How to Find a BIG Idea (3 Frameworks)

Cole draws on classic direct-response advertising history to teach three frameworks for finding a “BIG Idea” — the differentiating concept that makes copy compelling. The article opens with Claude Hopkins’ Pepsodent story (adding a tingling sensation to toothpaste turned brushing from rare habit into daily ritual) and builds to a free AI prompt generator for creating novel marketing concepts.

Key Takeaways

Framework 1 — Think In Opposites: List conventional wisdom, benefits, and problems in a niche, then find ways to say the opposite. Ship 30 for 30 used this by inverting standard writing-world assumptions to position their program as fundamentally different.

Framework 2 — Turn the biggest problem into the biggest benefit: Example: trading cards are fragile cheap paper (problem), but grading and encasing them transforms fragility into rarity and value (benefit). The BIG idea is often hiding in the industry’s most obvious weakness.

Framework 3 — Invent a problem your product solves: Purdue Pharma coined “breakthrough pain” to differentiate OxyContin; Listerine coined “halitosis” to medicalize bad breath. Both created demand by naming a condition customers did not previously recognize. Cole notes the ethical dimension is real (OxyContin caused hundreds of thousands of deaths) while still teaching the mechanism.

Core principle: Great copy does not convince — it makes people aware of something they were not aware of before. The BIG Idea comes before any subject line, email, or ad.

RDCO Mapping

Pure writing craft content — the most directly useful Write With AI issue for Sanity Check production. The “Think In Opposites” framework is essentially what our draft-review skill checks for when evaluating hook differentiation. The “invent a problem” pattern is ethically fraught but mechanically important to understand for honest newsletter positioning. These frameworks belong in our writing-craft reference library for research-brief generation.

Post promotes AI Writing Skool and a Copywriting 101 crash course.