Model note: run on Fable 5.2. The eight research files (t1-t5, s1-s3) and the cold audit were produced by Fable 5.2 on 2026-11-15; this part file, the site changes and the verification were done in a separate integration pass. No new web research was done during integration.
Contradiction-checked against the tree doc ([[2026-07-20-wilson-tree-v0]], rounds 1-12) and round 12 [[2026-10-24-frontier-round12-partU|partU]]/[[2026-10-24-frontier-round12-partV|partV]]. Mechanical downgrade rule applied: a CONFIRMED resting on one Find A Grave memorial, one index transcription or one compiled book is carried here as PROBABLE unless two independent sources agree. No living people are named; the 1965 newspaper profile's living names stay elided as in s3.
Headlines
- Sarah Olney (ahn 183) is a Providence Olney after all: pedigree collapse. The 1889 Olney genealogy lists Stephen⁶ (Nathan⁵), b. 31 Jan 1758, with a daughter Sarah⁷ b. 23 Oct 1787 and three Burt sons-in-law. Sylvester (1878) has John Burt marrying "Sarah Olney, daughter of Stephen Olney, of Saratoga" on 31 Dec 1807. Nathan⁵ is already ahn 352, so Ben descends from Nathan and Elizabeth Goodspead twice; William Russell Olney (44) and Sarah Mary Salisbury (45) were second cousins. One wrinkle is logged: the book marries the sister Dorcas to John Burt.
- Sophia Melick (ahn 81) placed, and her line runs to the Rhine. Mellick's The Story of an Old Farm (1889) p.697 names her with an exact birth date and carries her line down to Jeremiah Lambert, Garetta V. D. Vliet and John James Lambert "m. ... Josie Oakford". Parents Christian Melick + Anna Pickel; grandfather the immigrant David Melick of Bendorf (b. 1715); Moelichs of Bendorf and Winningen behind him; Pickels of Hamburg and White House on the mother's side. Garetta's father is named for the first time: Simon Vliet of Bedminster.
- Catharine Munson (ahn 95) placed; the Munson Record runs six generations to Capt. Thomas Munson of New Haven. Vol. I p.262 names "Catharine H." as a daughter of Peter Hall Munson, musician of New York, married to "Jacob Sharp ... of Broadway street-railway renown". The whole branch is drawn PROBABLE because it sits behind the PROBABLE Mary A. Sharp (47) step. M9 (married at about 13) is narrowed, not resolved.
- Jacob Sharp (ahn 94) anchored outside Find A Grave. His 1888 will names "Adele Olney" as a granddaughter, and she wired her husband "Come at once. Grandpa dead." Jacob is CONFIRMED as Adella's grandfather; which daughter was her mother stays PROBABLE.
- Salisbury: Sarah Salisbury Olney's own DAR application (Lineage Book vol. 16, No. 15157) names her parents (CONFIRMED), her grandmother Mary Powell and her great-grandfather "Thomas Salisbury, of Rhode Island" (both PROBABLE).
- LeQuire REVERSAL. John LeQuire's 1832 declaration says "I am a Frenchman by birth". The tree's round-1 claim that his testimony gave an NC birth and killed the France lore is backwards; it came from WikiTree's summary of the payment ledger.
- Kent: two honest negatives and corrected service dates. No Kent births in the Douglas Register; no second Kent-Taylor bond in Caswell. Alexander Kent enlisted 27 Jan 1777 and was discharged 31 Jan 1780 (contemporary papers), was at Valley Forge "On Command" in Jan 1778, and two of his children married by Caswell bond in 1807-08.
- Gibby: the logging-accident death is CONFIRMED (1965 profile + 2026 feature), with "a former Clay County Commissioner" and a c.1930 arrival from Swain County at PROBABLE.
VIZ-CHANGES (applied)
- ADD_PERSON 366 Stephen Olney (1758-1833) and 367 Sarah Irish (1762-1808, single FaG). Stephen carries
collapse:[352,353]: the tree draws a "↺ parents = ahn 352 + 353" link stub instead of a frontier "?", and his person page resolves Father/Mother to Nathan and Elizabeth; 352/353 list him as a child. No duplicate people at 732/733. Identity CONFIRMED (book); edge to 183 PROBABLE. - UPDATE_DATE 183 Sarah Olney: eb ~1786 / ed ~1848 retired; b. 1787, d. 1856. Do-not-conflate flag lifted; Sarah-vs-Dorcas note added. PROBABLE.
- UPDATE_STORY 182 John Burt: b. 14 Jun 1775 Chatham, d. 30 Mar 1871 (Sylvester); "two vs five children" narrowed (Sylvester's two secure). Edge to 91 stays PROBABLE.
- UPDATE_STORY 352/353: pedigree-collapse note.
- ADD_PERSON Melick/Pickel/Moelich, all PROBABLE: 162 Christian Melick (1744-1788) · 163 Anna Pickel (1749-1823) · 324 Johan David Moelich (b. 1715, ed ~1764 "d. about 1764") · 326 Balthazar Pickel 2d (eb ~1722 E2, ed ~1784 E3) · 648 Hans Peter Moelich (b. 1683, ed ~1745 E3) · 652 Balthazar Pickel (1687-1765) · 653 Charity (undated) · 1296 Jonas Moelich (1650-1722) · 82 Simon Vliet (name only, undated).
