everyone can go their own way after that. >> You mind? >> Well, I've been thinking about this and I'm like, there's clearly a massive need

[01:15:01] for open source and internals and SpaceX can win that. He should just open source all his models and then he should do a deal with Anthropic that he gets their models at cost basically. And he should use that to build better physics hardware and just out compete everyone on chips and hardware. Like why does he need to build the craziest models if he has unlimited deployment capability of anthropics models on the frontier? And why does he need to compete with them when he can have a Tesla power wall with a GPU in every company in America? You know, like he should have that dual strategy instead for the frontier. Use it to build better machines. Get it at cost from a um anthropic and on the other side own the open-source AI because that's the stuff that actually matters for society which is what he cares about, you know, and he can win. >> Well, let's let's move to the hardware side. Wait, wait, wait, wait. I want to make a couple of points. I think um one

[01:16:00] warning, right? These are like this is the target, not capacity, right? Cuz this is um uh we're kind of hoping that we can get there. We're a ways away from getting there yet. >> You say chip manufacturing >> on the chip manufacturing story. We're quite a ways away from the scale that he's talking about. But that's the the directionality is absolutely right. But there's something else here that's really important that I've kind of been running up against a lot with companies lately, which is, you know, I I was at a earlier this year at was at the Modec supply chain conference and somebody built a complete endto-end logistics thing where a robot a truck would pull up, a robot would unload the truck, load it up, take it over, and then you'd have a stockpicking robot loading up totes, and then it would get dispatched, etc. I was like, "This is amazing. This kind of solves a huge chunk of supply chain. How's it going?" And they're like, "Terrible." because uh each company has their loading department, their sorting department and they can't get it into the companies. What Elon has done recognizing this is gone, well the hell

[01:17:00] with the supply chain. We need to own our own supply chain so you get all the exponentials across the board and the vertical integration is going to become more and more critical for companies going forward. >> That's always been his game, right? And uh and Dave and I were at Figure yesterday recording a pod that'll be coming out I think after this pod and that's Brett's game too. vertically integrate everywhere. >> Oh my god, >> Brett is such an Elon. Holy crap. >> Yeah. >> Did you see that? >> Multiple hands. Did you ask about the multiple hands? >> I did. >> Oh my god. It's It goes so far beyond so far beyond Salem. You got to see what he what he's doing. >> Yeah. >> Miss that one. >> This episode is brought to you by Blitzy. Autonomous software development with infinite code context. Blitzy uses thousands of specialized AI agents that think for hours to understand enterprise scale code bases with millions of lines of code. Engineers start every development sprint with the Blitzy platform, bringing in their development requirements. The Blitzy platform

[01:18:00] provides a plan, then generates and pre-ompiles code for each task. Blitzy delivers 80% or more of the development work autonomously while providing a guide for the final 20% of human development work required to complete the sprint. Enterprises are achieving a 5x engineering velocity increase when incorporating Blitzy as their preIDE development tool, pairing it with their coding co-pilot of choice to bring an AI native SDLC into their org. Ready to 5x your engineering velocity? Visit blitzy.com to schedule a demo and start building with Blitzy today. >> All right, I'm I'm going to move us forward uh to the world of humanoids and this is the SpaceX Tesla uh maybe X company. We'll see what happens after merger. So, uh Elon's prediction that 20 to 30 million robots in America would outproduce all the humans. Uh let's take a look at this uh at this video. Well,

[01:19:00] the way to think about physical AI in the form of robotics is that um you like any given economy is the number of people in it times the average productivity per person. So if you have a humanoid robot that is extremely productive and can work 24/7. So it's working 168 168 hours a week. Um it doesn't take vacation or bathroom breaks or need to eat food or or anything like that. And um it's it's uh this the speed at which you can operate is faster than than human speed. Uh you can expect roughly a five you know a productivity per week that is uh on average five times better than a person roughly because a person's like maybe working 40 hours a week and and and doesn't need to take breaks obviously um and doesn't move as fast as a robot. So, so I say a minimum productivity expectation for human robot would be five times that of a human then um of of the you know say

[01:20:00] take the population in the United States say how many people are either in school or retired well that's about half of the people about half of people are either in in school or or retired and then of those who are working age not everyone works um or is engaged in in highly productive employment um so so then you're you're left with you know perhaps um around I don't know 120 million people in America that have a net uh positive output of goods and services. Um so so then you say well how many robots then would be needed to match that productivity? Well, I guess you you'd need um you know about 20 to 30 million robots to to match the goods and services output of the United States. And we would build those less expensive to build a robot than to build a car. >> Yes. Initially I'd say about the same. >> Uh but then over time uh it would be

[01:21:01] much less. >> So 30,000 cost per robot on the way to 20. >> Yeah. >> And we would rent those or we would sell them or what would we do? >> Do we have an idea yet? >> I think I think probably rent them. >> All right. Um, interesting. Dave, any reflections after our conversation with Brett on this one? >> Yeah, we talked a lot actually about lights out manufacturing or lights off manufacturing, which I it's a phrase I hadn't heard before. But once you have fully automated closed loop recursive self-improvement in manufacturing, you don't have to turn the lights on in the building anymore because the robots don't need the lights. They they're fine in the dark. It's like, oh, that's a really cool compelling visual. But if you look at manufacturing today, you know, it's almost entirely automated already, but the human component that isn't automated dominates the cost. You know, between the labor cost and the pension cost and everything and the and the risk, the danger insurance. You take

[01:22:00] all that last part out and the cost comes plummeting down. So, I think the question there was, you know, how how cheap are these going to get and Elon said about the same as a car initially, but it'll come down really fast. But the car will also come down really fast >> because manufacturing of everything is going to come down really fast. The other big topic we had yesterday is you know designing new mechanical devices is now a Claude Fable 5.2 thing. It's like here today. If you can marry that to manufacturing that's specific to what you just designed. The proliferation of device types is going to be massive. We don't all have to do the same exact iPhone, the same exact car. There'll be thousands and thousands of variants and new types of devices coming out by the bazillions, which is gold for entrepreneurs. It's going to be a it's going to be a magical magical time. >> What what I heard there, Dave, was we're going to see 5x and 10x the US GDP as we start to bring hundreds of millions of robots online um over the next 5 years. Who wants to jump in? >> Yep.

