Contradiction-checked against the tree doc ([[2026-07-20-wilson-tree-v0]], rounds 1-11), round 10 [[2026-07-27-frontier-round10-partQ|partQ]]/[[2026-07-27-frontier-round10-partR|partR]] and round 11 [[2026-07-28-frontier-round11-partS|partS]]. Mechanical downgrade rule applied: any CONFIRMED resting on a single Find A Grave / WikiTree-class or single compiled transcription is carried here as PROBABLE. No living people are named. Monroe and Eleanor are both deceased (1996, 2010); their children are left unnamed.
Headlines
- Roger Goodspeed's mother: Alice (Harris), now PROBABLE. This reverses round 10's "keep her off" decision, and both of round 10's reasons have fallen. (1) The 1609 marriage is real. It is printed in Phillimore, Bucks Marriages vol. 1 p.92, under Soulbury "Transcripts": "Robt. God;spede[?] & Alice Harries ... 6 Nov. 1609". Round 10 searched under Wingrave, the wrong parish. (2) The "Agnes" in TNA C 5/405/103 belongs to a different Robert Goodspeed, of Stoke Mandeville. Round 10 partR had already ruled out merging him with our Robert, and the tree doc's round-10 line ("direct contrary primary evidence") follows partQ and contradicts partR. Robert's 1658 will names "my wife Alice". Roger was born c.1612-1620, inside a marriage to an Alice that ran from 1609 to at least 1658. One weak link remains: the 1609 groom's residence is not stated, and three Robert Goodspeeds were alive then.
- John Sayles Sr. and Mary (Williams) Sayles: gravestones give 1681 for both (RIHCC MT014, Middletown). Mary's original stone is quoted verbatim, "WHO DIED IN Ye YEAR 1681 AGED 45 YEARS", which settles her open 1681-vs-1684 question in favour of 1681. A new primary record, independent of Austin, also ties the Sayles family to Roger Williams. In October 1680 John Jr. petitioned for "35 Acors of Land which my Grand fathar Mr Rogor williams Gaue me" (Early Records of Providence XV p.215). Catharine's own parentage still rests on Austin alone. The birth register rules out John Jr. as her father, and a second adult Sayles man, Richard, was in Providence in 1663.
- Eva C. Brown: Samuel Brown (1817-1899) and Mary Ann Breazeale (1821-1905) are REFUTED as her parents. Mary Ann would have been 64 at Eva's birth in 1885. None of their sons has an Eva born about 1885 in the Old Pendleton GEDCOM. Eva's parents are back to unknown, and her 1938 GA death certificate and her 1899 marriage-license consent are still the two ways in.
- Rev. Joseph Hull's first wife: Crewkerne tested and closed as the marriage venue, for the transcribed register. FreeREG holds two transcriptions of the Crewkerne register, and a control search worked in both. Neither has a Joseph Hull marriage 1610-1634, and every Crewkerne Hull baptism 1614-1634 belongs to John or George. Merge trap: Joane Hull, bapt. 10 Nov 1619, is JOHN's daughter. The Exeter diocese licences (Vivian 1889) are also negative. Best remaining door: the Devon Bishop's Transcripts for Northleigh (founder-hands). At least one Northleigh 1620s baptism, Temperance's of 20 Mar 1625/6 (via Anderson), is known to survive somewhere.
- Tree corrections from the backstory pass: James Morgan Sr's oath of allegiance was 1779; 18 Jan 1785 is only DAR's last-seen-alive bound. Joseph Hull's inventory totals £52.5.5, not £62. Lothrop's 1639 entry reads "Mr Bursley and Mr Hulls daughter" and does not name Joanna. Joanna was alive in 1686, so her estimated death moves to ~1689. Thomas Olney was not banished with Roger Williams: he left under licence and was later excommunicated. Monroe was a Folk School student from 1938 to 1942, not a teacher, and served on the USS Tucson (PROBABLE).
- Pemberton (HOLD list, off-viz): Robert Stokes, M.A., of St Albans wrote a will in 1578 naming "my cousin Roger Pemberton" and "mine Aunt Pemberton". That makes Katherine Pemberton, Robert's widow, the Stokes brothers' aunt. It is the first documentary basis for the floating "née Stokes" claim. The maiden name itself stays POSSIBLE.
VIZ-CHANGES
- ADD_PERSON: ahn 11297, Alice (Harris) Goodspeed. Married Robert Goodspeed (ahn 11296), Soulbury, Bucks, 6 Nov 1609; living 15 Sept 1658. Est. birth ~1588 (E1: 1609 − 21). Est. death ~1661 (E3: 1588 + 62 = 1650, floored at last-seen-alive 1658 + 3). Set
mo:11297on ANC[5648] (Roger Goodspeed). PROBABLE.- Verbatim: "Robt. God;spede[?] & Alice Harries ... 6 Nov. 1609" (Phillimore, Bucks Parish Registers, Marriages vol. 1 (1902), Soulbury section p.92, "Transcripts"). "To my wife Alice all my household stuff in my house at Wingrave ..." (will of Robert Goodspeede, 15 Sept 1658, Moriarty NEHGR 82 p.444).
- Weak link, stated on the person page: the 1609 entry gives no residence for the groom, and three Robert Goodspeeds were of marriageable age. Moriarty assigns the marriage to the 1578 Robert. That choice is supported by the sons' names, which match the 1578 Robert's brothers, and by the Wingrave-Soulbury ties in Nicholas Goodspeed's 1605/6 will.
- UPDATE_DATE: ahn 5651, Joanna (Hull) Bursley Davis. Death estimate
ed ~1682becomes ~1689 (E3 floor: alive 1686 + 3). PROBABLE. Otis vol. 1 p.130 has "Wid. Joanna Davis" occupying the old Bursley house in 1686, and Davis 1881 p.27 has her living in 1683. - UPDATE_DATE: ahn 1409, Catharine Sayles. b. 1671, d. 21 Feb 1751 per Austin 1887 p.353 (page image read). This retires both E1 halves: the ~1671 birth becomes real, and the ~1733 death is replaced. PROBABLE, single compiled source, the same source that anchors her parentage. The implementer may hold this pending the open touchstonetruth "d. 24 Feb 1753" stone question (see CONTRADICTIONS). The LDS-mirror 21 Feb 1751 agreement is not independent of Austin.
- UPDATE_STORY: ahn 414, James Morgan Sr. Oath of allegiance = 1779, Randolph Co NC (DAR A132519 service description). 18 Jan 1785 is DAR's "death POST" bound only. The
edfield (post 1785) is unchanged; the bio sentence "oath ... January 18, 1785" must be rewritten. CONFIRMED (DAR fields read side by side). This closes round 10's contradiction #1. - UPDATE_STORY: ahn 2818, John Sayles. Death 1681 is now gravestone-anchored (RIHCC 138061: d. 1681, age 48, so b. c.1633). Add the 1676/1678 last clear "Sen." records and the absence of a probate across all 21 Early Records volumes. Drawn dates unchanged. PROBABLE (single volunteer transcription; the inscription is not quoted).
- UPDATE_STORY: ahn 2819, Mary Williams. d. 1681 per her original gravestone (RIHCC 138062, verbatim; the stone was replaced c.1995). This resolves 1681-vs-1684 in favour of 1681 (drawn value unchanged). The stone does not name her father; "[WILLIAMS]" is the database's own addition. The age-45 versus b. Aug 1633 conflict persists. PROBABLE.
- UPDATE_STORY: ahn 11302, Rev. Joseph Hull. Inventory total is £52.5.5, not £62 5s 5d, and he died 19 Nov 1665. Add Winthrop's 1635 Wessaguscus entry and 1643 "excommunicated person and very contentious" remark, the Lothrop excommunication of 1 May 1641 and readmission of 10 Aug 1643, the c.1645 return to England (1669 deposition), and Calamy's "Burien: Mr. Joseph Hull". Note the institution date conflict: 4 Apr 1621 (Exeter Registry letter) vs 14 Apr (Weygant/WikiTree). PROBABLE overall; individual items CONFIRMED where read directly.
- UPDATE_STORY: ahn 5651, Joanna Hull. Correct "date preserved in her father's church diary / names Joanna". It is Rev. John Lothrop's register, which reads "Mr Bursley and Mr Hulls daughter ... att Sandwidge". The identification as Joanna is PROBABLE: she was Joseph's only daughter of marriageable age, and Otis, Goodspeed 1907 and Davis 1881 all name her. Replace the children list with Lothrop's entries. CONFIRMED (register read directly).
- UPDATE_STORY: ahn 11296, Robert Goodspeed. Wife Alice is named in his own 1658 will. The 1649 Agnes belongs to the Stoke Mandeville Robert. PROBABLE.
- UPDATE_STORY: ahn 15, Eva C. Brown. The round-11 POSSIBLE candidate couple is refuted (age arithmetic). The bio's "nothing was found" paragraph should record the test. PROBABLE (downgraded from CONFIRMED: Eva's birth date rests on one Find A Grave memorial, though the 1900 census age corroborates it).
