Composition test (2026-10-06)
Can code-composed pages read as scenes? See comparison-sheet.png.
Verdict: scene, with fixable weak spots
- Hiding lines works. Each object has a white silhouette, so objects in front hide the lines behind them. No line crosses an object on any page.
- Same line weight. Every line prints at 16px (1.35mm) at any scale.
- Depth reads. Hills hide the feet of figures behind them. A size rule keeps scale consistent.
- Reuse rarely shows. Sheep, stable, manger, donkey and palm appear on 2-3 pages. Page A's two shepherds are the clearest repeat. The angel stays on-model in all 4 versions, including [[2026-09-19-icon-set-bakeoff-quiver-vs-grok|Quiver]]'s re-pose.
What looks pasted on
- Straight ground lines under feet look ruled.
- Small sizes: the 16px line fills in details (far sheep, baby's face).
- Figures face the right way but nobody looks at anyone.
- Page B: the donkey's ears cross into the manger, and the kings are crowded.
- Open outlines (
library/leaks/): the camel has a gap between its legs (3.65%; not used on a page), the donkey at its tail (1.4%).
Cost (provider tokens x list price)
| Calls | n | USD |
|---|---|---|
| Arrow generate | 9 | 1.18 |
| Arrow edit (angel) | 1 | 0.08 |
| Total | 10 | 1.26 |
The edit reported only 81 input tokens, so its cost may be under-reported. 8 objects came from bake-off pages at no cost.
Fixes
- Use ground shapes, not ruled lines.
- Thin lines with distance. Drop details below about 300px.
- Add pose variants per character with Quiver edits (about $0.08 each).
- Check placements for overlaps automatically.
- Close leaks by hand or with a Quiver edit.
The art area is 7.5x10in: 8in does not fit 0.5in margins on an 8.5in sheet. To rebuild, run tools/build_lib.py, then pages.py, then sheets.py.