Housing feasibility check (2026-11-14)
CORRECTION (2026-11-14 ~13:50 ET, Ray). The property-tax line below is wrong, and it moves the bottom line. This note used 1.1% of (lot + project). The vault's own [[2026-08-20-save-our-homes-teardown-rebuild-reassessment]] shows that 1.1% is only part of the bill: the full City of Tampa rate is 19.84 mills (~1.98%) after the homestead exemptions (
$51K). Recomputed: tax is **$3.0-3.3K/month** if HCPA values the new house at cost ($1.9-2.0M), or **$2.6K/month** if it values it near market comps (~$1.6M). The note assumed ~$1.9K/month.
- $1.0M project / 2,500 sf / $400K down: ~$9.9-10.9K/month, not $9.2-9.5K. That breaks the ~$9.75K lender cap unless HCPA values it near $1.6M.
- Corrected target: a
$850-900K project (≈ 2,000-2,200 sf on the same cost model), $400K down, **$9.1-10.0K/month** at 7.0-7.4%. Or keep ~$1.0M and put $450K down: ~$9.6-10.5K/month.- 3,200 sf (~$1.18M): ~$10.8-12.1K/month, so even the ~$275K-comp bull case (cap ~$11.1K) only clears it at the favorable end.
- Upside lever not counted: the same 08-20 brief says a documented 2024 flood claim could qualify the rebuild for the "calamity" assessment carry-over (FS 193.155(4)(b)). That is worth up to ~$2K/month of tax and needs a written determination request to HCPA for folio 120668-0000. This is now the single biggest swing in the plan after the builder bid.
- Insurance is also unsettled: this note uses $7K/yr (09-30 basis); [[2026-07-22-florida-ae-zone-insurance-repricing-tampa]] says $11-13K/yr, about +$330-500/month more. A new elevated build should price lower than the existing house, but this is unverified.
- The runway rows below shorten by about a month each (burn ~$1K/month higher).
Founder ask (iMessage 12:33 ET): his parents closed on their townhome, so the family can live there rent-free during the build but wants to leave as soon as possible. He asked for (1) what we can afford: a down payment, a monthly payment and a square-footage target; (2) the rainy-day plan: how long savings and investments last if it turns out to be too much; (3) the bull case, and how to make his career take off.
Assumed path: build on the current lot at 1212 S Suffolk (founder, 08-27; two stories, 10-18) and live at the townhome during the build. Speed matters, so this assumes a semi-custom builder working from a stock plan, with no architect design phase.
Bottom line (Ray's numbers, estimates)
| Target | Stretch ceiling | |
|---|---|---|
| Down payment | ~$400K: ~$50K cash + ~$350K sold from the taxable brokerage | $450K |
| Build project (all-in, land excluded) | ~$1.0M (bottom of the 10-17 semi-custom range) | ~$1.1M |
| Square feet (heated, two-story) | ~2,500 | ~2,900 |
| New loan (project + $414K payoff − down) | ~$1.01M | ~$1.06M |
| Monthly all-in (P&I + tax + insurance) | ~$9.2-9.5K at 7.0-7.4% | ~$9.6K, and only at a rate of ≤7.0% (at 7.4% it is $9.9K, which breaks the lender cap) |
| vs today ($4,527) | +$4.7-4.9K | +$5.1K |
- The lender cap binds first. Lenders allow ~36% of $325K household gross for housing, about $9.75K/month all-in. The 3,200 sf from his 09-23 pick does not fit today. That house is a ~$1.18M project; even with $450K down it comes to ~$10.2-10.5K/month.
- The practice gap is real. Monarch for May-Oct 2026 shows core spend of ~$14.5K/month. That excludes the one-off $12.75K tree removal and $7.5K of Florida Prepaid, which is savings. Income averaged ~$17.7K/month.
- Counting Michelle's ~$1.8K/month of transfers: surplus
+$3.2K, so a payment of **$7.7K** is practicable today. - Excluding those transfers (the 08-30 ruling keeps her income out of the practice test): surplus
+$1.4K, practicable payment **$5.9K**. - The gap to $9.4K is therefore ~$1.7-3.5K/month. New money not already in that average: the 12.5% bonus (
$1.4K/month net, annualized), the dormant-RDCO subscription cut ($1.3-1.5K/month if not already done) and the cert raise. Together that is roughly enough. It is not proven: the 6-month "practice the payment" clock is still the test. (Third-paycheck months are already inside the May-Oct average, so they are not counted again here.)
- Counting Michelle's ~$1.8K/month of transfers: surplus
- The build carry is the townhome's real gift. The construction-to-perm loan pays off today's ~$414K mortgage at the start. Interest-only carry then rises with the draws, reaching ~$6.2K/month at full draw ($1.01M at 7.4%), plus lot tax and builder's-risk insurance. It stays at or below today's $4.5K for about the first third to half of the draws (estimate). No rent is what makes that tolerable.