[01:23:01] I would like to challenge the fivey year or five time productivity thing, you know, because it's nice number, but running 24/7 doesn't take into account uh maintenance and reliability, battery outages, uh dexterity, all of that stuff. So, I would challenge that, but the the direction obviously is is is accurate, but I think it's going to be a ways before we get there. Alex, >> I I'll maybe comment the the from my perspective, the most interesting part wasn't his bit about 5x productivity. Al although I would note parenthetically the US has approximately 300 million motor vehicles and approximately 350 million humans. So approximately 1:1ish ratio and Elon predicting a 1:10 ratio of humans to general purpose humanoids. Mildly interesting, not super interesting. The most interesting thing to me is the business model of rentals. Tesla seems to be so clearly pivoting from selling products to selling

[01:24:01] subscription services. And I think that's right post inevitably Tesla SpaceX merger where SpaceX used to be a rocket company and is now a Neo cloud/hyperscaler selling cloud subscription services selling GPUs by by the flop. There is a marriage here that I think is about to happen where uh on the one hand you have SpaceX selling GPU hours uh as basically uh you know metered metered compute in the data center and then on Tesla before the SpaceX merger inevitably Tesla he's migrating it towards selling autonomy subscriptions cyber cab rentals uh FSD subscriptions and then Optimus humanoid rentals. presumably by the hour, by the task, something like that. >> Which gives him infinite borrowing power because he's got predictable revenues. >> Sure. Well, I mean, the markets love it.

[01:25:00] Presum, not investment advice, but presumably this is more attractive to the markets because it smooths out income, but also it translates humanity to the extent this is like the the industrial ecology for the future of humanity translates humanity away from an ownership model for the atoms. You don't own your your GPUs anymore. you don't own the physical labor anymore. It's everything is a rental. And I I think that's what he's converging toward. >> Interesting. >> But a rental also with a with a forward purchase. You know, like we were talking about earlier, a lot of these things are going to move to 5-year commits. And you know, we only have a limited supply. So, give me a rental on these robots, but also commit to how long is the max that you're willing to commit to that rental agreement. Very very similar to data centers. like if you weren't willing to commit to a 5year time horizon, you got frozen out. Uh same thing is going to apply to a lot of things in the singularity, including robots. >> I wouldn't to to that point, I wouldn't even be surprised if two to three years from now, OpenAI has their own robot. Anthropic has their own they're clearly

[01:26:01] moving in the direction of their own robots based on their capabilities. wouldn't be shocked if you see the Frontier Labs say to enterprises, okay, you're going to make like a one-year commitment in return for which you agree to purchase N robot hours and NG GPU hours as part of a bundle. >> Yeah, I think that we're maybe missing something here. Like I think he's actually a bit high on his 20 million robots. I think 10 million robots will do it cuz 45% of US jobs are manual jobs. >> But let's think about that. You'll be able to build 10 million robots by 2031, 5 years from now. You will be able to build enough robots to replace every manual job in America. Now, that should be top of the political agenda. I think >> you just made it. You just you achieved that goal. >> There's a bunch of If only the US had like midterm elections or something that might send regarding this topic. There's

[01:27:01] a bunch of union bosses freaking out right now. >> They should be. >> I mean, I mean, I met with Mike Row, who used to run uh, you know, I forget what Discovery Channel, dirty jobs. >> Dirty jobs. >> Yeah. We were talking about the notion that these robots are going to do the dirty jobs. They're going to do the roofing and the air conditioning and the plumbing and the welding and all of these things. >> Oh, yeah. >> Uh, Alex Mike Row is an opera singer, too. You guys need to meet and do a duet. That would be >> inevitably. He is awesome. >> I think as you move out from GPUs now because of espionage or whatever, I mean the robotics investment spending is going to go exponential. I mean, we even set up a robotics company that I'll tell you guys about. It's a bit stealth at the moment. Like it's going to go crazy. But as Alex said, the most interesting thing is the rental versus purchases. Will you be able to buy a robot as the means of production? Cuz that basically influences the economy. If you've got 10 million robots and you can basically do the entire physical economic output of

[01:28:00] America, like just think about the power dynamics of that. That's insane. >> It's insane. All right. >> Well, there's a bigger gap. There's a bigger gap on the transportation side because if you own a car, it sits empty 94% of the time, right? So, it doesn't take a big dent of cyber taxis and so on to completely change the equation on car ownership to car access. And that will completely break the car industry. agreed. Um during the conversations, he went on to talk about Star Mind putting up their first satellite in 2027 and beginning to launch in volume in 2028. He also jumped into conversation about Starlink um and potentially, you know, disrupting or replacing the Telos out there. Let's take a quick listen. >> I think SpaceX will be able to get very far with the spectrum that it's acquired. Uh but you know at certain point if if we're able to make much better use of the spectrum than um than say a legacy telco is we could just acquire that legacy telco and use that spectrum you know 10 times more

[01:29:01] effectively. >> People love that. I mean I I have to imagine uh he's going to do that. I I would be shocked. It was you know there were rumors about him uh buying T-Mobile for a while. Uh you know we're going to have Starlink phones. we have Starlink services uh and it just it will decimate terrestrial. Anybody disagree with that? >> He's going to buy a lot of stuff. Actually, I think what he's trying to do is bite his tongue a little bit and not tip the market so the prices run up on him. But after everything's consolidated and the grand merger happens, as Alex has been predicting forever now, his market cap will be big enough to start absorbing all these assets that they just take too long to rebuild, you know, and there's a regulatory cycle. he's just going to accumulate them with this massive market cap and glue them together into this this grand vision. But, you know, when you when you start talking about things too early, then the the stock runs up on you and everything gets too expensive. >> It's the new everything company. >> Yeah. I also think based on the the applause from the audience that maybe

