Canva is the only comparable that meters generation, and it sells volume rather than capability — while Etsy banned AI-generated instructions and TPT is reported to be banning AI resources
The question
"Where exactly do comparable marketplaces (Teachers Pay Teachers, Canva, Etsy print shops) draw the line between free/curated content and paid/custom-generated content, and what conversion data exists for that split?"
Asked to pressure-test the Scribble Works tier line against live comparables, rather than against general freemium theory, which the vault already covers.
What we already know (from the vault)
- The founder ruling is two rulings, and the newer one is narrower than the slogan. Ruling 14 (2026-09-01 21:35 ET, [[2026-08-31-product-model-rulings]]) is the "curation free / generation paid" wording: "free / no-account = Ray curates a playset from the shelf; paid = Ray generates new pages on demand. Curation is the magic moment; generation is the subscription." Ruling 31 (2026-09-02 18:44 ET, same doc) narrowed it: signed-in free gets the rolling two-week plan and the whole shelf but "must self-curate those playsets," while "AI-curation and customization ... is a paid plan," delivered by email. The doc's own gloss: "the plan is free, the filling and the sending are paid." [[2026-09-11-business-opportunity-pricing-and-acquisition]] restates the current line as the "free manual-planning versus paid curation/delivery boundary." The standalone phrase "curation FREE / generation PAID" appears nowhere verbatim.
- The paywall mapping was explicitly held open. Ruling 20's 07:19 ET correction (2026-09-02): the founder was "talking more about our cost basis... The what capabilities do we paywall is a different discussion." The code-free / model-paid tier mapping was recorded as WITHDRAWN. The tier table in [[2026-09-02-tier-line-plan]] is Ray's proposal, not a ruling, and ruling 31 overrode its gateway framing.
- Free, not price, is the competitor. [[2026-07-23-executable-agentic-info-product-pricing-scan]]: "Every operator in this scan runs a large free tier as top-of-funnel." Its boundary recommendation was free = a scoped runnable instance that produces a real finding, paid = the methodology and the runbook. [[2026-08-30-step1-memo]] reached the same place from the printables side — "the market largely clears at zero," Education.com gives away three downloads a month — and recommended shipping step 1 entirely free, revisiting as "free-catalog-plus-paid-packs rather than subscription."
- The no-conversion-data finding is already established and should not be re-derived. [[2026-08-18-free-skill-funnel-paid-conversion]]: "Nobody in this ecosystem publishes the number." Its two load-bearing conclusions: cannibalization resolves NO on available evidence, and "every quantified source blames the boundary, not the abundance" — free tiers fail by never producing an upgrade trigger. [[2026-09-05-kids-subscription-box-comparables-scribble-works]] found the same vacuum on retention: "None of the three discloses churn, and none is required to."
- The TPT price line in the vault is unverified and still is. [[2026-08-30-step1-memo]]: "Individual preschool items commonly $1.25-3.25. Bundles ~$25," sourced from browse snippets with "no individual listing verified," under a table-wide warning that nothing was read off a live pricing page. This brief did not re-verify it either; listing-level fetches remain blocked.
