Archetypes: how 2,566 [[2026-10-04-starter-story-pat-walls-assessment|Starter Story]] businesses split, and where the work is agent-shaped
Do not publish; internal analysis (Starter Story ToS: non-commercial reuse with link back).
Unit = business (3,261 stories deduped by website to 2,566). A fixed-prompt model assigned each an archetype, B2B/B2C, and a 0-3 score per core job for agent carry today (0 cannot, 1 assists, 2 does most, 3 runs it). Aggregates exclude 66 revenue-suspect businesses (2,500 remain; 2,052 with revenue). Revenue is self-reported.
The scheme
- agency, Agency & productized service: B2B done-for-you marketing, SEO, design, dev or video, on retainer or project.
- saas, B2B SaaS & developer tools: software sold to businesses, incl. Shopify/WordPress apps and APIs.
- consumer_app, Consumer app & micro-tool: software for individuals; apps, AI generators, extensions, templates, games.
- dtc_brand, DTC physical product brand: factory-made goods sold online under its own brand.
- maker, Handmade & artisan goods: made by hand; capacity is the maker's hands.
- retail, Online retailer & reseller: resells third-party goods.
- marketplace, Marketplace & platform: two-sided; takes a cut or lead fee.
- media, Content, media & audience: blog, newsletter, podcast, YouTube, affiliate site; the product is attention.
- edu, Courses, info products & communities: courses, cohorts, exam prep, paid communities, edtech.
- coaching, Coaching, consulting & professional services: expert time, incl. accounting, legal, PR.
- local, Local & in-person service: cleaning, gyms, spas, tours, venues, clinics.
- ops, Operations, logistics & B2B supply: manufacturing, packaging, 3PL, print, hosting, wholesale.
- other: no fit; 37 (1.4%), mostly video pages.
Per archetype (clean rows)
| Archetype | n | Median $/mo | Median $/mo per person | Median people | Median agent-carryable | B2B share | Most agent-shaped job | Least |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| saas | 513 | 42k | 6.0k | 7 | 58% | 79% | admin 2.3 | find 2.0 |
| dtc_brand | 425 | 75k | 13.0k | 5 | 40% | 1% | admin 2.1 | deliver 0.8 |
| agency | 357 | 46k | 5.3k | 8 | 48% | 95% | admin 2.2 | deliver 1.5 |
| media | 210 | 8k | 3.4k | 2 | 55% | 2% | admin 2.3 | support 1.6 |
| consumer_app | 200 | 19k | 4.5k | 3 | 60% | 0% | deliver 2.3 | find 1.9 |
| local | 142 | 44k | 7.6k | 5.5 | 25% | 11% | admin 2.0 | deliver 0.03 |
| coaching | 138 | 22k | 8.2k | 2 | 32% | 48% | admin 2.1 | deliver 0.7 |
| marketplace | 131 | 80k | 8.3k | 8 | 50% | 36% | admin 2.2 | deliver 1.5 |
| edu | 99 | 18k | 7.5k | 2 | 55% | 12% | admin 2.2 | deliver 1.7 |
| ops | 85 | 200k | 10.8k | 14 | 30% | 76% | admin 2.0 | deliver 0.4 |
| retail | 84 | 140k | 18.0k | 5 | 45% | 6% | admin 2.1 | deliver 1.0 |
| maker | 79 | 6k | 3.0k | 2 | 30% | 1% | admin 2.1 | deliver 0.1 |
Job scores are 0-3 means. "Other" (37) omitted. Overall median agent-carryable share 45%.
What the table says
- Admin is the universally agent-shaped job. Top job in 11 of the 12 real archetypes (consumer_app's top job is deliver, 2.3), never below 1.9. Bookkeeping, invoicing, scheduling, reporting go first.
- Deliver is the moat for anything physical. Local 0.03, maker 0.1, ops 0.4, coaching 0.7, dtc_brand 0.8. These five hold 869 businesses (35% of clean rows). Revenue per person is mixed: dtc_brand ($13.0k) and ops ($10.8k) rank second and third, maker ($3.0k) ranks last, and retail ($18.0k), outside the five, ranks first. For factory goods the money is where the agent is not.
- Software and content are already half-agent. consumer_app 60%, saas 58%, media and edu 55%. For saas and consumer_app the weak job is finding customers (1.9-2.0); for media it is support (1.6) and for edu it is deliver (1.7). Distribution is still bought with a face or a decade of SEO.
- Agencies are the odd one. 95% B2B, 48% carryable, deliver only 1.5: clients buy judgment. Lowest B2B revenue per person (5.3k): the opportunities thesis.
- Small teams dominate the agent-shaped archetypes (median 2-3 people). The overhang here is a solo-founder story.
One named example per archetype (monthly revenue)
- agency: Custom Creatives $300k.
- saas: Fastlane $69k.
- consumer_app: Sprouty $280k.
- dtc_brand: Joker Greeting $300k.
- maker: Frailey Woodworks $30k.
- retail: PokeNE Trading $280k.
- marketplace: ThirstySprout $300k.
- media: Entrepreneurs on Fire $194k.
- edu: Consulting Success $240k.
- coaching: The Uncaged Life $68k.
- local: Iron Storage $225k.
- ops: LogoClothz $32k.
Caveat: scores come from a 300-character public description per business (spot-check: 28 of 30 archetypes agreed, all 30 within one point on a 0-3 scale, judged by the producer, not an independent reader). The medians describe this dataset, not the economy. Bear case: Starter Story is a self-selected sample of founder-reported successes whose header figures can be peak, stale or wrong. The carryable share is a model grading its own capability from a blurb, and incumbents can adopt agents too.