01-projects/printables-product/reviews

Charter / kill-criteria / hardening check 2026-11-01

2026-11-01·review·status: gated (verify-strategic-output ITERATE r1 → 9 fixes; r2 ITERATE → 4 mechanical fixes, parent-verified)

What was reviewed

Charter, memo §5, rulings, state files, gh, git.

What changed since 10-25

Findings

  1. Output outruns review (inference). §8c: 0 final fails (rounds.md:1197-1373); signal 2 (charter:414) has no founder-time instrument (escalations.md:605).
  2. §8d broken since September; the train widened it. 110 merges by mid-September (escalations.md:246), then 43 in 18h, vs "must not exceed 10" (charter:466). One hybrid hardening round since (rounds.md:391); R48 never logged (queue.md:150); §8d question (escalations.md:603) dropped from carried list (:721).
  3. Kill criteria: launched in practice, dormant on paper (inference). Memo clock = "publicly live" (memo:151); 93 games live, two Plus households emailed daily (reviews/2026-10-27:24).
  4. Hardening debt: 17 open non-game PRs (ruling 38 = games only, rulings:182), incl. #356 (live defect), #485 (#481 phase 1, "starts now", rulings:189; conflicting, untouched since 10-28).
  5. Hidden merges are production releases. Each merge auto-releases the site (deploy-website.yml; 09-12 amendment): 19 overnight, 2 failed verification (runs 40810343550, 40833564955). §8c says "nothing reaches production overnight" (charter:435-436); ruling 38 authorized it ("each merge = site redeploy", escalations.md:589). Ray records that at charter:436.

Proposed queue.md changes

@@ -44 +44,2 @@
-- MERGE PLAN: order per escalations.md:670; R54 re-run per batch (:40).
+- MERGE PLAN: after decision 2 and the Actions-minutes check (escalations.md:757), run merge-prep/2026-10-31-batch9-recipe.sh (ruling 38); R54 re-run per batch (:46).
+- R66. [engineering, S, next non-game slot] Refresh #485 onto main; npm test; scoped critic; stays draft.
@@ -53,0 +55 @@
+- R67. [process, XS] DRAIN line adds R48's §8d count, including merge-prep/ merges; strike R48 (:150).

Decisions needed (founder)

  1. Throttle: 1 new game/night until a verdict or D1 token; freed slots to R66, #356 (overrides charter:430). 5th ask (escalations.md:681, :717, :766). Low confidence; no default; silence keeps slots. Bear: you withdrew back pressure (:589); same shape.
  2. §8d: exempt hidden game merges, go weekly, or strike. Default weekly (low confidence; silence keeps charter:466). Bear vs exempt: every merge edited 6 shared files incl. a Worker and released production (finding 5).
  3. "Launched" (your declaration, charter:19; open since escalations.md:604): declare 11-01, read 2027-01-30? Silence = dormant. Bear: 2 of 3 signals uninstrumented (memo:164), Search Console unverified (escalations.md:424).