What the web says
- TPT: "free" is a seller-set price field, and the platform caps how much of it a seller may run. Free resources are an ordinary listing at $0, surfaced by a
Price: Freesearch facet at/browse/free, not a curated hub; a free TPT account is required to download them (help.teacherspayteachers.com, updated 2026-07-22, observed 2026-10-31). TPT's Seller Guidelines endorse the funnel and then ceiling it, verbatim: "You're welcome to offer free resources to showcase the quality of your work and attract Buyers to your store. However, the majority of resources in your store should be paid listings" (observed 2026-10-31, page stamped ~2026-10-15). TPT also retired its all-access subscription and is moving to restrict AI generation rather than sell it. TPT School Access, the flat-fee unlimited-use product over a curated library, "was retired on September 30, 2025"; its replacement, School Express, is a prepaid wallet where "Resources are purchased at the marketplace price" and "It isn't a separate subscription platform" (both TPT help pages, observed 2026-10-31). Seller tiers as of 2026-10-31: Basic $29 one-time / 55% payout / 30c per resource; Exclusive $59.95/yr / 77.5% payout (80% until 2027-01-01) / 15c on orders under $3, plus platform exclusivity. Premium closed to new sign-ups 2026-10-01. On AI: TPT's Seller Guidelines contain no AI clause, and no TPT AI generation feature was found for buyers or sellers; Chalkbeat (2026-10-15) reports TPT plans to ban AI-generated resources, quoting spokeswoman Sarah Lehman that seller material "should be unique, expertly crafted, and AI-free." No effective date published. Trade press, not a vendor page — flagged as such. - Canva is the only comparable that meters generation, and it meters it on both sides of the pay line. Canva's unit is a "monthly AI allowance" across Standard / Premium / Ultra tool tiers, which "resets each month" (canva.com/help/ai-access/, observed 2026-10-31 — read directly in-browser for this brief). The en-US page now publishes only multipliers: Pro gets "10x more AI allowance than Canva Free," Business/Enterprise "20x more." The en_gb variant still carries absolutes: Canva Free "Up to 20 uses of Standard AI tools OR Premium AI tools"; Pro "up to 200 uses of Premium AI tools OR up to 20 uses of Ultra AI tools" (observed 2026-10-31). Crucially, free is not zero — and at the cap Free users get "short pauses between generations," not a wall. But the top tier is paid-only: Ultra AI tools (conversational design, video generation) appear only in paid allowances, and overage is a separate SKU, AI Pass at "USD $100 globally per person, per month" for 40x Pro's allowance, also unavailable on Free. Three caveats on quoting any of this: the 20-use free figure exists only on the en_gb page, the en-US page has withdrawn absolute numbers in favour of multipliers (itself evidence of how fast these caps move), and Canva's own pricing table and help page disagree on whether "Create an image with Canva AI" is a Standard or a Premium tool.
- Canva's hard paywall is the curated library, gated per item by watermark. canva.com/pricing (observed 2026-10-31): Free 4.7M+ stock assets and 1.6M+ templates; Pro 141M+ assets and 3.6M+ templates, at US$144/yr (Business US$250/yr per person, yearly view). Enforcement, verbatim from canva.com/help/premium-elements/: "Premium elements will have watermarks (criss-cross patterns) on your design until they're purchased," clearable per item via a "Remove watermarks" button, licensed per design — "If you want to use them on several designs, purchase new licenses for each use." Meanwhile the editor and export as PDF/JPG/PNG are free; print-ready CMYK export is not.
- Etsy has no free/paid content split at all, and in October 2026 it banned AI-generated instructions. Browsing and buying are free with no buyer tier; sellers pay $0.20 per listing, 6.5% transaction, 3% + $0.25 US processing, with Etsy Plus at $10/mo (etsy.com/legal/fees/, last updated 2026-10-05). Digital downloads sit in the "Designed by a seller" category and "must be made and/or designed by you, the seller," with a distinct made-to-order download listing type where no file is uploaded until after purchase — the structural match for pay-to-generate; Etsy's FY2025 10-K (filed 2026-02-19) puts custom and made-to-order merchandise at roughly 30% of total GMS. Seller-prompted AI is allowed with mandatory disclosure and requires "direct, individual human prompting, curation, and creative input into that specific item." But the Seller Handbook article stamped 2026-10-22 adds a categorical ban: "AI-generated functional instructions are not allowed on Etsy," naming craft patterns, recipes, project plans, assembly manuals, and "instructional guides or e-books that provide directions for completing a task." Etsy's stated reason: such output "may be more likely to contain errors or lead to poor results, and buyers often won't discover the problem until they've already spent time and materials following them."
