01-projects/printables-product/reviews

Charter / kill-criteria / hardening check 2026-10-25

2026-10-25·review·status: gated (verify-strategic-output ITERATE → 6 exact-text fixes applied by parent)

What was reviewed

Charter :19, :387-389, :409-416, :438, :466; queue.md:37, :52-54; rounds.md:1030-1187; escalations.md:449, :589-713.

Findings

  1. WIP cap is due. 10-21 #4: re-ask today if hidden merges stayed unanswered (escalations.md:681). Unanswered (:703). Last studio message: "ACCEPT #461 Trace the Letter C!" (chat.db, 10-21 07:05); none of 66 since.
  2. Nothing drains, and no meter sees it. gh: 62 open (57 draft), 47 games; since 10-12, 39 opened, 0 merged. Five founder ACCEPTs (#368 #377 #451 #452 #461) sit MERGEABLE, against "ACCEPT = ready → merge → flip live" (queue.md:37). Every meter is green: gates 23/24 (rounds.md:1081-1181); §8c no trips; §8d counts merges, so it cannot fire at zero (charter:466); kill criteria dormant (:19); signal 2 (:414) cannot fire, since his studio time fell. The charter warned "Output is not the constraint" (:387-389) but set no signal; its two-week review (:438) never ran (escalations.md:449).
  3. Hardening, no durable fix:
    • studio-packet.py hand-patched three nights running (rounds.md:1099, :1127, :1143); it has no test.
    • 10-24 restart (rounds.md:1173): last shows a console login 06:07; the plist has RunAtLoad. The script empties its log each run (claude-channels-restart.sh:13), erasing evidence. Killed builders left 5 unpushed commits and 5 unlogged loosened thresholds (rounds.md:1178-1179).

Proposed queue.md changes

@@ -52 +52 @@
-- R32: log every round close.
+- R32: log every round close, plus a DRAIN line: open PRs, game PRs, merges since 10-11, last founder studio message.
@@ -54,0 +55,3 @@
+- R60. [engineering, S] studio-packet.py fixture test (number words, "New <band> game:" prefix, -es renders, before-*.png); --publish stops on a fail.
+- R61. [ops, S, ESCALATE: outside §2 columns] claude-channels-restart.sh: append to its log; record the trigger.
+- R62. [process, XS] round-common: builders push work after each critic pass and log each loosened threshold at once.

Decisions needed (founder)

  1. WIP cap (re-ask): 30+ open passed game PRs → 1 new-game slot; the rest go to merge prep and refreshes until a merge lands. Default: cap. Bear case: it reverses "We shouldn't have the PR back pressure" (:589).
  2. Merge path: a gh allow rule for ready/merge (:659), or run the command (:698). Default: allow rule. Bear case: Ray merges without terminal approval.
  3. New §7 signal: "7 rounds with zero merges → no new games." Default: add it. Bear case: back pressure again (:589), for a founder-side block.
  4. Carried: hidden merges (:589), D1 token (:591), "launched" (:604).