- UPDATE_STORY 81 Sophia Melick (b. 17 Oct 1774, m. 8 Mar 1807, d. June 1849), 80 William Lambert (b. 1 Mar 1782, d. 31 Aug 1854), 40 Jeremiah Lambert (second source), 41 Garetta (father named).
- ADD_PERSON Munson, all drawn PROBABLE (dashed) because of the ahn 47 step: 190 Peter Hall Munson (eb ~1786 bound, ed ~1848) · 191 Charlotte Wilkinson (eb ~1801, ed ~1863) · 380 Peter Munson (1735-1830) · 381 Elizabeth Hall (eb ~1741, d. 1822) · 760 William Munson (1695-1773) · 761 Rebecca Curtis (eb ~1712, ed ~1774) · 1520 Samuel Munson (1669-1741) · 1521 Martha (eb ~1672, d. 1707) · 3040 Samuel Munson (1643-1693) · 3041 Martha Bradley (eb ~1644, ed ~1706) · 6080 Capt. Thomas Munson (c.1612-1685) · 6081 Joanna (c.1610-1678).
- UPDATE_STORY/CONF 95 Catharine Munson (c.1824/25; father named; M9 reworded; d. Rome NY), 94 Jacob Sharp (story + "Confirmed grandfather of Adella · daughter step probable"; stays dashed), 47 Mary A. Sharp (daughter of Jacob CONFIRMED by the will; mother of Adella PROBABLE), 23 Adella (will + telegram).
- UPDATE_CONF 45 (parents CONFIRMED by her own DAR application), 90 + 91 (→ Confirmed, solid), 180 Preserved (negatives + new parents). ADD_PERSON 181 Mary Powell (1773-1858; DAR name + FaG dates; moved from doc-only) and 360 Thomas Salisbury (eb ~1748, ed ~1810; PROBABLE; service POSSIBLE). 178 Richard Burt: negatives added.
- UPDATE_STORY 132 Alexander Kent (service dates, Valley Forge, bounty assignment, Caswell marriages, 1840 census → POSSIBLE), 66 (marriage search negative; Gilmer 1853 vs Halifax 1861 question), 67 (Caswell negative; Dorman Taylor POSSIBLE kin only), 265 (Douglas Register negative). New hints for mary-kent and catherine-dudley-taylor.
- REVERSE LeQuire: 200 (story from S7130, correction note, conf "pension S7130"), 100, 50, 25 and GROUPS. Bios for john-lequire, joseph-a-lequire-sr, sarah-lequire-gibby rewritten. Source link added for S7130.
- UPDATE_STORY 12 John Martin Gibby (s3 text) in ANC and GROUPS; bio rewritten.
NEW-PEOPLE
25 drawn: 366, 367 · 82 · 162, 163, 324, 326, 648, 652, 653, 1296 · 190, 191, 380, 381, 760, 761, 1520, 1521, 3040, 3041, 6080, 6081 · 181, 360.
Not drawn (doc-only): 325 Elizabeth (David Melick's wife, "probably named Elizabeth": POSSIBLE) · Friedrich (1611-1695) + Lucia Rormer, Michel + Margaretta Knaus, Theiss, Peter of Winningen (POSSIBLE: one compiled source, OCR digits unchecked) · 83 Garetta's mother (unknown; Van Dyke hypothesis) · Simon Vliet = Susan Melick's husband (POSSIBLE) · 6082/6083 William Bradley + Alice Pritchard and 1522 Thomas Curtis (named in the Munson Record, not drawn this round; listed in hints) · 1774/1790 RI census Thomas Salisburys (POSSIBLE) · 364 Richard Burt as John Burt's father (a second pedigree collapse; noted in John Burt's hint, not wired).
ESTIMATES-RETIRED
- 183 Sarah Olney: eb ~1786 and ed ~1848 → b. 1787 (1889 book; age 69 at death) / d. 1856 (Sylvester). Two halves.
- 22605 Joanna (Peson) Hull: ed ~1629 → d. 1629 (a sourced Coddington date that had been stored as an estimate; audit M4).
- Corrected (rule fixes, not retirements): 264 Robert Kent Sr eb ~1712 → ~1728 (E2: 1755 − 27); 2828 John Woodin ed ~1718 → ~1691 (E3 floored at Wells ME c.1688 + 3).
Target 1: Sarah Olney (ahn 183) and Stephen Olney "of Saratoga"
Headline. YES, with one named wrinkle. Stephen⁶ is Nathan⁵'s son in the 1889 book, twice; his daughter married John Burt.
Verbatim.
