Category Newsletter Creator course map
What it is: a Skool community created 2024-11-01, with 1,746 members. It teaches how to position, write, automate and monetize a niche newsletter. The examples and copy are from 2024. All automation templates assume ConvertKit (now called Kit).
Structure (courses → sections, lesson counts)
| Course | Sections (lessons) |
|---|---|
| Onboarding Checklist (1) | intro post, Sacred Hours, public commitment |
| 1/ Positioning Playbook (32) | free vs paid 3 · platform 5 · niche + competitive analysis 8 · naming 6 · description/About 6 · visual brand 4 |
| 2/ Publishing Blueprint (35) | idea generator 4 · 90-day calendar 4 · writing templates 6 · pinned post 3 · subject lines 7 · analytics 4 · repurposing 3 · bonus "mirror" newsletters 2 · watch-me-write 2 |
| 3/ Automation System (110) | welcome 14 · 10-day pre-launch 16 · 10-day launch 23 · abandoned cart 16 · post-purchase 16 · book-a-call 15 · 20-email "Million Dollar" 4 · opt-out 4 · index 1 |
| 4/ Marketing Secrets (36) | autoplug CTA 7 · viral drop 5 · PS templates 3 · paywall cliffhanger 2 · Substack Notes 2 · blog posts 3 · Substack SEO 4 · guest posts 10 |
| 5/ Monetization Mastery (23) | affiliate 6 · sponsorship 4 · subscription 4 · digital product 5 · services/coaching 4 |
| Bonus: 0 To $1 (21) | first digital product, Gumroad |
| Bonus: 1-Person Publishing Empire (22) | newsletters republished as Amazon KDP books |
| Bonus: Ghostwriting Crash Course (1) | selling ghostwriting services |
| 🔒 Product Promotion Blueprint | locked (their Black Friday launch assets) |
| 🔒 The Vortex: Content Strategy 2025 | locked (organic strategy + retargeting) |
Rules and formats worth knowing
Positioning
- Start free. A paid newsletter is "10x harder"; their bar for going paid is 10k+ followers, 1+ year of writing and a $100k+ product.
- Niche = information advantage × genuine interest. "Your FIRST niche, not your forever niche."
- 1-liner = topic + niche-down + 1 problem + 1 outcome: "I write about how to {X}, {Y}, and {Z}."
- Make claims tangible and objective (true or false, not open to interpretation).
- Name rules: clear not clever, 7 words or fewer, a promise, a specific audience, no colons.
- About page in 5 parts: welcome + 1-liner / who it's for / who I am / best issues / my promise.
Publishing
Cadence trades off with length: fast-moving topics get short, frequent issues; slow-moving topics get long, less frequent ones.
Never skip a week, even if the issue is only 300 words. Batch 1-2 sessions a week, or one 3-4 hour session every 2 weeks.
90-day calendar: 12 weekly long issues, each with 7 social posts cut from it.
Issue anatomy, mix and match: opener / curated list ("{Resource + Link} (Reading Time) Description") / sponsor / deep dive / conclusion / Good-OK-Bad poll / P.S.
Deep-dive headline formula: "{Number} {Things} To {Outcome} With {Benefit} Even if {Obstacle}". The AI writer prompt targets 700-900 words.
Pinned post evolves: first issue → best issue → best issues by topic (30+ issues) → multimedia.
Subject lines:
- 5-15 words, like talking to a friend.
- One of 4 hooks: lots of value for little time, lots of value for little cost, no effort, an instant outcome.
- "Name & claim" a named thing.
- A/B test ideas, not wordings.
Benchmarks:
Metric Great Good OK Broken Opt-in rate over 50% 20-50% 10-20% under 10% Open rate over 50% 30-50% under 20% Unsubscribes: about 1 per 10+ new subscribers is great. Retention floor: 80% at 30 days, 50% at 6 months, 30% at 1 year.
No send day or time is prescribed anywhere.
Automation (Kit only)
- Welcome sequence, 4 emails sent immediately and then daily: what to expect → greatest hits → biggest mistake → origin story, which pitches the product. Later it is upgraded into a 5-day educational email course, which becomes the only thing promoted on social.
