Fable 5.2 fix run: implementation notes (2026-11-10)
Implements the "Safe" steps of task1-harness-audit-B.md. Order: 0b, 1b, 1a, 1d, 1c, 3a, 2d, 2c, 4c, 5b, 5d, 4e, 5a.
Pre-change snapshot (read-only reference): ~/.claude/state/pre-fable-fix-2026-11-10/.
Session start: 2026-11-10 06:29 ET.
Summary (written at the end of the run)
| Step | Status | Evidence in one line |
|---|---|---|
| 0b | DONE | The three sensitive files are out of the git index and ignored; leak-scan.py --staged rc=0 on tonight's commit; throwaway-repo test holds back a planted token and fails closed when the scanner is broken |
| 1b | DONE | New selector finds 38 runs with denials in the real logs; the old one matched 0 of 406 |
| 1a | DONE (books-refresh not fired) | house-clock produced its first run log ever and filled the October row; old code reproduced the silent no-run in a sandbox |
| 1d | DONE (opt-in per job) | report= held on the live house-clock run; 7 sandbox cases pass |
| 1c | DONE | graph-reingest ran model-free through the dispatcher (first audit-log line since 08-17); sync-contacts ledger mtime moved from 2026-08-17 to 2026-11-10 06:50:47 on Haiku 5.5 with 0 denials |
| 3a | DONE | All three IDs smoke-tested OK before the switch; one tier file read by dispatcher, runner and watchdog; the 08:00 check-board cron ran on claude-sonnet-5-5, exit 0, 0 denials |
| 2d | DONE (positive path not run with a real channels session) | Real claude -p children skip with and without the inherited flag; private-tmux run of the restart script's own export line arms window 0 and not the fleet window |
| 2c | DONE (new brief step first runs 06:30 tomorrow) | 263 files moved to archive/2026-11-10/, 279 files before and after, 13 left and listed; dead crontab line removed |
| 4c | DONE | The restart script's own filter now yields only caf-architect and ingest-agent; no process killed |
| 5b | DONE (settings lines proposed only) | grep CLAUDE\.md over skills, runner context and runner leaves only two intentional mentions; throwaway sync pushes AGENTS.md, crontab and both plists |
| 5d | DONE for scripts | 41 unreferenced files moved to scripts/archive/2026-11-10/; 4 backups and ask-model.sh skipped because still referenced |
| 4e | PARTIAL | Changelogs: 14 active skills migrated, 42 KB out of SKILL.md, line-for-line conservation check passes. Off-skill archive skipped: every one is still referenced |
| 5a | DONE | 22 of 22 sandbox tests; live 07:11 tick migrated state and fired nothing unscheduled; a real scheduled job fired at 08:00 and logged to the new persistent log; --validate rc=0 |
Files changed (everything else is untouched; the founder-gated files were verified unmodified at the end: settings.json is byte-identical to the snapshot, settings.local.json, SOUL.md, AGENTS.md and agents/ have pre-run mtimes):
~/.claude/scripts/: modifiedcron-dispatcher.py,cron-job-runner.sh,scheduled-jobs.txt,emit-cron-rearm.sh,claude-channels-restart.sh,memory-watchdog.sh,fleet-manifest.txt; newmodel-tiers.conf,model-tier.sh,graph-reingest.sh,cron-undelivered.sh,skill-changelog.py; 41 files moved intoarchive/2026-11-10/.~/.claude/skills/:morning-prep,improve,graph-reingest,check-board,sync-contacts,process-newsletter,acquisition-rescan,publish-site,graph-query,finance-pulseSKILL.md edits; 14 skills gained aCHANGELOG.md(andimproveaCHANGELOG-archive.md).~/.claude/state/:cron-runner-context.md(two words);cron-undelivered/archive/2026-11-10/(263 moved files);cron-dispatch-state.json(migrated by the dispatcher).~/Projects/ray-config/:bin/sync.sh,bin/bootstrap.sh,.gitignore,README.md, newbin/leak-scan.py; three files removed from the index (staged, not committed). No commit, no push.- User crontab: one line removed.
- Written by jobs I force-fired, as designed:
~/rdco-vault/04-finance/house-fund-tracker.md(October row),~/.claude/state/graph.duckdbandgraph-reingest.log,sync-contacts-ledger.json, three ops-log entries.
Two files under the do-not-edit memory path (MEMORY.md, feedback_delegation_model_effort_pairing.md) show an mtime of 06:29:31. My first command ran at 06:29:38 and I never wrote there; that change predates this run.
Session-level notes
- The SessionStart hook told this headless session to arm
/morning-prep(06:30). Not armed: this is not the channels session, and arming here would double-fire a founder-facing brief. That is audit finding 7, fixed in step 2d. - No secrets were printed. Scans report file names and pattern labels only.
0b. Backup excludes + pre-commit leak scan: DONE
Re-verified live: git ls-files in ~/Projects/ray-config still tracked dotclaude/settings.local.json, home/.claude.json, dotclaude/state/books-raw.json; a names-only scan of the whole tracked tree flagged exactly one file (dotclaude/settings.local.json, "1Password service account token").
Changed (all in ~/Projects/ray-config):
bin/sync.sh:17-31: no longer copies~/.claude.jsonorsettings.local.json.:41-44: state rsync excludesbooks-raw.json.:85-119: aftergit add -A, runsbin/leak-scan.py --staged; each flagged file is unstaged (the rest of the backup still goes out) and a line is appended to~/.claude/state/cron-failures.log; if the scanner errors or is missing, nothing is committed or pushed (fail closed).bin/leak-scan.py(new): loadsCREDENTIAL_PATTERNSfrom~/.claude/scripts/verify-action.py(falls back to a built-in mirror), plus private-key / Notion / Discord / GitHub-OAuth patterns. Printspath<TAB>labelonly, never the value. Exit 0 clean, 10 hits, anything else = scan broken. Namedleak-scanbecause the repo's own.gitignoreglobs*secret*and*credential*would have hidden a file with either word in its name..gitignore: three anchored paths added.README.md: two rows updated.- Index only:
git rm --cachedon the three files. No local commit was made; the staged deletions ride out with tonight's 03:33 sync commit. The on-disk copies inside the repo working tree were left in place (now ignored).