- UPDATE_STORY: ahn 5632, Thomas Olney. Corrections: (a) not banished; he left under licence in 1637/8, and the record prints his name as "Thom: One"; (b) twelve named grantees (the "thirteen" count includes Williams), and the deed date of 8 Oct 1638 is itself a 1666 reconstruction; (c) the birthplace is St Albans, and "Hertford ... part of the Parish of St Albans" is a geographic error; (d) neither Austin nor the 1889 book says which side of the c.1652-4 schism he led; (e) the death window is will 21 Mar 1679/80 to inventory 9 Oct 1682. PROBABLE/CONFIRMED per item.
- UPDATE_STORY: ahn 2816, Thomas Olney II. The "father led the breakaway, son pastored the original" framing is a synthesis, not a source statement. Note his wife's surname variant: Austin prints MARSH twice, the 1889 book "March of Newport". Add the 1721/2 will and the burying-place reservation. CONFIRMED/PROBABLE per item.
- UPDATE_STORY: ahn 5633, Marie Ashton. She died before 21 Mar 1679/80 (her husband's will makes no provision for a wife) and was buried in the homestead family ground (Thomas II's will). The existing ~1667 estimate is not contradicted and stays. PROBABLE.
- UPDATE_STORY: ahn 4, Herman Monroe Wilson. Folk School student 1938-42 (Cherokee Scout, multiple issues), replacing "teacher". He studied engineering at IIT and served on the USS Tucson (CL-98) (1961 profile; PROBABLE). Add the 1949 move to the "Cornwell place", the DHIA dairy records 1949-53, Lidseen, the postmaster swearing-in of 14 Apr 1961 (corroborates USPS), and Episcopal vestry secretary (1961).
- UPDATE_STORY: ahn 5, Eleanor Lambert Wilson. Add the Christmas 1941 chorus with Monroe (the earliest record of the two together), the 1947 home demonstration club, the 1955 five-member Good Shepherd mission committee (corroborates "founding couple"), Vassar class secretary 1955, AAUW and 4-H leader in the 1960s. Arrival 1941 (obituary) vs 1940 (folkschool.org 2021) is logged, not changed.
- UPDATE_STORY: ahn 11303, unknown first wife. Add the Crewkerne negatives, the Exeter licence negative and the Joane-1619 merge trap. Flag the existing bio's "Agnes (probable surname Hunt), m. 13 Mar 1633 Wells" as unverified. It rests on one blog citation (round 9 [[2026-07-26-frontier-round9-partO|partO]]), and HFA says Agnes's surname is unknown.
NEW-PEOPLE
- Alice (Harris) Goodspeed, ahn 11297. m. 6 Nov 1609 Soulbury, Bucks; living 15 Sept 1658. PROBABLE. Mother of Roger Goodspeed (ahn 5648). See VIZ-CHANGES #1.
Not added (doc-only):
- Katherine Pemberton (ahn 22555): HOLD list.
- Richard Sayles (witness 1663): unknown identity.
- Mary (Morgan) Parr: collateral, through whom DAR lines run.
- Rev. James Morgan Jr.: collateral, link POSSIBLE.
- Lucretia Carpenter and her daughters: unanchored hypothesis only.
ANC 147 → 148.
ESTIMATES-RETIRED
- Catharine Sayles (ahn 1409): E1 birth ~1671 becomes 1671, and E3 death ~1733 becomes 21 Feb 1751 (Austin p.353; PROBABLE; see VIZ #3).
- Joanna Hull (ahn 5651): not retired but re-floored. ed ~1682 becomes ~1689 (last seen alive 1686).
- Alice (Harris) Goodspeed (ahn 11297): new estimates minted (eb ~1588, ed ~1661), with bases as in VIZ #1.
Frontier target 1: Identity of Rev. Joseph Hull's first wife (ahn 11303)
Facts
- HONEST NEGATIVE: Crewkerne St Bartholomew marriages are on FreeREG twice (Parish Register and Phillimore's Transcript, 1558/9-1813). Searching for groom Joseph HULL, Som/Dev/Dor, 1610-1634, returns 0. Surname-only Hull marriages in Som+Dev 1610-1634 return 17 rows, none fitting. Control: Thomas HULL x Johane PESON, 11 Jan 1572/3, is found in both transcripts. (FreeREG, run 2026-10-24. CONFIRMED.)
- HONEST NEGATIVE: every Hull baptism at Crewkerne 1614-1634 names its father as John or George, never Joseph. George's children: Josias 1616, Marie 1618, Martha 1620, Elizabeth 1625, Cornelius 1628, John 1630. John's children: Isacke 1615, Ffrauncis 1618, Joane 1619, Ruth 1622, Judith 1625, Sara 1627. (FreeREG detail records, Crewkerne PR. CONFIRMED.)
- MERGE TRAP: Joane HULL, bapt. 10 Nov 1619 at Crewkerne, father JOHN Hull. Do not merge with Joanna Hull (ahn 5651). (CONFIRMED.)
- George Hull married Thomzen/Thamzen Michell at Crewkerne, 25 Aug 1614 (PR) or 27 Sep 1614 (Phillimore). Corroborates the family cluster but says nothing about Joseph's wife. (PROBABLE.)
- HONEST NEGATIVE: Vivian, Marriage Licenses of the Diocese of Exeter (1889, covering 1523-Mar 1631), full text has no Joseph Hull. The OCR is imperfect, and banns marriages never appear in licence registers. (CONFIRMED.)
- "William HULL 'Mr Vicar'" buried Colyton St Andrew, 1 Jun 1627. Independent corroboration of brother William's death. (FreeREG Colyton Other Transcript. PROBABLE.)
- "Josephe HULL" bapt. 30 Mar 1594 at Crewkerne: probably an elder same-name brother who died young. Do not merge into Rev. Joseph (bapt. 25 Apr 1596). (POSSIBLE.)
- Wikipedia, citing Anderson's Great Migration (GMB) p.455: the first wife's name is unknown, and she died during or soon after the birth of her seventh child in 1632. The "Joanna Coffin" idea traces to Monnette, and Joanna Coffin was bapt. 1616, so she would have been about 3 at the marriage. Consistent with the quarantine. (PROBABLE.)
- HFA errors page (Hughes): "no proven evidence that Rev. Joseph even married a Joanna"; Agnes's surname is unknown. (CONFIRMED.)
- Northleigh's surviving registers start in 1697/1700/1708. Wood cites a now-lost Northleigh register for predecessor John Carpenter's 1620/1 burial. Carpenter's will (dated 1617, proved 1621) names wife Lucretia (née Carwithen) and children Nathaniel, Samuell, Ruth, Abraham, Dorothie. (GENUKI; Skinner, DCNQ 7:3 (1912). PROBABLE.)
Narrative (trimmed to the facts) This round tested Crewkerne, Joseph Hull's home parish in Somerset, as the place he married his first wife, and the test came back negative. FreeREG holds Crewkerne's marriage register in two separate transcriptions, and neither has a marriage for Joseph Hull between 1610 and 1634. A control search on his parents' 1572/3 marriage came back correctly from both copies, so the search itself works. None of the Crewkerne baptisms from 1614 to 1634 is for a child of Joseph: every Hull child baptized there belonged to his brother George or to a John Hull. One record could easily be merged by mistake. A Joane Hull was baptized at Crewkerne on 10 November 1619, close to our Joanna's estimated birth, but the register names her father as John. The Exeter diocese marriage-licence registers, which run to 1631, have no entry for Joseph either, and the Colyton registers were already searched in round 11 with the same result. The first wife is still unnamed. Anderson's Great Migration, as quoted on Wikipedia, says only that she died during or soon after the birth of her seventh child in 1632. The best chance of naming her is the Devon Bishop's Transcripts for Northleigh, where Joseph was rector from 1621 to 1632/3 and where the children were probably baptized; the parish's own registers from those years are lost. The "Joanna Coffin" name stays quarantined.
Dead ends: Crewkerne marriages (both transcripts); Crewkerne baptisms 1614-34; Exeter licences 1523-1631; Phillimore printed Somerset Marriages on archive.org (these volumes lack the Crewkerne section); FreeREG nationwide, whose only same-name hit is Joseph Hull x Mary Wall, Hertford 1614 (do not merge: our Joseph was an Oxford undergraduate then); CCEd PersonID 57456 returned HTTP 503 (tooling, not a negative).
Leads: Northleigh Bishop's Transcripts 1621-1633 (Devon Heritage Centre / FamilySearch). Anderson GMB p.455 exact wording. Hughes, "The Myth of Joanna Coffin". Crewkerne Bishop's Transcripts vs the PR for 1614-21, plus Bath & Wells licence bonds. A Colyton FreeREG marriage-coverage double-check (low priority). Unanchored, zero evidence, NOT a claim: that Joseph married into his predecessor John Carpenter's family (unmarried daughters Ruth, Dorothie). The only test is a primary record, e.g. Lucretia Carpenter's probate abstracts. Most Devon probate was destroyed in 1942.