[01:30:00] folks in that audience had what from my vantage point is a misconception that Elon is just out there to replace legacy Telos because he doesn't like them or something. SpaceX is about as I've mentioned on the pod in the past to thanks to Starship to have an enormous amount of upmass supply that has to get used for something. It could be used for data centers, could be used for telecom, has to be used for something. So SpaceX has to have a voracious appetite given their enormous supply that's about to come online. They need to justify that supply with new demand. And even if that means basically force-feeding SpaceX or I should say Starlink direct to sell via acquisitions of legacy carriers, whatever it takes, they need to somehow force feed all of this upmass into existing markets. And I think that's >> methane conversion in minutes. >> Yeah, it has to be used for something. So I think they're really hungry to force feed themselves to to existing

[01:31:00] markets. >> Can you imagine though, Alex, if if Opus 5.2 two finds the nutrino communication that you were talking about and that sort of like >> blew a hole into all >> 5.2, right? >> Sorry. Sorry. Fable 5.2. Yeah. >> Yeah. I mean, all this innovation is so fragile in the in the in the land of new physics every day and new math every day. >> But anyway, you're right. You're right. >> I'm I'm a simple ASI. I just want my nutrino phone so I can do nonline line of sight communication from one side of the earth to the other so I don't need Starlink. He might. >> Um, so is this Terrafab thing and the space data data centers a bit of a head fake in that isn't terafab just going to build the chips for the robot brains? There aren't enough of those when you actually think about the math there. Um, and does he really need data centers in space? I just still don't get it right. Like again, I think that can sustain the upmass narrative, Alex. But if I think

[01:32:00] about where compute's going to be with economically valuable compute as opposed to super ultra intelligence of 10,000 agents solving any problem, it feels it's going to be in the 10 million 100 million robots that he's going to >> prediction by 2040. >> Maybe maybe can build those. >> You're you're right. like that the head fake is a really interesting narrative cuz cuz you know in the a couple podcasts ago we were talking about him bringing online 10 gawatt and then 20 gawatts of new compute and I said in space and and you're like no no no that's terrestrial like okay that's a huge amount of compute on the land for a guy who's moving data centers into space so I don't think I think the head fake narrative actually has a lot of a lot of merit be could be cool to go off on that a little bit I don't want to step on too many landmines there but but you know he's is assembling the market cap. And once he has the terraab and he has the Optimus robots everywhere, you know, he the rockets were something that he invented before uh the singularity hit.

[01:33:02] >> Actually, there could be a head. >> Let me outline this. I think what's going to happen is this. >> Robot brains, car brains, home brains from SpaceX. If you get to a certain level of intelligence on the edge, whack them all into boxes and that's the majority of global compute. How much actually needs to be in a data center? How many geniuses do you need in space? I think very few versus the demand for that. And that's something is ideally suited for his entire supply chain. >> And so I think that yeah, the big chips aren't going to be it. It's going to be the smaller chips. Sorry, Alex. >> Maybe, maybe I can make arguments either way. On the one hand, given the midterm elections, I can make the argument given legislation that's under discussion of capping data centers or let's say light touch regulation for data centers at 20 megawatts. Maybe that creates a perverse incentive to suddenly create a whole bunch of basically mini data centers that are at 19.9 megawws everywhere.

[01:34:02] Like that could happen. People are already discussing that I suppose. But the arrow of history does seem at the moment to be pointing away from edge inference being the predominant destination or sync for all this compute that's going out there seems to suggest the smartphone the iPhone was the apex of edge inference or edge compute in general uh and from the iPhone here on we're we're headed back to mainframe computers basically data center type form factors for all this compute in which case for Optimus robots if if we tens of millions of them. I I think there's an alternative scenario where we have Starlink. It's really low latency, high bandwidth. Sure, there's some edge inference in cases where the Optimus robots are cut off and need to operate autonomously for a minute or something like that, but basically the scenario would be most of the inference for the Optimus robots can be operated from the cloud. I I so to to the question of

[01:35:00] where is the terra fab output going to go my bet is it's going to data centers >> Alex wants Dyson >> Alex wants his Dyson swarm >> it's not that I want a Dyson swarm it's that I think it's the default outcome at the moment >> it is definitely the end state it's just a question of the order of operations >> I have a short uh short-term exciting piece of this which is all the national telephone companies get decimated in this model and you move to like global infrastructure monopolies rather than uh nationbased stuff. And I think that's just generally a good thing. >> I I think that is Elon's plan. I'm going to show one last clip which I actually found the most fascinating where Elon saying the demand for digital super intelligence will come from digital super intelligence. Take a listen and talk about it. the the demand will be and this is going to sound somewhat circular but the demand for intelligence for digital super intelligence will come from digital super intelligence. It means that super intelligence will saturate all human needs by far. Uh

[01:36:03] there will be universal high income universal extremely high income um universal medical care that is better than the best medical care available on earth today. um where you could wish for a castle uh or a whatever you want basically um and and the digital super intelligence can make it for you as as a side project. So he's reading from the playbook uh uh of science fiction, you know, uh his notion that there's a posteconomic society in which money doesn't matter anymore and technology creates whatever you want whenever you want for anybody on the planet. Alex, >> I don't think it's I don't think it's sci-fi in the least. I mean, so like for Fable 5.2, to I spend a couple of minutes, single sentence, and I've instantly generated a rather amusing

[01:37:01] small video game. I I think Shelto spent a little bit more effort and gets a portal clone. It in my mind, it there's just such a straight line. Rather than spending one sentence prompting a disembodied super intelligence sitting in some anthropic operated data center, you spend one sentence worth of prompting to a fleet of generalist humanoid robots and you say, "Go build me a castle and they just go do it." This isn't, I think, that far out. I think at most a few years away. I I I think it's basically just a >> Yeah, you can get your castle and your blockchain marriage and everything else you're asking for, >> you know. So, so you know, Elon's favorite book series is the culture series by Ian Banks, right? And and that if you've read it, that's the world they're living in where everybody has whatever they want with on on a request without needing capital. >> Well, not every the civilizations that have sublimed maybe I think is a more realistic outcome which is also in the

