What was reviewed
[[2026-08-31-studio-charter|Charter]] :19, :46-51, :407-417, :430, :466; [[2026-08-30-step1-memo|step1-memo]]:148-152; 09-27/10-04 reviews; rounds.md:719-907; escalations.md:500-580; queue.md:14-52, :83-110, :715-752; gh.
Findings
- §7, rounds 10-05..10-10. Signal 1 clear, PASS 3/4, 2/4, 2/4, 3/4, 3/4, 4/4 (rounds.md:732, :779, :807, :846, :881, :897). Signal 2 unmeasured (10-04 #4 unanswered, escalations.md:505). Signal 3: none logged (unverified).
- §8d unenforced; counter false. rounds.md:907 logs "181 (unchanged)"; gh counts 219, with 38 merged 10-04..10-08. ~100 merges since the 09-14 hybrid hardening round (rounds.md:391), cap 10 (charter:466). 09-27 #5 unruled (escalations.md:448).
- Backpressure. 16 new-game PRs in 6 rounds (rounds.md:720-896); 15 game PRs await the founder (:907). The 10-04 throttle was withdrawn as answered by the daily packet (escalations.md:554), untapped during travel (:888).
- Live defects. Rocket PDFs 0.46 mm short (rounds.md:895); Moo f/t stubs (queue.md:751); kid-page answer footers (:716, :750); page-source answer keys unruled (escalations.md:523). Gate gaps: the smoke flake failed 4 releases, skipping verify/rollback (rounds.md:825, :832; runs 37216945537, 37786105559), retry unbuilt (queue.md:717); prod catalog sync is manual (:720-722); D1 cutover merges #415-#422 (authorized, #415 body:9) are unlogged in rounds.md.
- Launch drift. 89 live games (rounds.md:866), D1 production catalog (#422). The memo clock, "catalog publicly live" (step1-memo:151), is arguably met; nothing declared (charter:19) 40 days after strategy-spec-audit:84-86. Search Console unverified (escalations.md:568).
Proposed queue.md changes
@@ -110,0 +111,4 @@
+## 2026-10-11 review (reviews/2026-10-11-charter-kill-criteria-hardening-check.md)
+R47. [product, S] 10-12 round = §8d hardening round (charter:466): :717 retry; :722 sync in launch-games; ARCHITECTURE.md D1 + R29; R32; R33. No new games.
+R48. [engineering, XS] Round close logs literal R7 gh output + merges since last hardening.
+R49. [product, XS] LIVE DEFECTS block at top (rocket #356, :751, :715-716, :750), brief-line count until closed.
Bear on R47: hardening PRs also await his merge (rounds.md:904); it overrides the games-majority bias (charter:430), which 09-14 split instead (escalations.md:254).
Decisions needed (founder)
- Backpressure rule (replaces 10-10 #2; tonight's 2-game cut was Ray's): "At round open, count open game PRs awaiting the founder. At 10 or more, new-game slots drop to 1; at 20 or more, to 0. Freed slots: pre-grade, then hardening." Thresholds: Ray guesses. Bear: v0.2 went 16/16 ACCEPT (rounds.md:903); a bigger packet (escalations.md:577a) may clear faster.
- §8d: 38 merges in 5 days means near-nightly hardening. Weekly slot; non-launch PRs only; strike.
- "Launched": "publicly live" plus a date; first non-household print; stay dormant.
- Signal 2: instrument (taps + command bubbles/week) or rule not fired.