- Conversion data: none of the three publishes a free-to-paid rate, for three different structural reasons. TPT carries an "IXL family of brands" mark and an "(c) 2026 by IXL Learning" footer on its own About-Us page, and IXL is privately held, so no disclosure obligation applies; TPT's seller analytics are also listing-scoped, with no cross-resource metric linking a free download to a later purchase, so sellers cannot compute the rate either. Etsy is public but has no free content tier to convert from; its FY2025 10-K (filed 2026-02-19) and Q3 2026 10-Q disclose GMS, take rate (24.2% FY2025, 26.2% Q3 2026) and buyer cohorts, and use "conversion" only qualitatively or about Etsy Ads. No Canva free-to-paid rate appears on any Canva page read for this brief, and the one likely on-record exec characterisation of it (Inc., 2026-02-24, headlined "the Power of Free") is paywalled and was not read. The single vendor-page sentence pairing both numbers is "over 230 million people ... Our subscriber base has grown to over 24 million" (canva.com/newsroom, 2025-06-10), a computed 10.4%; end-2025 figures of 31.2M paid against 265M monthly active users, reported second-hand by Inc. and TechCrunch in Feb 2026 and not confirmed on a Canva page, compute to 11.8%. Both overstate true conversion, because the numerator counts seats rather than customers, the denominator counts active users rather than signups, and free-by-policy education seats sit inside it. The closest thing to an exec characterisation is Cliff Obrecht at a Stripe summit, via syndicated trade press (The Australian, republished Stockhead, 2026-08-24): with "200 plus million free users and say 30 plus million paying users," he said "the paying users need to subsidise the free users," that "a very generous free AI product comes with a huge cost," and that Canva slowed its AI rollout while cutting serving cost by about 90%. Hedged stage figures framed as cross-subsidy economics, not funnel performance.
- The nearest usable benchmark covers a different population, and must be labelled. RevenueCat's State of Subscription Apps 2026 reports a freemium median of 2.1% (top quartile above 4.5%) against 10.7% for hard-paywall apps, defined as "the share of installs that result in at least one paid subscription within 35 days of the install date," over "more than 115,000 apps" with 2025 as the target window. That population is mobile subscription apps carrying the RevenueCat SDK — not marketplaces, not printables, and not any of the three comparables. A targeted search for printables-specific freebie-to-purchase data surfaced only vendor blogs and single-seller anecdotes with no methodology; none was found.
- One real number is often mistaken for TPT conversion. It is not. Koehler, Shelton, Carpenter & Greenhalgh (Teachers College Record, 2020, data through Sept 2019): "A surprising 69% of all downloads on TPT were for free resources, although only 15% of the resources on TPT were listed as free." That is a demand-mix statistic across 1.53 billion downloads; it says nothing about whether a free downloader ever buys. Same dataset: over 92% of transactions were $5 or under, 81% of sales went to the top 1% of sellers, 34% of stores had $0 in sales, median store lifetime sales $131. Peer-reviewed but roughly seven years stale.
Convergences and contradictions
- Convergence, and it sharpens the vault's own best insight. [[2026-08-18-free-skill-funnel-paid-conversion]] concluded that free tiers fail by never producing an upgrade trigger, and that "every quantified source blames the boundary, not the abundance." Canva is that conclusion built into a product: free export is what makes the watermark bite, because the user reaches a finished file and then meets the gate. The trigger fires at the moment of completion, not at the moment of intent. The live Scribble Works surface has no such moment.
- Contradiction with the founder ruling as worded. Ruling 14 makes generation itself the paid capability. No comparable draws it there. Canva, the only one metering generation, gives its free tier a real nonzero allowance (up to 20 uses a month on the en_gb figure) and sells volume, degrading with pauses rather than blocking; what it keeps strictly paid is its top Ultra tier and its AI Pass overage, not generation as such. Etsy's made-to-order download does gate a generated deliverable behind payment, but Etsy has no free tier to contrast it with. And neither Etsy nor TPT is moving toward monetizing AI generation: Etsy banned AI-generated functional instructions outright on 2026-10-22, and TPT is reported, on trade press only, to be planning a broader ban. Ruling 31 already drifted toward the Canva shape without naming it, since it put "self-curate" on the free side and sold the filling and the sending.