Frontier target 2: John Sayles Sr. (ahn 2818): death, probate, deed, Catharine's parents
Facts
- RIHCC ID 138061: "SAYLES, JOHN, H/O MARY", Nicholas Easton Lot, MT014 Middletown. d. 1681, age 48 (so b. c.1633). Slate, skull without wings, "possibly carved by Mumford in Boston". Transcribed by MHS;JES;BA; last seen 2007; the inscription is not quoted. First primary-artifact dating of his death. (PROBABLE.)
- RIHCC ID 138062, verbatim: "HEAR LYETH Ye BODY OF MARY SAYLES WIFE OF JOHN SAYLES WHO DIED IN Ye YEAR 1681 AGED 45 YEARS". The original stone was destroyed c.1990 and replaced c.1995. A pre-1940 photo survives in R. W. Baker, "Baker-Cranston" (RIHS CS71-B17-1940). The stone does not name her father; "[WILLIAMS]" and "[D/O ROGER WILLIAMS]" are the database's additions. Age 45 conflicts with b. Aug 1633 (already logged). (PROBABLE.)
- Providence Town Papers 0314 (Early Records XV p.215), 27 Oct 1680: "my Request is I may Chang: 35: Acors of Land which my Grand fathar Mr Rogor williams Gaue me ... John Sayles. This Bill is Granted." This is John Jr., writing in Roger Williams's lifetime, and it is earlier than the 1694 laying-out and the 1702 quitclaim. It does not name Catharine. (CONFIRMED.)
- Last records that clearly mean John SENIOR alive: deputy, 7 Oct 1676 ("Jo Sayls Sen"); petty jury, 16 Oct 1678 ("John Sayles Se[n]"). The 1679-1692 plain "John Sayles" entries are ambiguous. The May 1682 allegiance list groups him with younger men, which suggests it is Jr. (Early Records VIII, XV, IV, XVII, XIV. CONFIRMED.)
- 1702/3 deed: "John Sailes of said Providence (now deceased)", matching the 1660 sale to William Hawkins. Only a latest-possible-death bound. (Early Records V. PROBABLE.)
- No probate, will, inventory, administration or estate entry for John Sr. in any of the 21 Early Records volumes or the Bowen Index. Consistent with dying intestate. (CONFIRMED.)
- John Jr. and Elizabeth's children start with Mary, b. 30 May 1689, so John Jr. cannot be the father of Catharine, who married in Dec 1692. (Early Records V p.[422]. CONFIRMED.)
- "Richard Sayles" witnessed a John Sayles deed on 12 Oct 1663 (Early Records I pp.5-6). His identity is unknown. He is a possible alternative father for a Catharine born c.1671. (CONFIRMED.)
- Moriarty (1918): John Sayles b. 1633, d. 1681, m. Mary Williams; "probably the son of John Sayles of Boston"; named a daughter Phoebe. No Catharine, and no source for the death date. (PROBABLE.)
- Austin 1887 SAYLES: d. 1681; last record "1679, Jul. 1. Taxed 1s, 3d"; buried Easton Burial Ground, Middletown, with his wife and William Greene. The gravestones agree on burial place and year. (Carried at PROBABLE, downgraded from CONFIRMED: Austin may have drawn on the same stones, so the two are not provably independent.)
Narrative (trimmed to the facts) John Sayles Sr. was born about 1633, probably the son of John Sayles of Boston, and married Mary Williams, daughter of Roger Williams. The Providence town records show him in public life through the 1670s. On 7 October 1676 the town chose "Jo Sayls Sen" as a deputy to the General Assembly. On 16 October 1678 "John Sayles Se[n]" was named to the petty jury for the General Court of Trials. Those are the last entries that clearly mean him rather than his son. He and Mary are buried in the Nicholas Easton lot in Middletown. The Rhode Island Historical Cemetery Commission recorded his slate gravestone, carved with a skull and possibly made by a carver named Mumford in Boston, as giving his death in 1681 at age 48. Mary's original stone read "Hear lyeth ye body of Mary Sayles wife of John Sayles who died in ye year 1681 aged 45 years." It was destroyed around 1990, and a replacement now stands. No will, inventory or estate settlement for John has been found in Providence's printed records, so he probably died without a will, and no record yet names his heirs. His son wrote one record that ties the family to Roger Williams. In October 1680 John Jr. petitioned to exchange "35 acres of land which my grandfather Mr. Roger Williams gave me," and the town granted it. That proves the Sayles-Williams marriage produced Roger Williams's grandchildren. The link from Catharine Sayles, who married William Olney in December 1692, to this couple still rests only on Austin's 1887 dictionary. The town records also show another adult Sayles man, Richard, in Providence in 1663.
Parents of Catharine (ahn 1409): father John Sayles Sr., mother Mary Williams, both per Austin 1887 p.353 only. John Jr. and Elizabeth are ruled out by the birth register. The 1663 Richard Sayles remains a possible alternative. PROBABLE (anchored per Austin only; not settled).
Dead ends: no estate or heirs record in Early Records I-XXI. No record naming Catharine's parents (her only entry is the marriage, V p.255). The 1679-92 "John Sayles" entries cannot be assigned to father or son. Find A Grave search returned 403 and HathiTrust full-text returned nothing via curl (tooling). The 1670 "father-in-law" deed is still quoted only through Austin.
Leads: Moriarty, TAG 15 p.228 (the Bowen appendix cite; same article as the TAG founder-hands lead). The identity of the 1663 Richard Sayles (Bartlett's RI Colony Records; Austin pre-1700). Moriarty's daughter "Phoebe". An RIHCC check for an Olney/Sayles stone 1751-53 to settle the touchstonetruth "younger daughter of Mr. Richard Sayles, d. 24 Feb 1753" stone; it probably belongs to the family of Richard b. 1695, which is the agent's reasoning only. The full RIHCC MT014 lot, for William Greene's stone.
Frontier target 3: English Goodspeed/Pemberton cluster
Facts
- Phillimore, Bucks Marriages vol. 1 (1902), "Marriages at Soulbury", p.92, "Transcripts" (from the Archdeacon's Registry at Aylesbury; the Soulbury register itself starts 1624): "Robt. God;spede[?] & Alice Harries ... 6 Nov. 1609". The "[?]" is the editor's. Round 10's "unverifiable" verdict was a wrong-parish search. (CONFIRMED that the entry exists.)
- Will of Robert Goodspeede of Wingrave, yeoman, 15 Sept 1658: "To my wife Alice all my household stuff ..."; sons Roger, Bennett, Thomas £6 13s 4d each "if they ... return from beyond the seas within ten years". Proved 13 Feb 1660/1 by son John. (Moriarty NEHGR 82 p.444. PROBABLE.)
- TNA C 5/405/103 (1649): "Jennings v Goodspeed ... Defendants: Robert Goodspeed, Agnes Goodspeed his wife, and another ... property in Stoke Mandeville". This is a different Robert. Round 10 partR had already ruled out the merge, so the tree doc's round-10 "direct contrary primary evidence" line contradicts partR. (CONFIRMED.)
- Timing: the first Wingrave register volume stops after Dec 1611 (gap to 1649). Roger married 1 Dec 1641, so he was born c.1612-1620, inside the 1609-1658+ marriage to Alice. Inference. (PROBABLE.)
- Weak link: there were three marriageable Robert Goodspeeds in 1609 (bapt. 1578, son of Robert & Isabel; bapt. 1587, son of Nicholas & Mary; son of Thomas of Cranborrowe). Moriarty picks the 1578 Robert without argument. In support: the testator's sons' names match the 1578 Robert's brothers, and Nicholas's 1605/6 will has a Soulbury tie. (PROBABLE.)
- Same-name trap: a different Roger Goodspeed of Wingrave, bapt. 1570 (the emigrant's uncle), married Alice Grace (1602) and Alice Spindler (1606/7) and was alive in 1637 (ship money). Do not attach either Alice or the 1637 entry to the emigrant. (CONFIRMED.)
- Robert Stokes, M.A., of St Albans (will 2 Aug 1578): "To my cousin Roger Pemberton my customary and copyhold lands ..."; "To mine Aunt Pemberton an Angel in gold." Roger Stokes, draper (will 3 Jul 1578): after Robert's death, administration was "granted Roger Pemberton next akin." PROB 11/60/415 and /416. (Waters, Gleanings I pp.330-331; TNA. CONFIRMED.)
- The "Aunt Pemberton" is almost certainly Katherine, widow of Robert Pemberton (bur. 16 Jul 1578; admon "to his widow Katherine Pemberton" 30 Sept 1578), so Katherine was the Stokes brothers' aunt. "Née Stokes" stays POSSIBLE: she could be their mother's sister, or an aunt by marriage. (PROBABLE.)
- Visitation of Herts 1634: "Robert Pemberton of St. Alban's ... = Catherin, da. of ...." (surname blank). Robert's parents are not given; "his ancestors came out of Cheshier" is the family's own claim. (CONFIRMED that this is what the Visitation says.)
- St Albans burials: "Robert Pemerton 15 December 1560" (with Joane 1560, Randall 1561). Unanchored as a father. The clustered 1578 Stokes/Pemberton burials suggest an epidemic. (POSSIBLE.)
