In-site mockups: A, E, H
These are mockups only. Nothing was written to the CMS, the repo, D1/R2, or any deploy. The art is swapped in the browser right before each screenshot.
Files
A/,E/,H/:home-1440-full.png,home-390-screens1-2.png(the first two phone screens),post-1440-full.png(post 1),post-390-top.png,post-390-diagram.png(Figure 1 in context),writing-1440-full.png.compare-home-1440.png,compare-post-1440.png,compare-home-390.png: A | E | H side by side, labeled.art/: new images for this round (see "What I made"). The originalimages/folder is unchanged.
Method
- Auth: I did not sign in to Access. In round 3, deployed pages were captured with an Access email code sent to ben@ (the founder's email), and this brief rules that out. Round 3 also used a local render, and I reused that instead: the round-3 working copy (
design/pack-v1@2f2144b, the head of PR #2) was copied into the session scratchpad and run withDENOMINATOR_TARGET=pack-v1 astro devon localhost:4410. - Content: the local miniflare D1 reuses the earlier read-only export of
ec_posts/ec_pagesfrom the pack-v1 rounds (3 posts, all published). There was no new remote read. The page chrome matchesfinal/round-3/home-1440-full.pngpixel for pixel in layout. - Swap: Playwright (
scratchpad/cap/cap.cjs) loads each page.page.evaluateputs an<img>(object-fit: contain, with the slot background set to the image's field colour so nothing is cropped) into each post's.artslot: the lead card, the story cards, the /writing thumbnails and the post feature image. It also puts one into the home hero and the series card. On post 1 it replaces Figure 1's code SVG (.fig-parts) with the diagram and rewrites the caption to match. Figure 1 already sits right after "...walk into the same meeting with two numbers." Images are served throughpage.route, so no file was added to the site. - Checks on every load (15 loads): 0 console errors, 0 4xx responses, 0 broken images, no horizontal scroll (1440/1440, 390/390). The only slot left unswapped is the /writing "Style test" row (the kitchen sink is not a post, so its specimen pictogram is correct). I opened and read every PNG.
What I made ($0; no paid calls, only code and the existing Quiver objects)
A5-post3-header(the SnowPro post, A style): one die-cut sticker object, a study card printed with a 10x10 grid (29 cobalt squares), a "29%" tag sticker and a "governance" hand label, on a peach field.E5-post3-header(E style): 100 paper squares with 29 in cobalt, a bracket, a "29%" tag and the mono label "1 square = 1% of the study guide".- Not in the brief, added so no placeholder pictograms were left on the home:
A6/E6-home-hero("the common factor": three objects over a fraction bar; the A version puts the definitions-box sticker under the bar, the E version a cobalt paper square) andA7/E7-series-fifth-job(four agents next to one big "the business" block). H uses the A versions, because headers sit in the conceptual tier. H2-post1-diagram= E2 unchanged plus one tweak: the same Quiver agent, used once as a small sticker label ("one agent, asked twice"), at the bottom right. Colour meanings already matched the A headers (cobalt = the thing in question, i.e. the 2.7-point gap; mono numerals; same grain). No other change.- Script:
tools/build_insite.py(it writes only toin-site/art/). Sheets:tools/compare_insite.py.
What the mockups show (Ray's read)
- H reads best in situ. The sticker headers give the home its personality (lead, cards and thumbnails all read as one family), and the E chart is the clearest Figure 1 at 1440: the reader sees the 2.7-point gap without having to read it.
- E is the most honest data, but the home gets visually repetitive (bars, blocks and grids in every slot), and the black post-2 card is heavy next to the pastel fields.
- A is the most charming, but its Figure 1 is a second illustration rather than a chart. It does not show the size of the gap.
- Phone caveat (applies to E and H): at 390 the 1200px chart shrinks to about 300px wide, and its axis labels and footnote become tiny. A's diagram holds up better on phones because its type is bigger. If H wins, the chart needs a phone crop or larger label sizes.
- Small leftovers outside the art: the post's "Cover." caption still describes the old pictogram ("two bars of different heights"), and the feature slot is wider than 16:9 (contain-fit adds side bands in the field colour at 1440).