01-projects/printables-product/reviews

Unit economics + cost basis review (2026-10-16)

2026-10-16·review·status: gated (verify-strategic-output ITERATE → 12 exact-text fixes applied by parent)

What was reviewed

Reviews 09-25, 10-09; charter :46-51, :129, :430; rulings.md:76-82, :137-141; rounds.md:846-1006; escalations.md:571-635; queue.md; ledger.sqlite; gh.

Findings

  1. Art per new game fell. Round Quiver 10-09 to 10-16: $7.14 (eight rounds, rounds.md:881-1006), ~$0.89/round, was ~$2.37 (10-09 F3). 21 game PRs opened since 10-09 (gh): ~$0.34 average. Max: $1.59 (#427, :896). Reuse and code geometry (ruling 20) drove it (:881, :890).
  2. Production yield: 0. None of the 21 merged; main last moved 10-11 (#432). Both 10-11 launches (older PRs) 404 pending the D1 token (escalations.md:591, :612). 27 of 39 open PRs are games.
  3. Waiting PRs cost rework. Refreshes cost $2.28 (#368) and ~$1.62 (#383) (rounds.md:922-923), 5-7x a new game; queue.md:796 requires one for every game PR older than #425. Open PRs copy art from other unmerged PRs (:971, :1003; escalations.md:633), so merge order matters.
  4. October art ~$29.51 by 10-16 ($18.47 [10-09 F3] + $7.14 + $3.90 refreshes), over the $20/mo line (escalations.md:572); unanswered.
  5. Ledger stale; no 10-09 item shipped. 63 rows, $15.33, newest 10-07. No token rows: agent effort unmeasured (charter:129). R44-R46 undone (#417: 0 comments); #371 red since 09-27.
  6. Marginal game: cheap in dollars (~$0.34 average vs $3 cap, queue.md:22); the growing cost is wait time. At ~2.6/round against 5-game packets (queue.md:33), 27 PRs need ≥11 all-ACCEPT daily reviews (inference). Founder away until 10-15 (rounds.md:1001).

Proposed queue.md changes

@@ queue.md:90 @@
-R23. ... -> #371: #353 merged 10-07; merge origin/main (normal push), re-run CI, merge. (2026-10-09 review)
+R23. ... -> #371: red, untouched since 09-27. Same slot as R44.
@@ queue.md:119-120 @@
-R44. ... backfill #387 and 10-08; ...
+R44. ... backfill #387 and 10-08 to 10-16 (~$12.66, rounds.md:846-1006); ...
-R45. [product, XS] R24 proxy: art cost per critic ACCEPT, reported at round close; ...
+R45. [product, XS] Round close: art $ per new game PR, open game PRs, games merged. ...
@@ after queue.md:135 @@
+R53. [engineering, XS] After #428 and source PRs merge: point copied art in #427, #439, #442, #444, #445, #447 at content/art/.

Decisions needed (founder)

  1. Monthly Quiver ceiling (carried, :572). Pace: ~$43 by 10-31; ~$53-57 with six refreshes.
  2. While merges stall: 3 game slots (charter:430) or 2 games + 1 refresh/R53 slot for 7 rounds? Bear: founder rejected backpressure (:589); its unanswered merge-hidden proposal clears the queue.
  3. $3 cap (carried, :574): $1 for new games (#427: $1.59), $3 for refreshes?