- Roger Pemberton's will (13 Nov 1624, proved 5 Dec 1627): "unto my cosen and Godsonne Roger Williams the some of ten pounds". Codicil 7 Nov 1627. TNA also holds PROB 11/154/18 (Robert Pemberton gent., proved 3 Jul 1628), a likely companion to the 14 May 1628 Sentence. WARD 2/57C/212/18 names John Glover as an executor. (CONFIRMED.)
- The Roger Williams descent through Alice Pemberton is unchanged by this round. (PROBABLE.)
Parents of Roger Goodspeed (ahn 5648): father Robert Goodspeed of Wingrave (bapt. 3 Aug 1578; will 1658), PROBABLE. Mother Alice (Harris) (m. Soulbury 6 Nov 1609; living 1658): given name PROBABLE, surname PROBABLE with the groom-identity weak link stated.
Dead ends: no Robert Goodspeed x Agnes marriage in Phillimore Bucks vols 1, 2, 4, 6, 8 ("Robt. Goodspeed & Anne Sear" is a later man). Alice Harris's parents are unreachable on free registers. Robert Pemberton's parents: none in any free primary. The 1628 Sentence content is unknown. Bucks Archives catalogue is JS-only and the Google route via jina returned 403 (both tooling).
Leads: Correct the tree doc's round-10 "Agnes contrary evidence" line. Add the Stokes kinship to Katherine (22555) at PROBABLE, doc-only. Possible Harris kin of Alice in Soulbury (C 8/18/44 of 1612, C 3/358/26 of 1623, C 2/JasI/H31/2; Soulbury Harris marriages 1575/1605/c.1621), none anchored; the anchor would be a Harris will naming "my daughter Alice Goodspeed". Candidates for the Stoke Mandeville Robert: the 1587 Robert and the Cranborrowe Robert. The 1560 Robert Pemberton as a possible father of Robert (d. 1578).
Frontier target 4: Eva C. Brown (Foster) (ahn 15): Samuel Brown / Mary Ann Breazeale test
Facts
- Old Pendleton District GEDCOM (rev. 1 Jan 2006): "BROWN, Samuel,25 Apr 1817,5 Sep 1899,Lewis /BROWN/,13"; "BREAZEALE, Mary Ann,24 Jul 1821,6 Jan 1905,(S)-Samuel /BROWN/,13". Agrees with SCGenWeb P023, except for Samuel's death day (5 vs 4 Sep). (PROBABLE.)
- Refuted as Eva's parents: in Sep 1885 Mary Ann was 64 and Samuel 68. The dates come from two compilations, neither primary. (Carried at PROBABLE, downgraded from CONFIRMED because Eva's birth date rests on a single Find A Grave memorial, FaG 16161990. The 1900 census age about 14 corroborates it, so the conclusion is robust.)
- Samuel (1817) is the son of Lewis Brown (1778-1848) and Julia Tatum. (POSSIBLE.)
- 18 database children list the father as "Samuel /BROWN/": 13 for Samuel 1817 plus 5 for a second Samuel (b. 1815, m. Mary J. Nations). The two sets are mixed and cannot be cleanly separated. (POSSIBLE.)
- Grandparent route: no Eva or E-name born about 1885 among the children of any Samuel-Brown son. Closest are Effie (1884-1888, died a child) and Wiley Harbin (1885, a son). (PROBABLE.)
- No Eva Brown born about 1885 anywhere in the Anderson/Oconee/Pickens BRO-BT file. No Julius C. Foster in FM-FZ, and no Robert J./Opelia Brown. The database is incomplete, so this is a weak negative. (PROBABLE.)
Parents: father unknown, mother unknown. The Samuel Brown / Mary Ann Breazeale couple is REFUTED as parents (a grandparent hypothesis at most, without support even for that).
Narrative (trimmed to the facts) Eva C. Brown was born on 4 September 1885 in South Carolina. Both of her parents were also South Carolina-born. She married Julius Calloway Foster in Towns County, Georgia, on 10 October 1899, at fourteen. The last round put forward one possible South Carolina family for her: Samuel Brown and Mary Ann Breazeale Brown of Pickens County. This round recovered that family's record from the Old Pendleton District GEDCOM database. It gives Samuel as 25 April 1817 to 5 September 1899, son of Lewis Brown and Julia Tatum, and Mary Ann Breazeale as 24 July 1821 to 6 January 1905, with thirteen children. Those dates rule the couple out as Eva's parents: Mary Ann would have been sixty-four when Eva was born. The database also shows no granddaughter named Eva born around 1885 among the children of any Samuel Brown son. Eva's South Carolina parents are still unknown. Her 1938 Georgia death certificate, or the parental consent on her 1899 marriage license, is still the most likely way to find them.
Dead ends: Samuel/Mary Ann as parents (retire). Their database grandchildren (no Eva). No Eva, Julius or Robert J./Opelia in the GEDCOM. usgwarchives Towns Co Brown Bible/bio files (connection refused, tooling). WebSearch returned nothing. FamilySearch GA deaths index is login-gated, so not attempted.
Leads: Old Pendleton flat files can be curled whole (oldpendleton.scgen.org/cemetery-txt/pd_<range>.txt), a reusable tool. Eva Lou Brown (a later generation) is noted only, do not merge. Towns Co GA "G. W. Brown Family Bible" and "Biography of George W. Brown": retry in a live browser. Target a Brown couple born c.1840-1865, both SC-born, in Towns Co by 1899; check the 1900 census pages near the Fosters.
Backstory 1: Herman Monroe Wilson (1921-1996) and Eleanor "Ellie" Lambert Wilson (1919-2010)
Living-status check: both are deceased (tree doc; obituary read directly). Their four children (1961 profile) are not named here.
Parents (unchanged from tree v0): Monroe ← Herman Everett Wilson + Letha Leona Mashburn (PROBABLE). Eleanor ← Walter Rittenhouse Lambert + Florence Olney Lambert (CONFIRMED, 2010 obituary).
Facts (selected; full citations in the dispatch return, Cherokee Scout lccn sn83004710 on DigitalNC)
- Monroe "first moved to Brasstown in 1938 to attend the John C. Campbell Folk School" (CS 1961-06-01 p.1). CONFIRMED.
- Student lists: "Monroe Wilson of Hemp, Ga." (1939-12-28 p.7). "In his second year at the Folk School", assembly talk on the Saturday Evening Post article "War Has Lost Its Pocket" (1940-02-01 p.7). Long-term students (1941-03-06 p.8). CONFIRMED.
- 1939 student comedy, "in overalls and with bare feet, a bandaged toe"; working at the school, July 1939. PROBABLE.
- Christmas 1941 chorus under Mrs. John C. Campbell included "Eleanor Lambert" and "Monroe Wilson", the earliest document placing the two together (1942-01-01 p.6). CONFIRMED.
- Nov 1942: in the Folk School group sent to the Rabun Gap festival (1942-11-05 p.1). Navy entry therefore after Nov 1942 (inference). CONFIRMED.
- Studied engineering at IIT, then served aboard the light cruiser USS Tucson in the Pacific, and returned to Brasstown in 1946 (1961 profile, single source). PROBABLE.
- USS Tucson (CL-98): commissioned 3 Feb 1945; with TF 38 from Jun 1945; reached San Francisco 5 Oct 1945. That fits the NYT wedding notice of 19 Oct 1945 (inference). PROBABLE.
- IIT's WWII Navy program is unknown; V-12 enrollment is unproven. POSSIBLE.
- "Mrs. Monroe Wilson" hosted the home demonstration club, Dec 1947. CONFIRMED.
- Apr 1949: "Mr. and Mrs. Monroe Wilson from the Folk School have moved into the place where the Cornwells did live." Whether that is 106 Settawig is unproven. CONFIRMED.
- 1949-53 Cherokee-Clay DHIA: herd of 4-7 Jerseys and Holsteins, often ranked 1st-3rd; top cow a grade Jersey, "Red"; Dec 1952 second in the association. CONFIRMED.
- "Test demonstration dairy farmer" (1961). PROBABLE.
- Classifieds: cocker spaniel pups (1948); baled Ladino clover and orchard-grass hay (1959). CONFIRMED.
- Almost five years with Lidseen of N.C. at Hayesville before becoming postmaster. Gustave Lidseen, Inc. opened a Brasstown plant in Jul 1956. PROBABLE.
- Sworn in as acting postmaster 14 Apr 1961; certificate 24 May 1961; 12th District meeting Sept 1961. Corroborates USPS. CONFIRMED.
- 1961: secretary, Bishop's Vestry, Episcopal Church of the Good Shepherd. CONFIRMED.
- Good Shepherd services from 14 Aug 1955 in members' homes; "Mrs. Monroe Wilson" elected to the five-member mission committee (1955-09-08 p.10). CONFIRMED.
- Vassar class secretary, June 1955. CONFIRMED.
- 1954 Adult Class teacher, Hickory Stand Methodist. Monroe was "maid of honor" in a womanless-wedding fundraiser for that church in 1956. CONFIRMED.
