No, It Is Not "Storage" - but a Truly Open-Sided Pavilion Probably Never Needs to Be: FEMA Treats It as "Development," Not an Accessory Structure, Which Routes It to Tampa § 5-121.331 Instead of § 5-121.247. The Kitchen Equipment Is the Part That Must Go Up, and the Routing Needs a Written Interpretation
The question
"Does an open-sided pavilion with an elevated outdoor kitchen (no bath, no sleeping) qualify as 'storage' under Tampa's at-grade accessory-structure flood rule (City Code §5-121.247), or does it need a formal floodplain-administrator determination?"
Context: second open item from [[2026-10-17-adu-pool-house-rules]]. It decides whether a pool-adjacent pavilion on the Sunset Park lot (Zone AE, BFE 11.0 ft NAVD88, grade about 8.5 ft) can sit cheaply at grade or has to be raised like the house.
Retrieval note. Tampa's code was read directly on Municode via Playwright on 2026-11-18 (§ 5-121.41-.42, .111-.117, .181-.182, .241, .247, .331). FEMA P-2140, the Florida Building Code flood provisions and two Florida Division of Emergency Management (FDEM) guidance documents were read as PDFs. This is research, not legal advice, and no City staff were contacted.
What we already know (from the vault)
- The parent brief's rule. [[2026-10-17-adu-pool-house-rules]] recorded that below BFE an accessory structure may be used "only for parking or storage," must be one story and 600 sf or less in AE, and that a pool house with a bath or kitchen must be elevated to BFE+1 (12.0 ft). It left the open-sided pavilion as an explicit open item and priced "storage-only at grade, or an open cabana" at $30-90k against $140-270k for an elevated pool house.
- The elevations. Required finished floor is BFE + 1 ft = 12.0 ft NAVD88 under FBC-R R322.2.1, and Tampa's design flood elevation in AE is just the mapped BFE, 11.0 ft ([[2026-10-25-tampa-freeboard-ae-zone-codified-requirement]]). Average existing grade is about 8.5 ft ([[zoning-flood-zone-findings]]). So "BFE+1" is about 3.5 ft above grade and "DFE" is about 2.5 ft.
- § 5-121.247 was already quoted once. The freeboard brief identified it as Tampa's only BFE+1 language and as scoped to accessory structures.
- Zoning side. Detached accessory structures under 1,125 sf take 3 ft side and rear setbacks, a 15 ft height cap, and 10 ft eave-to-eave separation from the house ([[2026-10-17-adu-pool-house-rules]]). No bath plus no sleeping keeps the pavilion out of the EFR rules in [[2026-11-17-tampa-extended-family-residence-parking-requirement]].
- Coastal A status. The parent brief put the nearest Limit of Moderate Wave Action line about 2,370 ft away, so the lot is likely plain AE. Everything below assumes that; a Coastal A designation would add § 5-121.335-.337.
What the web says
- The citation is correct. § 5-121.247 is captioned "Accessory structures" and reads: "Accessory structures are permitted below the base flood elevation provided the accessory structures are used only for parking or storage and:" (1) in A/AE, "one-story and not larger than six hundred (600) square feet," (3) anchored, (4) flood damage-resistant materials "below the base flood elevation plus one (1) foot," and (5) "mechanical, plumbing and electrical systems, including plumbing fixtures, elevated to or above the base flood elevation plus one (1) foot" (Municode, Art. III Div. 2). One small correction to the parent brief: the flood-vent requirement is not in § 5-121.247. It comes from FBC-R R322.2.1 item 5.2.4.
- A cooking and entertaining pavilion cannot be "storage." Tampa defines the term by use: "Accessory structure means, for the purposes of this section, a structure used only for parking and storage" (§ 5-121.182). FEMA P-2140 lists, as things that are accessory in nature but not accessory structures for floodplain purposes, "Structures used for entertainment (such as workshops, recreational rooms, or game rooms)." FDEM's pool guidance is blunter: "recreational use is not a permitted use" (FEMA P-2140 v1.1, § 2.4.1; FDEM 2010).
