No clearinghouse or practice-management vendor was found publishing a specialty-level first-pass or resubmission rate; the behavioral-health figures in circulation are unsourced ranges, and the metric would not answer the rework question even if it existed
The question
"Do any clearinghouse or practice-management vendors (Availity, Waystar, Office Ally, Optum) publish a first-pass claim acceptance rate or resubmission rate broken out by SPECIALTY, which would give a behavioral-health rework share from a non-payer angle?"
This is open follow-up #4 of [[2026-10-17-behavioral-health-silent-rework-market-size]], the one follow-up that could have turned that brief's clean behavioral-health null into a number. It does not. The null holds from the non-payer side too, with one important limit on how hard this pass tested it (see "Evidence strength" below).
What we already know (from the vault)
- The rework share is measured, but only all-specialty. 60% of denied claims resubmitted, 40.8% of all initial denials resubmitted and paid, on 270 million Medicare Advantage claims from 2019 (Vabson, Hicks, Chernew, Health Affairs, June 2025). Zero behavioral-health mentions in the full text. From [[2026-10-17-behavioral-health-silent-rework-market-size]].
- One of the four named vendors was already read at source and came up empty. The Change Healthcare 2022 Revenue Cycle Denials Index (Change Healthcare is now Optum's clearinghouse) covers roughly 441 million hospital remits, is hospital inpatient and outpatient only, has no behavioral-health cut, and contains no resubmission share at all. Same parent brief.
- Payer-side and regulator-side are exhausted until plan year 2027. CMS adds a behavioral-health versus non-behavioral-health split of claims received and denied for plan year 2027; Virginia does not report resubmission. From [[2026-10-04-behavioral-health-claim-denial-rate-primary-sources]] and the parent brief.
- The measured behavioral-health denial numbers the vault does hold are modest, not extreme. Virginia non-pharmacy mental health runs 1.13x medical/surgical and substance use disorder 2.73x ([[2026-10-04-behavioral-health-claim-denial-rate-primary-sources]]); the one state Medicaid table with an applied-behavior-analysis row puts it at 9.31%, below the non-behavioral-health average in the same table ([[2026-10-17-state-medicaid-behavioral-health-denial-rates-by-category]]).
What the web says
Evidence strength, stated first because it bounds everything below. Three extended web searches were aimed at this exact quantity, naming all four vendors plus Experian Health, MGMA, Tebra, SimplePractice, TherapyNotes and athenahealth. None surfaced a first-party vendor publication with a specialty breakout. The vendors' own report pages were NOT opened in this pass: the one first-party fetch attempted (a guessed Optum 2024 Denials Index URL) returned HTTP 404, and the fetch budget went to tracing where the circulating behavioral-health figures come from. So the per-vendor rows below are "not found by search," not "confirmed absent by reading the report," except where marked.
| Vendor | Specialty-level first-pass or resubmission statistic published? | Basis for the verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Optum / Change Healthcare | No, for the 2022 index (read at source by the parent brief). Hospital-only, all-specialty, no resubmission share. 2024 edition not read. | Parent brief's full-PDF read of the 2022 index; 2024 edition URL guess returned 404 |
| Availity | None found | Search null only; no first-party page read |
| Waystar | None found | Search null only; no first-party page read |
| Office Ally | None found | Search null only; no first-party page read |
| Experian Health (State of Claims) | No. It is an opinion survey, not a claims index: 250 healthcare professionals surveyed June-July 2025, headline "41% of providers report a denial rate at or above 10%," all-specialty | Reported by a secondary page that links the survey; survey itself not opened |
| MGMA | No public specialty table located. Vendor blogs attribute a "16% behavioral health, highest of any specialty" figure to "MGMA specialty benchmarks" with no linked table. Any real table would sit in member-only DataDive | Search results; attribution unverified |
| Tebra/Kareo, SimplePractice, TherapyNotes, athenahealth | None found | Search null only |
- Every behavioral-health figure the searches returned is vendor marketing, and three were traced to their footing. Ranges in circulation for behavioral-health initial denials: 10-16%, 12-20%, 15-25%, 18-22%, 20-30%, and 20-28% for substance use disorder. For first-pass or clean-claim rate: 85-92%, 92-95%, "95% or higher." The spread alone (10% to 30% for the same quantity) says these are not measurements of one thing.
- OmniMD, "Average Claim Denial Rates by Specialty (2026 Report)," 20 March 2026: no source, no sample, no data year. Behavioral health 10-16%. The only qualifier is a table header reading "Denial Rate (Estimate)." The page does not say the figures are OmniMD's own claims data. It also contradicts itself on the industry average (8-12% in the intro, 6-10% in its scorecard). No first-pass or resubmission rate by specialty. MARKETING.
- Medi (medibilling.app), "2026 Denial-Rate Benchmark by Specialty": explicitly not measured. Behavioral health 20-30%, sourced to "2024 Behavioral Health Parity Report; Experian; specialty billing analyses," with no publisher or link for the parity report. The page states, as relayed by the fetch tool: "Medi does not yet have a proprietary customer dataset and makes no claims based on internal performance data." Credit for saying so; the number is still a blend of unlinked sources. MARKETING, self-declared.