Verified:
bash -n bin/sync.sh,python3 -m py_compile bin/leak-scan.py: OK.python3 bin/leak-scan.py --stagedin the real repo: rc=0 (tonight's commit is clean).- End-to-end in a throwaway
HOMEwith a local bare repo asorigin(never touched GitHub): (A) a file with a syntheticghp_AAAA…string was held back, everything else pushed, failure line written; (B) scanner with a syntax error: rc=1, commit count unchanged, "backup NOT pushed" logged; (C) scanner file missing: same; (D) clean tree pushes, andsettings.local.json,.claude.json,books-raw.jsonnever appear in the pushed tree. The first version of this test caught a real bug (Python exits 1 on SyntaxError, which collided with "hits = 1"); fixed by moving hits to exit 10.
Not done / needs a human:
- History still contains the token (first commit 2026-04-28). Rotation (0a) and history purge (0c) are founder steps. The scan deliberately checks only what is about to be committed; it does not scan history, which would fail forever.
~/.claude.json(MCP server config) now has no off-machine backup. If that matters, store a copy in 1Password.- Memory files with health/address data still sync (founder decision 1 in the audit).
1b. Denial parser: DONE
Re-verified live: every one of 406 run logs has its result JSON starting {"duration_api_ms"; the old selector grep -m1 '^{"is_error"' matched none.
Changed: ~/.claude/scripts/cron-job-runner.sh:224-226 selects the result with jq -R -c 'fromjson? | select(type == "object" and .type == "result")' (last one wins, non-JSON lines skipped). :228-239 the is_error verdict now reads the parsed result instead of grepping the whole log (the old grep could in principle match text inside a result). :285 the denial block reuses that result.
Verified:
bash -n cron-job-runner.sh: OK.- Against the real logs (read-only loop over
~/.claude/logs/cron-runs/*.log): old selector finds a result line in 0 of 406; new selector finds 38 runs with one or more denials. - Sandbox (throwaway
HOME, stubclaude): snapshot runner on a denial result gives 0 alert sends and 0 ops-log entries; new runner gives 1cron-denial-<slug>ops-log entry and 1 alert send; with the alert send forced to fail, the alert lands incron-undelivered/andcron-failures.loggetsdenial-alert-undelivered. A result whose text contains the string"is_error":trueis not miscounted as an error. - No real alert was sent by any test.
Heads-up: the alarm is now live. Deep-research had denials on 7 of its last 15 runs, so expect a cron-denial-deep-research ops-log entry and an iMessage attempt roughly every other night until those commands are allow-listed. From the launchd tree that iMessage usually fails (audit finding 3) and falls back to cron-undelivered/ plus a cron-failures.log line, which the morning brief reads.
1a. Slugs, lock failures, backfill: DONE (books refresh deliberately not fired)
Re-verified live: the four inline-prompt jobs had 617, 1023, 1270 and 990-character slugs. Reproduced in a sandbox with the snapshot dispatcher + runner: FORCE-FIRE logged, 0 run logs, 0 failure lines, claude never invoked.
Changed:
cron-dispatcher.py:192-214slugs:name=wins, else the slugified command, cut to 60 chars plus an 8-hex hash when longer. Short slugs are byte-identical to before.cron-dispatcher.py:217-244, 355-404manifest v3: optional options field (name= timeout= effort= report= fresh=) between precheck and command; 5-field and 2-field lines still parse. A malformed line is skipped and logged, never fatal.cron-dispatcher.py:526-602new--validate(exit 1 on any error) and--dry-run [--at YYYY-MM-DDTHH:MM](no prechecks, no state writes, no spawns).cron-job-runner.sh:53-55record_failure;:57-69slug sanity guard;:71-90a lock that cannot be taken for any reason other than a live overlapping run is now a recorded failure (wasexit 0).emit-cron-rearm.sh:112reads the command from field 6 on v3 lines.scheduled-jobs.txt: format header documents v3;:150 name=freshness-watch,:159 name=books-refresh,:176 name=hq-deploy-watch,:207 name=house-clock.
Verified:
python3 -m py_compileunder both/opt/homebrew/bin/python3(what launchd uses) and/usr/bin/python3;bash -non runner and rearm hook: OK.- Regression vs the snapshot (script in sandbox): same 21 system jobs, command text identical, 17 of 21 slugs unchanged, 4 renamed to the names above, longest slug now 33 chars; timeout, effort and model identical for every job; minute-by-minute schedule identical over 64,800 minutes (1,582 fires).
- Runner matrix in sandbox, 16 cases, all pass: 300-char slug gives
NOT RUN: bad slug(rc 1); unwritable lock dir givesNOT RUN: cannot take lock: ... Permission denied; live overlap still skips quietly; stale lock still runs; timeout still gives exit=137; no locks left behind. --validaterejects a bad minute, a typo'd option, a missing precheck, a duplicate slug and a 7-field line (rc 1), and passes the live manifest:OK: 22 jobs (21 system), 0 errors.- Installed with atomic renames, in the order runner, dispatcher, rearm hook, manifest; each new file is compatible with the old version of the next. Live files were byte-identical to the snapshot immediately before install.
- Live backfill, house-clock: wrote
house-clockto~/.claude/state/cron-force.txtat 06:41:28; the 06:42 launchd tick fired it.~/.claude/logs/cron-runs/house-clock-20261110T064203.logexists (the first run log this job has ever produced),=== done exit=0 ===, 0 permission denials, 11 turns.house-fund-tracker.md:32went from an empty row to the scored October row (a MISS, streak 0/6), and the ops log has## 2026-11-10 06:42 ET · house-clock. No failure line was written, so thereport=house-clockpostcondition held on a real run.
