The Agency Framework Permits a Rate Modification at Conversion, So Single-Close Rate-Rigidity Is a Program Term and Not a Structural Rule; But No Published Jumbo One-Time-Close Float-Down-at-Conversion Exists, and the Carry Question Is Worth Roughly Half the Rate Question
The question
Verbatim: "What financing terms apply to the construction-loan structure choice (construction-to-perm vs separate construction loan + take-out refi) for the Sunset Park rebuild — rate-lock float-down options, interest-only carry during the 10-12 month build?"
This is Critical Open Question #4 on [[01-projects/home-rebuild-2027/README|home-rebuild-2027 README]], and it is the named open follow-up #1 of [[2026-08-14-construction-to-permanent-loans-florida]], which mapped the structures but left float-down availability explicitly unresolved. Scoped to the structure choice and the two named mechanics only: not general construction-loan mechanics (covered by the 08-14 brief), not the flood-zone layer (covered by [[2026-08-04-flood-zone-ae-construction-loan-requirements]]), not qualifying capacity (covered by [[2026-08-19-jumbo-construction-perm-qualifying-envelope]]).
What we already know (from the vault)
- The parcel and the day-one draw. 1212 S Suffolk Dr, Sunset Park 33629; teardown and rebuild at ~3,000 sqft, $1.5-1.8M all-in, build window Q3 2027 - Q3 2028. There is an existing mortgage of $415,622 (as of the 2026-08-01 Monarch pull), and because the construction lender needs first lien on the same parcel it "gets paid off out of loan proceeds or out of cash before a dollar of construction is funded." Which of those two it is remains open, and it turns out to be the single largest carry lever in this brief. [[2026-08-14-construction-to-permanent-loans-florida]] (V — vault-internal, dated)
- Loan size is contested inside the vault, and the figures below use the larger set. The 08-14 brief puts a plausible note at $1.1-1.6M; the project README's own plan line still reads "$920k equity roll + $300k cash down + $300-500k construction-to-perm mortgage" with a "~$1.0-1.2M" DTI ceiling. [[2026-08-19-jumbo-construction-perm-qualifying-envelope]] corrected that ceiling downward on an escrow-basis error, so the README line should not be treated as current. I model $1.2M as the base case and $1.5M as sensitivity. (V as to the conflict; the base case is my choice, not a vault consensus)
- Everything here is jumbo, so the GSE single-close products are out of range on size alone. The fork is jumbo-portfolio vs national jumbo one-time-close. [[2026-08-14-construction-to-permanent-loans-florida]] (V)
- The 08-14 brief's rate claim was sourced to one lender's marketing page, not to a structural rule. It states the permanent rate "is set at the initial closing," citing BuildBuyRefi's jumbo one-time-close page, and flagged float-down as "program-specific and unverified here." (V — vault-internal)
- On the agency baseline, construction-period interest is not a qualifying item. [[2026-08-25-temp-housing-rent-dti-construction-perm]] established that B5-3.1-02 anchors qualifying to the finished-house PITIA and is silent on the construction-period interest-only payment. That brief also warns, explicitly unverified, that some construction lenders instead handle interim carry as a reserves requirement. So carry is an agency-baseline liquidity question, with portfolio treatment (U).
