The adopted SAPWG item never says "private credit," adds no new fields, and the two Schedule BA magnitudes were a real but misdated YE2024 snapshot
The question
Verbatim: "Do the adopted year-end-2026 NAIC SAPWG private-credit reporting changes make AI-infrastructure credit separable in a statutory annual statement, or does it stay buried in Schedule BA — and do the cited Schedule BA magnitudes (6.4% of invested assets, +7.8% YoY) survive a primary-document check?"
Two merged follow-ups from [[2026-08-13-ai-capex-lender-exposure-insurance-pension-vehicles]], both resolving against the same NAIC (National Association of Insurance Commissioners) primary documents in one pass. The parent brief itself flagged the magnitudes as conference-summary-only and barred their reuse until checked. Note at the outset that the question's own framing — "private-credit reporting changes" effective "year-end-2026" — is itself inherited from the secondary source and does not survive contact with the primary text.
What we already know (from the vault)
- The parent brief asserted Schedule BA "grew 7.8% YoY to 6.4% of total invested assets" and that the Statutory Accounting Principles (E) Working Group (SAPWG) "adopted changes effective for year-end 2026 specifically to improve reporting of private credit holdings by insurers" — both sourced to a J.P. Morgan Asset Management conference recap, with an explicit do-not-reuse flag attached [[2026-08-13-ai-capex-lender-exposure-insurance-pension-vehicles]].
- That brief's conclusion was a latency argument: the first Schedule BA reflection of AI-capex credit arrives in year-end-2026 statements filed around March 2027, concurrent with or after the transition window of Q3 2026 to H1 2027 that the vault tracks as the phase-2-to-phase-3 turn [[2026-07-07-dram-hbm-phase2-phase3-early-signals]]. A leading indicator that arrives with the event is not a leading indicator.
- Its recommended gauge deliberately routed away from statutory data: data-center asset-backed-securities (ABS) new-issue spread, subordination levels, and business-development-company (BDC) non-accrual rate — "not 13Fs, not Schedule BA."
- The sibling brief found the parent's Form 13F eligibility premise was wrong while its conclusion survived anyway, because Form 13F has no look-through field [[2026-10-22-13f-eligibility-bdc-feeder-interval-funds]]. This brief lands the same shape of result on the statutory leg.
What the web says
(a) The separability read — the adopted text. The item behind the "private credit reporting changes" characterization is Ref #2025-29, "Reporting Clarifications," exposed December 9, 2025 and adopted by SAPWG on March 23, 2026 (NAIC Ref #2025-29 agenda item).
- The phrase "private credit" appears zero times in the adopted agenda item, and zero times in the SAPWG hearing agenda for that meeting (SAPWG hearing agenda, March 23 2026). The item's own scope statement is narrower and differently aimed: to "modify and/or clarify reporting for certain investments, particularly for aspects related to debt securities predominantly incorporated with the implementation of the principles-based bond definition." It is a bond-definition cleanup, not an asset-class initiative.
- It adds no new reporting fields. This is the correction that matters most, because it is the opposite of what both the recap and our parent brief implied. All three touched elements already exist in the blank: Payment Due at Maturity is "currently in electronic column 20 for both Schedule D-1-1: Issuer Credit Obligations (ICOs) and Schedule D-1-2: Asset-Backed Securities (ABS)"; Origination Balloon Payment % is a "Current annual statement instruction" whose "reporting column is limited to ABS classified as financial ABS – not self-liquidating, non-financial ABS – practical expedient, and non-financial ABS – full analysis"; and the Schedule BA maturity-date instruction already "require[s] reporting for investments that have a stated maturity date." The adopted text is explicit that the balloon-payment scoping is unchanged: "There are no proposed changes to the applicable categories." The item states it "did not result in any SSAP revisions" (Statements of Statutory Accounting Principles) and only "communicates support for sponsoring a blanks proposal."
- The one change that would have created separability was proposed by NAIC staff and then declined. The exposure draft proposed, for rated notes and rated feeder funds, that "a new investment characteristic code (for identification in electronic column 23) be developed to identify whether the reported is a rated note / feeder fund," noting that "the reporting line for rated notes or rated feeder funds is not currently defined in existing guidance." At adoption this was dropped: "The Working Group did not propose revisions for rated notes or feeder funds, aggregate deferred interest or to clarify the reporting of SSAP No. 48 investments on Schedule BA as part of this agenda item." The hearing agenda's reasoning: "Pursuant to industry comments these are properly being reported as ABS. If a code is supported in the investment schedules, this could be further considered." Rated notes and rated feeder funds are precisely the wrappers through which private credit reaches insurer balance sheets.
