The $118 appeal cost is real and first-party: it is on slide 6 of the 2017 Change Healthcare index, with no published derivation
The question
Does the superseded 2017 Change Healthcare Healthy Hospital Revenue Cycle Index actually contain the $118 formal-appeal cost figure, or is that number a secondary-source artifact with no first-party origin at all?
Context: [[2026-10-17-behavioral-health-silent-rework-market-size]] found the 2022 successor index carries no cost figure of any kind and could only trace $118 through a vendor attribution table to an MGMA article of December 2018. That left open whether the number had a first-party origin at all.
Answer: yes, it has one. The figure is in the original 2017 index and in the same-day press release. It is not a secondary-source artifact. No retraction is needed. What the index does not contain is any derivation, sample size, or definition of what work the $118 covers.
What we already know (from the vault)
- The parent brief established that $118 is quoted as a formal-appeal figure for hospitals, attributed to MGMA (December 2018) citing a 2017 Change Healthcare index, and that the 2022 Change Healthcare Revenue Cycle Denials Index contains no cost-per-claim figure ([[2026-10-17-behavioral-health-silent-rework-market-size]]).
- The same brief found the circulating "$25 to $118 per claim" range is a splice of two units of work: MGMA's $25.20 practice-level rework (March 2021, no sample) and the hospital appeal figure. That finding stands and is sharpened below.
- The only vault note citing the $118 appeal figure is the parent brief itself (lines 48, 49, 80 and 114). A
grep -rn '\$118'across the vault returns other hits, all unrelated dollar amounts (finance pulse, tax prep, Quiver cost projections, a reverse-mortgage table, a capex brief). - Behavioral-health billing context for the family venture sits in [[2026-10-03-behavioral-health-billing-ai-bundled-vs-standalone]] and [[2026-10-05-behavioral-health-billing-firm-ehr-count]]; neither quotes the $118.
What the web says
- The index itself contains the figure, twice. The original 10-slide PDF (file name
Change_Healthcare_Healthy_Hospital_Denials_Index_2017-06-A.pdf, PDF metadata creation date 23 June 2017, authored in PowerPoint) was retrieved from the Wayback Machine capture of the Business Wire media attachment and read directly, including rendered images of slides 3 and 6. Slide 6, titled "Appeals Are Costly", reads: "While 63% of denied claims are recoverable on average, appeals cost providers roughly $118 per claim, or as much as $8.6 billion in administrative costs nationally." The graphic labels it "Appeals Cost Average $118 Per Claim" and "Total Admin Costs $8.6 Billion." (Change Healthcare, 2017, slide 6.) - The entire published methodology for the number is one sentence. Slide 3: "The $118 per claim average appeal cost is based on Change Healthcare statistical averages for hospital customers." The same slide adds: "The data used for the analysis is based on internal Change Healthcare data, and may or may not be representative." No sample size, no cost components, no time-per-appeal, no labor rate, and no definition of "appeal" are given for the $118. The 724-hospital, 3.3-billion-transaction sample described on that slide is the basis for the charge and denial amounts, not stated as the basis for the cost figure.
- The earliest dated citation is Change Healthcare's own press release, 26 June 2017, 09:00 Eastern, issued at the HFMA ANI 2017 conference in Orlando. Its subhead: "appeals costing providers $8.6 billion to rework, an average of $118 per claim." Its body: "reworking each denial costs providers roughly $118 per claim, or as much as $8.6 billion in appeals-related administrative costs." (Business Wire, release 20170626005391, read from a Wayback capture dated 6 March 2019.)
- The appeal-versus-rework blur starts at the source, on day one. The index slide says "appeals cost"; the press release for the same document says "reworking each denial costs." Change Healthcare used both words for one number in two documents published together. Downstream confusion is inherited from the vendor, not introduced by secondary writers.
- Trade press repeated it the same week. Search results show Becker's Hospital Review running the headline "Denial rework costs providers roughly $118 per claim: 4 takeaways", plus Healthcare Finance News, Healthcare Dive and ACDIS ("Claims appeals cost hospitals up to $8.6 billion annually"). These were seen in search results only; the Becker's page returned no usable text to a direct fetch and was not retried, so its exact publication date is unverified. Becker's choice of "rework" in the headline is the likely route by which the figure entered the rework-cost conversation.
- The national total implies a volume the index never states. $8.6 billion divided by $118 is about 72.9 million claims. That arithmetic is mine. The index publishes no count of denied or appealed claims, so it is not possible to tell from the document whether $8.6 billion was built up from $118 times a claim count or $118 was backed out of a total.
- Minor defect in the source. Slide 3 footnotes the $118 to note 1 (Change Healthcare statistical averages for hospital customers). Slide 6 marks it with a superscript 2, which on slide 3 is the reimbursement-rate note, and slide 6 carries no footnotes of its own. This looks like a numbering slip and does not change the stated basis.
- Not retrieved: the companion microsite MyHealthyHospital.com, which the press release points to "for more details on the methodology." The Wayback index shows only redirects and asset files for the 2017 index pages, and the one broad index query I ran against the vendor's own domain hit a temporary Internet Archive outage. A fuller methodology may have existed there; none was found.
Convergences and contradictions
- Corrects the parent brief on one point. The parent brief wrote that $118 "cannot be traced to a current first-party publication" and raised the possibility of no first-party origin. The first half remains true (the 2022 successor dropped it); the possibility in the second half is now ruled out. The figure has a dated, retrievable first-party source.
- Confirms the parent brief on scope. It is a hospital figure, from one vendor's customer base, for 2016 claims, published 2017. It was never a physician-practice or behavioral-health number.
- Sharpens the splice finding. The "$25 to $118" range still joins two settings and two publishers. But the claim that it joins "rework" to "formal appeal" is less clean than the parent brief stated, because the $118's own publisher called it both. The accurate statement is that the unit of work behind $118 is undefined at source.