- Florida's two recording levies, read at the statute. §201.08(1)(a): doc stamp $0.35 per $100 on notes, capped at $2,450. §201.08(1)(b): doc stamp on recorded mortgages, no cap, due only on the excess over the amount already taxed. §199.133: nonrecurring intangible tax at 2 mills ($0.002/$1), no cap. [[2026-08-25-florida-intra-family-purchase-money-note]] (V — read at the statute in that brief)
What the web says
- The agency framework explicitly permits modifying the interest rate at conversion on a single-close. Fannie Mae Selling Guide B5-3.1-02, section dated 05/06/2026 (SEL-2026-05): "If the terms of the permanent financing change after the original closing date of the construction loan, the loan may be modified to reflect the new terms if it meets all of the following criteria" — and interest rate is one of four modifiable terms, with loan amount, loan term and amortization type. "The modification must take place prior to or at the time of conversion." Documented on Form 3179 or Form 3161. The modified loan must be underwritten on the modified terms, with DU resubmission unless within the B3-2-10 tolerances. (V)
- Single-close construction period is hard-capped, and a 10-12 month build has no slack against it. B5-3.1-02: "no single period of more than 12 months", total "may not exceed 18 months", and "Exceptions to the 12-month and 18-month periods will not be granted." (V, but agency-only: see the caveat below)
- The agency "one underwrite" allowance is conditional, and the condition is unreachable here. B5-3.1-02 requires credit, income and employment documents "no more than four months old at the time of conversion", except they may be up to 18 months old if at the original closing LTV/CLTV/HCLTV did not exceed 95% and DU returned Approve/Eligible. A jumbo loan cannot carry a DU Approve/Eligible, so this allowance does not transfer to the portfolio product actually in scope; whether a given portfolio program grants an equivalent is (U). Form 1004D is required at completion, and if value has declined the lender "must obtain a new appraisal for the property and requalify the borrower." (V as agency text)
- Two-close's take-out is a refinance, not a purchase, and the note cannot be modified. Fannie B5-3.1-03 (section dated 08/07/2019; current in the Guide published 10/07/2026): the permanent mortgage closes as a limited cash-out or cash-out refinance; "A modification may not be used to update the original note" — a new note must be signed. Cash-out requires the borrower to have "held legal title to the lot for at least six months prior to the closing of the permanent mortgage." The lender "must underwrite the borrower based on the terms of the permanent mortgage." (V)
- I did not find a published float-down that operates at conversion on a jumbo one-time-close construction product. The nearest thing is U.S. Bank's Builder Resource Center (page ©2026, no rate as-of date; "program terms are subject to change without notice"), which publishes a "U.S. Bank builder lock" giving "extended rate protection up to 360 days" with "A fee … collected upfront to secure the rate", plus "a one-time float down rate option within 60 days of closing" exercisable "no earlier than 60 days prior to closing or lock expiration date, whichever is earlier, but not less than five days prior to closing." Two disqualifiers: the page states it is "intended for homebuilder and condo developer use only", so the builder lock protects a builder's buyers on new-home purchases; and the lock is listed as a benefit separate from the page's "one-time closing on custom constructed homes" bullet, with nothing tying the float-down to that product. (U — the lock terms are quoted accurately, but their application to a borrower-side custom one-time-close is unsupported.)
- Extended-lock-plus-float-down is nonetheless a real priced product category. Bank of America's builder division prices locks at 120/180/270/360 days with a lock-in fee and a float-down window opening 60 days before the original closing date (material dated 2024, stale). Embrace Home Loans publishes the same ladder with a one-time float-down within 30 days of closing, but excludes jumbo (conventional/FHA/VA only). (U — marketing collateral, undated or stale; directional only, and neither is a jumbo custom-construction product)
- Construction-period interest-only is near-universal on the Florida products already inventoried: MIDFLORIDA (interest-only during construction; posted rates as of 2026-08-03 on a $300,000 example), Goldwater (12-month term, interest-only), BuildBuyRefi jumbo one-time-close (fixed interest-only up to 18 months). Per [[2026-08-14-construction-to-permanent-loans-florida]]. (V as to the interest-only feature; those rates are stale and non-jumbo)
Convergences and contradictions
- Contradiction, and it is the finding. The 08-14 brief's working assumption, that single-close means the perm rate is fixed at initial closing with no recourse, is not a structural rule. It was one lender's program term. B5-3.1-02 (05/06/2026) treats a rate modification prior to or at conversion as a standard, formed, documented event. This deal is jumbo-portfolio and not agency-eligible, so B5-3.1-02 is not an entitlement here; it is the text to hold a lender's term sheet against. That portfolio programs mirror the agency framework is a common pattern but (U) and not sourced in this run.
