Design reference sheet (2026-10-05)
30 real, live sites (each checked live on 2026-10-05: HTTP 200 + a rendered 1440x900 screenshot). Built after the founder said all 7 AI-generated style boards were bad. His follow-up (iMessage 16:04 ET): he does not follow any one style. What makes a site good or bad is execution, and whether the form fits what the site does. So this set covers many styles and keeps only well-made examples, leaning toward content-heavy reading sites. Sites he named himself: 1-6, 7-9 (from the Tailwind showcase), 10-12.
How to use: thumbs-up or thumbs-down by number (e.g. "up 2, 13, 22 / down 5, 29"). Picks matter more than tags. We work out the taste from what the picks have in common.
- Contact sheets:
sheet-1.pngtosheet-5.png(6 per sheet, numbered). - Full screenshots:
shots/NN-<domain>.png. When there is a-article.png, that file shows the reading/article layout. - Tiles 14, 25 and 26 use the article page, because their homepages do not show their design well (Craig Mod opens on a subscribe block, Ink & Switch on a black interactive piece, Chimero on a sparse dark index).
| # | Site | Style tag | What's distinctive | Execution - why it works (or the risk) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | commoncog.com | editorial-credible | Serif headline with an italic Serious, faint topographic line texture, testimonial cards with highlighter marks | Credibility comes from structure: Start Here, Case Library, a clear membership path. The highlighter on quotes adds personality without colour noise. Article: a calm serif title above a series table of contents. Good model for a body of work in a series. |
| 2 | stratechery.com | utilitarian-publication | Cream header band, letter-spaced wordmark, orange accents, sidebar of updates/podcasts | The post IS the homepage. No hero, no marketing. Readable column, dated posts, member CTA tucked in the header. Proves content-heavy can skip decoration if hierarchy and cadence are disciplined. |
| 3 | statamic.com | illustrated-warm | Large paper-cut style landscape illustration, sunset palette, soft serif display with an italic actually | Imagery quality carries it: a single art direction, not stock. Restrained type and two buttons on top of rich art. Blog article: big centered serif title, generous whitespace, editorial feel inside a product site. |
| 4 | jackmcdade.com | maximal-handmade | Teal field, cutout photo with neon scribble outline, handwritten annotations, palm tree, chunky display type | Loud but controlled: one bold idea per screen, handwritten notes (his own font) used as margin asides. Article pages switch to a flat color, a big display title, and a monospace body. Character survives into the reading view. |
| 5 | radicaldesigncourse.com | grunge-texture | Black textured background, condensed all-caps manifesto, words mixed between outline and solid | Type as the whole design. The texture is real (grain, stickers). Works for a manifesto. Risk for long reading: all caps does not hold up past a paragraph. |
| 6 | m3.material.io | systematized-product (Material done well) | Lilac surfaces, rounded containers, large type, a tight grid of real product mockups | Shows a design system done by its owner: consistent radii, spacing scale, tonal color. Not "turnkey Bootstrap", because every component is tuned and the imagery is specific. |
| 7 | theverge.com | editorial-brutal (Tailwind showcase) | Giant cut-off wordmark, mint/purple accents, rotated "Most Popular" set in huge type, serif body | Bold layout moves at the edges, a calm serif in the reading column. Shows how far you can push the frame while the text stays readable. Screenshot has a gray ad slot at the top (ads stripped, the slot stayed). |
| 8 | column.com | calm-precise (Tailwind showcase) | Pale dotted world map, navy type, one floating data card, quiet logo row | Restraint done right: one illustration idea (the dot map), very tight type, lots of air. Shows how a "data" brand can feel calm and expensive at once. |
| 9 | zed.dev | technical-crafted (Tailwind showcase) | Faint blueprint grid, serif blue headings with monospace body, dark code-like post art | Engineering identity in the details: grid lines, monospace metadata, featured posts above a dense list. Article (CRDTs): a table of contents in the right rail and code art used as illustration. Strong fit for a technical practitioner blog. |
| 10 | wesbos.com | loud-personal | Thick black-bordered nav boxes, yellow highlighter behind display text, faded photo background, monospace bio | Personality through one repeated device (the yellow highlight block). Busy, but always clear which bit is the headline. |
| 11 | adamwathan.me | plain-text-personal | Avatar, name, small-caps nav, a short bio with underlined links | Almost no design, by choice. Works because the writing is direct and the measure and spacing are right. Shows the floor: good defaults beat bad decoration. |
| 12 | joshwcomeau.com | playful-technical | Sky gradient with clouds, 3D mascot, colored category chips | Delight in the details (sounds, dark mode, springy interactions). Article: soft hero, sticky TOC, interactive demo widgets inside the text. Shows rather than tells. |
| 13 | maggieappleton.com | warm-scholarly | Warm off-white page, heavy serif display, small illustrated glyphs, "Garden" structure | Typography does the work (serif contrast and scale), with the illustration saved for essays. Article: big serif title, metadata about how mature the note is, a hand-drawn header image. Strong model for "show the work". |
| 14 | craigmod.com | book-typography | Classic book-like serif, drop-cap bar, tiny letter-spaced nav, huge margins | Pure reading craft: narrow measure, generous leading, hyphenation, almost no chrome. The calmest page on this sheet that still clearly has a voice. |
| 15 | gwern.net | dense-scholarly | Old-style serif, small-caps headings, boxed nav tabs, sidenotes, popups, margin toolbar | Built for depth: link previews, sidenotes, metadata on how certain a claim is. Looks dense but is highly ordered. Worth a look if long reads with citations matter. |