- Contradiction between the vault's TPT price line and what is verifiable. [[2026-08-30-step1-memo]]'s $1.25-3.25 figures remain snippet-level; this brief could not re-verify listing prices (TPT help and Etsy legal pages both return 403 to automated fetch, and listing-level prices were not read live). The academic "over 92% of transactions at $5 or under" is better sourced but is a different metric (transaction value, not list price) and is roughly seven years stale, so it belongs alongside the vault figure with both caveats, not in place of it.
Synthesis for RDCO
The question assumed the comparables would show us where to put the free/paid line for generated content. The honest finding is that two of the three have no such line, and the third draws it somewhere other than where ruling 14 draws it. TPT's free/paid boundary is a seller's price field with a policy ceiling on how much free a store may run — a marketplace-governance rule, not a product design, and one Scribble Works is structurally exempt from because it is a single publisher rather than a marketplace. That exemption matters: the step1-memo's instinct to ship entirely free has more headroom than a TPT comparison would imply, because nobody caps how much free RDCO may give away. Etsy has no free tier whatsoever; its only relevant structure is the made-to-order download listing, which is the cleanest external proof that "pay to have one generated for you" is a recognised commercial shape, carried by roughly 30% of Etsy GMS in custom and made-to-order merchandise.
Canva is the only real precedent, and its lesson cuts against ruling 14's wording. Canva does not make generation as such the paid capability: it gives Canva Free a genuine metered taste, sells roughly a 10x multiple of the same tools to Pro, and degrades at the cap with pauses rather than a wall. What it does keep strictly paid is the top of the range, the Ultra tier and the AI Pass overage, and its hard wall sits somewhere else entirely, on the curated asset library, gated per item by watermark, with the editor and basic export deliberately free as the acquisition surface. Canva's stated rationale for the metering is cost, via syndicated trade press rather than a vendor page: Cliff Obrecht (2026-08-24) said "the paying users need to subsidise the free users," that "a very generous free AI product comes with a huge cost," and that Canva slowed its AI rollout until serving cost fell about 90%. Scribble Works faces the same shape of economics far smaller, against a credit cost the vault carries as a $0.71 ceiling per 7-page pack and an unmeasured ~$0.10 per page ([[2026-09-02-tier-line-plan]]). So the transferable design is a generation allowance tiered by volume, nonzero on the free side, degrading rather than blocking, with the top capability tier reserved — close to the credits already proposed in [[2026-09-02-tier-line-plan]], but with one real trade-off it does not resolve. That plan's Decision 3 default of a lifetime-20 free Customize budget is deliberate: the twentieth customization is the designed upgrade trigger, "moment 3." Canva's resetting monthly allowance is the only comparable shape in evidence, and a reset removes that scarcity moment and replaces it with a recurring one. Nothing found here says which converts better; the choice is between a one-time cliff that fires once per household and a monthly ceiling that fires every month, and only the second has an external precedent.
The live surface is where this becomes urgent, and it is the gap this brief most wants in front of the founder. As of 2026-10-31, scribbleworks.co has no pricing page at all (/pricing returns 404), the home page contains no pricing, paid, credit or subscription language, and the FAQ reads: "Every game on the shelf prints free, and you don't need an account or an email address to do it. That part stays free, and it is not going to stop being free," with an account required for "having the AI customize a game for your kid." So the line currently shipped is curation free / generation identity-gated, not payment-gated — a defensible pre-revenue posture, consistent with the vault's record that the founder-owned Stripe account is not yet opened and nothing billable can go live without it ([[2026-09-02-members-area-spec]]), but it means the product today has no upgrade trigger anywhere in it. That is precisely the failure mode [[2026-08-18-free-skill-funnel-paid-conversion]] identified as the one that actually kills free tiers. The founder-facing decision is not what to charge; it is where the completion moment lives, because Canva's watermark works by sitting exactly there.