Not fired, needs Ray or the founder:
- books-refresh (missed 11-03). Its prompt ends with "commit src/data/books.json and push to main (Cloudflare Pages auto-deploys)". That is a push to production, not just a file write, so I did not force-fire it. To backfill:
echo books-refresh > ~/.claude/state/cron-force.txt. Otherwise it runs on its own 12-03 06:40. - freshness-watch was not in the backfill scope; it fires on its own Saturday 11-14 06:37.
- hq-deploy-watch messages the founder by design and only fires when its precheck says the deploy is unhealthy. Not fired.
My own mess: a root-cause probe for 1c ran ops-log.sh --help, which is not a help flag; it appended an empty entry ## 2026-11-10 06:42 ET · --help to ~/.claude/state/ops-log.md. The file carries the uappnd (append-only) flag, so I left it. Two older --help entries (10-14, 10-20) show other runs have made the same mistake.
1d. Runner postconditions: DONE (opt-in per job)
Changed:
cron-job-runner.sh:121-158baselines taken before the run plusreport_landed(searches only the bytes appended to the ops log since the run began, for a header whose source starts with the wanted name) andfresh_since_start(file mtime at or after start).cron-job-runner.sh:240-256on exit 0 withoutis_error: a failure is recorded if there is no result JSON, ifreport=was declared and no entry landed, or iffresh=was declared and the file was not written.cron-dispatcher.py:488-523passesRAY_CRON_REPORT/RAY_CRON_FRESHto the runner as env vars.scheduled-jobs.txtreport=set on: vault-health (:78), check-board (:85), improve (:109), curiosity (:120), deep-research (:123), community-watch (:208), and the three inline jobs whose prompts mandate an ops-log call (freshness-watch, books-refresh, house-clock).
Why opt-in rather than on for every job: I measured the last 14 days. open-threads-check reports on about 1 run in 5 by design (silent when nothing to park), process-youtube and cert-study skip the ops log on no-op runs, and process-newsletter, finance-pulse, compile-vault and self-review did not show an entry on every run. A blanket rule would have put false failures in the morning brief daily. The six slash-command jobs above reported on every measured run.
Verified: sandbox cases 2-8 (report landed, prefix match, none landed, wrong source, fresh written, stale file, missing file) all pass, and the live house-clock run above passed its report= check.
Not covered: jobs without report=/fresh= are still trusted on exit 0 (though a denial now raises the 1b alarm). sync-contacts gets fresh= in 1c.
1c. Haiku jobs: DONE
Root cause, now confirmed (the audit only had a hypothesis). Probe from ~, headless, same two commands on each model (an append to a file in ~/.claude/state/ and an ops-log.sh call): claude-haiku-4-5-20251001 returned permission_denials for both and answered "DENIED"; claude-haiku-5-5 ran both with 0 denials. So under Haiku 4.5 every Bash call outside the allow-list was denied in headless runs; the allow-listed stage commands ran, the writes did not.
graph-reingest is now model-free:
- New
~/.claude/scripts/graph-reingest.sh: stage 1graph-ingest.py --discover, stage 2qmd update+qmd embed, then one summary line to~/.claude/state/graph-reingest.logand to the ops log. Exit 1 and aFAILED (...)summary if any stage fails. cron-job-runner.sh:182-206newshellmode: when the model argument isshell, the command is a script under~/.claude/scripts/plus plain arguments, run directly (no eval, no globbing,..rejected) under the same lock, timeout, run log and postconditions.cron-dispatcher.py:119-122, 554-562shellpseudo-tier;--validateerrors if the script is missing, not executable or outside~/.claude/scripts/.scheduled-jobs.txt:11717 3 * * * | system | shell | vault-newer-than-graph.sh | name=graph-reingest report=graph-reingest | ~/.claude/scripts/graph-reingest.sh.skills/graph-reingest/SKILL.md: on-demand path now says to run the script; changelog entry added.
sync-contacts stays a model job on the haiku tier, which is now Haiku 5.5 (see 3a), with scheduled-jobs.txt:129 fresh=~/.claude/state/sync-contacts-ledger.json.
Verified:
bash -nongraph-reingest.shand the runner; parser functions unit-tested against real captured output (docs 5121, vertices 15812, edges 45817, 14 new, 1 updated, 111 chunks).- Sandbox S1-S8 all pass: shell job ok, args passed literally (a
*is not expanded), exit 1 recorded, script outside the scripts dir refused,..refused, missing script refused, missing report recorded, claude jobs unaffected, and the stubclaudewas never invoked for a shell job. - Live graph-reingest through the launchd dispatcher (
cron-force.txt, fired 06:49:04):logs/cron-runs/graph-reingest-20261110T064904.logends=== done exit=0 ===;state/graph-reingest.loggained2026-11-10T06:49:35-05:00 | Reingested 5121 docs → 15812 vertices, 45817 edges in 30s; ...(previous line was dated 2026-08-17); the ops log has## 2026-11-10 06:49 ET · graph-reingest; no failure line. - Live sync-contacts on Haiku 5.5 (forced, fired 06:50:00; the skill is idempotent by its own rule and does not message the founder):
=== done exit=0 ===,permission_denialsempty,modelUsageshows onlyclaude-haiku-5-5, andstatonstate/sync-contacts-ledger.jsonmoved from2026-08-17 04:00:56to2026-11-10 06:50:47. Thefresh=postcondition passed (no failure line). First· sync-contactsops-log entry in over 30 days.
Not done: nothing kills a shell job's child processes on timeout (same limitation the claude path already has).