- 1960s: AAUW Cherokee County branch member (with Marguerite Bidstrup); Clay County 4-H leader certificates 1968-70. CONFIRMED.
- Pallbearer 1953, 1964, 1967; honorary pallbearer 1971. CONFIRMED.
- folkschool.org (2021): "Ellie" came in 1940; started the Episcopal church; taught at Martin's Creek; started Industrial Opportunities Inc.; WCU sociology degree in the '60s "while raising three children". Conflicts on year (1941) and child count (four). PROBABLE. The Industrial Opportunities founding is POSSIBLE.
- Folk School context: incorporated 23 Nov 1925. Bidstrup from 1926; Deschamps left 1943; 1941 carvers earned $7,000; GI Bill-approved 1946; dairy herd sold 1973. Olive Campbell's director tenure ends 1946 (NCpedia) or 1947 (WCU), conflicting. CONFIRMED.
- Brasstown straddles Brasstown Creek (Clay/Cherokee line). Post office 1871, re-established 1889 (PROBABLE). The origin of the Settawig Road name is unknown.
Narrative (trimmed to the facts) MONROE. Herman Monroe Wilson grew up in Hemp, Fannin County, Georgia. In 1938, at about seventeen, he moved to Brasstown to attend the John C. Campbell Folk School. The Cherokee Scout lists him as "Monroe Wilson of Hemp, Ga." among the students in December 1939. By February 1940 he was "in his second year at the Folk School," and he gave a morning-assembly talk built on a Saturday Evening Post article, "War Has Lost Its Pocket." In 1939 he acted in a student-written comedy, barefoot "in overalls" with "a bandaged toe." At Christmas 1941 he sang in the school chorus led by Mrs. John C. Campbell. Eleanor Lambert, a new Vassar graduate, was in the same chorus: it is the earliest record of the two together. In November 1942 he was still with the Folk School group sent to the Rabun Gap folk festival. The 1961 Cherokee Scout profile says he studied engineering at the Illinois Institute of Technology and then served aboard the light cruiser USS Tucson in the Pacific. The Tucson screened the fast carriers from June 1945 and reached San Francisco on 5 October 1945. That date fits the New York Times notice of 19 October 1945 that Eleanor had married a "Navy Man."
He came back to Brasstown in 1946. In April 1949 the couple moved out of the Folk School into "the place where the Cornwells did live." From 1949 to 1953 the Cherokee-Clay dairy-herd tests list his small herd of Jerseys and Holsteins near the top of the association, led by a grade Jersey named Red. He sold hay and cocker spaniel pups. For almost five years before 1961 he worked for Lidseen of N.C. He was sworn in as Brasstown's acting postmaster on 14 April 1961 and held the post until about 1983. He served as a pallbearer at neighbors' funerals and as secretary of the Episcopal vestry. In 1956 he played the "maid of honor" in a womanless wedding to raise money for Hickory Stand Methodist Church.
ELEANOR. She came to the Folk School in 1941 for one year and stayed for the rest of her life. In 1947 the Brasstown home demonstration club met at her house. In 1955 she was elected to the five-member committee that organized the Episcopal Church of the Good Shepherd, which met in members' homes until it could build. That same year she was elected secretary of her Vassar class. In the 1960s she was active in the American Association of University Women (AAUW) and led 4-H clubs.
Dead ends: no 1945 wedding item in the Cherokee Scout; no Navy item 1942-46; no "Settawig" hits; the Murphy/Rome "Eleanor Wilson" hits are quarantined; "Aud Herman Wilson" (1968) is a different man; no hits in Folk School/NCpedia/WCU sources; no company history for Lidseen beyond the newspapers.
Leads: SF-180 refinement (USS Tucson; entry after Nov 1942; IIT). NARA Catalog NAID 594996, Tucson muster rolls 1945 (free, browser). IIT Galvin Library V-12 rosters. The Cornwell place: Clay Co deeds Cornwell→Wilson c.1949. Lidseen plant histories 1956-61. Monroe's Oct 1996 obituary (post-1971 microfilm). Industrial Opportunities Inc. incorporation records. "Geraldine Wilson" (1939): a possible sister. Check only if she is confirmed deceased; name withheld here.
Backstory 2: Thomas Olney (ahn 5632), Marie Ashton (5633), Thomas Olney II (2816), William Olney III (1408)
Parents: Thomas Olney Sr's parents are unknown (documented dead end; his baptism is absent from the intact St Albans register). Marie Ashton ← James Ashton (bur. 1651) + Alice (bur. 1643), CONFIRMED in prior rounds, not re-verified.
Facts (selected)
- Austin p.352 (page image): Thomas Sr "b. 1600, St. Albans", d. 1682; wife printed "Mary Small", d. "1679 (-)"; "He was a shoemaker." PROBABLE. "Small" is the known error; the registers give Ashton (CONFIRMED).
- Permit, 2 Apr 1635, Planter: certificates "from the Minister of St. Albans"; "Tho. Olney, Shoemaker, 35; Marie Olney, 30; Tho. Olney, 3; Epenetus Olney." CONFIRMED.
- The 1889 book's "city of Hertford ... part of the Parish of St. Albans" is a geographic error. CONFIRMED.
- Freeman of Mass. Bay, 17 May 1637 (Shurtleff I p.373). CONFIRMED.
- Salem: "Tho: Olney f. 40" grant; inhabitants list; Mar 1636/7 appointed with Thomas Gardener to survey fences (Salem Town Records I pp.21, 26, 41). PROBABLE. The 1889 book's "surveyor" and field-book scene is embellishment.
- Austin: Nedabiah bapt. 27 Aug 1637 (the 1889 book has 27 June); 25 Dec 1637 household of five. PROBABLE.
- Not banished with Williams. 12 Mar 1637/8 order: licensed Salem men "Francis Weston, Rich'd Waterman, Thom: One, & Stewkely Waskote, are to appear also, if they bee not removed before the next Courte." Reading "One" as Olney is editorial. PROBABLE.
- Hugh Peters, 1 Jul 1639: "the great censure" on Williams, Throckmorton, Thomas Olney and wife, Westcott and others: "These wholly refused to hear the church ... and (except two) were all rebaptised." PROBABLE.
- Initial Deed "8 of ye 8th mon: 1638 (so called)", twelve grantees including "Tho: Olney". Williams's 1666 note: dated "as neere as wee Could guesse". CONFIRMED.
- Twelve grantees; the 1889 count of thirteen includes Williams; "8th month" is October, not August. CONFIRMED.
- Second-year orders: meadow laid out to "neighbour Olney" (Early Records I pp.3-4). PROBABLE.
- Treasurer 1638 and 1669 (Austin; 1889 book); no town-book entry found. PROBABLE.
- 1639, one of the twelve original First Baptist members; the 1889 book says a leader in the c.1652-4 laying-on-of-hands schism, side not stated. PROBABLE.
- Combination 27 Jul 1640; offices per Austin and the 1889 book. PROBABLE.
- Moderator of town meetings, early 1660s ("Thomas Olney Senior Modderator"); named to treat with Indians alongside John Sayles and others. CONFIRMED.
- Laid out land for others; 60 acres at Caucaunjawatchuck, 28 Mar 1667. CONFIRMED.
- Will, 21 Mar 1679/80: Bible and "Smiths vice" to Epenetus; dwelling house, home share, "all my Bookes & writeings" to Thomas; land to son-in-law John Whipple; oxen share to Joseph Williams; movables split with "my Daughter Liddea Williams"; no wife named (Early Records VI pp.63-66). CONFIRMED.
- Inventory 9 Oct 1682; will approved 17 Oct 1682. CONFIRMED. (The tree's "after 16 Jun 1682" bound was not re-checked.)
- Inventory £78 9s 5d; three books; shop with smith's vice, currier's shears, shoemaker's last (Austin). PROBABLE.
- Homestead lot between Thomas Angell's and Robert Cole's, on the Towne Streete. The family burying place on it is reserved in Thomas II's will "where my father and mother ... are buried", "five poles square". CONFIRMED. Later reinterments: tradition, POSSIBLE.
- Marie died before 21 Mar 1679/80 and was buried in the homestead ground. PROBABLE.
- Children per Austin: Thomas, Epenetus, Nedabiah (died young), Stephen, James (d. 1676), Mary (m. John Whipple Jr), Lydia (m. Joseph Williams). The Stephen conflict with the 1889 book is logged. PROBABLE.
- Thomas II: 1632 to 11 Jun 1722; m. 3 Jul 1660 Elizabeth MARSH (Austin, twice) or MARCH (1889). Town clerk (long run 1683-1715); ordained 1668; 1699 declined the agency to England. PROBABLE. Will 20 Feb 1721/2, proved 9 Jul 1722 (Early Records XVI pp.200-210): CONFIRMED. The Wenscott half "already Confirmed to my Grandson William Olney" refers to William IV (b. 1694): CONFIRMED.