- Convergence on the carry mechanic, with one correction. Vault and web agree construction-period payments are interest-only on the drawn balance. The 08-14 brief described the balance as ramping "from near-zero"; if the $415,622 payoff is financed, it does not. Roughly a third of the note is then outstanding and accruing from month one.
- Partial convergence on whether carry can kill the loan. On the agency baseline it cannot, because qualifying runs on the finished-house PITIA. But the reserves-treatment caution in [[2026-08-25-temp-housing-rent-dti-construction-perm]] is unresolved, and it would interact with TD's already-known 10%-of-construction-cost reserve hold. Treat "carry is only a cash-flow problem" as the agency answer, not the portfolio answer.
Synthesis for RDCO
Size the two mechanics against each other first, on one consistent basis, because they are not the same order of magnitude. Derived from the vault's inputs at a $1.2M note and a 7.0% assumed note rate (U; anchored to MIDFLORIDA's posted 7.000% as of 2026-08-03, which is a $300,000 example and will not be the jumbo price), with the $415,622 payoff financed at day one and the remaining $784,378 disbursed linearly: average outstanding is ~$807,800, so interest-only carry runs ~$47,100 over a 10-month build and ~$56,500 over 12 months, a $47-57k band carrying $10k of duration risk. The monthly payment ramps from **$2,425** in month one to ~$7,000 at full draw; at a $1.5M note the 12-month figure is $67,000. Now the rate mechanic, stated as present value rather than an undiscounted sum so it compares honestly: on a $1.2M 30-year, 7.00% amortizes to $7,984/mo and 6.25% to $7,389/mo, a $595/mo difference whose present value at the 7% note rate over a full 30-year hold is **$89,400** (the undiscounted total is $214,000, which is the number not to use). So the rate question is worth roughly 1.6-1.9x the entire construction carry, on an assumed 75bp move and a no-refinance hold. One lever beats both: financing the $415,622 payoff rather than clearing it in cash adds ~$29,100 of gross interest over a 12-month build ($56,500 vs ~$27,500), before netting the yield given up on the cash. That belongs in the sources-and-uses conversation, not this one, but it is 2-3x the entire two-close duplication cost computed below.
Two-close's cost side is now partly computable, and Florida is the part nobody had priced. Because B5-3.1-03 makes the take-out a refinance with a new note, Florida's recording levies fire a second time. On a $1.2M obligation: §201.08(1)(a) note stamp is $4,200 but capped at $2,450; §201.08(1)(b) then charges the uncapped mortgage levy on the excess, $4,200 less the $2,450 already paid, so $1,750; which means the celebrated $2,450 note cap is cosmetic and total doc stamp lands at $4,200 either way. Add §199.133 intangible at 2 mills, $2,400. That is ~$6,600 of Florida recording tax per recorded obligation, derived from the statutory rates established in [[2026-08-25-florida-intra-family-purchase-money-note]]; gross, because the §201.09 renewal exemption is not checked and could reduce it (see follow-ups). Stack the $3,000-5,000 of duplicate closing costs the 08-14 brief cites as a reported figure (U) and two-close carries roughly $9,600-11,600 of duplication on this deal, plus a second lender's title policy that I could not price. Against that, two-close buys one thing: you shop the perm rate at completion, an option worth the ~$89,400 present value above if a 75bp improvement actually materialises. On those two numbers the option is worth buying unless single-close can capture most of the same move.
And the honest answer on whether single-close can is: the agency text says the mechanism exists, and no published jumbo program I could reach says it is available. B5-3.1-02 contemplates exactly the thing two-close is bought for, a rate reset at conversion on a Form 3179-equivalent modification, which is why the 08-14 brief's rigidity claim should not be carried forward as settled. But I could not find a single jumbo one-time-close product publishing a float-down or rate modification exercisable at conversion. The U.S. Bank 360-day lock looked like it until the page turned out to be builder-and-developer-facing, protecting a builder's buyers rather than a custom one-time-close borrower, with the lock listed separately from the custom-construction bullet. So the deliverable here is a yes/no question, not a recommendation: ask each lender whether a float-down or a rate modification operates at conversion, and get it in the term sheet. If yes, single-close dominates on every axis in this brief. If no, two-close's option retains real value and the ~$9,600-11,600 of duplication is the honest price of it. Do not let the question go unasked and then default to single-close on closing-cost arithmetic; the rate mechanic is the larger number.