3a. One tier map: DONE
Smoke tests, run before anything was switched, each with claude -p "reply OK" --model <id> --strict-mcp-config --no-session-persistence --output-format json:
claude-haiku-5-5: rc=0,is_error:false, result "OK", modelUsageclaude-haiku-5-5claude-sonnet-5-5: rc=0,is_error:false, result "OK", modelUsageclaude-sonnet-5-5claude-opus-5-5: rc=0,is_error:false, result "OK", modelUsageclaude-opus-5-5
Changed:
- New
~/.claude/scripts/model-tiers.conf(haiku=claude-haiku-5-5,sonnet=claude-sonnet-5-5,opus=claude-opus-5-5; no Fable). The header says how to change a tier. - New
~/.claude/scripts/model-tier.sh <tier>: prints the ID; prints a built-in default and exits 1 if the file or tier is missing, so a caller never gets an empty--model. cron-dispatcher.py:106-164reads the file (load_tiers); the hardcodedMODEL_MAPis gone; a damaged file falls back to built-in IDs and is logged, and--validatefails on it.cron-job-runner.sh:310-313denial-alert sender andmemory-watchdog.sh:52-55alert sender usemodel-tier.sh haiku(both were hardcoded Haiku 4.5).scheduled-jobs.txt:143open-threads-check model column-becamesonnet(it was silently falling back to sonnet; no behaviour change) and its stale "SESSION runner" comment was corrected.skills/check-board/SKILL.md:8no longer namesclaude-sonnet-5.cron-dispatcher.py:162-167the effort comment claimed inherit = medium; settings.json sayseffortLevel: high. Comment corrected; the behaviour is unchanged and remains founder decision 3b.
Verified:
--validatelive printstiers: haiku=claude-haiku-5-5 sonnet=claude-sonnet-5-5 opus=claude-opus-5-5andOK: 22 jobs (21 system), 0 errors, 0 warnings.- Sandbox: a tier file with a bad ID and an unknown tier fails
--validate(rc 1) while dry-run still resolvesclaude-sonnet-5-5; with the file deleted the tick logsTIER FILE: cannot read ...and still fires on the defaults; the denial-alert stub call showsmodel=claude-haiku-5-5. grepforclaude-haiku-4/ bareclaude-sonnet-5acrossscripts/*.sh *.py *.txt *.conffinds only the history comment inmodel-tiers.conf.- Real runs on the new tier IDs: the sync-contacts run above ran on
claude-haiku-5-5, and the scheduled 08:00 check-board run ran onclaude-sonnet-5-5(see the 5a addendum).
Proposed founder-gated diff (~/.claude/settings.json, not applied): the per-model override is keyed to the old Sonnet ID, so it no longer matches anything the crons run.
"modelSettings": {
- "claude-sonnet-5": {
+ "claude-sonnet-5-5": {
"effortLevel": "high"
}
}
It makes no difference today because the global effortLevel is also high; it will matter the day the global default changes. agents/fanout.md and the delegation memory (audit step 3c) are untouched.
2d. Re-arm hook is now an allowlist: DONE
Re-verified live: emit-cron-rearm.sh armed any session without RAY_HEADLESS_CRON or RAY_SUPPORT_AGENT; this session was told to arm /morning-prep one minute before 06:30.
Something the audit missed: ps shows this headless session is a descendant of the live channels session (claude --name channels-agent --channels ... → zsh → run-fix.sh → claude -p). An env flag is inherited by every child, so the audit's plan as written ("arm only when RAY_CHANNELS_AGENT=1") would still have armed this session once the flag existed. The fix therefore uses the flag and the launch shape together.
Changed:
~/.claude/scripts/claude-channels-restart.sh:102-109: the window-0send-keysexport line now also exportsRAY_CHANNELS_AGENT=1. It is set in window 0's own shell, not in the script's environment, so the tmux server does not hand it to fleet windows. One line changed plus a comment; nothing else in the script was touched.~/.claude/scripts/emit-cron-rearm.sh:21-101: decision rules, in order:RAY_HEADLESS_CRON=1orRAY_SUPPORT_AGENT=1: skip (kept).- Find the nearest ancestor process that is
claude(walks up to 8 parents withps). - It was launched with
--channels(and-p/--printdoes not precede it): arm, flag or no flag. This also covers a by-hand start in a fresh terminal. - It was not launched with
--channels: skip, even if the flag is set (inherited flag). - Launch shape unreadable (
psfails): arm only ifRAY_CHANNELS_AGENT=1. Every decision is appended to~/.claude/logs/cron-rearm.log. The armed output is unchanged.
Code path for tomorrow's 04:00 restart, read end to end:
~/Library/LaunchAgents/com.claude.channels.plist:/bin/zsh ~/.claude/scripts/claude-channels-restart.shat 04:00 (and at load).- Restart script
:101tmux new-session -d -s claude-channels -c /Users/raycreates window 0 with a login zsh. :109typesexport DISABLE_AUTO_UPDATE=true DISABLE_UPDATE_PROMPT=true RAY_CHANNELS_AGENT=1; source ~/.zprofile; source ~/.zshrcinto that shell. Neither profile file mentionsRAY_(grep), so nothing unsets it.:166typesclaude --name channels-agent --channels plugin:imessage@claude-plugins-official --chrome "<seed>"into the same shell; the retry at:183uses the same shell. The claude process inherits the flag and has--channelsin its arguments.settings.jsonhooks.SessionStart(matchersstartupandresume) runs/Users/ray/.claude/scripts/emit-cron-rearm.shas a child of that claude process, so rule 3 arms (and rule 5 would too ifpsfailed).- Fleet windows:
:220exportsRAY_SUPPORT_AGENT=1in each new window; rule 1 skips them, and they have no--channels.