- "Nathan5 (William4, William3, Thomas2, Thomas1). Born 1720, Nov. 20; married Elizabeth Goodspead, and with his family moved to Saratoga, N. Y., about 1765-70. He died 1788. His children, as follows: Peter6, b. 1754. Jesse6, b. William6, b. June 20, 1756. Stephen6, b. Jan. 31, 1758. Enos..." (J. H. Olney, Genealogy of the Descendants of Thomas Olney, 1889, No. 51, p.28; archive.org
genealogyofdesce1889olne) - "Stephen6 (Nathan5 ...). Born Jan. 31, 1758; married first, Sarah Irish; married second, Mary Demond in 1807; died 1833. He removed to New York with his father when quite young. His children, as follows: FIRST WIFE. Thomas7, b. Oct. 25, 1784. Stephen7, b. April 26, 1786; d. Aug. 2, 1807. Sarah7, b. Oct. 23, 1787. Dorcas7, b. Sept. 9, 1789; m. John Burt. Asenath7, b. July 21, 1791. Lydia7, b. July 27, 1793; m. Justus Burt ..." (same, No. 113, p.48)
- "No. 240. Sarah7 (Stephen6, Nathan5 ...). Born ; married Richard Burt. Her home in New York State. Her children ... I. John8. II. Richard8. III. Justus8." (same, No. 240, p.85)
- "The 31st of December, 1807, John married Sarah Olney, daughter of Stephen Olney, of Saratoga. They commenced life for themselves in a log cabin ... His mother died Dec. 9, 1856. His father ... March 30, 1871, at the age of ninety-five." (Sylvester, History of Saratoga County, 1878, ch. 41, sketch of Stephen O. Burt, printed p.413)
Facts.
- Stephen⁶ b. 31 Jan 1758, son of Nathan⁵; m. 1st Sarah Irish, 2nd Mary Demond 1807; d. 1833 (book) — CONFIRMED as the book's statement.
- John Burt m. Sarah Olney, daughter of Stephen Olney of Saratoga, 31 Dec 1807; she d. 9 Dec 1856 — CONFIRMED (Sylvester; informant her son).
- Sarah Olney Burt b. 23 Oct 1787, d. 9 Dec 1856, "lived 69 years", Bacon Hill (FaG 37190293) — PROBABLE.
- Stephen Olney b. 31 Jan 1758 Providence, d. 20 Mar 1833, Baptist Church Cemetery, town of Saratoga (FaG 43042297) — PROBABLE; the "of Saratoga" place anchor.
- Jay⁷ (William⁶) "married first, Lucinda Harris" (book No. 238) matches Sylvester's "Lucinda Harris ... married Jay Olney, of Oneida county" — CONFIRMED match; lifts the round-4 quarantine.
- Elizabeth⁷ (William⁶) m. Joseph Clark 1808 (book No. 112) vs Sylvester's "Joseph A. and Elizabeth Clark, of Oneida county" — PROBABLE.
Parents found. Father Stephen⁶ Olney (ahn 366): CONFIRMED that a daughter of his married John Burt; PROBABLE that she is Sarah⁷ b. 1787. Mother Sarah Irish (ahn 367): PROBABLE. Grandparents = existing 352/353 (book text, same grade as the William⁶ link the tree already uses).
Story. A log cabin, then a frame house two years later; a first son, Stephen Olney Burt, born ten months after the wedding and named for Sarah's brother who had died that August; Olney sisters married to Burt brothers, then Lucy Burt to James A. Olney, then their son to John Burt's granddaughter. Stephen's sons went on to Michigan; a grandson, Edward Olney (1827-1887), became professor of mathematics at the University of Michigan.
New leads. Bacon Hill stone photo (FaG 37190293) · Richard John Burt's 1901 Coldwater MI death certificate (Michiganology, free) · Stephen Olney's 1833 Saratoga estate (FamilySearch) · Sarah Irish's parents (Nathaniel⁶ also married an Irish) · Stephen's Revolutionary service (Albany Co militia).
Dead ends. The book never says "of Saratoga" for Stephen; no Burt marriage dates in the book; Sylvester's Saratoga-town and Stillwater chapters not read; FaG search CAPTCHA-blocked.
Target 2: Sophia Melick (ahn 81) in Mellick, The Story of an Old Farm (1889)
Headline. FOUND on p.697, which the assigned scan (storyofoldfarmor00mell) has as OCR garbage; read from three other scans (...00melli, ...00mellic, ...00mell_0).
Verbatim. "8. III. SOPHIA, of New Germantown, b. 17 Oct., 1774, the sponsors at her baptism being Godfrey Reinhart and wife, d. 28 [23 in two of three scans] June, 1849, m. 8 Mch., 1807, William Lambert, b. 1 Mch., 1782, d. 31 Aug., 1854; had 3 ch. ... II. Jeremiah, of N. Y., b. 12 Jan., 1812, d. 30 Oct., 1866, m. 11 Mch., 1840, Garetta V. D., dau. of Simon Vliet, of Bedminster, N. J.; their ch., William ...; John James, res. N. Y., who m. 24 Feb., 1874, Josie Oakford, and has 2 ch.; Anna Elizabeth, res. N. Y." (Mellick p.697)
Facts.
- Sophia b. 17 Oct 1774 New Germantown (Oldwick); m. 8 Mar 1807; d. June 1849 (day 23/28 UNRESOLVED) — PROBABLE.
- William Lambert b. 1 Mar 1782, d. 31 Aug 1854 — PROBABLE (two derivative sources agree on the years).
- Book's Jeremiah = ahn 40 — CONFIRMED (three identical dates + spouse + named son).
- Garetta "dau. of Simon Vliet, of Bedminster" — PROBABLE.
- Christian "often called Christopher" Melick 1744-1788, Tewksbury, d./bur. Woodbridge (pp.87, 696); Anna Pickel 9 Apr 1749 - 23 Jan 1823, widow of Rev. William Graff (p.696) — PROBABLE.
