What was reviewed
10-10 note; rounds.md:887-1023; escalations.md:576-641; gold-set grades (HELD not opened); feedback/ listing; queue.md:49-58, :136; gh 2026-10-17 ~05:50 ET. D1 feedback rows: not read.
Findings
- One founder sitting since 10-10. 10-11 07:19-07:26 ET: REVISE #430 (no room to connect dots), #383 and #368 (old template, weak art) (rounds.md:921-923); #361, #372 merged that morning (gh; ACCEPT inferred). Packets since 10-10: 8, tapped 1 (:898-:1023). Change: #430 is the first critic-ACCEPT v0.2 new game he REVISEd (10-10: 16/16); his reason repeats bedtime's cut gaps (founder-grades.md:7), n=2. No REVISE cites a mechanic: no new shape signal.
- Family testers silent since 10-05; feedback/ newest 09-08. First overlap: Rhyme Time grader-1 all-Y ACCEPT (v-grammy-grades.md:22) vs his REVISE (:923); n=1. Outside the household: none in feedback/.
- Critic, 22 new games. i1 REVISE 14/22. Brief-fixable repeats: B6 (#441 #448 self-check, #445 order), action room (#434 #436). C1 N on 8 ACCEPTs, but he graded C softer than Ray, n=5 (founder-grades.md:26): don't chase. Ray flagged 3 critic-ACCEPTs (#447 #448 #449; :1005, :1018-1019). Variance fix holding: 1 untouched-check flip (:931).
- Stall. 30 single-game PRs open; 24 opened since 10-09, none merged; main last moved 10-11 12:36Z (#432). Daily replacement showed #425-#427 once (:898); #368 filled 4 straight packets, #377 3 (:975-:1023). R53 (queue.md:136) misses #449 (art from #440) and #450 (needs #429) (:1019-1020).
- Attribution. escalations.md:639 called #429's nits "your"; earliest source is a Ray brief (dispatches/2026-10-12-slot-c-finish-429.md:5). Escalation and queue.md:59 fixed 10-17; confirm with him.
Proposed queue.md changes
Product + engineering autonomous (charter §2).
@@ -49 @@
-#383 carry V/Grammy ACCEPT sheets)
+#383 carry V/Grammy ACCEPT sheets; #383 founder REVISE 10-11 supersedes)
@@ -54,0 +55 @@
+- [product, XS] (10-17 cohort review) New-game briefs state the B6 self-check and the kid's action room in inches (dot lane, write box, cut gap); critic grades A6 against it.
@@ -136 @@
-#445, #447 at content/art/.
+#445, #447, #449 at content/art/; #450 merges after #429.
Decisions needed (founder)
- Carried: merge critic-ACCEPT games hidden as pending-review (escalations.md:589) plus the D1 token (:591). Ray proposal: yes. Bear: each merge redeploys; #430 got his REVISE after critic ACCEPT (1/17).
- Packet (:625): keep an untapped packet up until tapped (amends queue.md:34)? Ray proposal: yes. Bear: new games wait.
- V/Grammy (:579): drop the form? Ray proposal: one text asking whether a grandchild played anything. Bear: may feel like pressure.