Verified:
bash -n emit-cron-rearm.sh,zsh -n claude-channels-restart.sh: OK.diffagainst the snapshot restart script shows only the export line and its comment.- Decision matrix with a stand-in process whose argv[0] is
claude(13 cases, all pass): channels shape with flag arms; channels shape without flag arms;claude -pwith inherited flag skips;claude -pwithout flag skips; plain interactive session skips; fleet shape skips; headless-cron flag beats channels shape; a childclaude -punder a channels-shaped parent skips; a-pprompt that contains the text--channelsskips; nops+ flag arms; nops+ no flag skips. Armed output is byte-identical to the snapshot hook's output (diffclean). - Private tmux server (
tmux -L fable2d, separate socket, the live session untouched): ran the restart script's own:109line verbatim, with the real~/.zprofileand~/.zshrc. Window 0 shell:flag=1; hook launched from it: 1 arm instruction. A second window given the fleet loop's own export line:flag=unset support=1, hook output 0 bytes. The private server was ended by exiting its shells;tmux has-session -t claude-channelsstill reports the live session. - Real
claude -pchildren after install, asked whether their context held a[SessionStart auto-arm]instruction:no flag: CLEAN,flag inherited: CLEAN.~/.claude/logs/cron-rearm.logshows both asSKIP not the channels session: nearest claude has no --channels, which also proves the ancestor lookup works under the real hook runner. - The live channels process's actual command line (
ps -o args= -p 67131) run through the same rule: ARM.
Not verified, and how to check: the positive path with a real claude --channels process was not run, because a second channels session would attach to the founder's iMessage channel. After the 04:00 restart on 2026-11-11, tail ~/.claude/logs/cron-rearm.log should show one ARM launch shape has --channels (RAY_CHANNELS_AGENT=1) line near 04:01, and CronList in the live session should list /morning-prep. The live session was not restarted and no tmux or claude process was killed.
2c. Undelivered backlog, drain, dead crontab line: DONE (drain step not exercised live)
Re-verified live: ~/.claude/state/cron-undelivered/ held 276 top-level files (plus 3 in superseded/), oldest 2026-06-12; messages-watchdog.sh:16 is a bare exit 0 and the crontab still ran it every 5 minutes; morning-prep/SKILL.md read only cron-failures.log.
Changed:
- New
~/.claude/scripts/cron-undelivered.sh(list,count,show <name>,done <name>...,expire [days]). It only moves files intoarchive/<YYYY-MM-DD>/, never deletes or overwrites (a name collision gets a numeric suffix), ignores subfolders, and sends nothing. - Backlog triage:
cron-undelivered.sh expire 7moved 263 files older than 7 days to~/.claude/state/cron-undelivered/archive/2026-11-10/. Nothing was delivered and nothing was deleted. skills/morning-prep/SKILL.md:33new Gather bullet "Undelivered cron alerts": list, relay or mark moot, thendonethe handled files andexpire 7.- User crontab: removed the one line
*/5 * * * * /Users/ray/.claude/scripts/messages-watchdog.sh >/dev/null 2>&1 # messages-watchdog. The script itself is left in place, still disabled.
Verified:
bash -n cron-undelivered.sh: OK. Tested first on a copy of the real folder: expire, done, a../xname refused, a missing name refused (rc 1), collision keeps both files, file count under the folder unchanged at 279.- Real folder:
find . -type f | wc -lis 279 before and 279 after;archive/2026-11-10/holds 263;superseded/still 3; 13 pending. Newest archived file is dated 11-01. crontab -lnow shows 4 lines (IP-drift, limit-watchdog comment + line, scratchpad-roll);diffagainst the snapshot crontab shows only the watchdog line removed.
Not verified: the new morning-prep step has not run (running the skill sends the brief). It first runs at 06:30 on 2026-11-11. Check that morning's · morning-prep ops-log record for the relayed/moot counts and that cron-undelivered.sh count drops.
For Ray to relay by hand (13 pending files, 6 topics, all from the last 3 days, none delivered by me). Check the thread first; any the founder has since answered are moot. Then cron-undelivered.sh done <name>....
- cert-study off-track alert (11-09 07:48), the one clearly founder-relevant item: "AWS AIP-C01 - off-track. Cold pretest still not taken, 3 days past the plan's own week-1 window, so the Dec-4 date stays a placeholder until it's scored." File
cert-study-20261109T074850.md. - Rental car: log as expense instead of mileage? Ray's unanswered ask from 11-09 16:58. Files
open-threads-check-20261109T181150.md,...T191143.md,...T201344.md. - Odometer reading for the mileage log. Ray's ask from 11-09 13:08. File
open-threads-check-20261109T151357.md. - Research queue re-aim to 3 outcomes: decision. Files
open-threads-check-20261109T111146.md,...T121150.md. - TagaPet post (Ship 30 Post 3): SC-020 honesty check, Amsterdam detail, post timing. Ray's ask from 11-08 11:37. Files
open-threads-check-20261108T131159.md,...T141217.md,...T151410.md,...T161210.md. - Dash cam price/fit check. Files
open-threads-check-20261107T181142.md,...T190713.md.
Still open (founder hands, audit 2a): the cause of the failed sends is untouched. Sends from the launchd tree will keep landing in this folder; the difference is that the morning brief now reads it.
4c. sw-* fleet lines: DONE
Re-verified live: fleet-manifest.txt listed six agents; scheduled-jobs.txt records the studio as paused by the founder on 2026-11-01; state/fleet-status/sw-*.md last written Oct 1-9.
Changed: ~/.claude/scripts/fleet-manifest.txt:14-22 the four sw-product, sw-design, sw-engineering, sw-growth lines are commented out under a dated note. caf-architect and ingest-agent are unchanged (4d is a founder decision).
Verified: the restart script's own filter (grep -v '^[[:space:]]*#' fleet-manifest.txt | grep '|') now yields only caf-architect and ingest-agent; diff against the snapshot shows only the comment block and the four # prefixes; the four running claude --name sw-* processes are still running (not killed) and all four handoff files are still in state/handoffs/.
