01-projects/printables-product/reviews

Unit economics + cost basis review (2026-10-23)

2026-10-23·studio-review·status: draft (ungated; reviewer returned text)

What was reviewed

Findings

  1. Art spend is $0, and builds continued. Rounds 10-17 to 10-22 log Quiver $0 (rounds.md:1022, :1041, :1081, :1100, :1128, :1144). Sixteen new game PRs (#448-#466) and the #381 refresh used reused art and hand-coded shapes (ruling 20). October Quiver stays ~$29.51; the ~$43-57 pace (escalations.md:636) is off.
  2. The $0 cap has an unpriced quality cost. Reused art caused style flags on #458 (:1095), #460 (:1093) and #381 (:1140). The turtle redraw and #377/#380 art were skipped (:1031). All passed gates; effect on founder ACCEPTs unmeasured (inference).
  3. Shipped games: still 0 (day 12). ~$11.04 of art (10-16 F1+F4) sits in unmerged PRs.
  4. Waiting now costs merge-order dependencies, not dollars. The #381 refresh cost $0 (earlier: $2.28, $1.62, rounds.md:922-923). #456, #465, #466 and #381 copy from unmerged PRs (:1060, :1140-1142); queue.md:148 omits them.
  5. #371 passes CI since 10-19; queue.md:102 still says it fails. Only a merge remains.
  6. Unchanged since 10-16: R44, R46, no token rows, no Cloudflare/Resend/gateway costs logged.
  7. 10-16 decisions: Ray's queue edit settled #2 (queue.md:40). #1 and #3 are not answered (escalations.md:636).

Proposed queue.md changes

@@ queue.md:102 @@
--> #371: red, untouched since 09-27; merge origin/main (normal push), re-run CI, merge.
+-> #371: CI passes since 10-19 (R54); merge only (founder command or allow rule).
@@ queue.md:148 @@
-... #445, #447, #449 at content/art/; #450 merges after #429.
+... #445, #447, #449, #456, #465, #466, #381 (ES nube) at content/art/ or the merged source; #450 merges after #429.
@@ after queue.md:22 @@
+- ART $0 HARD CAP (since 10-17): reuse and hand-coded shapes only; log each style flag it causes; October only; from Nov 1, queue.md:22 under $20/mo until escalations.md:636 item 1 is ruled.

Decisions needed (founder)

  1. Art budget from Nov 1 (:636 item 1): (a) stay at $0; (b) under the $20/mo autonomous line, named redraws only (turtle, #377/#380); (c) above $20. Ray recommends (b) (your 10-01 Quiver ask, queue.md:22). Bear: 16 games built at $0; no evidence Quiver raises ACCEPTs.
  2. Merges (carried): run the 10-21 command (rounds.md:1133), adding #371, or add an allow rule.
  3. The $3-per-game cap (:636 item 3): retire it, or keep it for (b)?