01-projects/printables-product/reviews

Charter / kill-criteria / hardening check 2026-10-04

2026-10-04·review·status: gated-iterate-applied

What was reviewed

[[2026-08-31-studio-charter]]; [[2026-09-27-charter-kill-criteria-hardening-check|09-27 review]]; escalations.md:443-499; rounds.md:605-713; queue.md:1-110; gh PRs, deploy-daily.yml, runs, env. HELD unopened.

Findings

  1. Reality. 43 open PRs: 23 draft, 20 ready. 0 merges since #359 (09-23). gh pr ready is classifier-denied; drafts get no CI (escalations.md:484, :459).
  2. Kill criteria cannot fire: "launched" undefined 33 days after [[2026-09-01-strategy-spec-audit]]:84-86.
  3. §8c: 1 trip/6 rounds (rounds.md:613-614). Signal 1 clear; signals 2-3 (L412-417) uninstrumented. Signal 2 matches the 10-03 review-bandwidth read (Ray's paraphrase, rounds.md:706); signal 3 seen once (queue.md:20; founder-ordered work, rounds.md:671).
  4. §8d: 181 merged since 09-02, 65 since the 09-14 hardening round (rounds.md:391; cap 10, L466); #379, #353 unmerged.
  5. Top risk: merge starts release. deploy-daily.yml:3-6 fires on green main CI; no reviewer rule; DAILY_AUTO_DEPLOY_ENABLED=true; daily.mjs:15 inputs cover 39/43 open PRs (18/20 ready). Run 35887356007 FAILED 09-23, none since; the first resumed merge of a daily-input PR releases onto a Worker unread 11 days.
  6. Throughput vs routing. 12 new games in 5 rounds (2.4/round; 14 with reworks) vs a 5-game Sunday packet (queue.md:31): backlog ≈+12/week. Calibration: 4/5 verdicts, 77% checks, n=5, art uncompared.

Proposed queue.md changes

@@ -74,0 +75,4 @@
+## 2026-10-04 review (reviews/2026-10-04-charter-kill-criteria-hardening-check.md)
+R30. [product, XS] Sunday packet (max 5): v0.2 ACCEPT drafts first, oldest-first (#386 #388 #390 #391 #392) per queue.md:17/19, then v0.1 drafts flagged hand-drawn (queue.md:20); paused bands hold.
+R31. [product, S] Round size 3 (2 games + 1 non-game; Ray-picked per L430, interim until decision 3) while ≥5 in-band ACCEPT games await a packet.
+R32. [engineering, XS] Round-close line logs deploy-daily.yml last run + conclusion beside the §8d counter.

Decisions needed

  1. Still open: 09-27 #3-#7 (7 days); gh pr ready allow-rule since 09-26 (escalations.md:437).
  2. Before the first tap: (a) authorize the read-only prepare-daily check (asked 09-28, 09-29), (b) NEW: DAILY_AUTO_DEPLOY_ENABLED=false until one green release. No release-free first merge: #352/#371 stay CI-red until #353, which edits ci.yml, a daily input. Bear on (b): reverses your 09-12 auto-release path (L481); prepare re-checks /health + pinned settings (escalations.md:464).
  3. NEW, supersedes 09-27 #1 and 10-03 #6a (R31 is the interim): games go SMALL (critic-only) once calibration clears a bar you set (Ray proposed 9/10), or new games cap at 5/week, or the packet grows. Bears: the critic passed 6/6 sheets you sent back, art uncompared (rounds.md:698); L430 wants more reps.
  4. NEW: signals 2-3 fired (L417: cron to on-demand)? If not, instrument signal 2 (taps/week).