Rainy-day plan
Liquid today (Monarch, 11-14): ~$260K cash (mostly Wealthfront joint cash) + $551K taxable investments = **$811K**. Excluded: ~$183K of retirement money (penalties) and the Mercury RDCO tax/opex balances.
After the down payment: ~$400K down plus a $60K overrun buffer leaves **$351K: a $150K cash ring-fence + ~$201K still invested.** Selling ~$350K of brokerage to fund the down payment will trigger capital-gains tax. Pull the cost basis before deciding the split, because the tax could be tens of thousands.
If his income stops after move-in (burn ~$19.5K/month: ~$10K non-housing + ~$9.5K house):
| Scenario | Months the $351K lasts |
|---|---|
| Normal spending; Michelle keeps covering her side and her ~$1.8K/month transfers | ~20 |
| Cut mode (travel, restaurants, subscriptions, 529 paused: about −$3K/month) | ~24 |
| Row 1, plus a 25% market drop on the invested $201K | ~17 |
| No income from anyone | ~18 (~15 with the market drop) |
If it happens during the build, the runway is longer: rent-free, and the carry is interest-only on what has been drawn.
Rules (Ray's proposal):
- Ring-fence $150K of cash (~8 months of post-move burn). It is never part of the down payment. Check it before signing.
- Fixed-price contract on a stock plan. The model carries a 10% contingency on hard cost only; the ~$300K of fixed costs (stem wall, demo, permits, site work) have none. The $60K buffer covers that and is separate from the ring-fence.
- Triggers if his income stops:
- Day 1 → cut mode.
- Month 3 with no offer → pause the 529 and the Trump account; spend the cash ring-fence first.
- Month 8 or so (ring-fence spent) → start drawing the invested money.
- Month 12 → decide: rent it out, sell, or keep drawing.
- Appraisal risk. Lot (~$1.03M Zestimate) + a ~$1.0M build ≈ $2.0M of cost. New AE-zone builds of 3,000-3,800 sf in 33629 sold for $1.14-1.75M with land (10-17 comps). A forced sale would probably not get the full cost back. Size down, not up.
Bull case
- Today's comp:
$205K base + 12.5% target bonus ≈ **$231K total**, plus cert escalators. - Each +$10K of gross ≈ +$540/month net (~35% marginal). After the added property tax on a bigger project, that buys ~$72K more loan, or ~250 sf.
- ~$275K total comp (+~$44K gross ≈ +$2.4K/month net). Two tests:
- Lender cap rises to ~$11.1K (36% of ~$370K household gross).
- Practicable payment becomes ~$10-12K once the levers above land.
- 3,200 sf (~$1.18M project, $450K down, ~$10.2-10.5K/month) passes both tests, with the ring-fence untouched.
- Rates: each −0.5% ≈ −$340/month on a ~$1.0M loan. Jumbo is ~7.4% today (Mortgage News Daily 7.37% on 11-09; Bankrate 7.36% on 11-04).
Career: what makes it take off (Ray's read of the 11-13 Elizabeth meeting)
What phData said it values (from the Zoom summary): Anthropic as the main driver of new logos; moving from activations to co-development and FDE engagements; content rationalization as a current priority; use-case POCs that turn into paid work.
- Own the content fix. Join Paolo's working session with a pilot: one use-case-led module (Tucows hands-on format) run at the next enablement. If it works, he is in line for the content seat he asked for.
- Turn rooms into revenue. Offer the RC office-hours email-triage plan as the pro bono POC Elizabeth floated. If it converts to a paid build, that is pipeline with his name on it, and pipeline is what moves comp.
- Certs as leverage. Claude Architect Pro and AWS AIP-C01 each pay $500 plus deal placement. Placement is where the FDE and co-development work goes.
- Ask with a number at the year-end review. Tie a title and comp step (toward ~$275K) to measured practice growth: pipeline sourced, enablements converted, facilitators certified. Not to effort.
- Public credibility. The Claude tips series (Ship 30) builds the inbound that makes 1-4 easier to argue.
Assumptions and what isn't verified
- Build cost model: ~$300K fixed (stem wall, demo, permits, site, plan adaptation) + ~$275/sf (hard cost ~$250 × 1.10). This is the low end of the semi-custom row in [[2026-10-17-build-cost-by-delivery-path]], not a builder quote. A real bid on this lot is still the #1 missing input.
- Lot basis: now the ~$1.03M Zestimate. The 09-30 note used $900K, so the tax line here is ~$120/month higher.
- Tax and insurance: tax is 1.1% of (lot + project); insurance is $7K/yr (homeowners + AE flood). Both follow the 09-30 basis. Hillsborough's reassessment of a new build could run higher.
- Lender cap: assumes $325K household gross, since lenders count Michelle's pay. The practice test is shown both with and without her transfers.
- Monarch income average: includes his paychecks, Michelle's transfers, interest and a little business income. October showed −$4.4K because only one paycheck landed in the month.
- Rates: 30-yr jumbo ~7.37% (Mortgage News Daily, 2026-11-09). Construction-to-perm usually prices at or above jumbo.