- But FEMA does not treat a roof without walls as a structure at all. P-2140 § 2.1.9: "a structure is a walled and roofed building that is principally above ground, where walled is considered 'two or more outside rigid walls' and roofed is 'a fully secured roof.'" The same § 2.4.1 list of non-accessory items ends with "Gazebos, pergolas, and carports that are not walled and roofed," and Figure 18 is captioned "Accessory Development; Gazebo with Roof but No Walls." Such items are regulated as "development" under § 3.4: anchored, flood damage-resistant materials, and "mechanical, plumbing, and electrical systems elevated or designed to prevent water from entering or accumulating within the components during flooding." No floor elevation is required.
- Tampa has the matching section. § 5-121.331, "General requirements for other development," covers "All development ... for which specific provisions are not specified in this section or the Florida Building Code" and requires it to be anchored, built of flood damage-resistant materials, and to "Have mechanical, plumbing, and electrical systems above the design flood elevation, except that minimum electric service required to address life safety and electric code requirements is permitted below the design flood elevation provided it conforms to the provisions of the electrical part of building code for wet locations" (Municode, Div. 8).
- Florida's state floodplain office answered almost exactly this question in 2010. "Any structure that is not a walled and roofed building must comply with the applicable provisions of the local floodplain management regulations and the Florida Building Code ... structures such as counter tops and bars with roof/shade coverings are not required to be elevated provided the structure is anchored to prevent flotation." On appliances: "communities should not simply ignore the risk and allow installations at-grade. Appliances and equipment must be anchored to prevent flotation and protected to prevent water from entering or accumulating within the components." Plus a separate GFCI circuit, and sink drainage designed to keep floodwater out of the sewer (FDEM 2010, same link). The document is 16 years old and predates Tampa's 2024 ordinance.
- The Florida Building Code elevates the equipment either way. FBC-R R322.1.6 requires electrical systems, "plumbing appliances and plumbing fixtures" and "other service equipment" at or above the R322.2 elevation (BFE+1), with an exception if they are "designed and installed to prevent water from entering or accumulating within the components and to resist hydrostatic and hydrodynamic loads ... in accordance with ASCE 24." Wiring may run below if it meets wet-location rules. Fuel gas G2404.7 points gas appliances to the same elevation with the same exception (FDEM, Flood Resistant Provisions of the 8th Ed. FBC).
- The variance route is close to shut. § 5-121.117 requires a showing that failure to grant "would result in exceptional hardship due to the physical characteristics of the land that render the lot undevelopable; increased costs to satisfy the requirements or inconvenience do not constitute hardship." The Division 7 section list (§ 5-121.111-.117) contains no administrative accessory-structure variance, confirming the parent brief's note that Tampa has not adopted FDEM's 600-1,200 sf option (FDEM Jan 2024).
- The interpretation power is explicit and separate from a variance. § 5-121.41 designates the Construction Services Operations Manager as floodplain administrator. § 5-121.42 gives that office "authority to render interpretations of this section," which "shall not have the effect of waiving requirements specifically provided in this section without the granting of a variance."
Convergences and contradictions
- Vault and sources agree on the "storage" test and disagree with the question's framing. The parent brief was right that only parking-or-storage structures get the at-grade pass. What it missed is that the pass may not be needed: FEMA, FDEM and Tampa's own Division 8 all give a roof-without-walls a different lane. The question is less "is it storage?" and more "is it a structure?"
- One real textual gap, and it cuts against us. Tampa's flood chapter defines neither "structure" nor "building." § 5-121.181(b) sends undefined terms to the Florida Building Code, whose definition of accessory structure is broad: "A structure that is accessory to and incidental to that of a building or dwelling(s) and that is located on the same lot." FBC-R R322.2.1 item 5 says "Detached accessory structures and detached garages" must either have floors at BFE+1 or be used "solely for parking or storage." Read literally, with the building-code meaning of "structure," a detached pavilion is caught and its floor goes to 12.0 ft. Read with FEMA's meaning, which FDEM says the provision was written to mirror, it is not. The text alone does not settle this.
- Three different elevation numbers govern the equipment depending on the lane. § 5-121.247(5) says BFE+1 with no exception. § 5-121.331(5) says DFE (11.0 ft here) with only a life-safety electric exception. R322.1.6 says BFE+1 with a designed-to-resist exception. The conservative design number is 12.0 ft.
