What I reviewed
Live 05:1x ET: /, /browse/, /faq/, /privacy/, /terms/, /account/, /guides/, the guide, all 59 sitemap /game/ pages (43 at escalations.md:423 + 16 in #394); /pricing, /plans, /plus 404. Source: origin/main 9e4d4bc.
Follow-through: R13/R14 live. R11/R12/R15/R16/R21 unstruck 11-21 days (live: browse.astro:164, :74; privacy.astro:325; account.astro:67, :135). All four 09-28 items dropped (queue never edited; R30-R33 reused at queue.md:77-80): guide stub (:46, published 09-12), tagline, faq.astro:79, sequencing.
Findings
- Flips shipped spec text as the public blurb. meta.yaml
descriptionfeeds meta/og/JSON-LD + page ([slug].astro:32, :97; seo.js:36). Of 16 flipped: 14 over 300 chars (older: 11 of 43); 8 print the solution ("For grown-ups, the longer one is: train bottom…", color-the-longer-one). No gate: rubric v0.2 never mentionsdescription; test-seo.mjs:44-45 checks equality only. - Second door frozen. recommended-playsets.yaml unchanged since 09-01 (35ba3f6): 4 sets, 16 of 59 games, 0 of the 16 flipped, all 3_4/5_6 (queue.md:14).
- Selling point off the front door. "screen"/"tutor": guide 26/17; home, faq, browse 0/0 (09-28 finding 2).
- Paid product invisible. "Plus" once in 8 pages (account.astro:213,
hidden); FAQ "Is it free?" = "Yes."; ruling 31: delivery is paid; pricing open (escalations.md:430).
Proposed queue.md changes
@@ -39 +39,2 @@
-4. R10
+4. R35
+5. R10
@@ -80,0 +81,6 @@
+## 2026-10-05 review (reviews/2026-10-05-marketing-copy-positioning.md)
+R34. [growth+engineering, S] Supersedes R11. Split `description` (≤160 chars, parent-facing; meta/og/card) from `parent_notes` (answers + ask line, rubric A9); all 39 over 160, 15 flipped first; test-seo.mjs caps 160.
+R35. [product, S] Ready-made refresh: one 3_4 + one 5_6 set from the 10-04 flips.
+R36. [growth, S] One PR: R12 (:164 only; limit line waits on escalations.md:267) + R15 + R16 (h1, lede) + R21.
+R37. [growth, XS] Guide: cut :46's last sentence; `published: 2026-09-23`; his #359, one HQ line first (queue.md:31).
+R38. [growth, XS] FAQ "Is it free?": one price-free sentence naming daily delivery as paid (ruling 31); ships with #332 pricing.
Decisions needed
- Front-door line (09-28 #1, never routed): (a) "AI tutor without a screen" in lede/meta/FAQ; (b) "screen-free" only; (c) guide only. Lean (a). Bear: "AI" repels wary parents; "tutor" promises a person (ruling 15).
- R10 (7-8/9-10 sets) under the 3-5 focus: keep (default) or drop? Bear, keep: an off-focus slot; drop: 16+14 tagged games, no second door.
- Open, cited: nav vs home-meta label :269/:394/:417; "three a day" :267; AI picker :270; 2-3 chip :395; faq.astro:79 :455; "Plus" :396/:433.