[01:38:01] culture. Sorry. >> Yeah. Something interesting that I found. Um, so I was up to hundreds of agents building out our new thing. Now we're down to a dozen. >> Uh, cuz we found theformational overhead was actually detrimental versus just utilizing the latent space and the KV cache in the right way. >> And I think you know I'd like to give a shout out to your company physical super intelligence here uh, Alex where they had the proof of the Arensson and Barney conjecture on quantum computing. Because now what you've got is the class of problems that the super intelligences will solve. A they'll have better models themselves to do it. But is it going to be 10,000 of them or is it going to be a dozen? And B, they will have quantum computers where now we know the right types of questions uh thanks to that proof to ask them which will be very interesting cuz again what is the bounded space of compute and energy required to solve an arbitrary problem that's real world? You're preaching to

[01:39:00] the choir, Amad. I I will just say I I think we're going to enter a second physics golden age. Mark my words. >> Okay. Uh I'll move us along. So next up, a small step towards AI personhood. Alex, I looking forward to the conversation or at least a step towards AI's running companies. So Delaware, the state that you know incorporates most of the large US companies, is drafting a new kind of corporate entity. They call it a quote artificial intelligence company or an AIC. So under the draft, an AI agent could manage the business, record its actions in a log, could sign contracts, hold property, and file lawsuits in the company's name. Uh it may have any lawful, it can have any lawful purpose other than banking. Uh while this is still in draft, it's not a law. The lawmakers are going to be considering it in January. You remember we discussed in this pod about four months ago when President Millle's Argentina initiative to allow companies to be run by AI. Contrasting the two the you know proposed Argentina versus

[01:40:00] Delaware proposal. Argentina's plan still keeps a human in the loop and the company stays liable for harm uh that the AI may cause. Delaware's draft lets the I run the firm, shields the human member except in the case of under uh underfunding, fraud, or willful illegal conduct. So, Salem, um you know, I don't know if this crossed your your screen at all, but uh we talk about the organizational singularity. This seems like an acceleration of what you proposed. >> Yeah. I mean, this is the most important story from an organization's perspective in our overall deck, right? Yeah, the big challenge as you've pointed out is who owns where does accountability sit. If an AI does something and the whole thing goes horribly wrong, let's say you set up a a legal patent enforcement company like some of the East Texas uh companies and you goes crazy filing lawsuits, you end up with a hell of a mess on your hands. Uh that's one kind

[01:41:00] of general issue. The second is well, what would stop it from creating a 100 companies underneath it? And then where does that accountability sit right? Um uh there's there's a we have to kind of rethink this. I remember um Vina Gupta pointing out that you know uh people complain about government etc. But note that the limited liability capability that the government gives you allows you to shield yourself to take big risks in a company whereas otherwise nobody would ever do that. So right there, that's a really important case for how oversight becomes important and you're given permission to do something certain things. Where does that permission sit? Where did the MTP sit in this model? It's uh it'll be fascinating to see what happens. I think we need to tread very carefully with this. Do very small functional, very clear, very well prescribed areas uh and then slowly broaden it out because otherwise we're going to lose the game pretty quickly. I suspect Alex has the opposite view here. >> Delaware wants to stay relevant here. Alex. >> Yes. >> Well, I I think Delaware is highly

[01:42:01] relevant, but I I think we're in the early innings of the the federalist or federalism take on AI personhood. Before this, before AIC's out of Delaware, we saw Wisconsin, which had remember DAO LLC's, digital autonomous organization or excuse me, decentralized autonomous organization LLC's. Wisconsin, excuse me, Wyoming being the only other state within the US that was seriously pursuing AI/ autonomous organizations. Now, Delaware pursuing AIC's. But I I think the second elephant, the elephant in this particular room is does this want to be a states rights issue or does it want to be a federal issue? You already see the beginnings of the Congress getting interested. Does there want to be a federal framework for AI corporate personhood or does this get delegated down to the states? And there are many other hot button issues, both current and historic, that touch on

[01:43:01] again this issue of personhood, including slavery. Slavery became uh in the American Civil War the ultimate states rights versus federal issue. Does do we regulate the issue of human personhood? Did we? And obviously the outcome was was clear. But at the time, was this a federal issue? Was this a state issue? Similarly, now AI corporate personhood, is this an issue where each state can craft their own way as Wyoming and Delaware are trying to do, or does this become a federal issue? And my my expectation is actually this is going to end up being a federal issue after a bunch of different states try different approaches at AI personhood. >> Yeah, that's exactly what'll happen. It's, you know, it's actually more similar or very similar to polygamy in Utah where you know that clearly nothing in the constitution makes that a federal issue, but the majority of the country is like that's ridiculous. We're going to vote against it where we'll find a way to make it federal. Here I think AI

[01:44:00] uh personhood or AI corporate nature is clearly a states right. But the federal government will say, well, it's interstate commerce and we're we're just going to move it to the national level because that's what always happens. You know, it's I I prefer more of it to stay at the state level because it's more resilient to mistakes, but but you know, when you see things like slavery, it's just so so like anathema to the population that of course it elevates to the federal level and gets abolished. So AI will do something nasty at the state level and they'll use that as the excuse to elevate it to the federal level and then then we'll lose the variety. >> Any other comments on this one? Immad? Does Europe uh just ignore this and wait for someone else? >> Pretty much. Yeah. I mean, but here the liability profile is just very different from America with the liability profile there. Um I think honestly, um the new Delaware thing is very interesting because you can see Delaware law actually has some crazy legal liabilities for various things. Um this

[01:45:02] would actually be a better company structure for most people uh because it's actually got a lower liability. like anyone can sue you and say anything um as you've seen with Elon and others and that can cost millions of dollars in Delaware court. Uh this actually reduces your liability and for AI first companies will probably be a superior structure to run. >> All right. >> I mean I can't wait till we can have an AI CEO uh like we really I would love that. >> Okay. >> Okay. Type it into Fable. >> All right. I'm going to move us uh into the world of robotics. So, um I see lots of interesting robot companies all the time. I think it'd be fun to sort of show them here on the pod. Uh this is one that just came out of Y Combinator in the fall 2026 batch. It's called Thesius. Uh they're in the supermarket business and their claim is quote, "Lights off at 9:00 p.m., shelves full by 9:00 a.m. Next stop San Francisco." Let's take a look at the video and we

[01:46:01] can chat about it. Unfortunately, Seem, this only has two arms. >> Every night at 9:00 p.m., this store closes, the lights go out, and everyone goes home. >> Well, everyone except Theo. Theo is our humanoid robot. Every night, he comes online and restocks the store shelves. Tio restocks up to 400 units per hour and picks 40 units per hour for online orders. Every shift he runs makes the model better, so both numbers keep going up. >> At night, Tio automates the whole restocking process. He unboxes cartons, throws away trash, moves trolley, and restocks the shelves. During the day, he picks online orders and hands them over to customers. Every shelf in the supermarket is different, and that's why retail is so hard to automate. We build a brain for this task and buy the body.

