Christmas coloring bake-off (2026-10-06)
G = Grok Imagine, then [[2026-09-19-icon-set-bakeoff-quiver-vs-grok|Quiver]] vectorize. Q = Arrow direct SVG. See comparison-sheet.png; PDFs are in grok/ and quiver/.
Screen
On all 10 pages: no gray or shading, no text, and ink at least 0.5in from every edge.
- G1 pass on retry (first try: Joseph drawn as a second Mary, no ox)
- G2 pass, but many tiny stars and grass tufts
- G3 pass after removing a vectorizer clip that cut off the star
- G4 pass on retry (faces on the wreath), then vectorized a second time (first one dropped the wreath outline)
- G5 pass on the 3rd try (faces on the church); 2 snowflakes nearly solid black
- Q1 pass, but ox and donkey outlines are open (colour will leak)
- Q2 pass, but odd side-view shepherds and open hill lines
- Q3 pass; faces and gifts are small
- Q4 pass on retry (smiley candles)
- Q5 pass; the cleanest page
Both arms draw in a square. Q art covers only about 62% of the page height.
Cost
Grok: provider-reported. Quiver: tokens x list price.
| Calls | n | USD |
|---|---|---|
| Grok generate | 9 | 0.18 |
| Quiver vectorize | 6 | 1.60 |
| Arrow generate | 6 | 1.34 |
| Total | 21 | 3.12 |
Wall time (calls in parallel)
G: about 2 min. Q: about 2.5 min.
Recommendation: Q
- Thicker lines and larger areas. This fits "bold and easy" for ages 4-8 better than G, whose pages are busier.
- One step. The vectorizer broke 2 of 5 G pages.
- Costs less per page ($0.27 vs $0.36) and needed fewer retries (1 vs 4).
- Before production: write prompts for a tall composition, and check each page by hand for open outlines.