- William III: b. 25 Jun 1663; m. Catharine Sayles 28 Dec 1692 (date CONFIRMED in a prior round from Early Records V p.255). Six children per Austin (seven per 1889, adding Lydia 1714). No death date. Alive Feb 1721/2. PROBABLE.
- Austin prints Catharine (Sayles) Olney b. 1671, d. 21 Feb 1751. PROBABLE.
Narrative (trimmed to the facts) THOMAS OLNEY (c.1600-1682). On 2 April 1635 a shoemaker of St Albans, Hertfordshire, received a permit to sail on the Planter. The party carried certificates from the minister of St Albans, and he was listed as 35, with his wife Marie, 30, and sons Thomas, 3, and Epenetus, an infant. At Salem he received a town grant of 40 acres and was appointed to survey the town's fences, and he became a freeman of Massachusetts Bay on 17 May 1637. By Christmas 1637 his household numbered five. He was not banished with Roger Williams, who had been sentenced in 1635. In March 1638 the General Court let a group of Salem men leave under licence, with the record printing his name as "Thom: One," and ordered them to appear at the next court only if their families had not moved. In July 1639 the Salem church passed "the great censure" on him and Marie, with the Williamses, for refusing to hear the church; all but two of the group had been rebaptized.
In Providence he was one of the twelve men named in the town's founding deed. That deed was recopied in 1666 and dated "as neere as wee Could guesse" to October 1638. Austin and the family genealogy call him the first town treasurer and an original member of the Baptist church, and the genealogy makes him a leader in its later schism over the laying on of hands. The town books show him moderating town meetings and laying out other men's land. His own holdings included a home lot on the Towne Street between Thomas Angell's and Robert Cole's, land along the Wanasquatucket, and 60 acres at Caucaunjawatchuck surveyed in 1667. His 1680 will left his Bible and smith's vice to Epenetus and his house and books to Thomas. The inventory recorded a shoemaker's last still in the shop.
MARIE ASHTON. Baptized at St Albans in 1605 and married there in 1629, Marie crossed with two small children and bore more in New England. Old books call her "Mary Small"; that is an error. She died before March 1680, when her husband's will made no provision for a wife. Her son's will confirms she was buried in the family ground on the homestead lot.
THOMAS OLNEY II (1632-1722). The toddler from the Planter became Providence's town clerk for decades. He was ordained pastor of the First Baptist Church in 1668, and in 1699 he declined to go to England as the colony's agent. He farmed at the Stampers and at Wenscot. His 1722 will fenced a five-pole burying place "where my father and mother ... are buried" and passed the Wenscot farm to his son William.
WILLIAM OLNEY III (b. 1663). Born in Providence on 25 June 1663, he married Catharine Sayles on 28 December 1692. They had six children (seven by the 1889 genealogy's count), and his father's will shows him holding part of the south end of Wenscot. The records give no death date. Catharine's descent from Roger Williams rests on Austin alone.
Dead ends: "Banished alongside Roger Williams" is not supported. The English birthplace beyond St Albans is unknown. William III has no death date in Austin or the 1889 book. Treasurer 1638 has no town-book entry. The Salem "surveyor" claim is a fence-viewer appointment.
Leads: Catharine's 1751 death needs a second source (ERTP probate or gravestone). Marsh vs March (Arnold vols). William III probate in ERTP XVII+ (c.1725-50). The 1665 division list (lots 23 and 41). Providence Ashtons of the 1660s (James, Thomas), linked to the 1716 "uncle James Asten" deposition: do not merge. Reinterment records for the Olney ground. A primary source for which schism side Thomas led (Backus, Comer). The manuscript spelling of "Thom: One".
Backstory 3: Rev. Joseph Hull (ahn 11302) and Joanna (Hull) Bursley Davis (ahn 5651)
Parents: Joseph ← Thomas Hull the Younger + Joanna (Peson), as on the tree. Joanna ← Joseph + his unnamed first wife (ahn 11303).
Facts (selected)
- Bapt. Crewkerne 25 Apr 1596, "son of Thomas Hull". CONFIRMED.
- St Mary Hall, Oxford: matriculated 22 May 1612 aged 17; B.A. 14 Nov 1614 (Foster; Paget letter 1895). CONFIRMED.
- Instituted Northleigh 4 Apr 1621 "on the presentation of Thomas Hull, of Crewkerne ... Yeoman"; resigned 1632; successor John Ford (Exeter Registry letter 1898). PROBABLE. Weygant and WikiTree give 14 Apr.
- Curate under William at Colyton c.1614/15-1621 (Weygant). PROBABLE. Licensed curate of Broadway 1633, 1634 (Anderson TAG 68:149 via WikiTree). PROBABLE.
- Hotten p.285, "Waymouth ye 20th of March, 1635": "Joseph Hall, of Somersit, a minister, aged 40 ... Agnis Hall, his wife, aged 25 ... Joane Hall, his daughter, aged 15 ... Joseph 13 ... [Tristram] 11 ... Elizabeth 7, Temperance 9, Grissell 5, Dorothy 3". Hotten prints "Cristian". CONFIRMED.
- The 1904 footnote "Really 1635-6" is wrong: Winthrop records the settlement in July 1635. CONFIRMED.
- 8 Jul 1635: "Mr. Hull, a minister in England, and twenty-one families with him, allowed to sit down there - after called Weymouth" (Winthrop I:154). CONFIRMED.
- Freeman Sept 1635 (Otis; Porter). Hingham grant 1636. Deputy 1638-39 and Hingham commissioner for small causes. Weymouth friction; farewell sermon 5 May 1639. All PROBABLE.
- Barnstable founders with Dimmock, 1639 (Otis). PROBABLE. Plymouth freemen and "committees for Barnestable", 3 Dec 1639 (PCR I:137). CONFIRMED.
- Lothrop register: baptisms "att Mr Hull's house" (Nov 1639); thanksgiving 11 Dec 1639 "att Mr. Hulls house"; Hull laid hands on John Mayo, 15 Apr 1640. CONFIRMED.
- "Mr. Hull excommunicated for his willfull breakeing of communion ... May 1, 1641"; received again 10 Aug 1643; "Syster Hull" renewed her covenant 11 Mar 1642/3. CONFIRMED.
- Hinckley land dispute, 7 Sep 1642 (PCR II:44). Order to apprehend Hull "being an excommunicant", 7 Mar 1642/3 (PCR II:53). CONFIRMED.
- Winthrop, 10 May 1643: Acomenticus "entertained one Hull, an excommunicated person and very contentious, for their minister". Acomenticus is York, not Dover as Otis has it. CONFIRMED. 1644 Cornish case: "something was discovered against the son of Mr. Hull" (unnamed). CONFIRMED.
- York deed witnessing 1643 and 1645 (Porter, citing York Deeds). PROBABLE. Isles of Shoals as possibly first minister. POSSIBLE.
- 1669 deposition: "about four and twenty years agoe ... naomy hulls father and mother they went for England", so c.1645. PROBABLE.
- Launceston c.1648-52, with baptisms of Reuben, Ephraim and Priscilla (Anderson via WikiTree). PROBABLE.
- Calamy 1713 p.150: "Burien: Mr. Joseph Hull". CONFIRMED. Identity with the emigrant, ejected 1662: PROBABLE.
- Oyster River c.1662; Quaker disruption. PROBABLE.
- Inventory: "Mr. Joseph Hull, who departed this life 19th of November, 1665"; appraised 5 Dec 1665; books £10; "The Ylands indebted to my husband for his ministry £20"; total £52.05.05; Agnes administratrix, £100 bond, attested 14 Jun 1666 (Porter 1891; Otis agrees on 19 Nov and £52.5.5). PROBABLE.
- Died at the Isles of Shoals: inferred from the inventory. PROBABLE.
- Reject the Durham history's "18 Nov" and "£62-5-5", WikiTree's "£62.5s.5d", Porter's "returned to England 1659" and "Northleigh 1614". CONFIRMED.
- 16-17 children by two wives. Seven by the first wife: Joanna c.1620, Joseph c.1622, Tristram c.1624, Temperance bapt. Northleigh 20 Mar 1625/6, Elizabeth c.1628, Griselda c.1630, Dorothy c.1632 (Anderson via WikiTree). PROBABLE.
- The first wife's name is unknown. Agnes (25 in 1635) cannot be Joanna's mother. CONFIRMED.
- "Joane Hull ... aged 15" gives Joanna b. c.1619-20. CONFIRMED.
- Lothrop: "Mr Bursley and Mr Hulls daughter aboute the 28 of Novemb. 1639, att Sandwidge." The bride is not named. CONFIRMED. The bride as Joanna: PROBABLE.
- "Mestresse Bursly joyned July 22, 1643." CONFIRMED.
- Bursley entries in Lothrop: a child buried 25 Jan 1640/1; Mary bapt. 29 Jul 1643; John bapt. 22 Sep 1644, buried 27 Sep 1644; Johannah bapt. 1 Mar 1645/6; Elizabeth bapt. 25 Mar 1649 "by my Brother Mao"; John bapt. 11 Apr 1652. CONFIRMED.