[01:47:00] Tio sees thousands of hours of product and manipulation. The more he sees the more he can do. >> So the company is the question is you know do companies like this survive with figure and optimist? Um thoughts? One, one has to admire the contrarian bet here because what we saw with tokens with disembodied super intelligence is they seem to want to find the highest revenue per token use case and stocking grocery shelves is seemingly unskilled labor that's very unproductive compared to say building data centers. to to Dave's earlier point, I have to imagine building data centers is far more lucrative per humanoid robot hour than restocking a grocery shelf. So I I would actually expect I I I view this as a highly contrarian bet against AI replacing the lowest productivity human manual labor rather than the highest productivity query whether it'll work out in the end

[01:48:00] because every indication on the digital side is no actually the the super intelligence wants to flow to the highest revenue per hour. The company quotes a $60 billion a year uh market in terms of humans in supermarkets stocking and and picking. Um the question is, you know, how long will they have a market and will they get unique data? Um interesting. >> Well, I don't think it's good for Figure or for Elon um to have these companies pursuing more humanoids without a foundation model in them. They they need to set up a roadmap for these entrepreneurs because you know one of the topics is tools like these Optimus robots and these figure robots what tools are they supposed to use and and you know they don't right now they use human design tools but that's just stupid you know like like let's redesign all tools so that they fit the new platform I don't think so >> get the specs out there >> I think the beauty of humanoid robots is they fit into the existing human you know universe and and you don't have to rebuild them they can pick up and use

[01:49:01] anything >> they they can. But when you look at a data center construction project, there's so much threading of wire and and fitting of pipes. And that's all done with tools. And you know, there's like a pipe wrench that was designed for a human is a really inefficient way like designing having that exact company, that group of mechanical engineers designed a much more efficient way to connect two pipes, which is a unit that the figure robot picks up, it grabs the two pipes, it uses this thing, and it does it much more efficiently. That's a better use of these guys' time. Anyway, my answer to your question is, you know, they're going to get obliterated by by Figure and and by Optimus. >> And we know that just from from seeing the the dexterity that's coming online and the foundation, the endto-end foundation model that drives all these things, you can't compete with that by building some like stocking robot, you know, shelf. >> So, what's your advice to robotic entrepreneurs out there? Don't do it, you know, because you're going to be crushed. No, I I think that you you need to focus on like Salem says other form factors

[01:50:01] that aren't currently on the road map of figure and optimist, you know, things that clean the sides of buildings that climb up the sides or whatever, you know, different form factors, but also talk to them. They're really good people and they need uh force multipliers around their around their mission statements, what they they need the app store equivalent. You know, if if you said, I really want to build the next great operating system for the iPhone, you're like, that is crazy. But then when they lay out the app store, which Steve Jobs was originally opposed to, but they talked him into it, the app store unlocked, you know, the, okay, this is how you interact with the device. The app store equivalent for the optimist and the figure robots hasn't been established yet, but that'll put these guys on a productive path instead of a head-on, you know, trying to compete path where they shouldn't be. The bet is that a vertical deep understanding of that particular domain in the short-term medium-term will will generate a fair bit of value compared to the long-term generalized robots uh kind

[01:51:00] of getting to that domain space over a period of time and I think it's a worthwhile bet. >> Yeah, I think Alex your point is an important one. you know, optimists and figure will flow to the highest value uh per hour productivity and >> which is not going to be restocking grocery shelves in the early days. It has to be far more valuable. And to to Dave's point, if if you are going to chase what's currently unskilled human manual labor, you'd better have robot prices that are priced to match. And that's not going to be the general purpose humanoids in the early days. >> Well, if you're if you're planning on having your shelf stocking robot run on a GPU, forget about it. There's no way you're gonna get get the GPU to do it. If you're doing it with like, you know, old school CPU, whatever, you know, lying around, maybe that'll work. But all these all these startups are trying to do it with, you know, they're trying to run, you know, foundation models, Chinese foundation models on GPUs inside the physical robot. And usually it's like two GPUs. There's no way they're going to get those.

[01:52:00] >> Interesting. >> The the numbers though are the numbers are kind of quite significant. Do you know how many people the average grocery store hi um kind of hires? It's 700. That's a it's a big number. So there's a lot of head space there >> at 20 bucks an hour or whatever it might be. Yeah. Um >> I mean I think that if you look at it like an Optimus or a figure robot like a freaking ninja surgeon robot that can do anything. These things are way simpler to do if you're just picking up shelves, right? With a couple of human overseers. And in terms of the compute, you could run an entire fleet of them with a Mac Mini or two because again, they don't leave the store. They don't go out onto the streets. They're doing a very limited range of stuff. And this will be money that actually Tesla figure won't be looking for. And so you've got an arbitrage between the $20 an hour and the fully loaded even $3 an hour, $5 an hour for these guys. and they could build a massive business just going

[01:53:00] after that segment with simpler robots that are run on a local mesh. So I think you know we got to differentiate those and the market opportunity there and there's loads of market opportunity and >> I wanted to share the story for the entrepreneurs out there to hear this dialogue how to think about what you might move into what you might build. Alex >> I would say so this is advice chase the high value not the low value. If if I this is not prescriptive, but if I had to build a company like this, an example of something that I would not be doing is chasing basically minimum wage human labor. It's low productivity and it's not transformative. It's not how you win this particular game. The way the game of capitalism works is you you need to address problems in the market that are both acutely felt and scarce and valuable. And See, I was just looking this up, but my understanding is the average grocery store in the US is 26 to 75 workers. And this is not super