Tell the founder: the four Scribble Works agents stop respawning from the 04:00 restart on 2026-11-11. Resume = uncomment four lines.
5b. Stale text and backup gaps: DONE (settings lines proposed only)
Re-verified live: ~/CLAUDE.md does not exist; AGENTS.md hard rules 1-4 carry the same numbers the skills cite, so the references map one to one.
"CLAUDE.md" → "AGENTS.md" (exact-string replacements, each asserted to occur exactly once):
skills/acquisition-rescan/SKILL.md:67,skills/check-board/SKILL.md:10,skills/morning-prep/SKILL.md:43,skills/process-newsletter/SKILL.md:10and:108,skills/sync-contacts/SKILL.md:29,:53,:217,skills/publish-site/SKILL.md:23(now names both files as things not to publish),state/cron-runner-context.md:27and:45, and the comment atscripts/cron-job-runner.sh:108.
Discord remnants outside settings: most mentions are accurate history ("replaced Discord #ops on 2026-09-04") and were left. Changed only text that still read as a live instruction: skills/graph-query/SKILL.md:52, skills/finance-pulse/SKILL.md:294, the comment at scripts/cron-job-runner.sh:99-100, the comment at scripts/scheduled-jobs.txt:75-77.
Backup gaps (~/Projects/ray-config):
bin/sync.sh: copies~/AGENTS.mdinstead of the non-existent~/CLAUDE.md; backs up the user crontab tohome/crontab.txt(via a temp file, so a failedcrontab -lcannot truncate it); addsco.raydata.cron-dispatcher.plistandco.raydata.memory-watchdog.plistto the plist list.bin/bootstrap.sh:29-32: restoresAGENTS.md, no longer the staleCLAUDE.md.README.md: rows updated.
Verified:
grep -rn 'CLAUDE\.md'overskills/*/SKILL.md,state/cron-runner-context.md, the runner and the manifest now returns only the two intentional mentions (publish-site's "do not publish" list and the runner's "(was ~/CLAUDE.md)").bash -non runner,sync.sh,bootstrap.sh;cron-dispatcher.py --validate: OK.- Throwaway-HOME sync run: pushed tree contains
home/AGENTS.md,home/crontab.txt(4 lines),launchagents/co.raydata.cron-dispatcher.plist,launchagents/co.raydata.memory-watchdog.plist. leak-scan.pyon the two plists and~/AGENTS.md: clean.
Skipped on purpose:
scripts/ask-model.shmentions~/CLAUDE.md; it belongs to a retired critic and is handled under 5d.home/CLAUDE.md(stale, Sep 18) is still tracked in the backup repo. It is no longer synced or restored; removing it from the repo is a one-linegit rmfor the founder if wanted.channels/discord/.env(bot token) is audit step 0d: founder revokes first.- The 22 memory files that mention Discord or CLAUDE.md are under the do-not-edit path.
Proposed founder-gated diffs (not applied):
~/.claude/settings.json:14-18, remove the five permissions for the retired Discord plugin:
- "mcp__plugin_discord_discord__reply",
- "mcp__plugin_discord_discord__react",
- "mcp__plugin_discord_discord__edit_message",
- "mcp__plugin_discord_discord__fetch_messages",
- "mcp__plugin_discord_discord__download_attachment",
~/.claude/settings.local.json, in permissions.allow:
- "mcp__plugin_discord_discord__reply"
(mind the trailing comma on the line before it). In the same file the env block holding OP_SERVICE_ACCOUNT_TOKEN should be deleted after rotation (audit 0a); scripts/op-service-account.sh reads the token from Keychain. I did not open that block.
~/.claude/settings.json:106, the skill override for a skill that does not exist:
- "investing-edgar-watch": "off"
(and drop the trailing comma on the line above).
5d. Clutter sweep: DONE for scripts (settings backups left for the founder)
Re-verified live: ~/.claude/scripts/ held 38 .bak-* files and 125 entries in total.
Changed: 41 files moved (not deleted) to ~/.claude/scripts/archive/2026-11-10/, with an ARCHIVE-MANIFEST.md listing each one and how to restore it.
- 34 backup copies (
*.bak-*). - 7 one-off scripts:
test-codex-write.sh(proof script for the retired Codex critic) and six single-use paper-trade deploys/checks from May 2026 (alpaca-intc-doublecount-fix-deploy.py,alpaca-longevity-v1-deploy.py,alpaca-nvidia-v1-deploy.py,alpaca-power-v1.1-deploy.py,alpaca-smm-v1-fill-check.py,alpaca-smm-v1-post-topup-check.py).
Reference check before each move (/tmp/fable-wip/refcheck.sh, a loop of grep -F for the file name): user crontab, ~/Library/LaunchAgents, scheduled-jobs.txt, every live script and precheck, settings.json and settings.local.json (match only, nothing printed), skills/, agents/, AGENTS.md, SOUL.md, CAPABILITIES.md, cron-runner-context.md, ray-handoff.md. Every moved file had zero references. leak-scan.py over all 41: clean.
Skipped because still referenced:
claude-channels-restart.sh.bak-2026-06-09and...-2026-09-18-mcp-startup-wait-DISPROVEN(named in comments in the restart script).scheduled-jobs.txt.bak-2026-06-11and...-2026-07-10-prerestore(named in comments in the manifest).ask-model.sh: the audit called it retired, butdelegation-gate.pystill references it. Left.messages-watchdog.sh: disabled and off the crontab now, but named inray-handoff.md. Left.
Skipped by judgment: alpaca-paper-smoke-test.py and catalog-sync-prod.sh are unreferenced but are reusable hand-run tools, not one-offs.
Verified: ls scripts | wc -l went 125 → 85 (41 out, the archive/ folder in); ls archive/2026-11-10 | wc -l is 42 (41 files + manifest); ls scripts | grep -c '\.bak' is 4, exactly the four skipped; bash -n cron-job-runner.sh and cron-dispatcher.py --validate still pass.