- The door is explicitly left ajar, not closed. The declined list is headed "Unless otherwise directed by the SAPWG, NAIC staff does not propose revisions for the following items at this time" — a staff recommendation, not a Working Group settlement. The adopted Status block also routes the adjacent question onward: "clarification of the SSAP No. 48 reporting, particularly based on the underlying characteristics of the SSAP No. 48 investments, will be included as part of agenda item 2025-26: SSAP No. 48 Equity Changes."
- Schedule BA's reported roll-up has no sector or collateral dimension. The NAIC's year-end-2025 aggregation of Schedule BA reports twelve asset-type rows — Private Equity, Hedge Funds, Real Estate, Mortgage Loans, Fixed Income/Bonds, Collateral Loans, Surplus Debentures, Any Other Class of Assets, Residual Tranches, Housing Tax Credits, Other, Non-Collateral Loans — with no private-credit, infrastructure, technology or data-center line (NAIC Capital Markets Bureau, Schedule BA YE2025). Caveat on the strength of this evidence: that is a summary report, not the blank itself, and the same report shows the schedule does carry some sub-detail beneath those rows (it names "leveraged buyouts" as the largest private-equity strategy and "multi-strategy" as the largest hedge-fund type). We did not reach the Schedule BA blank and instructions, so read this as "the published aggregation has no sector axis, and nothing in the adopted item creates one," not as a verified field-list of the blank.
(b) The magnitude check — against the NAIC primary. Both cited figures trace to real NAIC data, but to year-end 2024, and were already stale when the parent brief used them.
6.4%is verified but misdated. Primary, verbatim: "U.S. insurers' exposure to other long-term investments increased to 6.7% of the industry's total cash and invested assets at year-end 2025, from 6.4% in 2024 and 6.3% in 2023."+7.8%is not verified. The Schedule BA primary puts the year-end-2024 growth rate at "increased 8% from the year prior." The 7.8% figure most plausibly traces to the NAIC's separate year-end-2024 asset-mix report; either way it is a prior-year rate, not a current one.- Current correct pairing: Schedule BA reached $637.9bn book/adjusted carrying value (BACV) at year-end 2025, +10.3% YoY (from $578.1bn), and 6.7% of total cash and invested assets — double-digit growth for the first time since 2021, outpacing the industry portfolio's 6.7% growth. Published May 2026, analysts Jennifer Vento and Michele Wong.
- A category error sits underneath both numbers. Schedule BA is overwhelmingly an equity schedule: private equity, hedge funds and real estate are 70% of it. Summing the clearly credit-shaped lines (mortgage loans, fixed income/bonds, collateral loans, surplus debentures, residual tranches, non-collateral loans) gives ~$146bn, 22.8% of Schedule BA — roughly 1.5% of an implied ~$9.5trn in industry cash and invested assets (that denominator is derived, by back-solving $637.9bn ÷ 6.7%, not stated in the report). Treating "Schedule BA" as a proxy for insurer private-credit exposure overstates it by about 4x. The ~1.5% is a floor: two further lines, "Other" ($10.1bn, whose footnote includes capital notes and non-registered private funds) and "Any Other Class of Assets" ($23.8bn, uncharacterized), may contain additional credit.
Convergences and contradictions
- Direct contradiction with the secondary source, on two counts. The conference recap characterized the year-end-2026 changes as "specifically to improve reporting of private credit holdings." The adopted primary text never uses the term, makes no SSAP revisions, adds no new fields, and explicitly drops the rated-note/feeder-fund identification code that staff had proposed. This is a recap describing a bond-definition cleanup in the vocabulary of the year's hot asset class.
- Convergence on the conclusion, from a mistaken premise. The parent brief was right that statutory data will not resolve this exposure, and right to route the gauge to data-center ABS spreads instead. But its stated reason — that AI-infrastructure credit stays "buried in Schedule BA" — looks wrong. Per the hearing agenda, stating NAIC staff's position rather than anything adopted, rated notes and rated feeder funds are "properly being reported as ABS"; the further step that this puts them on Schedule D-1-2 rather than Schedule BA is our inference from the bond-definition schedule structure, not a quoted NAIC statement. The conclusion survives a wrong premise, exactly as in [[2026-10-22-13f-eligibility-bdc-feeder-interval-funds]].