- Johan David Moelich b. Bendorf 1715 (day 12 Oct / 12 Nov / 17 Oct UNRESOLVED), Zion trustee 1749, warden 1757, d. c.1764 (pp.629, 696, 90-91) — PROBABLE; wife "probably named Elizabeth" — POSSIBLE.
- Hans Peter b. Winningen 19 Sep 1683; Jonas 1650-1722, Bendorf tanner and court assessor (pp.628-629) — PROBABLE; four generations above Jonas — POSSIBLE.
- Balthazar Pickel "a native of Hamburg", d. 5 Dec 1765 "In the 79th year of his age", wife Charity (p.79) — PROBABLE as Anna's grandfather.
Parents found. 162/163 PROBABLE (strong); 324 PROBABLE; 326 PROBABLE (name only); 652/653 PROBABLE; 648, 1296 PROBABLE. Charity as Balthazar 2d's mother is inferred from her being his father's wife.
Story. Rhine tanners to Jersey church-builders; David signed the 1750 bond "in German character" to Baltes Pickel, whose great-granddaughter Sophia also was; Sophia's godfather Godfrey Reinhart was later deposed from the vestry for defending a Methodist itinerant; her mother married Zion's pastor, so she grew up as his stepdaughter; her brother Balthazer P. Melick walked to New York at thirteen and became first president of the Chemical Bank.
Caution. Our line is the David (D) branch, cousins of the book's Johannes "Old Farm" household. Do not import Old Farm stories as direct-ancestor stories.
New leads. Zion Lutheran (Oldwick) registers (1774 baptism, 1807 marriage, 1849/1854 burials) · Balthazer P. Melick's 1835 NY will · Christian's Woodbridge stone and 1788 estate · Balthazar Pickel's 1765 Hunterdon will · Chambers pp.543-544 Vliet genealogy (a Simon b. 1747 m. Ann Terhune "res. at Lamington", POSSIBLE father of our Simon) · William Lambert's parents (exact birth date now a search key).
Dead ends. storyofoldfarmor00mell p.697 garbage (a negative from it alone would have been false) · storyanoldfarmo00mellgoog no text · no Lambert parents in Mellick or Chambers · Tunis Melick branch checked, no Sophia.
Target 3: Catharine Munson (ahn 95) in The Munson Record (1895)
Headline. FOUND (vol. I p.262). Six generations to Capt. Thomas Munson. M9 narrowed, not resolved.
Verbatim.
- "v. Catharine H.,(7) m. Jacob Sharp b. abt. 1818, of Broadway street-railway renown, a very able man; res. 326 W. 23d st." (MR I p.262; the "abt. 1818" dates Jacob, the spouse)
- "Peter(5) (William(4)) b. 22 Nov. 1735; m. 6 Oct. 1762 Elizabeth Hall; he d. 3 Feb. 1830; she d. 31 Oct. 1822. Cong.; res. Cheshire, Ct." (MR I p.247)
- "William(4) b. 13 Oct. 1695; m. Rebecca dau. of Thomas Curtis of Wallingford; he d. 21 July 1773." (MR I p.244)
- "Samuel(3) (Samuel(2), Thomas(1)) b. 28 Feb. 1668, i.e., 1669; m. Martha ---; 8 ch.; she d. 7 Jan. 1707; m. (2nd) 10 March 1708 Mary wid. of Caleb Merriman ... he d. 23 Nov. 1741, ae. 73. Town-Clerk; res. Wallingford, Ct." (MR I p.90)
- "Samuel(2) (Thomas(1)) bp. 7 Aug. 1643 ... m. 26 Oct. 1665 Martha dau. of William and Alice (Pritchard) Bradley ... he d. in 1693, between Jan. 10 and March 2, 1693. Shoemaker (and tanner)" (MR I p.65)
- "Thomas(1) b. abt. 1612; m. Joanna ---, app'y, b. abt. 1610; she d. 13 Dec. 1678, ae. 68; he d. 7 May 1685, ae. 73. Carpenter, civic office, military service" (MR I, family no. 1)
- "Granddaughter of Jacob Sharp and Catherine H. Munson, his wife. Gr.-granddaughter of Peter Hall Munson and Charlotte Wilkinson, his wife." (DAR Lineage Book vol. 26, No. 25396, pp.142-143)
- "Jacob Sharp, Died April 5, 1888, Aged 70 years. At Rest Catharine Munson His Wife Died February 11, 1897, Aged 72 years." (monument, FaG 57667493/57667447)
Facts. Father Peter Hall Munson — CONFIRMED. Mother Charlotte Wilkinson — PROBABLE (DAR 26 + Fitch). Peter⁵ → Thomas¹ entries — CONFIRMED as Record statements (Peter Hall as son of Peter⁵ PROBABLE: no birth given). d. 11 Feb 1897 Rome NY — CONFIRMED (Sun 12 Feb 1897, which calls her "Mary"). Birth c.1824/25 — PROBABLE (two death-time records). Marriage 23 Mar 1838 St Peter's Chelsea — PROBABLE (index via FaG). First known child George C., 1841 (the audit's "1845" was wrong). Subscriber "Sharp, Jacob, Mrs., 417 North Washington St., Rome, N. Y. (2)" — CONFIRMED.
Confidence ceiling. Every Munson node is drawn PROBABLE: the Record does not name Catharine's children, and the 47 step is PROBABLE.