Left for the founder (not touched): the 16 ~/.claude/settings.json.bak-* files. They are unreferenced and leak-scan.py finds no credential pattern in them, but they sit beside the two settings files I was told not to edit, so I did not move them. If wanted:
mkdir -p ~/.claude/settings-backups/2026-11-10 && mv ~/.claude/settings.json.bak-* ~/.claude/settings-backups/2026-11-10/
The 534 MB backup-repo .git is part of founder step 0c.
4e. Changelogs out of SKILL.md: DONE. Off-skill archive: SKIPPED (all still referenced)
Changelogs
Re-verified live, and the audit was wrong on one number: it said /improve was "56 KB, of which 52 KB is changelog". The first ## Changelog in that file is an example inside a code fence; the real changelog was the last 16 KB. The other 40 KB is the skill's own instructions (mostly the 14-check recurrence guardrail), which is not a changelog and was not touched.
Changed:
- New
~/.claude/scripts/skill-changelog.py:add <skill> "<text>": dated entry into<skill>/CHANGELOG.md. Budgets: 1,200 characters per entry (longer is refused, exit 2), 16 KB per file (oldest entries roll intoCHANGELOG-archive.md, never deleted). Keeps each file's existing order (newest-first or oldest-first).recent <skill> [n]: the newest entries.migrate <skill> | --all [--dry-run]: moves the real## Changelogsection (code fences ignored) intoCHANGELOG.md, leaves a 3-line pointer. Idempotent; writesCHANGELOG.mdbeforeSKILL.md, so an interruption duplicates history instead of losing it.
- Migrated the 14 active skills that had a changelog: behavior-critic, compile-vault, deep-research, design-critic, graph-reingest, improve, investing-backtest-thesis, process-youtube, self-review, sync-contacts, verify-dispatch, verify-pdf-output, verify-strategic-output, verify-vault-write. The 13 switched-off skills with changelogs were left alone (they are not loaded).
skills/improve/SKILL.md:77-87(step 6),:145(guardrail check 2),:184(autonomous step 3):/improvenow writes history withskill-changelog.py addand reads it withrecent, and is told never to append history to SKILL.md.
Verified:
python3 -m py_compileunder both Pythons.- Sizes: all SKILL.md files together 875,574 → 833,325 bytes (42 KB less).
improve56,454 → 41,756;process-youtube51,987 → 39,892;design-critic41,231 → 35,029. - Conservation against the pre-change snapshot, per skill: rebuilding the original from the new SKILL.md plus CHANGELOG.md matches line for line for all 14 (for graph-reingest and sync-contacts the only differing lines are the ones I edited on purpose in 1c and 5b).
- Second
migrate improvesays "already migrated";migrate --all --dry-runnow lists only the 13 off skills. - Sandbox (throwaway HOME): add to an oldest-first log appends at the bottom; add to a newest-first log inserts at the top; a 1,300-character entry is refused with rc 2 and the file is unchanged; rollover moved 4 old entries to
CHANGELOG-archive.mdand the entry count across both files was conserved (19 = 15 + 4 added); bad skill names are refused. - One real use: the entry describing this change was added to
improve/CHANGELOG.mdwith the tool (and rolled the 2026-04-18 entry intoimprove/CHANGELOG-archive.md, as designed).
Not verified: that the weekly headless /improve autonomous run (Monday 07:00, Opus) follows the new step and that auto mode lets it run the script. Check improve/CHANGELOG.md and the SKILL.md sizes after the 2026-11-16 run.
The 22 switched-off skills: not moved
The rule for this step was to skip anything still referenced, with settings.json on the list of places to look. Every one of the 21 off skills that exists is named in settings.json skillOverrides, so under that rule none can move without a settings edit, which is founder-gated.
The re-check also showed the audit's recommendation was too broad. Beyond the override:
- 19 of the 21 are still referenced elsewhere: 18 are listed in
~/rdco-vault/CAPABILITIES.md, 9 are cited by other skills or agents, andskillifyby a script. Two of them (ray-data-co-design,sanity-check-design) are the brand-design folders thatAGENTS.mdtells Ray to audit when CAPABILITIES.md is missing. Switched off as slash commands, they are still used as reference material. They should stay. - Only
building-an-exo(508 KB) andsnowflake-cli(4 KB) are referenced nowhere except the override. investing-edgar-watchhas an override but no folder (stale entry; diff in 5b above).
Being switched off already keeps a skill out of the listing, so the context cost the audit worried about is not there; the remaining cost is disk and backup size.
Proposed, founder-gated (not applied). If the two unreferenced ones should go:
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills-archive/2026-11-10
mv ~/.claude/skills/building-an-exo ~/.claude/skills/snowflake-cli ~/.claude/skills-archive/2026-11-10/
and in ~/.claude/settings.json skillOverrides:
- "building-an-exo": "off",
- "snowflake-cli": "off",
Leaving those two override lines in place is harmless and has one benefit: a restored skill comes back already switched off.
5a. Dispatcher hardening: DONE
Re-verified live: no catch-up logic; state[slug] was set before run_precheck; a missing precheck logged "proceeding (fail-open)"; the only log was /tmp/ray-cron-dispatcher.log; per-job timeout and effort lived in TIMEOUTS / EFFORT_MAP in the dispatcher and a case in the runner. Found one more while reading: a forced fire returned before the normal tick, so any job due in the same minute as a forced fire was silently dropped.
