01-projects/printables-product/reviews

Roadmap grooming

2026-10-07·review·status: gated-iterate-applied

What was reviewed

40 open PRs (20 draft).

Findings

  1. The ranked non-game list does not steer. After rank 1 (#382, 10-01 slot D, rounds.md:658), slots took #387 (:686), :26 (:705), :23 (:724), R34 (:766), #356 cornerMargin (:800); never ranks 2-7 or :16.
  2. Rank 1 is already built. #382 passed i1 10-01 (rounds.md:663); DRAFT, gate + smoke skipped. #353, #363, #367: ready, CI green, unmerged since 09-22..26.
  3. Done but not struck (queue.md:1-94): :11-12 (superseded), :19 (#388 merged), :54 R11 (superseded), :80 R30 (merged); :26 first half only (rest waits on homework). R32 never ran (rounds.md:732, :779). R33 open: .pyc still on main.
  4. 26 open game PRs. 13 in paused bands 7_8/9_10; 13 in band, 11 on #406's rebase-fail list (body:51). The packet backlog reads only origin/main (rounds.md:733, :780), so those 11 never reach the founder. 4 have V/Grammy ACCEPT sheets, grader unknown (rounds.md:759).
  5. Round size fits. Founder reviewed 5 games/day 10-05 and 10-06 (rounds.md:739-744, :785-790); rounds yield 2-3 critic passes. Keep 4 slots unless R31's trigger fires (decision 5).

Proposed queue.md changes

(a) Autonomous (product reorders, [[2026-08-31-studio-charter|charter]]:48, :468).

@@ -36,7 +36,8 @@ replace ranks 1-7 with:
+1. #356 cornerMargin + split (a) (in flight 10-07)
+2. ART LIBRARY, #396 phase 1 (:23, P1)
+3. :16 items, one slot
+4. R33 + R32
+5. R35 6. R10 (pending escalations.md:517) 7. R39 8. R40 9. vocabulary-triangle
+#382 built: review lane only.
+PACKET BACKLOG: in-band open PRs first, oldest-first (#366 #374 #376 #383); R34 split on rebase.
@@ strike :11-12 :19 :54 :80; :26 calibration half only (finding 3)

Bear: :16 drops below the art library, against charter L483 (2); re-ranking alone has not steered (finding 1).

Decisions needed (founder)

(b) Outside autonomous columns.

  1. Close the 13 paused-band PRs (4 draft, 9 ready), branches kept? Reverses charter L483 ("open, untouched"). Lean yes. Bear: reopening later costs a rebase plus the R34 split.
  2. Merge #406 now, not "after game PRs" (rounds.md:783)? 8 live blurbs leak answers (queue.md:85). Lean yes. Bear: gate fail at cap, 2 blurbs not re-gated (body:44); 25 open PRs then fail the validator.
  3. Merge #353, #363, #367 (green since September)?
  4. #405: accepted 10-06; gh pr ready classifier-denied (rounds.md:786).
  5. Withdraw 10-04 review #3 (escalations.md:504) and strike R31 (:81), answered by the daily packet? Bear: R31's trigger may fire once the 11 PRs join the backlog.