- Where our own first pass was wrong, and it cuts in a useful direction. We initially read the balloon-payment scoping as newly added and therefore arriving in year-end-2026 filings around March 2027. The primary says that column already exists and already carries that exact three-category limit, with no changes adopted. So whatever that field offers is already in year-end-2025 filings, filed around March 2026 — available now rather than in 2027. But available is not the same as clean: year-end 2025 is the first-year bond-definition vintage that Ref #2025-29 exists to clean up, and the item documents a specific population gap on this very field — "Clarification was requested to allow use of 'acquisition data' when origination data is not available," because "origination data may not be available for companies that acquire bonds on the secondary market." That fallback is the only balloon-related change actually adopted. Year-end 2026 is therefore the first consistently-clarified vintage, even though the column itself is not new.
Synthesis for RDCO
On separability the answer is no, but the honest characterization is "unresolved and trending negative," not "settled." Two things block it today. First, Ref #2025-29 is a bond-definition reporting cleanup: it clarifies the instructions for three elements that already exist, makes no SSAP change, and creates no asset-class category. Second, nothing in the published Schedule BA aggregation carries a sector, industry or collateral dimension, so even a perfect private-credit tag would not separate data-center lending from any other corporate direct lending. But the question is not shut. NAIC staff themselves proposed exactly the right instrument — a new investment characteristic code in electronic column 23 to flag rated notes and rated feeder funds — and the Working Group declined it "at this time," noting it "could be further considered," while routing the related underlying-characteristics question to agenda item 2025-26. That is a live workstream, not a closed door. The defensible claim for RDCO use is: the adopted text creates no separability, the one code that would have was proposed and deferred rather than rejected on the merits, and a successor workstream exists to watch.
The magnitude check is a clean win for the flag discipline, and it should raise our trust in that mechanic. The parent brief refused to let 6.4% and +7.8% into RDCO output pending a primary cite. That refusal was correct: the figures are real NAIC numbers but describe year-end 2024, and the parent presented them as current roughly three months after the NAIC published the year-end-2025 update superseding both. Nothing downstream has to be retracted, because nothing reused them. The correct current pairing is 6.7% and +10.3%, and the more useful fact is the one neither figure captures — Schedule BA is 70% equity, and its clearly credit-shaped portion is somewhere around 1.5% of industry invested assets. Anyone arguing "insurers are loaded with private credit" from a Schedule BA share number is arguing from a schedule that is mostly private equity and hedge funds.
Where this changes the gauge, concretely. The parent brief's recommendation stands: keep the lender leg on data-center ABS new-issue spread, subordination, and BDC non-accruals, which are market prices at daily latency. The statutory addition we flagged is weaker than first written but better-timed. Origination balloon payment percentage is reported on non-financial ABS already, so if we want a stock-of-risk read on how much of that tier is bullet-structured and therefore refinancing-cliff-exposed, it is obtainable from year-end-2025 filings now rather than from year-end-2026 filings in 2027. Three cautions before anyone builds on that. It is an aggregate across all non-financial ABS with no way to isolate AI infrastructure. The year-end-2025 vintage is documented by the NAIC itself as carrying origination-data gaps for secondary-market purchases, so coverage will be uneven until year-end 2026. And the bridge claim "data-center ABS is non-financial ABS" is our inference from the bond-definition categories, not something any of the three NAIC documents states — the words "data center" and "infrastructure" appear zero times across all of them. That inference needs its own verification before it carries weight.
The transferable lesson is about which NAIC document to read, and it applied to us too. Trade and asset-manager recaps of NAIC meetings reliably translate technical blanks items into asset-class narratives, because that is what their readers ask about. The adopted Form A agenda item carries a "Status:" block stating what was adopted and what was declined, and here the declined list was the load-bearing part. Our own first pass then made the mirror-image error in the other direction, reading clarifications of existing columns as new fields — the fix was in a parenthetical ("There are no proposed changes to the applicable categories") in the same document. For any future NAIC claim, the agenda item at content.naic.org/sites/default/files/inline-files/<ref> is the document and the Capital Markets Bureau special reports are the numbers, and both need reading past the headline. Mechanically: naic.org sits behind a Cloudflare challenge that blocks curl, and its PDFs defeat WebFetch's parser, so the working path is WebFetch to land the file on disk, then pdftotext -layout locally.
