What was reviewed
- Reviews 09-11, 09-25; none on 10-02 (round skipped, rounds.md:680).
- Rulings 20, 31 ([[2026-08-31-product-model-rulings|product-model-rulings.md]]:81, :139-141).
- rounds.md Quiver lines :676-678, :694, :710, :732, :779, :807, :846; queue.md:20-24, :37, :75-77.
- eval-ledger/ledger.sqlite.
- scribble-works origin/main b52d6dc; PR #417 body (g); #371, #353, issue #396.
Findings
- Gateway cost basis unchanged. Since 09-25 only #417 (catalog reads) touched gateway files. All four entry points still call
budgetedFetch (customize.js:217, shopper.js:161, customize-art.js:118, customize-icons.js:161).
- 09-25 items stalled. #371 (R23) last updated 09-27, failing check; its blocker #353 merged 10-07. GENERATION-COSTS.md unchanged since #302. R24 has only founder-pending accepted-spec-v0; R25 has no output.
- Studio art spend (gateway not compared). Quiver 10-01 to 10-08 was about $18.47, about $2.37 per round since 10-03. Projected 30-round month: $36-$118 by round, ~$71 at mean. Reuse #396 is unbuilt, ranked second (queue.md:37).
- Ledger is short about $3.14. It holds $15.33. #387's $1.5176 (rounds.md:676) is NULL. The 10-08 round (~$1.62, :846) has no rows. 13 rows store
created_at in ms.
- Art cost per critic-accepted draft is about $0.97. 10-03 to 10-07: $12.59 over 13 critic ACCEPTs, including unaccepted Egg to Butterfly ($1.80). Max since 10-01: $2.75 (#388); the $3 cap held (queue.md:20).
- #417 cost check uses the wrong tier. #417 (g) compares a 114.9k/day 10x worst case to the "100k/day free tier". The account is on Workers Paid (escalations.md:239): 10M requests/month included, then $0.30/million (developers.cloudflare.com/workers/platform/pricing). 114.9k × 30 is about 3.4M. D1 rows read: unverified.
- Ruling 31 fit. Paid curation is deterministic (GENERATION-EXECUTION.md:12), but free is not code-only: the anonymous planner calls the gateway (shopper.js:194-198). Customize's tier is undecided (rulings:80). Studio art is fixed content cost.
Proposed queue.md changes
@@ queue.md:75
-R23. ... -> #371, awaiting merge; CI gate red until #353 merges (escalations.md:441)
+R23. ... -> #371: #353 merged 10-07; rebase, re-run CI, merge.
@@ after queue.md:102
+R44. [engineering, XS] Ledger: created_at in seconds; backfill #387 and 10-08; round close checks ledger art sum = rounds.md Quiver line.
+R45. [product, XS] R24 proxy: art cost per critic ACCEPT, reported at round close; not the accepted-spec-v0 metric.
+R46. [engineering, XS] Correct #417 (g) by comment: Workers Paid included usage; add Functions requests and D1 rows read to R25.
Decisions needed
- Monthly Quiver ceiling? Projected run rate exceeds $20/mo.
- Rank #396 art reuse above #356?
- Keep the $3/game cap, or tighten toward the ~$0.97 average?