Synthesis for RDCO
The answer, in one line: an open-sided pavilion with an outdoor kitchen is not "storage" and cannot use § 5-121.247, but if it has fewer than two rigid walls it is most likely not an "accessory structure" in the flood sense at all - it is "other development" under § 5-121.331, which lets the slab and roof sit at grade while the kitchen's plumbing, gas and electrical equipment go to roughly 12.0 ft NAVD88 or get flood-protected. Which lane applies is an interpretation call that belongs to the floodplain administrator under § 5-121.42, so yes, get it in writing before design.
Confidence, stated plainly. High that the pavilion fails the storage test; three sources say so and Tampa's definition is use-based. High that the fixed equipment must be elevated or protected under every reading. Medium-high, about 70 percent as my own estimate, that Tampa will treat a genuinely wall-less pavilion as Division 8 development and not require the slab at 12.0 ft, because that is FEMA's published position, FDEM's published position for this exact use, and the only reading under which flood openings and "lowest floor of the lowest enclosed area" make sense. Low that a variance would rescue the design if the City reads it the other way: the hardship standard excludes cost and convenience by name. Nothing here was confirmed with City staff, and I found no Tampa-published guidance on pavilions, cabanas or outdoor kitchens.
What this does to the design. The cheap version from the parent brief (the $30-90k open cabana) survives, with a condition the estimate did not carry: the kitchen is the regulated part, not the roof. With grade near 8.5 ft, a standard 36-inch counter tops out around 11.5 ft, so a sink basin, built-in grill burner box, refrigerator and receptacles set into a normal counter all sit below 12.0 ft. Three ways through, in rising cost: keep the fixed kitchen on the elevated house terrace and make the at-grade pavilion shade, seating and a freestanding grill; raise only the kitchen run on a platform or plinth so equipment clears 12.0 ft; or spec equipment and enclosures a design professional will certify under the R322.1.6 exception. A freestanding cart grill is contents, not construction, which is my inference and not something the code says. The word "elevated" in the question is doing real work: if the kitchen platform is at or above 12.0 ft, the equipment issue largely disappears, and what remains is whether the roof posts and lower slab count as development. A platform more than 12 inches above grade may pull principal-building setbacks under the pool-deck rule the parent brief cited, which would cost rear-yard depth on a stack that already "fits, tight."
Two traps to design out now. First, walls later. Two rigid walls convert the pavilion into a structure, and its use then puts it outside § 5-121.247, which is an enforcement problem on a property in the City's permit record. FDEM allows lattice and insect or aluminum screening around pools; whether Tampa extends that to a pavilion, or how it treats a solid kitchen back-wall or roll-down storm panels, is unknown and is the detail most likely to flip the answer. One back-wall is under FEMA's two-wall threshold, but the administrator applies judgment. Second, attachment. Structurally tying the pavilion roof to the house makes it part of the house for flood purposes, and zoning already requires 10 ft eave-to-eave separation for a detached accessory. Keep it detached and structurally independent. Substantial improvement is not a live issue for a pavilion built with the new house; it becomes one only if the pavilion is added later as an attached addition, since Tampa accumulates improvement cost over a one-year window.
What to ask the floodplain administrator, verbatim (Construction Services, in writing, citing § 5-121.42):
- "For a detached, roofed, open-sided pavilion with no walls in Zone AE, accessory to a new single-family dwelling, does the City review it as 'other development' under § 5-121.331, or as a detached accessory structure under FBC-R R322.2.1(5) and § 5-121.247?"
- "If it is reviewed under § 5-121.331, may the slab be at existing grade, and to what elevation must outdoor kitchen plumbing fixtures, gas appliances and electrical equipment be raised - design flood elevation, or base flood elevation plus one foot?"
- "Will the City accept outdoor kitchen equipment below that elevation under the FBC-R R322.1.6 exception, and what documentation does it require?"
- "How many walls, and of what type (masonry back-wall, screening, lattice, roll-down panels), can the pavilion have before the City treats it as a walled and roofed structure?"
- "Does a kitchen platform raised above grade under the pavilion roof change the flood review, and is a floodplain development permit required in addition to the building permit?"