Story. "Peter H. 'was a great violin-player, could not be beat;' but he * * * * * was not prosperous" and the hawk shot from a disguised horse; Peter⁵ on the 1779 Continental clothing committee, six feet tall and 236 pounds; a son of Samuel³ "died at port royal" in 1710; Capt. Thomas a Pequot War soldier and New Haven carpenter.
New leads. Census ages 1850-80 + 1855 NY (settles M9) · St Peter's register image · Rome Daily Sentinel Feb 1897 obituary · NY death cert 6172 · DAR file 25396 · Elizabeth Hall (Davis, History of Wallingford) · Bradley/Curtis lines · MR I pp.1-60 (Thomas Munson narrative).
Dead ends. No Wilkinson in the Record; no dates for Peter Hall or his children; Chronicling America 1897 only the Sun notice; WikiTree no match. Caution: Fitch's "married Jacob Sharpe about 1818" misreads the Record.
Target 4: Richard Burt (178) and Preserved Salisbury (180)
Headline. No birth record for either man. But the DAR application of Sarah Salisbury Olney (ahn 45) names Preserved's wife and father.
Verbatim. Sarah (Salisbury) Olney: "Daughter of Hiram Salisbury and Sarah Burt, his wife. Granddaughter of Preserved Salisbury and Mary Powell, his wife. Gr.-granddaughter of Thomas Salisbury." "Thomas Salisbury served as a private in Capt. Joseph Springer's company, Col. Joseph Stanton's regiment, 1776, and under Capt. Malachi Hammett, 1777." (DAR Lineage Book vol. 16, No. 15157, pp.62-63; archive.org lineagebook00revogoog)
Facts. 45 → 90/91 CONFIRMED (her own statement; first non-FaG source) · Mary Powell PROBABLE · Thomas Salisbury as Preserved's father PROBABLE · his service POSSIBLE · daughter Delia Olney Bailey's entry follows (No. 15158) · 1774 "Salsbury, Thomas" and 1790 "Salsberry, Thomas" (Scituate/Smithfield area) POSSIBLE, not merged.
Dead ends (exact searches run). Richard Burt b. 17 Apr 1745: Arnold vol. 6 (Bristol/Warren/Barrington), vol. 4 (Newport incl. Tiverton/Little Compton), vols 1, 2, 5, 7 and the Providence County volume; Rehoboth, Swansea, Taunton 1-2, Norton, Freetown VRs; 1774/1790 RI censuses; H. M. Burt 1893. None. Preserved Salisbury: every "Preserved" in Arnold vol. 6; Little Compton Salisburys; Swansea, Rehoboth; full-text variants. None.
New leads. DAR application files 15157/15158 + DAR Ancestor Database (browser) · RI State Archives militia index (Stanton's regiment) · Scituate probate · Powell family c.1773 · Berkley/Dighton MA, Chatham NY church registers for Richard Burt.
Target 5: Kent — Mary (265) and the Kent-Taylor marriage (66/67)
Headline. Honest negatives on both. One new sibling marriage.
Verbatim. "TUCKER, Simpson, decd. & Mary Kent 3 Jan. 1757"; "KENT, Eliz: & Obadiah Tucker, both of Albemarle Dec: 11 1769 p. 11."; "Kent, Mary, in Albemarle, & Jo: Poor in Goochland, Feb. 3 1774 p. 14."; "Kent, Ann, in Albemarle, & Thomas Diggs in Louisa Jun: 9 1775 p. 16." (The Douglas Register, archive.org douglasregisterb00doug). Caswell bonds: "Dorman Taylor / Sally Kent / 21 Mar 1808"; "Smith F Kent / Sally Sadler / 21 Feb 1807" (NCGenWeb Caswell, Stainback transcription).
Facts. No birth of any child of a Kent father in the Douglas Register — CONFIRMED negative (scope: Goochland, not Cumberland's Southam Parish) · four Albemarle Kent women, a different household — PROBABLE · Smith F. Kent's bond — CONFIRMED; same family — PROBABLE · Dorman Taylor–Sally Kent marriage — CONFIRMED as an event; "daughter of Alexander" — PROBABLE · no Kent groom other than Smith F. and no Catherine/Caty Taylor bride in Caswell 1778-1868 — CONFIRMED negative · SAR P-259157 detail on Sally's line — POSSIBLE.
Parents. 265: nothing new; "Easley"/"Ligon" stay POSSIBLE. 134/135: none; Dorman Taylor POSSIBLE kin only, not drawn.
New leads. Kendall's Caswell bonds (bondsmen) · Person Co NC and Pittsylvania VA bonds · Dorman Taylor's 1810 household · Cumberland deeds/order books c.1750-60 (dower release).
Story 1: Jacob Sharp (ahn 94) and the Broadway "Boodle" case (s1)
Verbatim. "The grandsons and granddaughters, George C. Sharp, Thomson Rogers, Adele Olney and Maud Rogers inherit $5,000 each. The rest of the estate ... is bequeathed to Mr. Sharp's two daughters, Mary Ann Selmes and Sarah Agnes Stevens ... Mrs. Sharp is appointed executrix, and Mr. Selmes and Mr. Olney executors." "The petition is signed by the widow, John H. Selmes, a son-in-law, and James P. Olney, the husband of a granddaughter, who lives in Rome." (New-York Tribune, 12 Apr 1888, p.5, page image) · "Mr. J. P. Olney, Rome, N. Y. Come at once. Grandpa dead. Mrs. J. P. OLNEY." (Tribune, 7 Apr 1888, p.2, image) · "He appoints his wife, Catharine Sharp, to be executrix" (The Sun, 12 Apr 1888, p.6) · a man "cannot properly be made the subject of a judicial sentence unless the crime is substantiated according to the established rules of evidence" (People v. Sharp, 107 N.Y. 427).