Synthesis for RDCO
The provenance question is closed, and the answer is the less dramatic one: the number is real, first-party and dated. Anyone who says the $118 has no origin is wrong, and the vault should not say it. The right citation is Change Healthcare, Healthy Hospital Revenue Cycle Index, June 2017, slide 6, with the press release of 26 June 2017 as the earliest dated instance. The MGMA December 2018 article is a secondary citation and should stop being treated as the source.
What the source cannot support is most of what the number is used for. It is a single vendor's "statistical average" for its own hospital customers on 2016 claims, published in a ten-slide marketing deck released at a trade show to promote the vendor's analytics products, with an explicit disclaimer that the data "may or may not be representative." It has no stated sample, no cost build-up and no definition of an appeal. It is nine years old, has never been updated, and was dropped from the successor publication. Premier's $43.84 (2022) and $57.23 (2023) figures for full adjudication of a disputed claim are newer, first-party, and less than half the size, which is a reason to doubt that $118 describes a typical denial today, though the units are not confirmed to match.
For the family behavioral-health billing venture, the practical consequence is on the cost side of any appeal-versus-rework comparison. A model that prices a formal appeal at $118 and quiet rework at $25 is comparing an undefined hospital vendor average from 2016 against an unsampled practice figure from 2021, and the gap between them is not evidence that appeals cost about five times what rework costs. No number in this chain was measured for behavioral health. If the venture's case needs a cost per touch, it has to come from timing the work directly in a real billing operation, not from this literature.
One caution on my own reading: I verified the index and the press release at source, but the trade coverage only through search results, and I did not recover the microsite. The statement that no fuller methodology exists is an absence of evidence from an incomplete search, not a confirmed negative.
Why this is in the vault
It settles the open follow-up in [[2026-10-17-behavioral-health-silent-rework-market-size]] and fixes the citation and the caveats for any cost-per-denial input used in the family revenue-cycle venture's unit economics, so the $118 is neither dismissed as fabricated nor quoted as a measured benchmark.
Open follow-ups
- Did the 2017 MyHealthyHospital.com microsite publish a fuller methodology for the $118 (cost components, number of appeals, definition of an appeal)? A targeted Wayback pass on that domain's 2017 captures, run when the archive is not rate-limiting, would answer it.
- Are Premier's $43.84 and $57.23 "cost to adjudicate a disputed claim" figures the same unit of work as Change Healthcare's 2017 "appeal cost", and does Premier publish a sample and method that would make it the better benchmark to cite?
- Has any source timed denial follow-up work directly (minutes per touch and labor rate) in a behavioral-health or small-practice billing operation, as opposed to reporting a vendor average?
Related
- [[2026-10-17-behavioral-health-silent-rework-market-size]] (parent brief; only vault note citing the $118 appeal figure, at lines 48, 49, 80 and 114; its wording on first-party origin should be read alongside this brief)
- [[2026-10-03-behavioral-health-billing-ai-bundled-vs-standalone]]
- [[2026-10-05-behavioral-health-billing-firm-ehr-count]]
Sources
Primary, first-party, original document downloaded and read (text extraction plus rendered slides 3 and 6)
- Change Healthcare. Change Healthcare Healthy Hospital Revenue Cycle Index. June 2017. 10 slides. Wayback capture of the Business Wire media attachment: https://web.archive.org/web/20190307202910/https://mms.businesswire.com/media/20170626005391/en/595152/1/Change_Healthcare_Healthy_Hospital_Denials_Index_2017-06-A.pdf?download=1 (the live Business Wire media URL returns HTTP 403 to a plain fetch; the Wayback copy was used. Vendor-published marketing analysis promoting Change Healthcare's own revenue-cycle analytics products.)
Primary, first-party press release
- Change Healthcare. "Change Healthcare Analysis: An Estimated $262 Billion in Healthcare Claims Initially Denied in 2016." Business Wire, 26 June 2017. Wayback capture: https://web.archive.org/web/20190306141555/https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20170626005391/en/4106794/Change-Healthcare-Analysis-Estimated-262-Billion-Healthcare
Secondary, seen in search results only, not fetched or not readable
- Becker's Hospital Review, "Denial rework costs providers roughly $118 per claim: 4 takeaways." https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/finance/denial-rework-costs-providers-roughly-118-per-claim-4-takeaways.html (direct fetch returned no article text; not retried; date unverified)
- ACDIS, "News: Claims appeals cost hospitals up to 8.6 billion annually." https://acdis.org/node/6877
- Healthcare Dive, "Report: $262B in healthcare claims initially denied last year." https://www.healthcaredive.com/news/report-262b-in-healthcare-claims-initially-denied-last-year/445758/
- Healthcare Finance News coverage of the same release. https://www.healthcarefinancenews.com/news/change-healthcare-analysis-shows-262-billion-medical-claims-initially-denied-meaning-billions
Vault
- [[2026-10-17-behavioral-health-silent-rework-market-size]]
- [[2026-10-03-behavioral-health-billing-ai-bundled-vs-standalone]]
- [[2026-10-05-behavioral-health-billing-firm-ehr-count]]
Flagged, not retried
- MGMA and HFMA member-only methodology (out of scope per dispatch; not attempted).
- MyHealthyHospital.com 2017 microsite: no content capture found; one Wayback index query failed on a temporary archive outage.
Research budget used: QMD 0 of 5 (vault coverage done by direct grep and by reading the parent brief); WebSearch 1 of 3; WebFetch 0 of 3, replaced by direct curl retrievals: 2 Wayback page or PDF downloads, 3 Wayback index queries, 1 blocked Becker's fetch, 1 blocked live Business Wire fetch.