[01:54:00] skilled labor. >> No, it's a huge number of part-time workers and all sorts of things, late night folks that show up to do things. There might be that number of full-time, but it's a big number. I used to do a lot of work for Publix and other grocery chains. It's a it's a pretty >> I was going to say like the way to win if you want to build a robotics company is build something that is transformative that's attacking the high end of what's hardact and also exactly right and Elon in that other video it may have glossed over everybody but he said you know the this may sound circular but the AI economy is going to feed the AI economy I forget exactly how he phrased it but the but the entrepreneur hearing that should say I need to be talking to Chase Lockach Miller Abalene or Daario Amade at you know at Anthropic the that's the customer base you want to be dealing with if you're looking for the highest leverage use of your robot not a grocery store which society will get to the grocery store eventually but the highest

[01:55:00] value use cases are going to go first and that's the only place GPU compute is going to be used that's all within this AI community for the next couple of years >> so that all entrepreneurs should follow that advice >> Dave one of my favorite robot applications that I saw was a large machine, not humanoid, that was deploying solar panels at record speed, right? Uh, you know, supporting the innermost loop in the desert. I I think that's a great example of robotics. >> Great example. Great example. >> Want to float to the the high end. I one of my other favorite metaphors is that of an atomic vacuum cleaner. And in the postw World War II era, there was this notion atomic power would be so ubiquitous that you'd be able to to put some sort of atomic energy device in a vacuum cleaner, but that's not what happened. Similarly, while it's it's sort of fun to contemplate, as much as I would love to to see ubiquitous humanoid robots everywhere in the short term for grocery restocking, I I just don't think that's the very short-term arrow. Let me

[01:56:00] let me share the very high-end or high frontier use of robotics. Uh so on Saturday at Kenny Space Center, uh NASA announced their recent moonbased contract award. So uh Jared Isaacman, the greatest NASA administrator we've ever had, said quote, "We are building the moon base mission by mission." And when the crew returns to the lunar surface, quote, "The first elements of the moon base will already be waiting on the surface." So they announced the uh what's called the CLPS clips 2 contracts which stands for the commercial lunar payload services. Uh it's the next phase of NASA's program hiring a whole slew of entrepreneurial companies and larger companies. Eight companies are now competing for our younger commercial firms like Firefly, Intuitive Machines, Ispace and Voyager. The other four are SpaceX, Blue Origin, Loheed, and and Northrup. It's a 10-year contract with a $10 billion ceiling. Uh I'm very proud that two of these companies uh for you Dave and Sem, both of my X-P prize board uh both came out

[01:57:01] of the $30 million Google Lunar X-P prize that we launched back in 2008. Uh these missions are slated to land on the moon in 2027 and 2028. Blue Origin received a contract to land uh a nuclearpowered rover called Promise on the on the lunar south pole in 2028. Uh super cool stuff, a super high use of robotics. Um, any comments, Jens? >> Yeah. Why why nuclear as opposed to solar? You want to be on the dark side of the moon or something? >> Well, the South Pole is where the water ice is. Uh, and it's it's in the water ice is in the permanently uh shadowed craters. >> Right. All all the water ice from cometary asteroidal impact hit the lunar surface sublimates, goes directly to gas when it hits by sun and it escapes because the lunar's low gravity. But it's in the South Pole in these craters that you can find and mine the water and hydrogen from this ice. But I I love the fact NASA's support. You know, this is

[01:58:01] how SpaceX got started with the commercial crew contracts, you know, when the shuttle went down and they offered Elon back in December 2008 when he was on the brink of disaster. All right. Uh he had had his, you know, just had his third failure of uh of his first uh what was it? Um, Falcon 1 had failed for a third time. He'd scraped enough money to put Falcon uh one as a fourth launch and Tesla was going out of business and he got a contract. So, this is this is NASA supporting entrepreneurship, which I love it. Alex, >> I think there there's two things here. There's one, that's great that NASA's acting as a convenor, which is what it really should be doing, and then and then use the private sector to supplement everything else. But the second thing that I think is really uh interesting here, going back to the highpaying jobs, DDD jobs, dull, dirty, dangerous, this is where you're going to use humanoid robots uh or whatever robots in the highest use cases for

[01:59:02] quite a while before we get to, you know, sweeping my garage. >> At least the dangerous part. I mean, I I of course I'm familiar with the the dirty dull dangerous apherism as well, but increasingly I I'm I've come to the view it's dangerous and valuable more than dirty dull. Dirt dull especially. Um I I have to imagine doing stuff on the moon is anything but dull, but the motivation here is it's dangerous and it's valuable. I also think this is straight out of the plot of for all mankind where we start to see like nuclear energy deployed on the moon that the space program is driving energy applications transformatively so that aren't necessarily happening on Earth. I I've also of late in the past year come around to the view for a variety of reasons including political reasons the preview of what a post-s singular world looks like is increasingly in space and it's not in the terrestrial environment for political and other reasons. It's

[02:00:01] just a pain in the neck to create a post-s singular future in this legacy terrestrial environment. So if you want to see what the posts singular world looks like, you have to build in a new frontier versus an existing wellestablished ecosystem. And that means maybe in the future, as we're starting to see previewed with this NASA program, maybe we we finally get our atomic or nuclear our atomically powered vacuum cleaners, but on the moon. We get our atomically powered vehicles on the moon. Yes, exactly. >> Running Star Trek. You know, I I had such a fun morning this morning. I I did a podcast with Bill Shatner and Mel uh his daughter um you know about longevity about all of these areas. So you know his uh his son-in-law Joel is a huge fan of the pod. So uh yeah and uh and I'm excited we're going to get uh uh William Shatner is going to be the closing speaker at the Abundant Summit in March. You guys will all be there. I invited Jared Isaacman to come and co-host that

[02:01:00] conversation with uh with Captain Kirk. So, we'll see if that happens. >> Frontiers are important. We need more frontiers and I think we're starved for frontiers right now. We have space and we have super intelligence and that's about it. We need more. >> Yeah. >> Well, if you if you think about it, you know, the the highest of high-tech places on the planet is probably San Francisco right now, but it was the last place to be populated. You know, if you look at Western Europe and China expanding out and then the United States kind of comes into existence in in you know 1492 or 1776 and then westward expansion, but you know the last place people ended up is the place that was pristine and had a clean sheet of paper and is now the most high-tech in the world. And so if you say well the next frontier is the moon for exactly the reasons Alex just said, it's like it's not messed up by regulation yet. it would be consistent. >> There's another frontier which is inner space. This is where the eastern

