Why this is in the vault
Thompson, running agents on a headless always-on Mac Mini (the same shape as our channels setup), explains why Apple's macOS 27.3 permission changes still do not solve GUI-only permission prompts for agents, and argues Apple is stuck in an app-centric worldview.
The core argument
- macOS 27.3 beta splits "Device Control and Data Access" into Accessibility and a new "System and App Protection Override", with per-app scoping and an optional ask-every-time mode. Full Disk Access remains, with scarier warnings. Thompson is fine with that and sees real loosening, but it does not fix his problem.
- His problem is a different vector: ChatGPT and Claude are not controlling other apps, they are building new throwaway apps (sports channel listings, a label-printer controller) that each trigger fresh GUI-only dialogs such as local-network access.
- Aside worth noting: with an ethernet KVM his agents could see permission prompts but refused to click OK; Fable 5.2, told the Mac Mini is the agent's own machine, now willingly clicks it.
- Broader point: Apple's Siri/App Intents model needs developers to build integrations, while browser-use agents get integrations for free. Apple assumes intelligence augments apps; the future may be on-demand custom software where capital-A Apps are things to avoid.
- Short iPhone Duo review: he loves it as a "big iPhone Air"; iOS 27.3 adds face-unlock and lock-on-close, which he reads as Apple late-realizing how people actually use it. Gruber's point: the compromised lineup is what makes it fun.
Source note: email body rendered in full. A Stripe/OpenRouter ad block sits mid-issue.
Mapping against Ray Data Co
Most concrete link: our channels agent runs on a Mac Mini under LaunchAgent and tmux with cron osascript jobs (see [[feedback_cron_osascript_permissions]]), so the macOS 27.3 split of Accessibility versus System and App Protection Override, and the ask-every-time option, may change which TCC grants our cron and app-scripting jobs need. Worth a one-time check of the Mini's grants after 27.3 ships, as an ops hygiene item, not a decision. The "agents build one-off apps" thesis also supports our build-on-the-spot habit. Medium: operationally relevant, no direction change.
Related
- [[2026-10-05-stratechery-ben-thompson-apple-hackers-future]]
- [[2026-09-10-stratechery-iphone-duo-intelligent-personal-hub]]
- [[2026-11-16-stratechery-obituaries]]
- [[feedback_cron_osascript_permissions]]
- [[project_channels_agent_setup]]
⚠️ Sponsorship
"Presented by Stripe" banner plus a mid-issue Stripe/OpenRouter ad (OpenRouter recently joined Stripe). Paid house sponsor; not related to the Apple or permissions argument, so no bias evident.