Why this is in the vault
It closes the second open item on [[2026-10-17-adu-pool-house-rules]] for the Sunset Park home build and changes the pool-house decision: the at-grade option is an open pavilion with the kitchen equipment raised, not a "storage" structure, and the five questions above go on the pre-application list in [[zoning-flood-zone-findings]].
Open follow-ups
- How do other Florida cities that adopted the same state model ordinance (St. Petersburg, Clearwater, Sarasota) publicly document their treatment of open-sided cabanas, tiki huts and outdoor kitchens below BFE - is there a published local bulletin Tampa's reviewers would likely mirror?
- What do ASCE 24-14 (and the newer ASCE 24-24) actually require for a roofed, wall-less structure and for attendant equipment below the design flood elevation? The standard is paywalled and was not read; R322.1.6's exception depends on it.
- Does Tampa's § 27-290.3 deck rule, or any other Chapter 27 provision, treat a raised outdoor-kitchen platform over 12 inches above grade as subject to principal-building setbacks, and does a roofed open pavilion count toward the 1,125 sf accessory threshold?
- Is a roofed, wall-less pavilion and its built-in equipment insurable under an NFIP dwelling policy or only under private flood or homeowners coverage? The NFIP building definition uses the same two-rigid-walls test, which suggests not, but this was not verified.
Related
- [[2026-10-17-adu-pool-house-rules]] - parent note; this brief answers its first open item and corrects the flood-vent attribution
- [[2026-10-25-tampa-freeboard-ae-zone-codified-requirement]] - source of the 12.0 ft required floor and the DFE = BFE = 11.0 reading used here
- [[zoning-flood-zone-findings]] - lot elevations and the pre-application question list
- [[2026-07-22-ae-zone-elevation-cost-premium-tampa]] - elevation cost model the pool-house estimates lean on
- [[2026-11-17-tampa-extended-family-residence-parking-requirement]] - the other open item from the same parent note
- [[2026-10-21-tampa-rs75-height-limit-datum]] - "required finished floor" datum for the 15 ft accessory height cap
Sources
- Vault: [[2026-10-17-adu-pool-house-rules]]; [[2026-10-25-tampa-freeboard-ae-zone-codified-requirement]]; [[zoning-flood-zone-findings]]; [[2026-07-22-ae-zone-elevation-cost-premium-tampa]]; [[2026-11-17-tampa-extended-family-residence-parking-requirement]]; [[2026-10-21-tampa-rs75-height-limit-datum]]
- Tampa City Code Ch. 5, § 5-121 (Ord. No. 2024-15), §§ 5-121.41, .42, .111-.117, .181, .182, .241, .247, .331, read 2026-11-18: https://library.municode.com/fl/tampa/codes/code_of_ordinances?nodeId=COOR_CH5BUCO_S5-121FLSIDE
- FEMA P-2140, Floodplain Management Requirements for Agricultural Structures and Accessory Structures, v1.1, Aug 2021 (§§ 2.1.9, 2.4.1, 2.5.2, 3.2, 3.4): https://www.fema.gov/media-collection/floodplain-management-requirements-agricultural-and-accessory-structures (text read from the Los Angeles County mirror of the same PDF)
- FDEM, Technical Topic: Guidance for Pools and Outdoor Kitchens/Bars in Flood Hazard Areas, Nov 2010: https://www.floridadisaster.org/contentassets/5a671dfdfadf45ab9a2c61635e2a4fed/florida-guidance-for-outdoor-kitchens-and-pool-equipment.pdf
- FDEM, Guidance for Accessory Structures: Non-elevated, wet floodproofed in flood hazard areas, Jan 2024: https://floridadisaster.org/globalassets/fdem-ofm-guidance_accessory-structure-fbcr_1-2024.pdf
- FDEM, Flood Resistant Provisions in the 8th Edition Florida Building Code (2023) - FBC-R § 202, R322.1.6, R322.2.1, G2404.7: https://prod.floridadisaster.org/globalassets/8th-ed_fbc_floodprovisions_dec20232.pdf
- Not read: ASCE 24 (paywalled); FDEM Jan 2026 guidance on flood-damaged exterior equipment (surfaced in search, not opened)