- Also covered: 10-day pre-launch, 10-day launch (a P.S. in every email raised click-through 30-40%), abandoned cart (5), post-purchase (6), book-a-call (5, high-ticket) and a 20-email launch sequence.
Marketing
- Autoplug a newsletter CTA on ~25% of posts. The CTA must match the topic. 5 CTA templates.
- 11 P.S. templates.
- Paywall cliffhanger: send paid issues to the free list too, paywalled 25-30% of the way in.
- Substack Notes.
- Republish to your own blog and to Medium with a canonical tag. Substack SEO: Google is ~1% of traffic but converts 4x better.
- Guest-post swaps.
Monetization
- Affiliate: 4-50% commissions.
- Sponsorship: CPM = price ÷ (subscribers × open rate) × 1000. They buy sponsorships but never sell them in their own newsletters.
- Subscription: $10-20/mo.
- Digital product: up to $350 is an impulse buy; $1-2k is a dead zone.
- Services/coaching: a "Power-Hour" at $250-500 or more.
- Monetization (course 5), the services/coaching section, the ghostwriting bonus, the book-a-call sequence and much of course 3's launch machinery assume selling.
Tools named:
- Email: Kit (their free newsletters), Substack (their paid ones), Beehiiv.
- Sales and automation: ThriveCart, Zapier.
- Social: Hypefury, Taplio.
- Pages and analytics: Carrd, Fathom.
- Writing: Typeshare.
- Books: Reedsy, Publisher Rocket, KDP.
Operationalize for The Denominator
Ray-selected, awaiting his read. Context:
- The Denominator (thedenominator.dev) is Ben's personal-brand site and list, per [[2026-10-02-site-spec]]. The list runs on Resend, per the 2026-09-28 decision.
- The goal is buyer credibility that turns into phData pipeline, not newsletter revenue.
- The phData rule: personal brand only; no selling services, no clients.
| # | What Ray runs | Effort | phData-rule check |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Positioning sheet for The Denominator. Fill the course's 8-step checklist (info advantage → niche-down → problem/outcome → 1-liner → tangible rewrite → objective test). Output: one "I write about how to {X}, {Y}, and {Z}" line plus a 5-part About page draft for the site. Ben edits. | S | Clean. Must not imply he takes clients ("who I am" names phData as employer, no "work with me"). |
| 2 | Issue template + 90-day calendar. A fixed issue skeleton (opener / deep dive / "what broke" / poll / P.S.), plus 12 issue slots, each mapped to 2 LinkedIn cuts. Ship 30's best pieces feed the slots. Stored as a markdown template in the vault. | S | Clean. The P.S. points to the next issue or the site, never to an offer. |
| 3 | Subject-line + benchmark checklist. A pre-send checklist (5-15 words, one of the 4 hooks, a named thing). A monthly Resend metrics pull scored against the course benchmarks (opt-in, open rate, unsubscribe ratio, 30-day retention), filed to the vault. | M (the Resend analytics pull needs a small script) | Clean. |
| 4 | Welcome sequence, 4 emails adapted: what to expect → greatest hits → biggest mistake → origin story. The last email's "pitch" is replaced with "reply and tell me what you're building". Built as a Resend automation or scheduled sends. Ben writes the copy; Ray wires it. | M | Conflict risk if copied as-is: email 4 pitches a product. Swap the pitch for a conversation ask. |
| 5 | Republish flywheel. Each issue goes to the site (canonical) → LinkedIn long post → 1 short post. Track which topics pull replies from buying titles (the [[2026-10-02-welsh-linkedin-os-applied]] tally). | M | Clean. Skip the Medium/Substack paywall mechanics. |
Skip for now:
- Monetization course 5, sponsorship, paid subscription and the ghostwriting bonus: these sell services or monetize the list, which is the phData conflict and off-goal.
- The launch and abandoned-cart sequences: there is no product.
- Viral Drop: engagement bait.
- KDP books: revisit only if the founder wants a book.
- The locked courses: not needed.
Related
- [[01-projects/personal-brand/2026-10-05-low-ticket-launchpad-course-map]]
- [[01-projects/personal-brand/2026-10-05-linkedin-ai-classroom-map]]
- [[01-projects/personal-brand/2026-10-02-site-spec]]