01-projects/printables-product/reviews

Copy review 2026-10-12

2026-10-12·review·status: gated (verify-strategic-output ITERATE → 9 exact-text fixes applied by parent)

What I reviewed

Live 05:13-05:15 ET (curl): /, /browse/, /faq/, /privacy/, /terms/, /account/, /sign-in/, /create-account/, /guides/, the guide, all 89 sitemap /game/ pages. /pricing/, /plus/, /login/: 404. Source: origin/main 46ed046. Rubric: [[DESIGN-scribble-works]], rulings 15-18/30/31, charter §2 (:48-51), [[WRITING-rdco]].

Follow-through

Shipped: R34. 89/89 live descriptions ≤160 characters (max 156), no em dashes, both 10-06 residual blurbs live. Still open, verified live: R12 (browse.astro:164 "every week"); R15 (privacy.astro:325; account.astro:67 on /create-account/; :135); R16 (browse.astro:74 h1); R21 (home <title> is "Scribble Works"); R35 (recommended-playsets.yaml unchanged since 35ba3f6, 09-01); R37 (guide :46 live, published: 2026-09-12); R38 (faq.astro:26-31 "Yes.").

Findings

  1. The shelf count is too high. Home says "Browse all 93 games" and /browse/ says "93 games". Four of those cards return 404: letter-sound-hunt, caceria-de-sonidos, ten-frame-race, carrera-de-marcos-de-diez (launched 10-11 in #431/#432). The sitemap lists 89. Cause: escalations.md:591-592 (D1 token). No check fails when a card's page returns 404.
  2. Copy work gets no slot. Since 09-17, front-door copy files changed only in #359 (guide), #363 (SEO head) and #417 (catalog plumbing), per git log. R34 shipped in 3 days without a rank, as a P1 leak (queue.md:99). R36 unranked (queue.md:35-44); its parts are 18-28 days old.
  3. No voice contract. [[DESIGN-scribble-works]] has no voice section. Copy rulings live only in product-model-rulings.md:70-73, :135. So no gate checks audience copy. "Teachers" is still on two live pages 40 days after the ruling-30 addendum.

Proposed queue.md changes

@@ -39,6 +39,7 @@
 4. R33 + R32 (XS)
-5. R35
-6. R10 (pending escalations.md:517, default keep)
-7. R39
-8. R40
-9. vocabulary-triangle revision
+5. R36 (copy PR; ranked 2026-10-12 review)
+6. R35
+7. R10 (pending escalations.md:517, default keep)
+8. R39
+9. R40
+10. vocabulary-triangle revision
@@ -115,0 +117,2 @@
+## 2026-10-12 review (reviews/2026-10-12-marketing-copy-positioning.md)
+R50. [engineering, XS] Post-deploy smoke: GET /game/<slug>/ for every /browse/ card; fail on any 404.

Both are inside charter §2: product reorders the queue (:48); engineering builds reversible PRs (:50). R47-R49: held 10-11 review (rounds.md:918). Bear: ranks 2-7 never steered (10-07 grooming:15).

Decisions needed

  1. Add a five-line Voice section to [[DESIGN-scribble-works]] that restates rulings 15, 16, 18 and the ruling-30 addendum? Amendments are founder rulings ([[DESIGN-scribble-works]]:12). Default yes. Bear: one more file to keep in sync.
  2. 10-05 decisions 1-3 stand (escalations.md:516-518); the front-door line is open since 09-28.