One risk this scan surfaced that was not in scope and should not be buried. Both of the two marketplaces scanned here moved against AI-generated content in the same month. Etsy's 2026-10-22 ban on "AI-generated functional instructions" names craft patterns, recipes, project plans and "instructional guides" — and does not name worksheets, activity sheets or educational printables, so whether a Scribble Works page falls inside it is genuinely unresolved on the face of the policy. TPT's ban is broader and vaguer still, and exists only in trade press as of 2026-10-31. Scribble Works sells direct and is bound by neither, so this is not a compliance problem today. It is a signal, not a settled norm: Etsy still explicitly permits seller-prompted AI with disclosure, and whether its ban even reaches a worksheet is unresolved on the policy's face. What is worth carrying is Etsy's stated rationale, that buyers discover errors only after spending time and materials. SW's existing answer to that rationale is already strong and under-used in positioning: ruling 14 requires generated pages to pass the critic before a child sees them. The parent-trust framing, not the capability framing, is what survives this norm — which fits the product's "parents on site, kids on paper" principle and its "AI tutor without the screen" line ([[2026-09-19-mentava-motivation-mechanics-paper-translation-scribble-works]]) better than a generation-volume pitch does.
Why this is in the vault
Supplies the external comparables for Decision 3 of [[2026-09-02-tier-line-plan]] (free Customize budget: lifetime 20 versus a monthly reset), left open by ruling 31, without resolving it. It also flags Etsy's 2026-10-22 functional-instructions ban as an unresolved constraint on ever using a marketplace as a Scribble Works distribution channel.
Open follow-ups
- Does Etsy's "functional instructions" ban reach educational worksheets and activity sheets? The 2026-10-22 policy text names patterns, recipes, plans and instructional guides but not worksheets, and no Etsy page resolves it. This governs whether Etsy is ever a viable SW channel.
- Where should the completion moment sit in the Scribble Works flow, given that Canva's watermark works by sitting at the finished-file step and SW's free print path currently ends with a finished PDF and no gate?
- Has any operator in the printables or education-resource category published a free-to-paid conversion figure since 2026-08-18? This brief extends that negative result into marketplaces; the open question is whether a category-specific number exists anywhere, as opposed to the mobile-app benchmark that has to stand in for it.
- Does a resetting monthly allowance outperform a lifetime trial allowance at the same total free volume? Canva's structure is evidence of the choice but not of the outcome, and no comparable publishes the A/B.
- What does TPT's forthcoming AI ban actually cover, and does it have an effective date? Only trade press has it as of 2026-10-31; TPT's own Seller Guidelines still contain no AI clause.
Related
- [[2026-11-07-teachers-pay-teachers-ai-policy-scope-effective-date]] - closes open follow-up #5: thirty days after the town hall, TPT has published no AI clause anywhere (Seller Guidelines, Content Guidelines, ToS); the only new AI text is a training-data promise, not a content ban
- [[2026-08-31-product-model-rulings]]
- [[2026-09-02-tier-line-plan]]
- [[2026-08-30-step1-memo]]
- [[2026-09-11-business-opportunity-pricing-and-acquisition]]
- [[2026-08-18-free-skill-funnel-paid-conversion]]
- [[2026-07-23-executable-agentic-info-product-pricing-scan]]
- [[2026-09-05-kids-subscription-box-comparables-scribble-works]]
- [[2026-09-19-mentava-motivation-mechanics-paper-translation-scribble-works]]
- [[2026-09-02-members-area-spec]]
- [[2026-08-24-claude-marketplace-free-skill-paid-cta-policy]]
- [[2026-09-16-us-household-printer-access-printable-subscription-tam]]
Sources
Vault
