Growth/SEO/GEO review, 2026-10-15
What was reviewed
- Live 05:49-05:56 ET, GET only: robots, all 96 sitemap URLs (head, JSON-LD), 186 /browse/ links, llms.txt, crawler user agents, DNS TXT.
- main
46ed046; gh pr list (36 open, last merge #432 on 10-11); deploy run 38140447165 log.
- Prior reviews; queue.md:37-47, :80-133; escalations.md:423-426, :591, :609; rounds.md:987.
Findings
- Nothing from 10-08 shipped. R20, R21, R26, R42 and R43 have no merge and no open PR. Live: 0 hreflang on 96 pages; home title "Scribble Works"; /faq/ has no JSON-LD; 1 lastmod in 96 URLs. Only R21 is slotted, inside R36 (queue.md:42, :107).
- R20 grew: 24 EN/ES pairs are both live (20 on 10-08).
- New: the sitemap and IndexNow disagree. Since #422, /sitemap.xml rebuilds game lines from D1 (functions/sitemap.xml.js:18-20), with no lastmod (src/lib/catalog/sitemap.js:13). IndexNow reads the static build (indexnow-ping.mjs:20). Run 38140447165 logged "submitted 100 URL(s)"; the live sitemap lists 96. The gap matches the 4 production 404s (inference). So R43's sitemap.xml.ts:21 fix alone misses production, and every deploy before the D1 token lands submits 404s.
- Healthy: 96/96 return 200 with a canonical; 89/89 descriptions ≤160 characters; 29 Spanish pages
lang="es"; four AI crawlers get 200.
- Unchanged: no Search Console or Bing verification (TXT: SPF only); pages.dev returns 200; llms.txt 404 (skipped 09-24; weak evidence, docs/AEO.md:12). "93 games" shows while 89 render, an answer-engine accuracy input (docs/AEO.md:24; escalations.md:609).
- Merges bind (inference): an SEO PR joins 36 unmerged; overnight merges await his yes (escalations.md:589).
- 3-5 creation quality (charter:483): not touched.
Proposed queue.md changes
@@ queue.md:84 @@
+ 2026-10-15: 24 live pairs. Emit only for siblings live in D1.
@@ queue.md:116 @@
-R43. ... add game lastmod (sitemap.xml.ts:21). With R27 (:572).
+R43. ... add game lastmod in sitemap.xml.ts:21 AND src/lib/catalog/sitemap.js:13. With R27 (:607).
@@ after queue.md:133 @@
+## 2026-10-15 review (reviews/2026-10-15-growth-seo-geo.md)
+R52. [engineering, XS] IndexNow submits the live /sitemap.xml set, not dist/ (indexnow-ping.mjs:20). Test: a slug that is live in meta.yaml but missing from D1 is not sent.
+For product (charter:48): slot 4 DONE (rounds.md:987); candidate: one PR, R20 + R42 + R43 + R52.
Decisions needed
- Carried: the D1 token (escalations.md:591). It also sends 4 404 URLs to IndexNow on every deploy.
- Carried: Search Console and Bing (:424; external account, charter:51). Without them, nothing here is measurable.
- Carried: the pages.dev 301 (:425).
- Carried: overnight merges (:589); each redeploys production.