[02:02:00] religions and philosophies do very well. They go and uh think carefully about what does it mean to integrate into existence rather than trying to model it or explore it or whatever. So there's that too >> which also radically helped with technology by the way like that's >> may maybe I mean inner space if I were to conrue inner space as like a bunch of people upload into data centers then sure but inner space as perhaps historically construed in eastern traditions is not necessarily a collective space that can be shared. It's more perhaps individual in which case it doesn't look like maybe a social frontier. >> Oh my god agree but we could leave that separate. I just backed a a amazing company uh that's in stealth that's working on the human conneto. So I can't wait for the uploads to come. Immod close us out on this one here. >> Again, all the science fiction is becoming reality, right? Like we keep talking about these TV shows and other things and what was at once not possible now seems to be structurally possible. like we're actually not patting an

[02:03:00] eyelid on lunar nuclear rovers and stuff being done out there because I think some of these lines are becoming clear whereby we're seeing big push back actually starting on the ground and I think we can all assume that's going to be bigger and so we're actually literally looking to space and beyond for other things right and that's kind of exciting because it increases the impetus to do this even as the mechanism for getting there is all coming into being and I think there's going to be no doubt that actually it's going to be a two-way thing right like stuff will be figured out on the moon and beyond that will come back and as you said the convening factor is actually one of the most important one which is how do you create structures for all this innovation to occur and then benefit everyone. >> It's almost like the Europeans fleeing uh the constraints and going to the new world. >> I I I want to argue the old world is becoming the old world and the new world is becoming the new world. >> Yeah. Humans have always wanted the frontier. I mean dur on the frontier is where the greatest innovation the greatest social societal uh revolution and reinvention occurs where people can

[02:04:01] go start a fresh. We need new frontiers. >> Well, this is innovation at the edge. This is Buckminister Fuller. You can never fix an existing system. Go to the edge and build a new system and let that become a new gravity center. Yeah, I >> I think it's the same thing we see in in ecology where there's a forest fire or there's some new biome that opens up and you see procession, but you give every every form of life an opportunity to to Dave's earlier point to start with a blank sheet of paper. And I I think we since the American West closed at the end of the 19th century, we've been a little bit starved of blank sheets of paper to reinvision how society should work, how technology could integrate with society. The internet was a new space and that was great for a while to the extent it was the frontier for a while. Super intelligence is a frontier right now, but I think we're pretty starved as a planet, as a human civilization for new frontiers, and space could potentially give us a longer duration, longer release frontier.

[02:05:01] >> You know what I'd add to that, Alex, is you know, it'll it'll take a while for the moon to really become the the true new world. But between here and there, you know, the Cayman Islands became an important financial hub, as did Bermuda. And I'm still looking for biotech land to emerge, you know, some some regulatory environment. But what's different about AI, you know, when when the western frontier was being developed, you needed huge amounts of land for either mining gold or for cattle or whatever, AI doesn't need an enormous amount of space uh like physical space. So if some South American nation or some other you know region of the world wanted to become the stepping stone to the moon, the door is wide open. You know, some regulatory friendly environment. I know Ahmad comes into contact with tons of world leaders and these guys are they're super accessible. You know, you think of governments as being very hard to talk to, but in these smaller nations, they're actually incredibly accessible. So, there there's room for that. >> Welcome to the health section of Moonshots brought to you by Fountain Life. The discussion in this section is

[02:06:00] forformational purposes only and is not medical advice. Please consult a qualified health care professional about your individual needs. I'm a co-founder of Inclient at Fountain Life. You know, my mission is to help you use the latest technologies, including AI, to not just do your work at home, teach your kids, but to help you live a long and healthy life. I'm here today with an extraordinary physician, the chief medical officer of Fountain Life, Dr. Don Mucalem. Dawn, let's talk about cancer. Uh, you know, I know from the member database that we've have at Fountain are members who come in who think they're healthy. It turns out 3.3% of them have a cancer in their body they don't know about. >> That's right. You know, the majority of cancers that we screen for, those aren't the ones that are necessarily taking the lives when found at a late stage. We know that when cancer is found early, the chances for cure are much higher. We know it's much easier to treat a cancer when found early versus when found late.

[02:07:00] What we're finding in our members is over 3.3% were found to have these cancers that were otherwise wouldn't have been found or detected. >> Yeah. You know, it's interesting. People, you don't feel the cancer until stage three or stage four. And and if you don't know what's going on inside your body, it's like driving your car with your eyes closed and you can know. And so when members come through found, how do they detect cancers? >> So we're doing full body MRI and we also do early cancer detection screening. This is very very important. And these are not typical tools used in the conventional care setting when it comes to prevention. This is a hard thing because currently these are not studies that insurance would yet be covering. But the goal is to collect these numbers, do the research, and work hard to democratize wellness. >> Yeah. So, at the end of the day, you can know what's going on inside your body. It's your obligation to know. So, check out Fountain Life. You can go to fountainlife.com/peter to get access to the latest technology to help you detect cancer at the very beginning at stage one when it is curable before it gets to stage three or

[02:08:02] stage four in your world to hurt. All right, I'm going to move us to our last story where more billionaires correlates with less poverty. So there's a lot of resentment against the tech billionaires against a concentration of wealth. Uh, and for our final story, I want to look at a post by economist Christopher Clark, who examined cross-country data showing that more billionaires per capita is associated with less poverty. He wrote that a 10-fold increase in billionaires per capita goes with a reduction in poverty of 43%. Uh, he noted that Sweden has more billionaires per 10 million people than the US. It's 34 versus 30. He stressed that the graph shows only a correlation. uh and it asks you know what is the cause uh let me show the graph here and let's talk about it and I think it's an important realization uh for people I mean there's been such you know the billionaire tax uh and and resentment out there um here's the chart uh showing the data uh we see uh you know percent