Verdicts. Tree's Jacob = the magnate — CONFIRMED · Catharine = his wife — CONFIRMED · Mary Ann Selmes = his daughter — CONFIRMED · Adele/Adella Olney = his granddaughter — CONFIRMED · Adele's mother = Mary Ann (not Sarah Agnes) — PROBABLE.
Timeline. b. 6 Jul 1817 Montgomery Co NY · rafted to NYC at 21 · Broadway franchise Aug 1884 · indicted 19 Oct 1886 · guilty 29 Jun 1887 (jury out 18 minutes) · sentenced 14 Jul 1887, four years + $5,000 · reversed 29 Nov 1887 · d. 5 Apr 1888 · buried Green-Wood 8 Apr. Siblings Conklin and Kate Sharp (PROBABLE/CONFIRMED). Rev. Dr. Thomas Armitage buried him — the probable source of Florence Armitage Olney's name (b. 1889).
New leads. Edgar Rogers's 1875 NYC death/probate; 1870/1880 census households (Rogers vs Stevens) · Rome Sentinel 6 Apr 1888 sketch · NY County Surrogate file (will executed 22 Jul 1887) · Kate and Conklin Sharp → Jacob's parents.
Story 2: the two pensions (s2)
Alexander Kent (ahn 132) — S38113 + VAS3918 + Valley Forge roll
Verbatim. "he Enlisted a private Soldier in the month of March 1777 in the company of Capt. Hughes Woodson, 10th Virginia Regiment Commanded by Col. Stephens for three years ... and was discharged in Philadelphia in March 1780, which Discharge is mislaid" and "he was Engaged in the battles of Brandywine, Germantown and the Capture of Stoney Point" (S38113 p.7, Sept 1823) · "aged seventy years the 29th of July next" (S38113 p.24, 27 Jun 1825) · "Alex'r Kent enlisted as a Soldier in Virginia Continental line the Twenty Seventh of January Seventy Seven for three years" (Capt. Clough Shelton, VAS3918) · "Alex Kent Formerly a Soldier in the 6th Virginia Regiment has duly and faithfully served ... and permitted to return to his home free and unmolested ... Given under my hand at Philadelphia this 31st Day of January 1780, Christian Febiger" (VAS3918) · "I do assign to Wm Reynolds the full contents of this Discharge being for my bounty of land & allowance of pay" (21 Aug 1784, VAS3918) · Valley Forge record VA26048: January 1778, "On Command".
Facts. Identity CONFIRMED (Halifax court, birth date, the 1853 "Alexander Kent, Jr." of Gilmer Co GA) · enlisted 27 Jan 1777, discharged 31 Jan 1780 — CONFIRMED by contemporary papers (Graves reads "January 3", Harris "31st": image check) · battles CONFIRMED as sworn · 70 acres worth $140, wife and two adult children (1823) · pension $8/month from 28 Jun 1825 · no wounds claimed · 1840 census age 84 and 1841 death NOT re-verified.
John LeQuire (ahn 200) — S7130 ("John Laquir") + SC4865
Verbatim. "I spent the prime of my life in the defense of our liberty I am a Frenchman by birth my father came to the colonies when I was about Eight years of age and his lessons to me when a Child ... the expression was something like this John I left France in search of Liberty now the call is Liberty or Death he gave the Charge and I Obeyed it" · "All the information I have on that subject is this I recollect that I have heard my father say I was born in France in the year 1755." · "I am illiterate it is impossible for me to give dates" · "I am now poor Indeed and Call on a Generous public to give me something to soothe my Frooping Spirits, that when time is no more it may be said that John Laquir has done his duty." (S7130, declaration of 23 Oct 1832)
Facts. Born in France 1755, on his father's word — CONFIRMED as sworn (hearsay; no French record) · brought over about 1763 with both parents · Tryon (Rutherford) Co from about 1775 · Hambright volunteer; Briar Creek wagon guard (eyewitness Joshua Roberts); Tuckasegee Ford; ten months with Sumter's horse (Charles Thompson) · $60/yr for 18 months allowed · 1783 "Sumter's wages" sale (SC4865) PROBABLE same man · d. 7 Jul 1847 PROBABLE (ledger via WikiTree) · the file names no wife or child: the link to Joseph Sr (100) is unchanged.
Correction applied. Tree doc (round 1+2 lines) and partA lines 134/140 annotated REVERSED; site 200/100/50/25 and three bios rewritten.