Changed:
- Timeout and effort moved into the manifest.
cron-dispatcher.py:TIMEOUTSandEFFORT_MAPdeleted;job_settings(:488-504) reads only the manifest line.scheduled-jobs.txt:timeout=3600on process-newsletter (:88), process-youtube (:132), improve (:109), acquisition-rescan (:168);timeout=5400 effort=highon deep-research (:123);effort=highon curiosity (:120); the paused family-research-round line (:158) carriestimeout=10800 effort=high bgwait=0.cron-job-runner.sh:166-174: the hardcodedcase "$SLUG" in family-research-round)is replaced byRAY_CRON_BG_WAIT_MS, set from the newbgwait=option. - Catch-up, opt-in. New option
catchup=<hours>;previous_scheduled(:341-352) and the catch-up branch oftick(:652-666). If a job's latest scheduled minute inside the window was never handled, it fires once on the next tick. A job with no state only gets a baseline (a newly added job never fires on sight). Set on file-writing weekly and monthly jobs only: compile-vault, self-review, improve, freshness-watch (24h); books-refresh, acquisition-rescan, house-clock (72h). Deliberately not set on cert-study, hq-deploy-watch or anything else that messages the founder, since a catch-up can fire at any hour. - State written after the precheck, one atomic save per job:
handle(:605-615).migrate_state(:423-439) carries state from the old whole-prompt slugs to the new short ones and drops the old keys. - Prechecks fail closed (
run_precheck,:442-466): missing, crashing or hanging (60s) precheck means the job does not fire and a line goes tocron-failures.log. - Persistent log:
log()(:170-180) appends every line to~/.claude/logs/cron-dispatcher.log(rotates to.1at 1 MB) as well as stdout. The LaunchAgent plist was not changed, so/tmp/ray-cron-dispatcher.logstill gets the same lines plus interpreter crash output. - Isolation: each job is handled inside its own
try(:644-669), so one failing job cannot stop the rest; a crash of the whole tick is recorded incron-failures.logat most once an hour (main,:672-690). - Forced fire no longer swallows the tick (
:622-636).
Verified:
python3 -m py_compileunder both Pythons,bash -non the runner: OK.- Sandbox suite with an injected clock (
/tmp/fable-wip5/test5a.py), 22 of 22 pass: timeout and effort for all 21 jobs equal the old in-code tables; schedule parity old vs new vs the compiled matcher over 64,800 minutes; first tick on a copy of the real state file fires nothing and migrates the state (24 keys to 22, longest key 33 chars); a missed monthly slot is caught up exactly once; not caught up outside the window; not caught up when handled on time; no-state job gets a baseline only; daily jobs withoutcatchup=are never caught up; catch-up honours a "no work" precheck; missing precheck and hung precheck fail closed with a failure line; double tick is a no-op; an exception in one job does not block the next; forced fire plus due jobs all fire; log lines land in the persistent log; a dispatcher crash is recorded once, not every minute;bgwait=0,effort=highandtimeout=120reach the real runner and the (stub) claude process. - Runner regression in the sandbox after the change: ok, report landed, report missing, is_error, 300-char slug, shell job, bgwait unset / 0 / garbage, denial alert: all as expected, no locks left.
- Installed between ticks at 07:10:16 (dispatcher and manifest have to change together: the old dispatcher rejects
catchup=, the new one has no timeout table). - Live:
cron-dispatcher.py --validateprints the 22-job table with the tiers andOK: 22 jobs (21 system), 0 errors, 0 warnings(rc 0). The 07:11 launchd tick ran on the new code:cron-dispatch-state.jsonwent to 22 keys, longest 33 chars, withhouse-clock: 2026-11-02T07:15,books-refresh: 2026-11-03T06:40,freshness-watch: 2026-11-07T06:37inherited; nothing fired;grep -c Traceback /tmp/ray-cron-dispatcher.logis 0; no new failure lines.
Not done:
- The LaunchAgent still points stdout at
/tmp. Changing the plist needs alaunchctlreload of the dispatcher, which I did not do. Optional, since the script now keeps its own log. - Effort defaults (audit 3b) are untouched: jobs without
effort=still inherithighfrom settings.json. Pinning reporting jobs to medium is now a one-word manifest edit per job once the founder decides. - The pre-change files for this step are in
/tmp/fable-wip5/live-before-5a.*(will not survive a reboot); the full pre-run snapshot is in~/.claude/state/pre-fable-fix-2026-11-10/.
5a addendum: live due-job self-test (07:15)
To prove the live path a scheduled job takes (launchd tick, tick, handle, fire, runner) without waiting for a real job, I appended one temporary manifest line at 07:14:17: 15 7 10 11 * | system | shell | - | name=fable-selftest timeout=60 | ~/.claude/scripts/model-tier.sh sonnet (a model-free job that only prints a model ID). Result at 07:15:05: ~/.claude/logs/cron-runs/fable-selftest-20261110T071505.log contains claude-sonnet-5-5 and === done exit=0 ===; ~/.claude/logs/cron-dispatcher.log (the new persistent log) got its first line, FIRE fable-selftest model=shell timeout=60s effort=inherit; the state file recorded fable-selftest: 2026-11-10T07:15; no failure line. Then the manifest was restored byte-for-byte (cmp against the copy taken before the test), the state key was removed, and --validate is back to OK: 22 jobs (21 system), 0 errors, 0 warnings. The run log is left in place; the runner's 14-day retention removes it.
Observed at 08:00, the first natural claude job on the new dispatcher, runner, manifest and Sonnet 5.5: ~/.claude/logs/cron-dispatcher.log shows 2026-11-10T08:00:05 FIRE check-board model=claude-sonnet-5-5 timeout=1800s effort=inherit; logs/cron-runs/check-board-20261110T080005.log header carries report=check-board and ends === done exit=0 === at 08:00:41; the result JSON has is_error:false, 11 turns, 0 permission denials, modelUsage only claude-sonnet-5-5; the ops log has one ## 2026-11-10 08:.. ET · check-board entry, so the report= postcondition held on a natural run; cron-failures.log has no line dated after 07:00; the lock was released; state reads check-board: 2026-11-10T08:00.
Run ended 2026-11-10 08:01 ET.