[02:09:01] share of the population under $30 a day that's the definition of poverty and on the bottom we're seeing basically the uh the number of billionaires per country. Um it's a pretty stark correlation. Uh obviously these people are building companies, creating wealth and employing people, but I think also paying taxes that flows through through social services. Uh Immod your thoughts here? >> Yeah, I mean I think this is unsurprising to a degree like where you have billionaires, you typically have the infrastructure to build billionaires, right? And as you said, there's the tax, there's the kind of other element of it flowing down, etc. Um, and if we move into this new phase whereby you see literally companies being launched that can get to a billion dollars in no time whatsoever, right? Like you're seeing Anthropic, I think, is going to have almost 5,000 millionaires made, you know, and dozens

[02:10:01] of billionaires. like it's a crazy time whereby even the companies at the top left can create environments for millionaires, centilionaires and billionaires to come about. Um, and I think that's just very exciting to think about it as well as hopefully lift up the base level of everyone. >> Dave, >> well my read on this chart is you top right is suck land. That's where you don't want to be in the top right. You got lots of poor people and lots of billionaires and it's a world of suck and everybody thinks that socialism is is somehow correlated. Look at the world of suck. It's just it's just sucky sucky governments. And you know, look who's up there. You I'm not going to get myself in trouble by reading the slide. You guys read the slide. But it has nothing to do socialism sucks. It sucks for everybody. It's obvious on this chart. And then look at the the thriving countries in the bottom right. Switzerland and uh Germany and um United States is is down there. Uh so it's not a question of left versus right. It's a question of good ideas versus bad ideas.

[02:11:02] And so this chart tells you everything you need to know. What you want is your population to be thriving. And at the bottom bottom right corner or bottom, you know, anywhere on the bottom of this chart, you're doing really really well. And so yeah, the line is kind of a loosely fit line. I think that the real story here is good ideas percolating the top and getting out of partisan messes. >> Um, two or three things. one uh naturally if you have a lot of billionaires it may indicate a generally robust economy and therefore you'll get better uh a less number of a smaller number of people in deep poverty. So I don't I don't think correlation is causation here. Uh I do think there's a couple of interesting things here. One is the Sweden example is really interesting because it challenges the idea that entrepreneurship and a strong safety net are incompatible. Right? We like I'm Canadian. It's awesome to have a decent social safety net with health care provided for you so you're not worried about uh having your family go bankrupt if somebody gets sick. I think

[02:12:00] the big question in all of this is can we lift the bottom? The hell with how much the richest people have in the world and Peter, you and I talk about this all the time. Can you lift the bottom? And I think the demonetization and democratization of all these technologies is where you're going to see some incredible magic coming out of out of this. I mean it's it's the big metric I would like to see talking about benchmarks is how quickly can we lift the bottom. >> Yeah. Yeah. I want to make that point again. You know we will have trillionaires living forever on Mars as long as every single human on the planet has access to all the food, water, energy, healthcare and education. >> If I was a trillionaire, by the way, I'd rather be living in Bali just to to make a point. Happy happy to visit Mars just as an exploration. But here's my question for the group. If you have an AI economy, right, would you rather have twice as many billionaires or drop the cost of living by 50%. And I think I'm going to suggest that the second part is better. >> Inevitably, I'm going to question the premise. I I think that's a a false tradeoff. I I think the the the cost of 2026 era living becomes too cheap to

[02:13:02] meter sometime in the not too distant future. And also I would argue and I have argued we want to live in a world with the most the most possible trillionaires. I I would say the world doesn't have enough trillionaires. Right now we have approximately one. Um maybe more than one if you count certain nation state quasi monarchs but approximately one. And I think the world needs billions of trillionaires. And that's that's the world that we should be marching to. Well, I think I think you nailed it, Alex, in the sense that there are there are dictator trillionaires and then there are productive trillionaires, right? >> And the key to tax policy is to tax the former and let the second group reinvest. And so, it's not about taxing more or less. It's not about taxing trillionaires or not taxing. It's about targeting taxes at unproductive parts of the economy and reinvesting in productive parts of the economy. >> I feel like I'm a trillionaire in inner space. >> So, there we go. Mhm.

[02:14:00] >> All right. >> As as as my grandfather used to say, Seem, that and a nickel will buy you a cup of coffee. >> Yeah. And today that and five bucks will get you a Starbucks coffee. >> That's right. >> All right. I'm going to I'm going to play us out with a tribute to Jean Luke Peicard uh by CJ Truheart. It's called Make It So. >> They said it was just science fiction, but every fiction starts with someone's vision. The future isn't something that happens to us. It's something we build one moonshot at a time. I'm a man with a plan. And the moonshot is my mission. Divided by hypocrisy, inspired by a vision. I know I'm not the only one. Tired of division. So the future I'm creating to shape the way we're living. Cuz abundance is my nature. This is the gift we're giving. Inspired by my moonshot mission. Inspired by a Star Trek vision. Make it real what I saw on teleision.

[02:15:02] Teleision. There's no replacement for what's real. Though it inspires what we feel. If we lose our dreams and drift away, life just seems to waste away. Hanging on. But the power's in what we do. I see a society before me where we live among the stars. Inspired by each other to explore beyond Mars. This is a Star Trek future, but one we must create through your moonshot mission. It's time to innovate. It's time to innovate. Your moonshot cannot wait. Only certain things can't be done by you. Only you can see the lens of view and through.

[02:16:01] Empowered by your heart is how you make it true. You need us just as much as we need you to transform this moonshot mission into united human vision. Where povertyy's extinct disease is historical fiction. Where energy is endless knowledge no restrictions. As we explore the cosmos, not through competition, through collaboration. That's a composition. Think about the phone in your pocket. More power than Apollo's rocket. Now someone moonshot. Someone who wouldn't stop. Every breakthrough that we're living started with someone giving. Everything they had to make. The world in which we're living. The mistakes we made before. The limits we swore were carved in stone. We're carved in stone. Until someone alone said, "I'll make it better. and change the world forever. >> All right, gentlemen. And that's a wrap.

[02:17:01] Thank you for a great show. >> Awesome conversation. >> Fun times. >> Thank you. >> Yeah. >> Love you all, guys. >> Love you, too. >> I got to go give a talk on top. I got to give a talk on top of a dugout. Stand on the dugout photos.