01-projects/printables-product/reviews

Review-and-plan: roadmap grooming (2026-10-28)

2026-10-28·review·status: gated (verify-strategic-output ITERATE -> 7 fixes applied 2026-10-28)·by sw-critic review slot
printablesscribble-worksroadmapqueuedrain

Reviewed

Ranges in frontmatter; no D1 or production reads.

Findings

  1. Ruling 32 may not cover the drain. 09-02: "In general, okay to release these games as they pass the critic" (rulings:145), before the merge became the production gate (charter:50); :589 asks for an explicit OK. gh: 71 open PRs, 56 of them games (30 5_6, 26 3_4), 47 PRs (43 games) created since 10-12, last merge #432 on 10-11. The hidden-merge proposal (escalations.md:589) would apply it; unanswered 17 days. Last studio tap: 10-21 (rounds.md:1249).
  2. The eval loop has stopped. The ledger's newest human critique is from 10-04 (14 rows, sqlite). Game PRs after #411 have no rows except the 10-25 three (rounds.md:1203, :1217). Creation-eval work goes first by rule (charter:483 (2)), but no creation-eval item ranked since 10-15 (queue.md:51). Founder verdicts since 10-04 (#430, #461) never reached the ledger.
  3. Dead or used-up items:
    • The GAME LANE refresh list (queue.md:42) is used up. #383 was redone (rounds.md:923, :940); only #380 is left, waiting on dice.
    • #407: REVISE at the cap, CONFLICTING, no gh update since 10-06 (escalations.md:669).
    • R10 keep/drop still open (escalations.md:517).
    • Lines 58, 150, 157 and 158 wait on a merge.

3-5 creation quality: yes, see finding 2.

Proposed queue.md changes

@@ -42 +42 @@ AUTONOMOUS (product: reordering, charter:48)
-- GAME LANE (10-21): slot A = one :809 refresh, …
+- GAME LANE (10-28): refresh list used up; #380 after the dice ruling. Slot A = new game.
@@ -51,0 +52 @@ AUTONOMOUS (product :48; engineering, non-production data :50)
+- NEXT NON-GAME SLOT (creation-eval): ledger backfill after #410 (:25, R44) + founder packet verdicts 10-08..10-21 as human rows.
@@ -824 +824 @@ AUTONOMOUS (product: status; #407 retire pending :669)
-## 2026-10-11 — TEMPLATE REFRESH SWEEP (…)
+## 2026-10-11 — TEMPLATE REFRESH SWEEP: DONE except #380 (dice). #407 retire pending escalations.md:669.

ESCALATE: hidden merges (engineering, charter:50: the merge is the production gate). The #407 close is a gh write, classifier-denied before (escalations.md:682).

Decisions needed (founder)

  1. Does ruling 32 cover overnight hidden merges of critic-ACCEPT games (:589)? Default: yes. Bear: #430, #453 drew your non-ACCEPT after critic ACCEPT.
  2. Close #407: gh pr close 407 --repo RayDataCo/scribble-works --comment "REVISE at cap 10-06; retired". Default: close.
  3. Carried: WIP cap, merge path, zero-merge signal (10-25), D1 token (:591).