- Analytic Healthcare Solutions (globalahs.com), a behavioral-health-specialist billing analytics firm: rules of thumb only. First-pass clean claim rate "should sit at 92-95%"; initial denial 5-10% "workable." Sourcing is "From years of working denials across SUD and mental health facilities, the pattern is consistent" with no claim counts, facility count or date range, and no clearinghouse or MGMA/HFMA citation. MARKETING.
- The metric definitions are not stable across sources. One vendor guide measures first-pass acceptance at the 277CA level (the clearinghouse/payer front-door acknowledgment); one says clean claim rate and first-pass acceptance are the same thing; another separates clean claim rate (accepted by the payer) from first-pass resolution (paid without rework). These are search-result summaries, not pages read in full.
- A widely repeated resubmission figure runs the opposite direction from the peer-reviewed one. "Up to 65% of denied claims are never resubmitted" appears on both fetched benchmark pages; Medi attributes it to "Change Healthcare 2024" with no sample base. Health Affairs measured 60% of denied claims being resubmitted. The parent brief found no resubmission share in the 2022 Change Healthcare index, so the attribution is suspect; it was not checked against a 2024 edition.
- Other measured-looking bases named in passing, none specialty-level: MGMA 8% first-submission denial rate for physician practices, 2023 (aggregate); MDaudit, 1.2 million providers and 4,500 facilities, first three quarters of 2025 (as described by Medi; not opened).
- Paywalls skipped, not retried: MGMA DataDive (member-only), the one place a specialty denial table attributed to MGMA could live. Vendor benchmark reports behind lead-capture forms were not attempted.
Convergences and contradictions
- Convergence: the null is now three-sided. Payer filings, regulator tables and vendor-published material all lack a behavioral-health rework share. On the vendor side that conclusion is firm for Change Healthcare 2022 and search-level for everyone else.
- Contradiction: vendor blogs say behavioral health has "the highest denial rate of any specialty" at 16-30%; the vault's measured tables do not support that as a general statement. Virginia mental health is 1.13x medical/surgical, and the only public applied-behavior-analysis rate (9.31%, one state's Medicaid) sits below the non-behavioral-health average. The elevated block in measured data is substance use disorder specifically. The blog ranges are the same family of unsourced "3-5x" claims [[2026-10-04-behavioral-health-claim-denial-rate-primary-sources]] already took apart.
- Contradiction: "65% never resubmitted" (vendor-circulated, unsampled) versus 60% resubmitted (peer-reviewed, 270 million claims). Anyone sizing the rework market from vendor content gets it roughly backwards.
Synthesis for RDCO
The answer is no, with a caveat on depth. No clearinghouse or practice-management vendor was found publishing a first-pass acceptance or resubmission rate by specialty. Optum's Change Healthcare 2022 index is confirmed empty on this point by a source read; Availity, Waystar and Office Ally are search nulls, which is weaker. I would put the chance that one of those three has a public, sampled, specialty-level table that three targeted searches all missed as low but not zero, and a gated PDF is the likeliest place for one to hide. The behavioral-health number does not exist in public from the non-payer angle either, as far as this pass can see.
The more useful finding is that the question was aimed at the wrong metric. A clearinghouse sees the front door. Its native statistic is acceptance at the 277CA acknowledgment: did the claim pass format, enrollment and payer front-end edits. A claim that fails there is a rejection. It never reaches adjudication, never becomes a denial, and is not in the denominator of the 40.8%. So even a perfect specialty-level clearinghouse acceptance table would measure the pre-adjudication scrub loop, not the post-denial resubmit-and-paid loop the parent brief sized. The two are adjacent kinds of rework and they do not add or substitute. The entity that sees the post-denial loop from the provider side is the practice-management system, which holds both the original claim and the corrected one. That is why, if this number ever appears outside a payer filing, it will come from a behavioral-health EHR with a billing module, not from Availity or Waystar. None of them publish it today, and the reason is probably commercial rather than technical: a vendor's own resubmission rate by specialty is a statement about its scrubber.
What this does for the venture's pitch material. Two things. First, the borrowed 40.8% stays borrowed until plan year 2027 data, and the pitch should say so plainly rather than reach for a "behavioral health denial rate of 16-30%" from the benchmark blogs. Every one of those traced here is an estimate with no sample, and one publisher says outright it has no dataset. Quoting them to a clinic owner or an investor who checks is a credibility cost with no upside, given the vault holds real Virginia and state Medicaid tables that say something more specific and more defensible: substance use disorder is elevated, mental health barely is. Second, the absence is itself the market observation. Nobody on the provider side publishes a measured behavioral-health first-pass or rework rate, so a practice cannot benchmark itself against anything but folklore. A venture that sits on claim-and-remit pairs for even a few dozen behavioral-health practices would hold the only measured specialty rework share in existence. That is an asset to name as a by-product, not a product: it is credible only after there are customers, and I would not let it carry weight in the plan before then.