- Lived in her father's Barnstable house until about 1650, then on the West Barnstable farm (Otis). PROBABLE.
- John Bursley died 1660, inventory 21 Aug 1660 (Otis). Davis 1881 argues he was alive in Apr 1670. PROBABLE, with conflict logged.
- Joanna married Dolor Davis c.1671; on 4 Jul 1673 the court took "the oath of Joannah Davis widdow" (Davis 1881). PROBABLE.
- Alive 1683 (Davis); "Wid. Joanna Davis" in 1686 (Otis). PROBABLE.
- PCR V:42-43 (5 Jul 1670): "Elizabeth Goodspeed, widdow, the relict of Nathaniel Goodspeed"; "the two children". This supports two children (Mary and Nathaniel (10)) against Otis's one. CONFIRMED.
- Elizabeth Bursley m. Nathaniel Goodspeed Nov 1666, and (2) Increase Clapp Oct 1675. PROBABLE.
- Descent to Eleanor as on the tree. The Goodspeed generations are the weakest links. PROBABLE.
Narrative (trimmed to the facts) REV. JOSEPH HULL (1596-1665). Joseph, son of Thomas Hull, was baptized at Crewkerne, Somerset, on 25 April 1596. He matriculated at St Mary Hall, Oxford, on 22 May 1612, aged 17, and took his B.A. on 14 November 1614. He then served as teacher and curate under his elder brother William, vicar of Colyton in Devon. In April 1621 his father, "Thomas Hull, of Crewkerne ... Yeoman," presented him to the rectory of Northleigh, Devon, which he resigned in 1632. His first wife, the mother of our Joanna, is unknown. By 1635 he had married a second wife, Agnes.
On a list dated at Weymouth "ye 20th of March, 1635," "Joseph Hall, of Somersit, a minister, aged 40" heads a company. With him were Agnes, aged 25, and seven children, starting with "Joane ... aged 15." On 8 July 1635 the Massachusetts court allowed "Mr. Hull ... and twenty-one families with him" to settle at Wessaguscus, which was renamed Weymouth. He later held land at Hingham, sat as a deputy, and served as one of Hingham's commissioners for small causes. In 1639 he and Thomas Dimmock led the founding of Barnstable in Plymouth Colony, and early church gatherings were held at his house. Rev. John Lothrop's congregation arrived in October 1639. On 1 May 1641 the Barnstable church excommunicated Hull for joining a group at Yarmouth as their pastor against the church's advice. In March 1643 Plymouth Colony ordered his arrest if he preached or administered the sacraments there. That May, Governor Winthrop called him "an excommunicated person and very contentious" when Acomenticus (York, Maine) took him as its minister. The Barnstable church received him back in August 1643.
A deposition suggests that he and his wife went back to England around 1645. A Joseph Hull is listed as ejected from St Buryan, Cornwall, after the Restoration, probably the same man. He returned to New England and preached at Oyster River and the Isles of Shoals. He died on 19 November 1665. His inventory, which totals £52 5s 5d, notes "The Ylands indebted to my husband for his ministry £20."
JOANNA HULL (c.1620-after 1686). Lothrop recorded the marriage, about 28 November 1639 at Sandwich, of "Mr Bursley and Mr Hulls daughter." The register does not give her name, but she was Joseph's only daughter of marriageable age. Lothrop's register records the Bursleys' children: one buried in January 1641, then Mary in 1643, a John who lived only days in 1644, Johannah in 1646, Elizabeth on 25 March 1649, and John in 1652. After John Bursley died, Joanna married Dolor Davis, and she was his widow by July 1673. She was still living in the old Bursley house in 1686.
THE LINE DOWN. Elizabeth Bursley married Nathaniel Goodspeed in 1666. The line then runs: their son Nathaniel; Stephen Goodspeed; Elizabeth Goodspead, wife of Nathan Olney; and five generations of Olneys to Florence Olney Lambert, whose daughter was Eleanor Lambert Wilson (1919-2010).
(Trimmed from the dispatch narrative: "about 106 people", which is not in this round's facts, and "six children baptized", since Lothrop records five baptisms plus one burial.)
Dead ends: the BHO Alumni Oxonienses URL returns 404. The PCR I:126 grant text was not found in the OCR. Cornwall OPC is behind a CAPTCHA. Hull 1904 has no return-to-England or St Buryan coverage. No free source names the first wife.
Leads: The Temperance Northleigh baptism (1625/6) implies surviving Bishop's Transcripts; search them for the first wife's burial c.1632-33. Log the Bursley death conflict (1660 vs alive 1670) and pull the original Plymouth inventory. Consider raising Nathaniel (10)'s link on the strength of PCR V:42-43. Launceston registers (Cornwall OPC). CCEd for Launceston/St Buryan.
Backstory 4: James Morgan Sr. (ahn 414) and Rev. James Morgan Jr. (pension S7251)
Facts (selected)
- DAR A132519: b. c.1729 MD; d. "POST 1-18-1785 RANDOLPH CO"; service "1) TOOK OATH OF ALLEGIANCE, RANDOLPH CO, 1779"; source The North Carolinian 2 (June 1956) pp.179-180; spouse MARY DAVIS. CONFIRMED.
- Correction: the oath was in 1779. 18 Jan 1785 is the death-POST bound only, and the tree merged the two fields. CONFIRMED.
- The 25 DAR applications run only through son Perminter (m. Gracie Jones; 22) and daughter Mary (m. Arthur Parr; 3). None goes through Susannah or James Jr. CONFIRMED.
- A "James Morgan" signed Regulators' Advertisement No. 9 (Orange Co fees petition) in May 1768, Colonial Records of NC vol. 7 p.736; Solomon and Ruddy Morgan signed other copies; Herman Husband signed the same sheet. CONFIRMED. Round 8's "p.786" and round 7's "April 1768" are wrong.
- Petition text: "We the Inhabitants of Orange County pay larger Fees for recording Deeds than any of the adjacent Counties ..." CONFIRMED.
- The signer as ahn 414: POSSIBLE.
- Chilton (2016): the Regulators were on the Orange-Rowan border, "now eastern Randolph and Guilford". PROBABLE.
- WikiTree Morgan-1173: m. Mary Davis 18 Jul 1754, Baltimore Co; last record a Rowan deed of 23 Feb 1804. Conflicts with DAR. POSSIBLE.
- JP, militia Major, NC 1764, Uwharrie: WikiTree and duplicated tree prose only. POSSIBLE.
- No Randolph estate file (round 11). PROBABLE.
- Susannah's (ahn 207) link to ahn 414/415 stays POSSIBLE. James Jr. as son of ahn 414: POSSIBLE.
- S7251: 20 Oct 1834, "the Reverend James Morgan a resident of the County of Yancey", aged 74. "born in Baltimore County in the State of Maryland on the 26th day of April 1760 -- that his parents brought him to North Carolina where he was raised." Tours: spring 1781 under Col. John Collier, Capt. John Hinds, Lt. William York, Tory fight in Chatham (3 killed, 2 wounded incl. York); late summer/fall 1781, 3 months as a substitute (paid with a horse) under Capt. Thomas Dougan, then a move to Guilford; 1782 under Capt. Daniel Gillespie, Col. John Paisley, 7 weeks 2 days. Always a private. After 40: SC, "the Western country", Ashe, then Yancey. "he has followed teaching school in preaching & traveling for many years." Supporting affiant Stephen Morgan, clergyman. $21.11/yr from 4 Mar 1831. Signed "Jas. Morgan". All CONFIRMED.
- Not on the 1840 Yancey pensioner list. POSSIBLE inference.
- The Randolph library roster merges Sr. and Jr.; S7251 is not service proof for ahn 414. CONFIRMED.
Narrative (trimmed to the facts) JAMES MORGAN SR. (ahn 414). DAR's patriot record (A132519) gives him a Maryland birth about 1729, a wife named Mary Davis, and one documented Revolutionary act. In 1779 he took the oath of allegiance in Randolph County, North Carolina, which DAR counts as patriotic service. The record's other date, 18 January 1785, is not the oath; it is the last date DAR has him alive. The tree had merged the two. Randolph County lies in the Piedmont country where the Regulation broke out in the late 1760s, among farmers on the Orange-Rowan border who protested the fees officials charged. In May 1768 a "James Morgan" signed a copy of Regulators' Advertisement No. 9, a petition from Orange County inhabitants complaining that they paid "larger Fees for recording Deeds than any of the adjacent Counties." Herman Husband signed the same sheet. Whether that signer is our James is only POSSIBLE: the petition names no place or relatives, and several Morgans signed. Online trees also call him a Justice of the Peace and a militia Major who came to the Uwharrie River in 1764, and none of that has a primary source yet. No estate file has been found for him. Susannah (ahn 207) is tied to him only at POSSIBLE, and DAR's approved lines run only through his son Perminter and his daughter Mary, wife of Arthur Parr.
