What was reviewed
Live (curl, 05:1x ET): /, /browse/, /faq/, /privacy/, /terms/, /planner/, /account/, /create-account/, /guides/, all 89 live /game/ pages. /pricing/, /plans/, /plus/: 404. Source: origin/main 46ed046 (last merge 10-11, unchanged since 10-12). 45 open PRs; 32 are new games, all 3_4 or 5_6 by title. Rubric: [[DESIGN-scribble-works]] (no voice section), rulings 18, 30, 31, and queue.md:16-17.
Findings
- New: the age promise is older than the band focus. "2–10" is in 12 copy spots: Shopper.astro:53, Base.astro:52/53/547/655, seo.js:15, browse.astro:69/76, faq.astro:18, index.astro:64, planner.astro:12, shopper.astro:12; plus 3 model prompts (engine.js:379, art.js:218/456). Focus is 3-6 since 10-01 (queue.md:16-17). /browse/ age filters: 2-3: 5 games, 3-4: 47, 5-6: 44, 7-8: 16, 9-10: 14 (the filters overlap). The FAQ origin story ("his own preschooler") is 3-6. R21 (queue.md:90) would add "2–10" to the home title.
- Repeat: dead ends are spreading. The 4 cards that 404 still count toward "93 games". 18 of 89 live game pages link to them under "Goes well with", including first-sounds, trace-abc, sonido-inicial and silabas-de-m, which anchor the ready-made playsets on the home page. Open because of the D1 token (escalations.md:591, 8 days); #435 (R50) unmerged.
- Repeat: copy still has no slot. R36, ranked 10-12 (queue.md:45), has no PR. "new games land on the shelf every week" (browse.astro:164) is now false: 0 merges in 8 days. "Teachers" is still on account.astro:67 and privacy.astro:325, 47 days after the ruling-30 addendum. R54 holds slot D (queue.md:40).
Proposed queue.md changes
@@ -40,1 +40,2 @@
- R54. [engineering, M, slot D until done] MERGE-READINESS ...
+- R36. [product] Run next after R54, ahead of R55; drop R21 until 10-19 decision 1.
@@ -45,1 +45,0 @@
-6. R36 (copy PR; ranked 2026-10-12 review)
@@ -143,0 +144,3 @@
+## 2026-10-19 review (reviews/2026-10-19-marketing-copy-positioning.md)
+R56. [growth, S] Apply the 10-19 decision 1 to the 12 spots and 3 prompts via one constant.
+R57. [engineering, XS] #435 also checks "Goes well with" links; skip slugs that are not in the production catalog.
Decisions needed (founder)
- Age line on the front page: (a) keep "2–10"; (b) "made first for 3–6, games up to 10"; (c) "3–6" only. Lean (b). Bear case: (b) and (c) change every page's SEO description.
- D1 token (escalations.md:591): open since 10-11. It blocks every launch and causes finding 2.
- Carried over: the voice section (escalations.md:607), plus the 10-05 front-door line and R10 (:516-518).