What was reviewed
10-17 note; rounds.md:1015-1167; escalations.md:575-695; queue.md:30-62; gold-set/ and feedback/ listings; feedback D1 count; gh.
Findings
- Founder verdicts, 10-17 to 10-23: 7. ACCEPT #452 #368 #377 #451 on 10-18 (rounds.md:1047-1048) and #461 on 10-21 (:1133). He REVISEd #453's spinner ("I don't understand the spinning", :1047), then KILLed the critic-ACCEPTed rework, reason unlogged (:1051-1052). Change: first non-ACCEPT naming a mechanic, not art (10-10 F2; 10-17 F1). v0.2 critic ACCEPT then his non-ACCEPT: #430, #453 twice.
- No cohort signal. Feedback D1 has 0 rows all-time. feedback/ newest file is 09-08. Newest tester grades are 10-05. The V/Grammy ask has no logged answer since 10-10 (escalations.md:579). He is the only grader.
- Packets: 7 published, 2 tapped (10-18, 10-21). He has not tapped since 10-21 07:06. #448 has appeared in 6 packets without a tap, #449 in 5 (:1023, :1079, :1099, :1127, :1143, :1159). Counterpoint: #368 got its ACCEPT after many repeats (:992-:1047).
- ACCEPT does not mean merged. All 5 ACCEPTs are open and MERGEABLE (gh). The classifier blocks iMessage taps (escalations.md:652). The merge command (first sent 10-18, escalations.md:654; latest rounds.md:1133) has not run.
- Unanswered, age at 10-24: hidden merges (:589) and D1 token (:591), 13 days; V/Grammy, 14; art budget (:636), 8; age line (:663), 5; merge command, 6; dice (:674), 4.
3-5 creation quality: yes. #453 is a 3-4 mechanic signal. The bar on 5-6 dice is Ray's inference (:674), not his ruling.
Proposed queue.md changes
Product lane is autonomous (charter §2).
@@ -31,0 +32 @@
+- [product, XS] (10-24 cohort review) 3_4 briefs: no spinner or point-to-pick mechanic (#453 spinner REVISE, rounds.md:1047; point rework KILLed 10-18, reason unlogged, :1052). Dice stay barred only until escalations 2026-10-20 is answered.
@@ -61 @@ (in-line edit)
-#383 founder REVISE 10-11 supersedes), then
+#383 founder REVISE 10-11 supersedes; #368 #377 #451 #452 #461 founder-ACCEPTed, out of backlog until merged), then
Decisions needed (founder)
- Merges: run the 10-21 command or add a gh allow rule (escalations.md:659)? Ray proposes the allow rule. Bear: Ray could then merge without a terminal approval.
- Packet (carried :642): stop rebuilding until he taps? Ray proposes yes. Bear: #368 got its ACCEPT after repeats.
- Cohort: text V/Grammy the feedback number once, or drop them (:579)? Bear: it may feel like pressure.
- Dice (:674): was the #453 KILL about pointing, or the game?