01-projects/printables-product/reviews

Cohort feedback synthesis

2026-10-10·review·status: gated-pass

What was reviewed

Baseline F1-F6; grades.md:1-48; rounds.md:683-897; queue.md:14-47, 86, 744-753; escalations.md:504; charter §2; feedback/ listing; gh.

Findings

  1. v0.2 work clears his bar; the 09-06 backlog doesn't. All 16 v0.2 new games he saw: ACCEPT. Pre-v0.2: 4 of 9; the 4 KILLs were 09-06 backlog (:733, :780), REVISE #361 dates 09-24 (gh). Change: on 10-03 critic ACCEPT vs his REVISE was 6/6 (baseline F1); the critic ACCEPTed all 16 before he did; no critic-REVISE game reached him, so reject-side agreement is untested.
  2. Every non-ACCEPT cites quality. 5/5 name art or "our standard" (:744, :787-790, :856); #361 adds "too advanced". Not mechanic: draw-an-animal KILL, Draw a Cat ACCEPT (:790, :812).
  3. Cohort input is thin. No new feedback/ files. Only V/Grammy: 64/64 Y, no comments, no kid play, graders unnamed (grades.md:14-15, 35). Follow-up ask (rounds.md:759): no logged answer.
  4. The packet cap bound throughput, not him. He cleared 5 of 5 each sitting 10-04..10-08; 20 game PRs merged (gh); 41 → 23 open also counts 13 band-pause closures on 10-07 (gh). No taps since 10-08 (:888); 12 in-band game PRs wait, 7 opened 09-24..10-01 (gh); "2+ weeks" fits only #361, #368.
  5. Tonight. #427 used the difficulty line (:896); #356 caught a live rocket glue shortfall (:895). #426 is reading for 3-4, nearest to "too advanced", no difficulty line logged (:891); #425 art is hand geometry (:890). All join an untapped queue.

Proposed queue.md changes

Within [[2026-08-31-studio-charter|charter]] §2 product + design autonomous columns.

--- a/queue.md
+++ b/queue.md
@@ -47,0 +48,2 @@
+- [design+product, S, next non-game slot, travel window] BACKLOG PRE-GRADE (10-10 cohort review): fresh v0.2 design-critic + founder difficulty line on #372 #377 #380 #381 heads (#368 #383 already packeted: no head changes); REVISE = fix on branch before its packet slot. Basis: open pre-v0.2 4/5, 09-06 backlog 0/4, v0.2 16/16.
+- [product, XS] Every new-game critic brief carries the founder difficulty line (rounds.md:856), as #427 did (:896).

Decisions needed (founder)

  1. Return catch-up. ~16-18 may wait by your return (inference; date not logged). (a) one packet of 10, oldest first; (b) 5/day oldest-first until clear; (c) as-is. Ray proposal: (b). Bear: oldest-first holds new v0.2 games ~3 days.
  2. Games while away. 3/night (queue.md:8) or 2 until you tap? Bear: R31 struck 10-07, daily packet answers it once you're back (queue.md:86).
  3. V/Grammy follow-up (rounds.md:759): keep asking or drop?