~/rdco-vault/01-projects/printables-product/2026-08-31-product-model-rulings.md— rulings 14, 20, 26, 31, 33~/rdco-vault/01-projects/printables-product/2026-09-02-tier-line-plan.md~/rdco-vault/01-projects/printables-product/2026-08-30-step1-memo.md~/rdco-vault/01-projects/printables-product/2026-09-11-business-opportunity-pricing-and-acquisition.md~/rdco-vault/06-reference/research/2026-08-18-free-skill-funnel-paid-conversion.md~/rdco-vault/06-reference/research/2026-07-23-executable-agentic-info-product-pricing-scan.md~/rdco-vault/06-reference/research/2026-09-05-kids-subscription-box-comparables-scribble-works.md~/rdco-vault/01-projects/printables-product/2026-09-02-members-area-spec.md— Stripe prerequisite~/rdco-vault/06-reference/research/2026-09-19-mentava-motivation-mechanics-paper-translation-scribble-works.md— SW-R18 product principle
Teachers Pay Teachers (all observed 2026-10-31)
- https://help.teacherspayteachers.com/hc/en-us/articles/360042626591-What-are-TPT-s-Seller-Guidelines — free/paid balance rule
- https://help.teacherspayteachers.com/hc/en-us/articles/360042469292-How-do-I-find-free-resources — free as price filter
- https://help.teacherspayteachers.com/hc/en-us/articles/360044219891-Seller-Fees-and-Payout-Rates — Basic/Exclusive tiers
- https://help.teacherspayteachers.com/hc/en-us/articles/35564860829204-What-happened-to-TPT-School-Access — retired 2025-09-30
- https://help.teacherspayteachers.com/hc/en-us/articles/39129533654548-How-does-TPT-School-Express-differ-from-TPT-School-Access-and-TPT-for-Schools
- https://www.chalkbeat.org/2026/10/15/teachers-pay-teachers-to-ban-ai-generated-teaching-resources/ — trade press, AI ban
- https://www.teacherspayteachers.com/About-Us — IXL family of brands, (c) 2026 by IXL Learning
- https://help.teacherspayteachers.com/hc/en-us/articles/360042733831-Where-can-I-find-statistics-on-my-products — listing-scoped seller analytics
- https://spencergreenhalgh.com/2020-Koehler-et-al-TPT.pdf — Koehler et al. 2020, data through Sept 2019
Canva (all observed 2026-10-31)
- https://www.canva.com/help/ai-access/ — monthly AI allowance, tiers, multipliers, cap behaviour (read in-browser)
- https://www.canva.com/en_gb/help/ai-access/ — absolute allowance numbers still published
- https://www.canva.com/help/ai-pass/ — AI Pass US$100/person/month
- https://www.canva.com/pricing/ — plans, asset and template counts
- https://www.canva.com/help/premium-elements/ — watermark mechanism, Pro Content license
- https://www.canva.com/newsroom/news/cnbc-disruptor-50-2025/ (2025-06-10) — 230M people / 24M subscribers
- The Australian (Perry Williams) via Stockhead, 2026-08-24 — Obrecht on paid subsidising free AI; syndicated trade press, no vendor-page equivalent found
Etsy (all observed 2026-10-31)
- https://www.etsy.com/legal/creativity/ — Creativity Standards, stamped 2025-06-10
- https://www.etsy.com/seller-handbook/article/1275449912004 — AI stance, stamped 2026-10-22, functional-instructions ban
- https://www.etsy.com/legal/policy/listing-image-requirements/253962679005 — stamped 2026-10-22
- https://www.etsy.com/legal/fees/ — last updated 2026-10-05
- https://help.etsy.com/hc/en-us/articles/115015628347-How-to-Manage-Your-Digital-Listings — instant vs made-to-order
- SEC EDGAR CIK 1370637 — FY2025 10-K filed 2026-02-19 (take rate, buyer cohorts, custom/made-to-order ~30% of GMS); Q3 2026 10-Q and shareholder letter, 2026-10-28
Benchmarks and own-product observation
- https://www.revenuecat.com/state-of-subscription-apps-2026/ — freemium median 2.1%, 115,000+ mobile subscription apps, D35 installs-to-paid
- https://scribbleworks.co/faq/ and https://scribbleworks.co/ — RDCO's own live surface, observed 2026-10-31: no pricing page, free printing promised, generation account-gated
Blocked, flagged, not retried
- canva.com returns HTTP 403 to automated fetch on every path; read via browser instead
- help.teacherspayteachers.com and etsy.com/legal/* return HTTP 403 to automated fetch; read via browser instead
- twinkl.com/premium/choose returned an empty body; Twinkl figures remain secondary and were not used as load-bearing
- Inc. 2026-02-24 "the Power of Free" section is paywalled — likely the only on-record Canva exec characterisation of free-to-paid
- Teachers College Record full text paywalled; the author-hosted PDF was used instead