Story 3: John Martin Gibby (ahn 12) — Chatuge and 1958 (s3)
Verbatim. "Mrs. J. M. Gibbey and the late Mr. Gibbey came to Clay County thirty five years ago, from Swain County. He was a former Clay County Commissioner who was killed in a logging accident six years ago. Mr. Gibbey operated ? sawmill and farm." · "During the time the Chatuge Lake was built in Clay County, living space became a premium. When my husband, myself, and two children were looking for some place to live, Mrs. Gibbey said just come on in, we will make room for you all. While we lived there, our third child was born." (Cherokee Scout and Clay County Progress, 10 Jun 1965, seq. 11, "Today's Neighbor"; living names elided) · "Five families must move within the next thirty days ... 32 families who have not moved, and don't know where they will go." (Cherokee Scout, 11 Dec 1941, p.1) · "Mr. Gibby, a brother of the late John Gibby of Hayesville, died of complications resulting from an aut[o] accident on December 23." (19 Jan 1967)
Facts. Logging-accident death — CONFIRMED (two accounts) · commissioner — PROBABLE (term unknown) · arrival c.1930 — PROBABLE · sawmill and farm — CONFIRMED · lodger family during Chatuge — CONFIRMED as reported · TVA farm loss / Gibby Island — PROBABLE (2026 feature only) · Chatuge: 278 families, 6,048 acres (NC HPO 2025 p.68) · I. B. Gibby a brother — CONFIRMED (supports G. W. Gibby's parentage from the sibling side) · "Bill" = Sherman Willard Gibby — PROBABLE · 1965 says seven children vs the tree's nine — a family question.
Dead ends. No 1958 obituary in the Cherokee Scout (17, 22 Dec 1958; Jan-Feb 1959) · no Hayesville Gibby in any 1940-43 Scout page · no 1940s-50s Clay County Progress on DigitalNC · Georgia Historic Newspapers zero · FaG 403 · NARA finding aids name no families.
AUDIT FIXES (2026-11-15 cold audit, section 1)
| Item | Status | What was done |
|---|---|---|
| H1 POSSIBLE edges drawn (414, 415, 45184) | FIXED | Removed from ANC → unknown placeholders with hints; pages kept via an OFFCHART list in build-people.mjs, labeled "Possible link · OFF THE CHART"; fa/mo pointers on 207 and 22592 dropped |
| H2 Olney-Sayles 20 vs 28 Dec 1692 | FIXED | Tree doc lines (round 1+2, round 4) annotated to 28 Dec; john-sayles bio + fact corrected |
| H3 solid nodes on probable edges | FIXED | prob:true + "Confirmed identity · lineage edge probable" on 22554, 11302, 45208, 45209, 264 |
| H4 "by his own 1670 deed" | FIXED | 2818 story, GROUPS, 1409, john-sayles + catharine-sayles bios, fact → Probable; leads with the 1680 petition; tree doc round-2 line → PROBABLE, anchored per Austin |
| M1 Mary Williams 1633 vs "aged 45" | FIXED (note) | 2819 conf + story note; facts updated |
| M2 Sayles children | PARTLY | KIN conf → PROBABLE, births per Arnold, death-year conflict stated; resolving deaths needs an Austin page-image re-read |
| M3 Morgan cluster | FIXED | james-morgan-sr facts[2],[3],[6]; susannah-morgan bio/facts; mary-molly-davis-morgan bio/facts ("Rev." and "three independent memorials" gone); off-chart page ed ~1791 with basis |
| M4 Hull dates | FIXED | Tree doc round-7 line corrected; 22605 ed → d 1629 |
| M5 orphan pages / slug mismatches | FIXED | Deleted people/rev-james-morgan-sr.html, people/harriett-foster.html (+ unknown-first-wife-of-rev-joseph-hull.html after 11303 was undrawn); bio and hint keys renamed to alice-hull-nee-unknown, harriett-osborn-foster |
| M6 stale hints | FIXED | rachel-strain, alice-pemberton, lumpkin-gaither-foster, james-ashton rewritten |
| M7 Oakford/Rittenhouse leak | SKIPPED | A founder decision (strip vs extend the labeled-bio convention), not mechanical |
| M8 "legally Surry at birth" | FIXED | ANC 64 + richard-wilson bio[0]/facts[1]: Rowan at birth (Surry formed 1771) |
| M9 Catharine married at 13 | NARROWED | Needs census ages (founder-hands); site wording made honest; first child 1841 |
| M10 1840 census age 84 | FIXED | Split; held at POSSIBLE in ANC 132, bio facts and tree doc |
| M11 Foster-Brown marriage | FIXED | julius-calloway-foster bio + fact (10 Oct 1899, index, PROBABLE); MARRIAGE map |
| M12 Roger Pemberton in KIN | FIXED | Removed (HOLD list) |
| M13 estimate-rule breaks | FIXED | 264 eb 1728 (E2); ebasis on 1412, 1413, 2828, 2829, 5648, 5649, 5650, 22554; 2828 ed 1691 (E3); 11303 → unknown placeholder |
| M14 Peter Stroud Sr | SKIPPED | Needs research (W7557 full file) |
| L1 353 ~1793 vs ~1795 | FIXED | Tree doc |
| L2 Monroe "teacher" | FIXED | Tree doc (Generation −2 + Stories lines) |
| L3 generation label | FIXED | Tree doc |
| L4 stale open keys | FIXED | Bertha lines struck; key 12 annotated |
| L5 Jonathan Gabby SC vs NC | FIXED (note) | Tree doc note; quarantined either way |
| L6 GROUPS drift | FIXED | Susannah Morgan GROUPS conf; John Sayles probate note |
| L7 1413-1415 solid | FIXED | prob:true |
| L8 EVENTS | PARTLY | 1941 event reworded; "1983" and "Danville KY" left for the founder (living family) |
| L9 FaG-only "Confirmed" | FIXED | 15 and 45 conf strings; 89 already said probable |
CONTRADICTIONS
- Sarah vs Dorcas (Olney). 1889 book: Dorcas⁷ m. John Burt, Sarah⁷ m. "Richard Burt" (children John, Richard, Justus). Sylvester: John m. Sarah. Favoured: book garble (age 69 at death fits Sarah b. 1787; her daughter is Sarah; Sylvester's informant was her son). Parent link holds either way. Not resolved.