Why this is in the vault
It retires two specific flagged claims from [[2026-08-13-ai-capex-lender-exposure-insurance-pension-vehicles]] — permanently barring reuse of the 6.4%/+7.8% pairing and replacing it with verified 6.7%/+10.3% — and it closes the statutory leg of the AI-capex lender-visibility question, so the fragility gauge build can stop treating NAIC reporting reform as a pending unlock and can start reading the balloon-payment column that already exists, while knowing its first vintage is incompletely populated.
Open follow-ups
- Does the Schedule BA blank and instructions carry any sector, industry or collateral field beneath the twelve reported asset-type rows? Our no-sector-axis conclusion rests on an aggregation report, not the blank. The report's own mention of reported private-equity strategy and hedge-fund type proves some sub-detail exists, so this needs the actual blank to settle.
- Is "data-center ABS reports as non-financial ABS on Schedule D-1-2" correct? This is currently our inference and it is the sole bridge from the NAIC fields to AI infrastructure. It is checkable against the principles-based bond definition and SSAP No. 43R guidance.
- Was the rated-note/feeder-fund characteristic code picked up by any later SAPWG or Blanks workstream, and what did agenda item 2025-26 (SSAP No. 48 Equity Changes) do with underlying-characteristics reporting? This is the only identified path to real separability, and both threads were explicitly left open.
- Did the year-end-2025 jump in Schedule BA "Fixed Income/Bonds" ($22.5bn to $31.7bn, +41%) and Mortgage Loans ($18.8bn to $32.7bn, +74%) reflect bond-definition reclassification out of Schedule D rather than new money? Reclassification years make YoY growth figures non-comparable, which is a second way the +7.8%/+10.3% framing can mislead.
Related
- [[2026-08-13-ai-capex-lender-exposure-insurance-pension-vehicles]] — parent brief; the two claims this brief tests
- [[2026-10-22-13f-eligibility-bdc-feeder-interval-funds]] — sibling follow-up; same pattern of wrong premise, surviving conclusion
- [[2026-07-07-dram-hbm-phase2-phase3-early-signals]] — the transition window that sets the latency bar
- [[2026-07-15-capex-financing-layer-as-memory-cycle-phase-marker]] — the financing-fragility gauge this feeds
Sources
Vault
~/rdco-vault/06-reference/research/2026-08-13-ai-capex-lender-exposure-insurance-pension-vehicles.md~/rdco-vault/06-reference/research/2026-10-22-13f-eligibility-bdc-feeder-interval-funds.md
NAIC primary (all fetched 2026-10-23)
- NAIC SAPWG Ref #2025-29, "Reporting Clarifications" — Form A maintenance agenda item with adopted Status block — exposed 12/9/2025, adopted 3/23/2026; scope, the six numbered items discussed, the proposed column-23 characteristic code, the declined items, and the supported instruction revisions. "Private credit," "data center" and "infrastructure" each appear zero times. The document contains no effective date (the string "effective" does not appear).
- NAIC SAPWG Hearing Agenda, March 23 2026 — staff recommendation text, Schedule BA maturity-date language, the "unless otherwise directed ... at this time" framing on declined items, and the rated-notes reasoning. "Private credit" appears zero times.
- NAIC Capital Markets Bureau, "Double-Digit Increase in U.S. Insurers' Other Long-Term Invested Assets at Year-End 2025" (May 2026) — the magnitude check; Tables 1 and 2 give the full year-end-2025 and year-end-2024 Schedule BA asset-type roll-up and BACV.
Secondary — the claim under test, and items NOT verified at primary
- J.P. Morgan Asset Management, NAIC 2026 Spring National Meeting — the conference recap that originated the "private credit" characterization and the 6.4%/+7.8% pairing.
- Unverified at primary: the December 31, 2026 effective date and the blanks proposal number 2026-07BWG both come from search-surfaced secondary sources (an NAIC SAPWG adoptions listing and a Gain Compliance summary) and are not present in any of the three primary documents above. Only the adoption date, March 23 2026, is primary-confirmed. The question's "year-end-2026" framing therefore rests on secondary sourcing and should be hedged in any reuse.