| 16 | simonwillison.net | builder-log | Serif title, tag chips with counts, purple nav band, daily entries with charts | The build-in-public archetype: high volume, tagged, dated, searchable. Not pretty, but structurally excellent for a practitioner log (closest content match to The Denominator). |
| 17 | jvns.ca | zine-frame | Gray backdrop, white page framed by an orange stripe, bold orange name | One frame device gives the plain list a strong identity. Article: friendly serif, step-by-step table of contents, code blocks. Approachable technical teaching. |
| 18 | ciechanow.ski | explorable-explainer | Blue header band, sans-serif body, full-width interactive 3D figures | The interactive figures are the content. The text column stays modest so the visuals lead. Gold standard for explaining a mechanism. |
| 19 | every.to | editorial-magazine | Black ground, elegant serif wordmark, commissioned engraving-meets-collage art, orange/blue | Imagery quality is the move: commissioned, consistent, half-tone/engraving feel. Magazine grid with a clear lead story. Closest match to his engraving/texture taste done at a professional level. |
| 20 | pudding.cool | playful-data | Hand-lettered logo, numbered issue cards in saturated colors, brushy headline type | Data journalism with a strong brand voice: each story card is its own visual, held together by issue numbers and the type. |
| 21 | increment.com | engineering-magazine | Rotated wordmark tag, issue tabs, flat editorial illustrations, bold serif headlines | A print-magazine way of organizing an engineering publication: issues, themes, commissioned art. Archive is still live. |
| 22 | worksinprogress.co | print-magazine-web | Monospace UI, full-bleed patterned cover art, serif titles in a navy caption block | Each essay gets a commissioned cover. Monospace UI next to serif titles gives an "ideas for policy nerds" feel. Very confident with color. |
| 23 | linear.app/now | dark-product-editorial | Near-black ground, tight grotesk sans, abstract monochrome post art | Precision: tiny type steps, strict 3-column cards, gray-scale imagery. The polish IS the brand. Risk: easy to copy badly into generic dark SaaS. |
| 24 | press.stripe.com | object-as-interface | Dark ground, 3D book spines with marbled covers you scroll through, serif italic tagline | Treats the catalog like real objects, so the craft of the books comes through. Proves "texture" can live in the imagery while the UI stays minimal. |
| 25 | inkandswitch.com | research-paper-web | Academic serif body, author block in the margin, PDF/citation details | Research-lab credibility: reads like a paper, gives the citation, no marketing. Model for "serious long-form essay with authority". |
| 26 | frankchimero.com | typewriter-minimal | Dark slate sidebar plus pale page, monospace everywhere, small type | Has personality with almost nothing: one typeface, two tones, odd proportions. The essays are the draw. |
| 27 | robinsloan.com | warm-literary | Orange nav band, blackletter-ish display type, warm off-white, clean signup | One loud display face does all the character work. Everything else is quiet and readable. |
| 28 | wizardzines.com | hand-drawn-zine | Orange wavy header, stick-figure speech bubble, chunky shadowed buttons | Fully committed to hand-drawn. Works because the product IS hand-drawn zines (form fits content). Gumroad-like button energy. |
| 29 | posthog.com | desktop-OS-playful | Fake desktop with icons and windows, illustrated landscape, orange 3D buttons | Huge amounts of personality and content (handbook, blog) inside a gimmick that holds up. The buttons are close relatives of the Gumroad button he liked. |
| 30 | tomcritchlow.com | calm-sidebar-blog | Left icon sidebar, sans body, green link color, dated writing list | A competent, quiet personal blog for a strategy writer/consultant. A baseline to compare the others against: it helps show whether "calm" without a twist reads as enough. |
Not included (and why)
- Substack-hosted publications (experimental-history.com, henrikkarlsson.xyz): rendered behind the Substack subscribe modal, and they share a template, so their design is not their own.
- Portfolio-minimal sites (rauno.me, paco.me, emilkowal.ski, lynnandtonic.com): well made, but they are portfolios, not content-heavy reading sites. Can add a round of these if picks lean that way.
- robinrendle.com: the current homepage is a photo-finder UI and does not show his writing design.
Founder votes (iMessage 2026-10-05 16:26 ET)
- NO: 15 gwern.net, 16 simonwillison.net, 18 ciechanow.ski, 25 inkandswitch.com, 26 frankchimero.com, 27 robinsloan.com
- Not his taste: 22 worksinprogress.co, 28 wizardzines.com
- UP: 20 pudding.cool ("may be my favorite... Well done all around"); 19 every.to ("the most modern editorial feel... good for multi-author, but I'm just building a personal site"); 30 tomcritchlow.com (voice + content yes, "website style is so so")
- Added by him: waitbutwhy.com ("Good example of low effort that is well done")
- No vote yet: 1-14, 17, 21, 23, 24, 29
- Round 2 (16:38 ET): 11-14 meh (adamwathan, joshwcomeau, maggieappleton, craigmod). 24 press.stripe.com "excellent in its use of color, clear typography, and 3D imagery. Reads as trying very hard. Not the right fit for us but well done." 29 posthog.com playful/nostalgic, "not what I want in a site." 23 linear.app/now "well done dark SaaS... consistent design language. Good balance of imagery and text"; better example = hex.tech (marketing + blog) "where I pulled in my blueprint inspiration." 21 increment.com LOVE: "Great design. Good colors. The boxiness doesn't feel sharp here." (footer word cloud too crowded). Still unvoted: 1-10, 17.
- Round 3 (16:41 ET): 17 jvns.ca "okay for a personal site. Feels like it is from an earlier time, but well done." 1-5 YES (commoncog, stratechery, statamic, jackmcdade, radicaldesigncourse; "I brought those to you"). 7 theverge.com "okay... editorial style just isn't for me. It feels heavy and too busy" (consistent language though). Added: Fast Forward Labs (pre-Cloudera): "Their design and white paper booklets were so nice." Unvoted: 6, 8, 9, 10.