Two terms to set at term-sheet stage regardless of structure. First, ask for 18 months of construction period rather than 12. The agency ceiling is 12 months per single period and 18 total with "exceptions will not be granted"; among the products the vault has inventoried, Goldwater's listing shows a 12-month term while BuildBuyRefi's jumbo one-time-close runs interest-only to 18 (U — two data points from an aggregator page, not a market norm). A 10-12 month build against a 12-month term has no slack, and in an AE-zone elevated build the schedule risk is documented: [[2026-08-04-flood-zone-ae-construction-loan-requirements]] puts two separate elevation-certificate deliverables and inspection-gated draws in the critical path. A longer term may carry a longer-lock or rate cost (U — unpriced here), but it is cheaper asked for up front than requested mid-build. Second, do not assume single-close buys one underwrite. The 18-month document-age allowance that would deliver that outcome is conditioned on a DU Approve/Eligible, which a jumbo cannot have, so on the portfolio product the re-verification posture at conversion is an open lender-specific term (U) and worth asking in the same breath. What does transfer is the shape of the risk: B5-3.1-02's value-decline trigger forces a new appraisal and requalification if the 1004D comes in low, and a 2028 completion appraisal under the subject-to-completion number is a scenario worth pricing rather than dismissing given the AE-zone insurance repricing tracked in [[2026-07-22-florida-ae-zone-insurance-repricing-tampa]] (the insurance-to-appraised-value link is (U), asserted as a mechanism and not sourced here). On a two-close the full re-underwrite is unconditional, so single-close is still the better posture on this axis; it is just better by a margin this brief cannot size.
Why this is in the vault
This closes Critical Open Question #4 on [[01-projects/home-rebuild-2027/README|home-rebuild-2027 README]] and open follow-up #1 of [[2026-08-14-construction-to-permanent-loans-florida]], and it retires that brief's inherited claim that a single-close permanent rate is immovable once set. It is the input to the Q1 2027 go/no-go gate's financing leg: the structure cannot be chosen on closing-cost arithmetic alone, because the rate mechanic is the larger number and its availability is a term to be negotiated rather than a property of the product.
Open follow-ups
- Does Fla. Stat. §201.09's renewal exemption, or any §199.133 credit for tax already paid, reach a two-close construction-to-perm take-out? The ~$6,600 second levy derived above is gross. §201.09 exempts certain renewal notes, and if a same-lender take-out of the same principal qualifies as a renewal rather than new indebtedness, a meaningful share of two-close's duplication cost evaporates and the structure comparison tightens. Statute-answerable; nothing in the vault touches §201.09.
- Does any jumbo one-time-close construction program publish a float-down or rate modification exercisable at conversion, and on what terms? This brief found none and found that the closest candidate does not apply. The answer flips the recommendation from "single-close dominates" to "two-close retains real option value," and it probably requires lender rate-lock policy documents or program guides rather than marketing pages.
- What is the historical distribution of 30-year jumbo mortgage rate changes over rolling 10-18 month windows? This is the actual expected value of perm-rate optionality, and the whole argument above about whether that option beats ~$9,600-11,600 of duplication rests on an assumed 75bp move rather than a distribution. Answerable from published rate series; the vault has nothing on it.
Considered and not proposed: whether the construction-period interest-only payment counts in DTI, already answered on the agency baseline by [[2026-08-25-temp-housing-rent-dti-construction-perm]], whose own open follow-up already owns the portfolio-overlay residue. Also not proposed: "call three Tampa lenders," which is a task rather than a research question.