Recommendation on this research line: stop. Four briefs have now approached the behavioral-health rework share from payer, regulator, academic and vendor directions and found the same hole. The remaining routes to a real number are not research: asking the Health Affairs authors about an Inovalon behavioral-health cut, waiting for plan year 2027, or measuring it on real practices. Further desk research here has low expected yield.
Why this is in the vault
It closes follow-up #4 of [[2026-10-17-behavioral-health-silent-rework-market-size]] for the family RCM/EOB venture and settles what its sizing slide can cite: the all-specialty 40.8% with its Medicare Advantage caveat, and the Virginia and state Medicaid tables, but none of the vendor "behavioral health denial rate" ranges, which this brief traced to unsampled estimates.
Open follow-ups
- Do the gated first-party reports (Optum 2024 Revenue Cycle Denials Index, Waystar and Availity benchmark reports, Experian State of Claims full PDF) contain any service-line or specialty table? This pass did not open them; it is the one place the search-level null could be wrong.
- What is the actual origin of the "50-65% of denied claims are never reworked/resubmitted" statistic, and does any first-party publication with a sample stand behind it? It contradicts the peer-reviewed 60%-resubmitted finding and is quoted far more often.
- Is there any published measurement of clearinghouse-level rejection rates (277CA rejections, pre-adjudication) by provider type, from CAQH, WEDI or a state all-payer claims database? That would size the front-door rework loop that neither the 40.8% nor denial data captures.
- Does any behavioral-health EHR with a billing module (SimplePractice, TherapyNotes, Kipu, CentralReach, Valant) publish network-level claims statistics in an annual report or S-1-style disclosure, as opposed to marketing pages? Search found none; investor and trade-press material was not covered.
Related
- [[2026-10-17-behavioral-health-silent-rework-market-size]]
- [[2026-10-04-behavioral-health-claim-denial-rate-primary-sources]]
- [[2026-10-17-state-medicaid-behavioral-health-denial-rates-by-category]]
- [[2026-10-03-behavioral-health-billing-ai-bundled-vs-standalone]]
- [[2026-10-05-behavioral-health-billing-firm-ehr-count]]
- [[2026-10-01-national-rcm-eob-ai-behavioral-health-scan]]
Sources
Vault
- [[2026-10-17-behavioral-health-silent-rework-market-size]] (parent brief, read in full: 40.8% figure, Change Healthcare 2022 index read, plan year 2027 date)
- [[2026-10-04-behavioral-health-claim-denial-rate-primary-sources]] (Virginia ratios; via the parent brief's summary and search snippets)
- [[2026-10-17-state-medicaid-behavioral-health-denial-rates-by-category]] (9.31% applied-behavior-analysis row; title and snippet only)
- [[2026-10-03-behavioral-health-billing-ai-bundled-vs-standalone]], [[2026-10-05-behavioral-health-billing-firm-ehr-count]], [[2026-10-01-national-rcm-eob-ai-behavioral-health-scan]] (context; search snippets only)
Web, fetched (content relayed by the fetch tool's summarizer, so quotes are second-hand)
- OmniMD, "Average Claim Denial Rates by Specialty (2026 Report)," 20 March 2026. https://omnimd.com/blog/average-claim-denial-rates-by-specialty/ (vendor marketing; no source, sample or data year)
- Medi, "2026 Denial-Rate Benchmark by Specialty." https://medibilling.app/docs/denial-rate-benchmark-2026 (vendor marketing; states it has no proprietary dataset)
- Analytic Healthcare Solutions, "Behavioral Health Billing Denial Rate Benchmarks." https://www.globalahs.com/behavioral-health-billing-denial-rate-benchmarks/ (vendor marketing; experience-based targets)
Web, search-result summaries only (not opened; all vendor marketing)
- https://revenuelogic.io/behavioral-health-billing/claims-submission/
- https://claimmaxrcm.com/clearinghouse-rejections-medical-billing-2/
- https://mdrevenuegroup.com/blog/behavioral-health-billing-kpis-monthly-scorecard
- https://www.breezybilling.net/blog/clean-claim-rate
- https://medheave.com/revenue-cycle-management/key-metrics-for-rcm-performance-in-behavioral-health/
- https://www.medprecisionbilling.com/services/medical-claims-processing-services/
- https://www.kff.org/patient-consumer-protections/claims-denials-and-appeals-in-aca-marketplace-plans-in-2024/ (plan year 2027 behavioral-health reporting element, consistent with the parent brief)
Failed / skipped
- https://business.optum.com/en/insights/2024-denials-index.html returned HTTP 404 (guessed URL; the Optum 2024 index was not read)
- MGMA DataDive: member-only paywall, not attempted
Research budget used: QMD 2 of 5; WebSearch 3 of 3; WebFetch 3 sources read of 3, plus 1 attempt that returned 404.