- Sarah Irish d. 1808 (FaG) vs Stephen remarried "in 1807" (book). One year is off.
- Sylvester's child order. He calls the daughter the eldest and Stephen O. the youngest; Stephen O. was b. 1808 and Sarah 1811.
- Sophia Melick's death day 23 vs 28 June 1849 (scans disagree). David Melick's birth day 12 Oct / 12 Nov / 17 Oct 1715.
- Lambert-Oakford marriage: Mellick 24 Feb 1874 vs Manhattan cert #923 22 Jan 1874. The certificate wins.
- Catharine Munson's age at marriage (M9): age 72 at death (two records) puts her at 13-14 in Mar 1838; unindexed census ages are the test. Fitch's "married ... about 1818" is a misreading of the Record.
- Adella's mother: the will lists Adele among the Rogers grandchildren; Tribune 8 Apr 1888 calls the Olneys "son-in-law and daughter of Mr. Stevens". Held: Mary Ann, PROBABLE.
- Alexander Kent's dates: 1823 memory (Mar 1777 - Mar 1780) vs contemporary papers (27 Jan 1777 - 31 Jan 1780, applied); Graves "January 3" vs Harris "31st" for the discharge; "aged 67" in Sept 1823 implies 1756 vs 29 Jul 1755.
- Alexander Kent, Jr. in Gilmer Co GA, 1853 vs William Alexander Kent's "d. 1861 Halifax VA". Open.
- LeQuire birthplace: sworn declaration (France) vs WikiTree bio (NC, citing only the ledger). Declaration wins; tree reversed.
- Gibby child count: 1965 profile seven vs tree nine. Family question.
- Thomas Salisbury's unit: Springer is a Tiverton-area name, the census Thomases are in northern Providence County. Two men or one is unknown; not merged.
FOUNDER-HANDS
- One FamilySearch login session: Catharine Munson's census ages (1850, 1860, 1870, 1880 US; 1855 NY state; household of Jacob Sharp, NYC) — settles M9 · Rome NY death certificate No. 6172 (Catharine Sharp, 11 Feb 1897: age, birthplace, parents) · St Peter's (Chelsea) register, 23 Mar 1838 · Stephen Olney's 1833 Saratoga County estate (does a will name "my daughter Sarah Burt"?) · Kendall's Caswell bonds (FS catalog 191173: bondsmen on the 1807/1808 Kent bonds) · Person Co NC bonds (FS catalog 345620).
- DAR application files: No. 15157 (Sarah Salisbury Olney) and 15158 (Delia Olney Bailey) — Thomas Salisbury's dates, wife and town; No. 25396 (Lucy Stevens Van Wagenen, Sharp line) and Nos. 20877, 22909 (Peter Munson). services.dar.org blocks headless access; needs a browser.
- NARA Atlanta, RG 142 (TVA): the Chatuge Reservoir Family Removal case file and land-acquisition tract file for John M. Gibby, Clay Co NC, 1941 (project boxes 527-530 are reports, not family files).
- Georgia death certificate, Dec 1958: John Martin Gibby, Towns Co GA (cause, place of injury, informant) — Georgia DPH Vital Records order or a FamilySearch session.
- Cumberland Co VA deeds and order books c.1750-60: a dower release naming Robert Kent Sr's wife Mary (ahn 265) — Library of Virginia / FamilySearch.
- Also: Clay County Board of Commissioners minutes (John M. Gibby's term; one call to Hayesville) · Michiganology: Richard John Burt's 1901 Coldwater death certificate (free) · Bacon Hill stone photo for Sarah Olney Burt · Zion Lutheran (Oldwick) registers · NC HPO Western Office file CY0220 "Gibby House".
TOP-OPEN-KEYS (for the tree doc)
- Catharine Munson's census ages (M9).
- Sarah vs Dorcas: Bacon Hill stone, Michigan death cert, Stephen Olney's estate.
- Adella's mother (Rogers vs Stevens): Edgar Rogers's 1875 probate; 1870/1880 census.
- DAR file 15157: Thomas Salisbury's dates and town.
- Zion Lutheran (Oldwick) registers: Sophia's baptism and death day; Christian Melick's 1788 estate; Balthazar Pickel's 1765 will.
- Pension S38113 p.3 image (66 → 132), now with the Gilmer 1853 vs Halifax 1861 question attached.
- John M. Gibby: GA 1958 death certificate; TVA family-removal file; commissioner minutes; I. B. Gibby's Gastonia obituary (tests G. W. Gibby + Sarah Lequire).
- John LeQuire: the other ~14 pages of S7130 (heirs naming Joseph Sr?); 1830 Rutherford census; a French family arriving c.1763-64.
- Carried: Matthew Mashburn's 1826 will; St. George's register; Eva Brown's 1938 certificate; Oakford certificates; Richard Hull's parents; Peter Stroud Sr (M14).