Related
- [[2026-08-14-construction-to-permanent-loans-florida]] — parent brief; structures, Florida lender list, sources-and-uses. This brief closes its follow-up #1 and retires its rate-rigidity claim
- [[2026-08-04-flood-zone-ae-construction-loan-requirements]] — the AE layer; the EC deliverables and inspection-gated draws behind the construction-term slack argument
- [[2026-08-19-jumbo-construction-perm-qualifying-envelope]] — qualifying capacity, and the escrow-basis correction that retires the README's $1.0-1.2M ceiling
- [[2026-08-25-temp-housing-rent-dti-construction-perm]] — qualifying runs on finished-house PITIA, making carry a liquidity question on the agency baseline
- [[2026-08-25-florida-intra-family-purchase-money-note]] — source of the §201.08 and §199.133 statutory rates used in the duplication arithmetic
- [[2026-07-22-florida-ae-zone-insurance-repricing-tampa]] — the AE insurance repricing behind the value-decline requalification concern
- [[01-projects/home-rebuild-2027/README|home-rebuild-2027 README]] — project README; Critical Open Question #4
Sources
Vault
- 01-projects/home-rebuild-2027/README.md
- 06-reference/research/2026-08-14-construction-to-permanent-loans-florida.md
- 06-reference/research/2026-08-04-flood-zone-ae-construction-loan-requirements.md
- 06-reference/research/2026-08-19-jumbo-construction-perm-qualifying-envelope.md
- 06-reference/research/2026-08-25-temp-housing-rent-dti-construction-perm.md
- 06-reference/research/2026-08-25-florida-intra-family-purchase-money-note.md
- 06-reference/research/2026-07-22-florida-ae-zone-insurance-repricing-tampa.md
Web (primary)
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide B5-3.1-02, Conversion of Construction-to-Permanent Financing: Single-Closing Transactions, section dated 05/06/2026 (SEL-2026-05), retrieved 2026-10-22 — https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b5-3.1-02/conversion-construction-permanent-financing-single-closing-transactions (modifiable terms including interest rate; Forms 3179/3161; 12-month and 18-month construction-period caps; 4-month vs 18-month document age with its DU condition; 1004D and value-decline requalification)
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide B5-3.1-03, Two-Closing Transactions, section dated 08/07/2019, Guide published 10/07/2026, retrieved 2026-10-22 — https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b5-3.1-03/conversion-construction-permanent-financing-two-closing-transactions (take-out as limited cash-out or cash-out refinance; new note required, no modification; 6-month legal title for cash-out)
Web (secondary / weak — builder-facing or marketing collateral, undated or stale; used directionally only, and none of it a jumbo custom one-time-close term sheet)
- U.S. Bank, Builder Resource Center, page ©2026, no rate as-of date, retrieved 2026-10-22 — https://www.usbank.com/home-loans/builder-resource-center.html (360-day builder lock with upfront fee; one-time float-down window; page states it is intended for homebuilder and condo developer use only, and does not tie the lock to its custom one-time-close product)
- Bank of America builder division, Builder Rate Lock Advantage (material dated 2024, stale) — https://promotions.bankofamerica.com/content/dam/consumer-marketing/ecs/builder-division-microsite/builder-rate-lock-advantage.pdf
- Embrace Home Loans, Extended Rate Lock (undated; excludes jumbo) — https://aficlient.embracehomeloans.com/-/media/feature/ameriprise/librarydocuments/client/products/extended_rate_lock.pdf
Not retrieved
- Freddie Mac Single-Family Seller/Servicer Guide section on construction conversion — not reached within this brief's source cap; the Fannie sections were prioritised as the closer analogue to the portfolio programs in scope.
- Reg Z / TRID treatment of single-close vs two-close disclosure (Appendix D, §1026.17(c)(6)) — not retrieved. The only verified Reg Z touchpoint here is B5-3.1-02's requirement that the construction loan "be structured as a temporary loan exempt from the ability to repay requirements under Regulation Z."