REV. JAMES MORGAN JR. (pension S7251). His link to ahn 414 is POSSIBLE, because his sworn statement never names his father. On 20 October 1834 "the Reverend James Morgan," aged 74, declared before the Yancey County court that he was born in Baltimore County, Maryland, on 26 April 1760, and that "his parents brought him to North Carolina where he was raised." Living in Randolph County in spring 1781, he volunteered under Colonel John Collier. His company was beaten by Tories in Chatham County, with three killed and his lieutenant among the wounded. Later that year he served three months as a substitute, paid with a horse, taking Tory stragglers prisoner through four counties, and then moved to Guilford. In 1782 he served again under Colonel John Paisley. He served about 13 months in all, always as a private. After age 40 he lived in South Carolina, then "the Western country," then Ashe County, and finally Yancey. For "many years" he had "followed teaching school in preaching & traveling." A clergyman, Stephen Morgan, swore for him. He drew $21.11 a year. His death is not yet found.
Dead ends: S7251 transcription fully read; it names no father, mother, wife or children. DAR has no Susannah or James Jr. application. NCGenWeb/yanceyfamilygenealogy give a name only. Searches on Stephen Morgan and on a Yancey preacher born 1760 found nothing.
Leads: Fix the citation (CSR 7 p.736, May 1768) and the oath year in the tree. The North Carolinian 2:179-180 (library or HathiTrust). Solomon/Ruddy Morgan deeds. Identify Stephen Morgan. NC pension-agency final payment. Ashe Co minutes for the denomination. Mary (Morgan) Parr as a sibling-strategy collateral.
CONTRADICTIONS
- Tree doc round-10 summary vs round-10 partR, on Agnes. The tree doc (following partQ) calls C 5/405/103 "direct contrary primary evidence" against Alice. PartR had already ruled the Stoke Mandeville Robert a different man. Round 12 re-fetched the TNA catalog and agrees with partR. Resolution: correct the tree doc line; Alice (Harris) is added at PROBABLE.
- Tree doc round 10, "Phillimore 1609 unverifiable in 8 volumes". It was a wrong-parish (Wingrave) search. The entry is in vol. 1 p.92 under Soulbury. Resolved.
- James Morgan Sr oath date. The tree (line 237, round 7) and the bio have the oath on 18 Jan 1785; DAR's service field says 1779. Resolved: oath 1779; 1785 is the death-post bound. This also closes round 10 partQ contradiction #1.
- Regulator citation. Round 8 has CSR vol. 7 "p.786" and round 7 "April 1768". Correct: p.736, May 1768 (the OCR renders 736 as "7S6").
- Joseph Hull inventory total: £62 5s 5d (rev-joseph-hull bio, Durham history, WikiTree) vs £52.5.5 (Porter's transcript and Otis, independently). Resolved to £52.5.5; bio to be corrected.
- Joanna's marriage record. The tree doc (round 6) and the joanna-hull bio say Lothrop's diary / "her father's church diary" names Joanna. Lothrop's register says "Mr Hulls daughter", and the diary is Lothrop's, not her father's. Resolved.
- Joanna's children. The bio lists five (Mary, Joanna, Elizabeth, John, Temperance). Lothrop gives one child buried 1640/1, Mary, John (d. 1644), Johannah, Elizabeth and John (1652), with no Temperance. Bio to follow Lothrop; Temperance is unsourced this round.
- Northleigh institution: 4 Apr 1621 (Exeter Registry letter, 1898) vs 14 Apr 1621 (Weygant/WikiTree; the current bio). Logged, not adjudicated; the registry letter should weigh higher.
- John Bursley's death: inventory 21 Aug 1660 (Otis) vs alive Apr 1670 (Davis 1881 meadow list). Logged.
- Agnes Hull's surname. The ahn 11303 bio (round 8) says "probable surname Hunt, m. 13 Mar 1633 Wells". HFA: "her surname is unknown". Round 9 [[2026-07-26-frontier-round9-partO|partO]] flagged the Wells marriage as resting on one blog. Flag in the bio as unverified; do not propagate.
- Thomas Olney: "banished / Salem exiled its dissenters" (bio) vs the record of licensed departure and later excommunication. Resolved against "banished". Also: "12 vs 13 proprietors" is resolved as 12 grantees; the "first Town Treasurer" claim (the tree doc via Wikipedia) has no town-book entry and stays Austin/1889 secondary.
- Olney schism framing. The thomas-olney and thomas-olney-jr bios state the father led the breakaway and the son pastored the original. Neither Austin nor the 1889 book says which side Thomas Sr led. Downgrade to "a leader in the schism; side unconfirmed".
- Thomas Olney II's wife's surname: MARCH (tree, 1889 book) vs MARSH (Austin, twice). Logged; check Arnold.
- Nedabiah's baptism: 27 Aug 1637 (Austin) vs 27 Jun 1637 (1889). Stephen Olney: d. 1658+ unmarried (Austin) vs constable 1659, d. 1689 (1889). Logged.
- Monroe as "Folk School teacher" (tree doc line 35, monroe-wilson bio) vs newspapers listing him as a student 1938-42. Resolved: student. Whether he later taught is unproven.
- Eleanor's arrival year and child count: 1941 and four (obituary; 1961 profile) vs 1940 and three (folkschool.org 2021). Obituary/1961 kept; logged.
- Monroe's Lidseen employer location: "Lidseen of N.C. at Hayesville" (1961) vs a Brasstown plant (1956 notices). Logged. The dispatch's "Brasstown plant" phrasing was trimmed.
- Olive Campbell's director tenure: 1946 (NCpedia) vs 1947 (WCU). Context only.
- Mary Williams: age 45 at death in 1681 (gravestone) vs b. Aug 1633 (better-sourced). Still open; the death year is now settled at 1681.
- Catharine Sayles's death: 21 Feb 1751 (Austin p.353; LDS mirrors) vs the touchstonetruth stone "younger daughter of Mr. Richard Sayles, d. 24 Feb 1753". The latter is probably a different woman (agent reasoning). Open; settle via RIHCC.
- Moriarty 1918's daughter "Phoebe" for John Sayles of Providence is absent from every child list held. Note that catharine-sayles' bio says Austin attests a Phoebe Sayles "through the families they married into". Logged.
- James Morgan Sr's death: DAR post-1785 Randolph vs WikiTree alive 23 Feb 1804 (Rowan deed). Still open.
- Joseph Hull emigration "May 6, 1635 aboard the James" (rev-joseph-hull bio) is not supported by anything read this round. The primary list is dated at Weymouth on 20 Mar 1635, and the Massachusetts settlement on 8 Jul 1635. Not removed; flagged for a source check. The 1904 "Really 1635-6" footnote is wrong.
FOUNDER-HANDS
- FamilySearch login, Devon Bishop's Transcripts for Northleigh 1621-1633: baptisms of Joanna (~1620), Joseph Jr. (~1622), Tristram (~1624), Temperance (1625/6), any mother's name, and a Hull wife's burial c.1632. Highest value for ahn 11303.
- NEHGS/AmericanAncestors login: Anderson GMB p.455 and Great Migration 1634-1635 III:452-460 (Joseph Hull); Anderson TAG 68:149; Moriarty TAG 15:228 / TAG 20:228 (Sayles; the best route to a primary source for Catharine's parents or the 1663 Richard).
- FamilySearch login, GA Death Certificates 1919-1998: Eva Foster, d. 2 Nov 1938 (parents). Or a GA DPH Vital Records mail request. Also the Towns Co Probate Court: the 10 Oct 1899 Foster-Brown marriage license (parental consent).
- TNA free downloads (free account): PROB 11/152/801, 11/153/522 (Latin), 11/154/18, and 11/60/415 + 11/60/416 (the Stokes wills).
- Buckinghamshire Archives (browser or email archives@buckinghamshire.gov.uk): the original 1609 Soulbury transcript (the "God;spede[?]" reading and the groom's parish); Robert Goodspeed's original 1658 will; Harris testators of Soulbury c.1600-45. Also the TNA C 5/405/103 document image.
- NARA: submit the SF-180 with "USS Tucson (CL-98); entry after Nov 1942; IIT engineering". Browse NAID 594996 (Tucson muster rolls 1945) in a browser.
- Eleanor's memoirs (signed copies on hand): Monroe's student years 1938-42, IIT/Navy, the "Cornwell place", Industrial Opportunities.
- Clay County Register of Deeds: 106 Settawig chain of title (Cornwell→Wilson c.1949?).
- RIHS: R. W. Baker, "Baker-Cranston" (1940), for the pre-1940 photo of Mary Sayles's original stone. An RIHCC/visit read of John's MT014 inscription.
- Full NARA pension file S7251 (Fold3/M804); a DAR record copy for A132519; Rowan Deeds 19:814-815 (FamilySearch DGS 7517738); Reamy p.87 (library/ILL).
- Somerset Heritage Centre: the Crewkerne Bishop's Transcripts 1614-21 vs the PR; Bath & Wells licence bonds.
- HALS: the 1578 St Albans archdeaconry admon book (Katherine Pemberton) and earlier Pemberton/Stokes wills. College of Arms: Roger Pemberton's funeral certificate.
- Murphy Public Library microfilm: Monroe's Oct 1996 obituary.